44 Best Sandwich Shops near Bay Village

“I got my son a black forest ham sandwich and myself a club, but that wasn't the best part. I left my debit card there for the second time in 3 weeks they called the bank and by the time I got to my house I got a call from the bank letting me know what I had done and I drove back and got my card. I love this community.“

“Great bagel sandwiches. Bagels were steamed and soft. Great toppings and flavor.“

“Lehman's made an awesome Danish Layer Cake for my husband! I told them he was a fisherman and hunter and they decorated it accordingly. Tasted great. Thanks so much! see photos in comments“

“You had me at bacon jam… phenomenal turkey sandwich with top notch fixings! The fresh fruit had blueberries, cherries, dragonfruit, peaches, and black raspberries 🤩 The oatmeal cream pie didn’t make it out of the parking lot 😋 Soooo good!!!!“

“The staff here is extremely kind and accommodating. The restaurant is clean and has plenty of seating available if you want to enjoy your meal inside. The food is fresh and it is definitely one of the best cheesesteaks in town. Highly recommend the Chicken California and the Bacon 3 Cheese as must try options.“

“I came in and it wasn't busy at 4:30 pm on a Wednesday.Cashier was nice and made a good recommendation.I got the romanburger and it didn't disappoint.I also got waffle fries (they call them waffers) with cheese sauce to dip it in (my first time dipping in cheese).It's definitely a fast food restaurant, so set your expectations accordingly, but overall I was impressed. I would definitely eat here again.“

“Ordered around 11:35am on line for a 12:30 curbside pickup I got there around 12:22 and asked if it was too early to pick up the order. They must have been busy I was on hold for a couple minutes the gentleman came out and asked if I was the one that ordered and he said that their computer system was down and they did not get any notification I showed him my copy he said okay give me a couple minutes and I'll bring it out stay right here about 10 minutes later he comes out brings me my order and everything was fine. Very friendly and polite I'll definitely order from there again.“

“This was my first experience with McAlister's. Deli and I will definitely be returning. The North Olmsted location did an awesome job with my party platters, from help ordering thru pickup. Thank you for such great service!“

“I just want to give a big thumbs 👍 up, I've been here 5-6 times and it never disappoints, Today I ordered the small original cheese steak as I was waiting on my sandwich and it was accidentally given to another customer, so they upgraded my sandwich to a large and gave me a free Fry, That's what you call great people working there and you guys didn't have to do that I understand mistakes happen, Thank you“

“Was very good! We will be back!“

“So wonderfully CLEAN!!! Great service, atmosphere and food. It’s the only Penn Station we’ll patronize. So CLEAN!!!“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“Nice clean location. They get you in and out. They are always so nice to me, too! Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon before shopping and had some lunch. Their sandwiches are always hot and tasty. I love the pickles, too. Lemonade is delightful, too. Charleys is better than Subway to me. I tried the Cali chicken sub cause i usually got the teriyaki at the mall.! It was awesome. I definitely will stop again when I'm in the hood again!“

“McAlisters provided a wonderful lunch spread to our Eastview Elementary teachers. We are grateful for the assortment of sandwiches, fruit and cookies they delivered. Thank you McAlisters deli, we’ll be back soon!“

“Went there yesterday to get tobacco and tubes somehow every time I go go there lately the price of my hot rod tubes go from 2.19/2.49/4.31 yesterday, I’m on a fixed income !! The tobacco hasn’t changed but if the owner/manager isn’t there they charge me what ever they want“

“My Kids eat Subway 5x + a month for 3 years. The food is always 🔥 the staff is always polite , courteous, super fast, and obviously well trained. The store is always spotless. Now not getting a complaint in 3 years from my kids is a big deal considering complaining is just what they do. Last night I went there to get my usual , the kid behind the counter whipped up 3 🔥 sandwiches in no time flat. Was super cool considering it was 10 minutes to close. I left and realized I forgot my phone , the kid put it in a safe place and notified the kid that opened . He opened 15 min early. Was super nice and handed me my phone with a smile . Love this place.“

“I had never been to a Jersey Mike's until today for their day of giving. I expected the long line and busy atmosphere. I did not expect the staff to be SO efficient. they were a very well oiled machine. I watched them hammer out order after order while taking more orders and did not see a single snafu or mistake during my half hour of watching. Very impressive !!! on top of it I really liked my sandwich. while this location is not convenient for me on a normal basis I would seek out another for another yummy sandwich.“

“I’ve ordered from the Fairview location on Uber a few times, and every time the food is amazing! They must have a great crew, they are very consistent with high quality order prep. My order was made quickly each time as well. If you’re looking for Philly cheese steak, you can’t go wrong here!“

“We ordered delivery and it was great! They even called to confirm our special requests on the sandwiches.Love the romanburger!Must get waffle fries and a cheese cup!Tuna was excellent.The mozzarella sticks were very good!Breaded mushrooms were good!Jalapeno poppers were also good.Everything arrived hot and fresh. Packaged with care in a box!I'd definitely recommend this location! Give it a try!“

“Stopped for a Cheesesteak meal today, 4/22/23 around 5pm. Everything was cooked just right, and delicious. I'll certaintly be going back. Also, staff very friendly and restaurant very clean. Thanks!“

“Stopped in because was craving a meatball sub and heard theirs was good. This sub hit the spot!! The daves sauce on the bottom gave it an amazing tang. Fresh out of the over the bread was perfectly crispy on the outside and soft inside. Great atmosphere inside. Recommend the meatball sub!!“

