Sandwich Shops near Sheffield Lake

“The young lady that made my sub was as good as they get. She was very fast and very attentive to each requested item. I was impressed with her job skills along with her attitude toward the job itself. This young lady could teach others in this field of work for sure.

Vegetarian options: You can choose any veggie sub you would like.“

“Thanksgiving meal was absolutely delicious! Looking forward to trying more in the future!“

“This Quiznos is absolutely fantastic!! I was greeted with friendly staff, an expensive menu, and clean restaurant. The owners take pride in their food quality and it shows. I ordered the Black Angus Combo and it was exceptional!! Steaming hot, perfect crunch on the toasted bread, and tender steak. If you want a bite of Nostalgia, come to this Quiznos!! They'll keep you full and happy. I will 100% be back!!“

“Good food yum! I so missed being able to come here delicious! Shake was very good!“

“I love Charlie’s. It’s good. But every time I order they always mess it up. I get a chicken Philly, everything on it and add cold jalapeños. They never give me the jalapeños even though it’s on the receipt, one time they gave me a steak Philly. Today was the final straw when I broke down what I wanted, and read the receipt afterward. I was given a chicken California which has ranch and I hate ranch. I was the only one at the restaurant. With how expensive they are, they need to start getting the orders right“

“Everything about this restaurant was great. The place was clean and smelled good. The staff and greeter was very nice. The food was fresh and awesome. Then we also had brownies and that was really good as well. Great atmosphere with really nice people.“

“The lady behind the counter was all by herself. And we happened to stop in after church,before heading to a play nearby. This lady was not only cool under pressure of a line,but she was really good at her job. She got all of our orders right,and did so with a smile. This location DEFINITELY needs some cosmetic upgrades,but it's a clean, convenient location for a quick bite!!“

“I would have given them a 5 star service but the young lady forgot my cheese sauce! However, my Roman w/Crispy BACON was 5 STARS! Waffle fries were hot too but, no cheese (at .99) landed them in the garbage.

Parking: There are several businesses in this area that share the same lot.

Wheelchair accessibility: There’s handicapped parking and no steps.“

“I recently visited the Mr. Hero location in Sheffield Village and had a fantastic experience. The food was absolutely great, and the store was spotless. The staff at the storefront were wonderful and really made my visit enjoyable with their friendly demeanor. They recommended I try the Waffle Doodle sandwich, and I have to say, it’s the greatest sandwich Mr. Hero has to offer! While I love the Roman Burger, the Waffle Doodle Chicken Bacon sandwich might just be my new favorite. The staff also mentioned trying their Nashville hot sauce sandwich on my next visit, and I’m definitely looking forward to that. Mr. Hero’s Roman Burger is already one of the best things you can find anywhere, and now I’d highly recommend trying both the Roman Burger and the Waffle Doodle. I can’t wait to come back!“

“First time I have ever been here. The food is fresh and delicious! I had a small gyro and fried pickles. My bf had a large gyro. I recommend ❤️“

“Absolutely love the owner & his coworkers! Store is ALWAYS clean!! Service is top of the line! Food is always presentable, hot and made right!!! I go out of my way for this location over the ones that are even closer to home!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!“

“McAlister's is a nice drive through or dine in restaurant deli. They do not offer a selection like a regular "deli". It is more of a deli style restaurant selection. The food is good and the staff and kind and customer service oriented. Reasonably priced. Recommend

Vegetarian options: There is a whole section of good salads and baked potatoes that can be made vegetarian.“

“I called about ordering like over the telephone and they literally were getting ready to close and said it's saying you know and now you you can't I said so can I come in and order she was like oh yes they literally waited for me to come in and order another closing to me that's great customer service and she was so sweet“

“been eating at this subway for 5 years now, and i can say with joy it's very nice. Although some trash from past customers are sometimes left around - that's not to say it isn't a great place for fresh tasty food. The staff are very kind as well and are very patient !!“

“I had their food for the first time today. The staff were super helpful recommend8ng things for me to try. It seemed kinda empty when i went in but picked up quick as i sat there eating.awesome food, super clean, great staff i will 100% be back“

“I stop by this location often. The service far exceeds any other location that I visit. The place is super clean always. The employees are always so friendly and top notch. Shout out to Hope and Faith. You two lovelies rock!! Love me some Avon Jimmy John's!“

“I order here alot during the work week. It's almost always quick & on time! The delivery lady is ALWAYS friendly! During COVID they were short staffed as everyone was/is she would always apologize if she was late even though it truly wasn't her fault it was late. Keep up the great work!! Please remember to tip well- it's usually not the drivers fault your food is incorrect or late“

