50 Best Bakeries near Sleepy Hollow

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“100% recomendado torta tres leches Tema Harry Potter me encanto el diseño y el sabor delicioso. Muchas gracias.“

“I absolutely love leaving positive reviews, especially when I come across businesses like Susan's. She operates on a whole different level of excellence, and her unwavering commitment to detail and high-quality products surpasses all other establishments. When it comes to bakeries and restaurants, Susan's place puts them to shame in the best way possible. Her team is simply outstanding, and their dedication to providing top-notch customer service was evident throughout my entire visit. The food was nothing short of exquisite – it was incredibly fresh, unbelievably fluffy, and wonderfully delicious. Every bite was a scrumptious delight that left me in awe. In fact, it was so amazing that I can only describe it as "AMAZBALLS"! I have no doubt that Susan's bakery is the best in the state, and I wholeheartedly encourage everyone to pay a visit and savor everything they have to offer. It's an experience you won't want to miss!“

“Vilma’s created the perfect Mr.Met cake for my husband’s 60th birthday! It looked amazing and tasted even better! Highly recommend!“

“The fresh off the rack help yourself bakery was a cool experience but the eating of the huge everything bagels, pretzels and pastries was heavenly 🥯🙏🥰“

“They are a cozy place (not huge) and the vibes were perfect for a cold Sunday. Food is ABSOLUTELY amazing and worth a drive (and wait if needed). Everyone was extremely courteous and accommodating, will absolutely travel the 2hrs to visit them again!“

“Crumbl is a fun spot to visit if you're in the mood for an indulgent dessert. One of the best parts is the rotating weekly menu, which keeps things interesting since there's always a new lineup of flavors to try alongside their classic chocolate chip cookie. The cookies are served warm and have that signature thick, soft texture that Crumbl is known for.

I enjoyed trying different flavors, although I found most of them to be a little sweeter than I personally prefer. They're also very rich and filling, so sharing a cookie or saving half for later is usually the way to go. While they're definitely not an everyday treat, they're still enjoyable if you're craving something decadent.

The prices are reasonable considering the size of each cookie, especially since one can easily be split between two people. If you like trying creative dessert flavors and don't mind an extra sweet treat every now and then, Crumbl is worth checking out.“

“Thanks goodness PB is finally here close to home 🤩. Now there are truly great and consistent options in pastries and cakes that are excellent treats and for special occasions while being very accessible in this neighborhood. Looking forward to frequent this shop. Favs are coffee drinks, buns with Asian flare i.e. those with red bean and sweet potato fillings. Everything chocolate is excellent... My bias since I love chocolates😜. The Croissant donut is great. Fruit pastries are excellent too. The savory and cheesy items are also great. And the themed and seasonal items are inventive and cute, definitely worth trying. Cannot go wrong with PB's yummy treats 👍“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“Thank you so much for making our engagement cupcake cake! Not only was it beautiful, it was SO delicious!! 😍“

“Lulu's Bakery is absolutely one of the most professional accommodating bakery I have ever dealt with. The quality appearance and taste was phenomenal. My mother's birthday was a success thank you so much I will always use this bakery for all of my parties. Dulce de leche 4 layer cake with jumbo dulce de leche cupcakes!“

“Excellent sitting inside,A/C very comfortable.Excellent food as well.Love this place.“

“We order a bunch of cookies. They were prefect for what we needed and they were extremely accommodating. During our party the folks eating the cookies were in aww of the cookies and wanted to know where we order them from. I told them Bella’s bake shop in Mount Kisco. We have also purchased bread from them at a farmers market and it was delicious! Will continue to purchase products from them. Staff are extremely nice!“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“A lovely and friendly place with delicious pastries and home made French Crepes. It was a pleasure to come and exchange with owner Pierre-Yves. Undoubtedly a place to come !“

“The food is really good and the place very pretty inside with great service. They have homemade pound cake that is so good and fresh.. I love it and will come back soon for sure. Great place for hang out with family and friends.“

“Fantastic, good quality gf options! Lovely store front with both amazing gluten free options (scones, cookies, bread, sandwich’s, and other goodies!) and a cafe with coffees, teas, matcha). I always look forward to visiting.“

“The best specialty cookies ever. Jess pays such close attention to detail in her work. The cake pops are beautiful and delicious- best I have ever had and my guests agreed! She is extremely responsive and attentive. Go to Just Desserts by Jess for all of your needs!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I cannot say enough wonderful things about this bakery and the incredible service they provided for our wedding.

We decided somewhat last minute that we wanted a wedding cake, and they were able to accommodate our request on a very tight timeline. There was a small rush fee, which was completely understandable, and absolutely worth it. From the moment we spoke with them, they were professional, helpful, and committed to making our vision come to life.

