50 Best Bakeries near Sleepy Hollow

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“100% recomendado torta tres leches Tema Harry Potter me encanto el diseño y el sabor delicioso. Muchas gracias.“

“I absolutely love leaving positive reviews, especially when I come across businesses like Susan's. She operates on a whole different level of excellence, and her unwavering commitment to detail and high-quality products surpasses all other establishments. When it comes to bakeries and restaurants, Susan's place puts them to shame in the best way possible. Her team is simply outstanding, and their dedication to providing top-notch customer service was evident throughout my entire visit. The food was nothing short of exquisite – it was incredibly fresh, unbelievably fluffy, and wonderfully delicious. Every bite was a scrumptious delight that left me in awe. In fact, it was so amazing that I can only describe it as "AMAZBALLS"! I have no doubt that Susan's bakery is the best in the state, and I wholeheartedly encourage everyone to pay a visit and savor everything they have to offer. It's an experience you won't want to miss!“

“The fresh off the rack help yourself bakery was a cool experience but the eating of the huge everything bagels, pretzels and pastries was heavenly 🥯🙏🥰“

“We order a bunch of cookies. They were prefect for what we needed and they were extremely accommodating. During our party the folks eating the cookies were in aww of the cookies and wanted to know where we order them from. I told them Bella’s bake shop in Mount Kisco. We have also purchased bread from them at a farmers market and it was delicious! Will continue to purchase products from them. Staff are extremely nice!“

“Not only are the cakes beautifully designed but they are incredibly creative, made with the best ingredients and is simply DELICIOUS! If you're looking for a special cake, look no further. By the way the staff is so helpful and caring.“

“Excellent sitting inside,A/C very comfortable.Excellent food as well.Love this place.“

“The cookies are good but a bit over rated. I love the cool flavors and the fact that the menu changes weekly but sometimes the cookies are way too sweet. There is usually a long line at this location but the employees are pretty fast so the wait is never more than 5-10 minutes. It would be nice if there were places to sit inside the establishment.“

“Their granola is the best we’ve ever eaten. It’s so yummy.“

“Vilma’s created the perfect Mr.Met cake for my husband’s 60th birthday! It looked amazing and tasted even better! Highly recommend!“

“What a wonderful place! My family and I often have breakfast/brunch at Guzzo’s and we are always pleasantly satisfied with the food and service. The staff is amazing and provide you with a warm welcome. We just celebrated my daughter’s 10th birthday here with her friends. I booked the tea party package that Guzzo’s has and it was such a great experience. The girls couldn’t stop talking about how much fun they had & how tasty everything was. Thanks again for making this a memorable birthday!“

“Jess created our dream wedding cake and it was absolutely PERFECT! The cake was not only delicious but so beautiful - it was everything we imagined. Our guests were raving about how delicious the cake was all night! She was a pleasure to work with. 100% highly recommend!“

“The food is really good and the place very pretty inside with great service. They have homemade pound cake that is so good and fresh.. I love it and will come back soon for sure. Great place for hang out with family and friends.“

“Love this place! Such a warm and welcoming staff, they went out of their way to make sure I got exactly what I needed.

As far as the baked goods- everything was fresh and absolutely delicious! I also got a customized cake order that came out perfect, exactly what I wanted.“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“I have been going to the official cake lady now for 10-11 years and about 3-4 times in a year. Kim never ever disappoints. She makes our vision come to life. The cake is so good we drive over an hour to pick it. Kim is always professional and listens to every detail needed for the cake.
The cakes are always moist and delicious . We will continue to drive to get our cakes.
Thank you“

“Never disappointed with L'Anjou. Over the years, I've ordered their quiches and pastries which are all quite delicious. Yesterday, the Irish Cream Cheesecake was superb. I'm so glad that L'Anjou continues to survive (and hopefully thrive) in our area.“

“Excellent service, taste and decorations. LOVE LOVE-LOVE THEM Thank you“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“The place is small and comfy, the service is great, the food is excellent, I had the grilled chicken with mushrooms sauce, the mini bandeja paisa, and the steak, everything tasted fresh and with great flavor, the millojas and the tres leches also tasted fresh, I recommend you this place to visit and eat there“

“Cannolis are the best. Try something new - Chocolate gellato with espresso "Afragatto"“

“I’ve had better pies, but these are probably the best in the area. The fruit in everything is super fresh. It’s a cute lil bakery experience to visit. Would I wait on that long af line I’ve seen in the holiday photos? No. I’ve had better pie at Stop and Shop and ShopRite in Scarsdale. But I’d go back for the sheer variety in pies for sure.