“I ate from here on back to back day because the Pastrami Sandwich was just that good! The first day I got the Chipotle Mayo one and the classic with mustard on the second day. Awesome sandwiches and I pray they are not a limited time deal. They deserve to make it on the permanent menu. Great job Jimmy Johns.“

“**⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️**
Demia at Penn Station Sub Store in North Olmsted is an absolute gem! From the moment I walked in, her warm smile and genuine enthusiasm made the experience unforgettable. Let’s start with the food: my fries were perfectly crispy and golden, and the cookie? Pure heaven—warm, gooey, and melt-in-your-mouth delicious. But what truly blew me away was Demia’s **INCREDIBLE** customer service. She went above and beyond, patiently answering questions, offering recommendations, and even remembering my name by the end of the order. Her positivity and attentiveness turned a quick lunch stop into something special. Demia, you’ve not only nailed the food game but also won a lifetime customer with your kindness and professionalism. If you’re near Penn Station, stop by—ask for Demia, and prepare to leave happier (and fuller!) than you arrived. Thank you for making my day! 🥪🍟🍪“

“Good place to eat nice staff, and great sandwiches.“

“Honestly the best thing since I’ve switch from the Denison location. Food a lot tastes better! I come in say hello and pick up my food with ease. There was a time I slipped during winter. They were quick to assist the side walk with salt. But still failed to fix their gutters…“

“I live near Vermilion . I called this deli for assistance. My Aunt just died. I wanted to send her family food to ease their daily burden during this difficult time. This deli showed up and put out. They are compassionate understanding and showed up for my family. My family expressed to me how delicious everything was. If you are in need during a family life event you should consider this establishment. They truly, went out of their way to accommodate my family during a time of grief.“

“We went to Penn Station in Avon tonight, where we met Logan. I haven't seen such genuine, friendly customer service in years!! We ordered a chicken teriyaki sub with ghost pepper cheese, a cheese steak sub with ghost pepper cheese, and fries. The ghost pepper cheese had an amazing kick and perfect flavor, and we really enjoyed it! Absolutely delicious and fresh!! Also very generous with the fries! I've already gone back to the menu to decide what I want next. Thank you for a wonderful experience, Logan!!“

“We go to this location fairly often to pick up sandwiches to take to Coe Lake for picnics in the summer. It's a good choice since we are always able to find something that we like and our pickier children will eat. The staff is always friendly and the service is prompt.“

“This mall partners with sports memorabilia scammers. Prime Time Sports and Framing sells fake autographs. I personally purchased 10k worth. If you purchased anything from them, get it look at by a legit company.“

“People r nice n food is great I would go here🍔🍟👍“

“May not have been the best sandwhich I’ve ever had, but it was large and I enjoyed it over two days.

I was more impressed with how helpful the cashier was, and how quickly the food was made. Would definitely come back to this location.“

“very clean and good customer service“

“Excellent restaurant very pleasant staff great food. My sandwich was awesome. As usual I get the tuna sub and I eat half there and half the next day and it wasn't soggy overall, this is a great restaurant and to me it is a little pricey but I get two meals out of it ! And it's worth it for the quality“

“The man that runs this establishment is one of the sweetest kindest men I have ever met in my life. It is one day before my pay day and i have overdraft protection that normally works. My children wanted Mr Hero and i only had 25 dollars. But i knew i get paid tomorrow so if my account goes negative it will be for less than 6 hours. Well my overdraft protection wouldn’t let the payment go through. I felt embarrassed and upset that they prepared food i couldn’t pay for. He didn’t make scene or cause a fuss. He took my 25 dollars and ask i come back and pay him tomorrow. Something most establishments wouldn’t do. I appreciate his kindness and will go in tomorrow and tip very well. Having your card declined is so embarrassing and he was so sweet about it. I will never go in anywhere thinking my bank had me covered ever again. But this was the kindest act I’ve seen in a long time.“

“Stopped by around 7:30 for a few Potbelly sandwiches, was greeted by two very nice young men who were very helpful with my accommodations. Made all the sandwiches perfectly and very quick, will definitely be stopping by again whenever I find myself in Cleveland Airport!!“

“Staff was great and seemed to work well together. They took my order for four subs and waffle fries, made the food, and I was back out the door quickly. Everything in the order was perfect, even with special requests on each sandwich. The whole place looked clean, including the restroom. Excellent experience!“

“The owner was absolutely amazing! My husband enjoys having staff fix up a veggie sub for him--their choice on what to add, etc. and the owner whipped up the best veggie sub he's ever had at a Subway restaurant.

The store was clean and well stocked. There was courteous staff who made suggestions for better deals from Subway for the choices we made for sandwiches. Had a great conversation and will definitely keep this location on our radar for when we pass through the area again.“

“Love it love it love it yeah“

“If you go to this location early between like 8:45 - 11 You're gonna get a good sub even if you order it on the app. Their is a older woman who has been working mornings for over a decade here and she actually cares about making the sandwich good.“

“big kahuna oh yeah baby! that's what Bobo like“

“My wife and I eat there once a week as a date for us the staff is awesome and the food is great,they do a wonderful job there great great service!“

“Helpful staff, delicious food, and incredible location all come together to make Dave's in Toledo a soom to be staple of our downtown landscape! The downtown area has needed something like this for a long time.“

“Clean and inviting dining area and approach to fast food counter service sandwich restaurant (non-drive-thru). Not too much parking available at this one, but friendly employees!

Parking: Not a high number of spots to park, but I didn't ever have to park in a different parking lot (so, I guess I can't complain)!“