What made the experience even more special was that the cake design was essentially a freestyle cherry blossom theme. We trusted their creativity, and they exceeded every expectation. The cake was absolutely stunning and became one of the most beautiful details of our wedding.

As gorgeous as the cake looked, the flavor was even better. We chose a two-tier cake with chocolate cake and cannoli filling on one tier, and yellow cake with fresh raspberry filling on the other. Both were phenomenal. The flavors were perfectly balanced, rich without being heavy, and sweet without being overpowering. The icing complemented the cake beautifully rather than overwhelming it.

To be completely honest, it was one of the best cakes I've ever had. Many wedding cakes look beautiful but don't necessarily taste amazing. This cake delivered both. Our guests loved it, and we received numerous compliments throughout the evening.

Thank you for accommodating us on short notice and creating such a beautiful and delicious centerpiece for our wedding celebration. We are so grateful and would highly recommend this bakery to anyone looking for exceptional quality, creativity, and customer service.“

“Excellent service, taste and decorations. LOVE LOVE-LOVE THEM Thank you“

“I am NYC born & raised but moved out of state. Happened to find this amazing bakery on a visit to NYC. I am beyond pleased with ALL the treats I purchased.“

“Amazing birthday cake for my 2-year old princess. Delicious and fun. Well priced for the quality. Definitely would recommend!! Also extra large chocolate chip cookies were incredible. Big hit in my house. Yummy!“

“I got a few goodies at the Philly GF Expo and they are so delicious! I have Celiac Disease & had no reaction ❤️“

“I would like to recommend Amato bread, I ordered the Eggplant, Mozzarella and Prosciutto on a fresh roll with Balsamic glaze. It was delicious and Joe the owner was very friendly and accommodating.“

“The most delicious mother daughter dynamic duo! Always delicious and cant get enough of everything they make. It’s too good!“

“I am genuinely surprised by some of the negative reviews. I decided to visit the bakery on a whim because my usual one was closed, and I was needed a cake and some sweets. I had the chance to meet one of the owners, who was incredibly sweet and friendly. She was incredibly patient as I placed my order, which included a multitude of items. My family and I were happy with the cake, and the mini chocolate, passionfruit, and mixed berry mouse cakes that we ate. Not to mention, I also got a loaf of bread, which was sooo tasty!! I will definitely be back!“

“I stopped to get a Dominican cake for a special birthday, when I walked in she greeted me and everything looked delicious I settled for a cake and Carolina wrote HB beautifully, the cake was delicious and not overly sweet just perfect. Am glad I gave this place a try 👏👏“

“Day, is amazing!!! She is always welcoming, always such a pleasure to see her smiling face. No matter how many people are lined up and waiting to be helped, she always approaches each and everyone with a smile, with curtesy and professionalism. My visit here, including today, is a wonderful experience, not just because of the sweets, but also her positivity of serving food and nourishment. Great experience. Thank you Day, for showing the best part of you. Rena“

“OMG! This place! I cant BELIEVE ive lived in Harrison for 25 years and never knew this amazing little nugget stayed open at night with a bubbly staff, the most amazing Sfiogatelle and coffee fresh and brewed to perfection…not too strong, not even slightly burnt! My hubby had the italian cheesecake…also delicious. Im on my way there now…in a storm! (YES THAT GOOD) :)“

“The best Gluten-free bakery I have ever tried, super fluffy and tasty, fresh right out of the oven. The cinnamon bread and cupcakes are out of this world!“

“I’m so glad I found Flourish Baking Company! I needed cupcakes for my daughter’s daycare birthday celebration, and they had to be completely free of nuts, eggs, and other allergens.

The website was incredibly easy to use, and Diane even called to confirm a few details, which I really appreciated. They were also very accommodating with my preferred pickup date and time.

Most importantly, the cupcakes were absolutely delicious, something that’s not always guaranteed with allergy-friendly treats.

I would highly recommend Flourish Baking Company to anyone looking for safe and great-tasting baked goods!“

“Tight space, friendly, helpful. Food is baked goods, Italian American pastries, cookies, and probably need to order cake ahead of time. Perfect place for someone who wants dessert to go. Traditional, old school Italian bakery that reminds me of Arthur Avenue, Bronx and Mulberry Street, Little Italy, Manhattan. Parking on Wheeler is extremely busy on a Saturday. The store is cute. All your favorite Italian American pastries and cookies are available here... especially cannolis, rainbow cookies, and biscotti.“

“We couldn’t help but peek inside after passing by the storefront. Ended up getting a matcha cream pie and key lime pie. Love how the flavors shine through without being too overpowering and with a good amount of sweetness! Lovely service as well.“