The other offerings are great here, cookies, rainbow cookies, bread, Bundt cake, etc.

I want to settle an issue I’ve read about in these reviews. I ordered the jelly doughnuts just to see if it was even possible to suck the jelly out. It is DEFINITELY not possible to empty the doughnuts of jelly or even lick it out. I had five people try besides me. So, it seems like there are fluke experiences where, indeed, the doughnuts are NOT filled. I do not believe the customers should have faced blame for the barren doughnuts. May God protect you from such calamities.“

“Wonderful family owned business with delicious bread, pastries, prepared foods and the best homemade pizza dough anywhere! Their St. Joseph's pastries are second to none!“

“I am NYC born & raised but moved out of state. Happened to find this amazing bakery on a visit to NYC. I am beyond pleased with ALL the treats I purchased.“

“Wonderful owner and talented baker!“

“For my birthday I wanted the fudgiest chocolate cake and Carolina Desserts went above and beyond the call of duty. it was the juiciest, richest chocolate cake I ever had. And I am really picky with chocolate cake. Please send business her way. You will not be disappointed.“

“We tried the chicken pot pie, pumpkin and cherry and all were absolutely incredible! Cherry was maybe the highlight. You can taste the butter in the crust and quality of the ingredients.

Service was also excellent! Thank you :)“

“So been here alot before i started writing reviews. In The Summer during the Thornwood car show, my parents and i can be seen eating their italian ices, which are very good. They also have cakes, pastries, and i believe i tasted my first almond horn from here, and it was good! Also once brought a pint to use for my 18th/Graduation party a few years ago. Inside, they do have chairs and tables where one can sit if they want.
Went here on Saturday August 10th 2024 while at the Thornwood car show with my parents. We were there to get italian ices. Staff was pleasant, and asked what we wanted right away. I got a Cotton Candy Italian ice, and my mom got lemon, and my dad got chocolate. We paid with cash, as they charge for using a credit card. Italian ices were very good! as we enjoyed them! We hope to be back soon!“

“The staff is lively & attentive. The variety of healthy/ vegan foods is excellent & the produce was attractive. Even though I didn't buy any this visit. I even was lucky enough to come across some hard to find Supplements. Very nice place. Upscale but affordable for everyone. I'll be back.“

“Simply amazing! I tried a vegan cupcake for the first time, but it was so flavorful and much better than the store bought cupcakes with mysterious ingredients. Will definitely order again and highly recommend to others who want to eat natural sweets!“

“The cannolis here are INCREDIBLE... 10/10!!! The cookies are pretty good, too, as they are not overly sweet and go perfectly with coffee or tea. However, their mini cakes are not the best, which is why I'm docking a star. I ordered a mini tiramisu which was dry and seemed to have a frosting layer rather than a creamy mascarpone, which was disappointing. Overall, awesome bakery! I would just say to avoid the mini cakes.“

“I fumbled the ball and didn’t order a cake. It had to be a certain combination per request. The night before I called 7 bakeries within 40 min of my job. No one had this cake or they never answered their phones. Any bright and early the next morning I called here and they had this cake! The place is immaculate, the owner was so kind, prices fair and most importantly the cake was AMAZING!!! Even though it’s out of my way I will ? be back“

“Move over pumpkin… Chai-Der is my new favorite fall drink! Friendly staff, delicious sweets and chai-der….. no more reasons needed to visit this store!“

“Local business with excellent desserts. Their ice coffee has a hint of burnt which can be improved. I also like their croissants, baguettes and sour dough bread.

- has no indoor seating but some outdoor
- fast & kind“

“Friday a lively group of Tarrytown elders enjoyed their tasty breakfast and morning coffee sitting in the sun at The Pastery Chef on Broadway. It made me smile and feel grateful that these wonderful seniors have a welcoming spot to enjoy their village. Thank you Maria!“

“everything. from the breakfast, lunch cakes, cookies, bread, biscuits, pastries, cake“

“Best Mexican tortas, right across from a hospital you will definitely get your moneys worth if you stop here for a meal. Prices are cheap you cant beat them. Mexican bread pan dulce also available you can have a beer with your meals. Street parking is the only issue“

“HAVING JUST MOVED TO OSSINING, NY ONLY 7 MOS BEFORE, IT WAS A MIRACLE TO DISCOVER DEL SOL SWEET BAKERY, 10+++! WHEN I COULDNT DECIDE BETWEEN TWO FILLINGS, OWNER, LUCIO SUGGESTED COULD DO BOTH- PRODUCING THE MOST FABULOUS, GORGEOUS, MOUTHWATERING CAKE ANYONE HAD EVER SEEN OR TASTED! ???????????????? PLUS WHEN COULD ONLY TAKE DELIVERY FOR THIS VERY SPECIAL HUGE BIRTHDAY EVENT DATE ON A MONDAY- HE FOUND A WAY, BECAUSE FINISHED CAKE SO FRESH, BUT PRRISHABLE -TO DELIVER ON A MONDAY- AND SO MADE ALL MY DREAMS COME TRUE!?❣️? + A MILLION ?sOs!“

“Beautiful modern store with gorgeous interior and wonderful floor tiles. They had all popular PB bakery items on display. Lots of sitting area, all clean and well maintained.

We went to get a cake. It was evening hours, so a lot of the popular ones were sold out, still we had 5-6 kinds to pick from. Cake was packed precisely in the box, got knife and candles with it. Staff were very friendly and got our order ready super fast.

The mini strawberry soft cream cake was pure quality. Fluffy soft cake with delicious cream all around it topped with glazed strawberry.

Vegetarian options: Hot and cold drinks, salads, fruit pastries

Parking: Lots of spots in front and around the store“

“Attended a fundraiser and other events at the bakery. Everything was delicious.

They employ students with special needs to help with the baking which is wonderful. They also have pop up events in and around Rockland and Bergen.“

“My family has been enjoying Anna's Bakery for as long as I can remember. We have never been disappointed and everything is always delicious!“

“I would rather swallow poison than anyone else's cappuccino. Best coffee, vibe of any cafe in Westchester. Staff is super cool and I love the music they play. I am not cool but I feel cool when I'm in there.“

“Love my mornings at First Village Coffee. It's like my daily recommended dose of good vibes all around!“

“The most delicious mother daughter dynamic duo! Always delicious and cant get enough of everything they make. It’s too good!“

“I've come here for many years and the quality of the food is always great, the expansion of the store and products is great to see and the pricing is fair so this is a must go

I have been coming to this store for many years and the quality of food is very good, the expansion of products in this store is a good variety to choose from and the prices are very fair, so I recommend that you stop by here“

“Just had a delicious visit to Nothing yBundt Cakes in Hartsdale, N.Y. Not only are the cakes a easy design, but they are so moist and light they are a pleasure to eat in the am with a cup of coffee or tea. My wife and I say yummy, yummy, yummy to Nothig Bundt Cakes ad best wishes in sales lDies.“

“The best Gluten-free bakery I have ever tried, super fluffy and tasty, fresh right out of the oven. The cinnamon bread and cupcakes are out of this world!“

“So it turns out every single babka I've ever eaten in my life was a disappointment until I had this babka. I cannot thank you enough for bringing this into my life and setting the bar so high. I wish ya'll nothing but great business and many years of success because ya'll are baking beautiful things. How do I order more babka? Can you bake me a house made of babka?“

“This place is amazing... it even smells amazing but, if you are a tourist you have to know what you want before you get there. The bakery is frequented by locals who are in a hurry and know what they want. The only list of bread items is on the website so I suggest you check that out before going. The pastries and cookies are magnificent, especially the Italian assortment This is a must for food lovers!.“

“My fave are the palmiers and raspberry almond croissants. So good.

Staff are so pleasant and efficient. Especially Day! Bought a mocha cake during my first visit there and she knew exactly what I needed. Cake server, candles, etc. I wouldn’t have remembered to bring them to the party.“