“Cute neighborhood spot that gives classic feel as soon as you entered. This spot is cash or check only, only street parking, and no seating. We got the almond danish and onion bread; danish was outstanding while the onion was average though we paid $24 for both so its pretty good value. Would come back again to try the jelly donut!“

“Amazing high quality bread and pastries that are comparable to any top bakery in NY, San Francisco or Paris. The croissant was buttery and flaky and not too sweet and the coffee was excellent. The service staff was sweet and friendly.
There’s only seating outside so mostly for takeout.“

“The food is amazing! The portions are plentiful and the quality is top notch. Prices are very reasonable! Cappuccino was perfect, hot and delicious! Top it off with excellent service, (thanks Andrea!) in a warm and welcoming environment and this was a five star experience. We will be back!“

“Everything I’ve ever gotten here is delicious, but the green goddess dressing I picked up today? AMAZING. I don’t know what they put in this stuff, but it’s worth every penny. I put it on every component of our dinner tonight — chicken, broccoli, roasted potatoes — and it’s perfection.“

“HAVING JUST MOVED TO OSSINING, NY ONLY 7 MOS BEFORE, IT WAS A MIRACLE TO DISCOVER DEL SOL SWEET BAKERY, 10+++! WHEN I COULDNT DECIDE BETWEEN TWO FILLINGS, OWNER, LUCIO SUGGESTED COULD DO BOTH- PRODUCING THE MOST FABULOUS, GORGEOUS, MOUTHWATERING CAKE ANYONE HAD EVER SEEN OR TASTED! ???????????????? PLUS WHEN COULD ONLY TAKE DELIVERY FOR THIS VERY SPECIAL HUGE BIRTHDAY EVENT DATE ON A MONDAY- HE FOUND A WAY, BECAUSE FINISHED CAKE SO FRESH, BUT PRRISHABLE -TO DELIVER ON A MONDAY- AND SO MADE ALL MY DREAMS COME TRUE!?❣️? + A MILLION ?sOs!“

“Wonderful owner and talented baker!“

“What a wonderful place. First of all, the cakes and cookies are out of this world - pure indulgence. I've bought them as gifts for friends and they've been blown away. Even better, though, is that everything is lovingly baked by adults with special needs and volunteers. I can't wait for them to have a regular retail space.“

“A friend of mine who lives in Connecticut told me about a bread bakery he loves that recently opened in Scarsdale. I sampled some breads a d bought some cinnamon buns that were delicious.i was disappointed that they didn’t sell any cookies! What’s a bakery without cookies and coffee!“

“My family has been enjoying Anna's Bakery for as long as I can remember. We have never been disappointed and everything is always delicious!“

“1. The taro-flavored bubble tea that the lady made was the most delicious out of all the places I've ever tried. I always buy it every time I go.
2. Glutinous rice donut. The walnut bread is chewy and delicious too.
3. Some days, they are sold out quickly, so you have to buy them in advance from the bakery as soon as you enter the supermarket🙌“

“So it turns out every single babka I've ever eaten in my life was a disappointment until I had this babka. I cannot thank you enough for bringing this into my life and setting the bar so high. I wish ya'll nothing but great business and many years of success because ya'll are baking beautiful things. How do I order more babka? Can you bake me a house made of babka?“

“The quintessential bakery, best Black and Whites, Napoleons and Eclairs, and so much more, served with a smile.“

“Just had a delicious visit to Nothing yBundt Cakes in Hartsdale, N.Y. Not only are the cakes a easy design, but they are so moist and light they are a pleasure to eat in the am with a cup of coffee or tea. My wife and I say yummy, yummy, yummy to Nothig Bundt Cakes ad best wishes in sales lDies.“

“Tasty food, great art, wonderful proprietor! 😁“

“Best Mexican tortas, right across from a hospital you will definitely get your moneys worth if you stop here for a meal. Prices are cheap you cant beat them. Mexican bread pan dulce also available you can have a beer with your meals. Street parking is the only issue“

“Absolutely Thrilled! Fast, Perfect Cake & Kind Service!
We were absolutely thrilled with our experience at the Great American Cookie Company location in the Palisades Mall!
From start to finish, the entire team was exceptional. Everyone we encountered was so kind and creative, truly making my dream cake a reality. I placed my order for the cake the night before, and it was perfect, fast, and ready right on time for pickup.
A massive shout-out and thank you to Marlene, Jamie, and Saniyah—your speed, creativity, and service made this a fantastic experience. Highly recommend this location!“

“Love my mornings at First Village Coffee. It's like my daily recommended dose of good vibes all around!“