“We went to Penn Station in Avon tonight, where we met Logan. I haven't seen such genuine, friendly customer service in years!! We ordered a chicken teriyaki sub with ghost pepper cheese, a cheese steak sub with ghost pepper cheese, and fries. The ghost pepper cheese had an amazing kick and perfect flavor, and we really enjoyed it! Absolutely delicious and fresh!! Also very generous with the fries! I've already gone back to the menu to decide what I want next. Thank you for a wonderful experience, Logan!!“

“I had never been to a Jersey Mike's until today for their day of giving. I expected the long line and busy atmosphere. I did not expect the staff to be SO efficient. they were a very well oiled machine. I watched them hammer out order after order while taking more orders and did not see a single snafu or mistake during my half hour of watching. Very impressive !!! on top of it I really liked my sandwich. while this location is not convenient for me on a normal basis I would seek out another for another yummy sandwich.“

“I live near Vermilion . I called this deli for assistance. My Aunt just died. I wanted to send her family food to ease their daily burden during this difficult time. This deli showed up and put out. They are compassionate understanding and showed up for my family. My family expressed to me how delicious everything was. If you are in need during a family life event you should consider this establishment. They truly, went out of their way to accommodate my family during a time of grief.“

“It was great. The employee who waited on me liked my truck, so a little bias. Seriously the only draw back is getting to this place. The way the traffic flows in parking lot is weird but definitely doesn't take away from the taste of the food. I had a sub.

Parking: Spots in front of the store. Also a drive thru.

Wheelchair accessibility: Newer building handicap parking available or use the drive thru“

“The lady that serve me today was excellent she was so professional the place was spotless she gave me a sandwich that was exactly what I wanted and I haven't had a Subway and a couple years I will definitely be returning there very soon having just moved to this area.“

“I want to give a huge shout out to the amazing employees who literally came out in this horrible weather and helped me get my car unstuck!! You did not have to but you did. Thank you so much you are amazing!!“

“Just had my first sandwich, very good! The cosmo sauce was really tasty, had the big Dave. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Staff was great and seemed to work well together. They took my order for four subs and waffle fries, made the food, and I was back out the door quickly. Everything in the order was perfect, even with special requests on each sandwich. The whole place looked clean, including the restroom. Excellent experience!“

“Quick and tasty. Made to order with a few changes that they executed perfectly. Our first time going to a Penn Station will definitely be returning. Just don't expect it to look like the website as with any fast food marketing. Staff was very friendly quite“

“It was great nice workers and food was warm“

“This Subway definitely stands out among the others in the area for sure. I live in Lakewood, but attend college at LCCC, and I always choose to go to this one. The staff is always extremely friendly and helpful, but my experience yesterday was amazing. I walked in, was greeted, and I started ordering. I forget their name, but the person making my sandwich for me was one of the nicest people I’ve met. They held a conversation for me and made my sandwich perfectly. Their nails were immensely pretty, I do remember that. 5/5 Subway for sure.

Parking: Plenty of parking in the lot in front of the store“

“Every single time I've ordered from here, it's been a worldly difference than any other Subway I've dined at. I'm 36 and have been chowing on Subway since I was a young fella, so I've eaten at quite a few of these establishments in the U.S.

Yesterday, 02/28/2025, I picked up an online order and even though the interaction was short, the gal and gentlemen working were having fun, hard at work, gave positive engagement and of course when I got home, the sandwich was made to quite literal perfection.

I do remember the store was very clean and like the other visits, you could feel the warmth in the atmosphere when walking in. Surely will be using this location as my to-go-to. Management should be very proud.“

“The food is amazing, this is the only place that you are going to find this taste it's delicious, be careful though if you order a large meal it will be 20 dollars but you'll get 2 burgers the size of a double Q lbs with cheese at mcdonalds, a full basket of fries and a delicious cup of cheese, more than enough cheese trust me for the fries and a large drink, more than enough food for the price for sure. The customer service was also decent, they seem like good people.“

“My favorite subway of all time! I travel for work and am constantly eating on the road and have been to many different subways but this location is the best. All the workers have good customer service skills, especially a younger girl with glasses and darker hair. I was making a group order during lunch time (it was busy) and she was very polite and patient with me and I did not feel rushed.“

“We rode over here to get lunch, and our cashier was very nice. He said it was his first day, so it affected my rating of this place. He didn’t give us a bag, stamp our sandwiches, and he put a little too much of something on my sandwich. Overall, very good experience.“

“Food was good but I have to say an employee named Tara made my day. I had a super long and complex order and she was extremely patient and helped to make sure my order was correct. She was so kind, welcoming, and engaging. Honestly was best experience I've ever had at a subway period. Shout out to Tara you made my day and the sandwiches were delicious :)“

“Changed my mind! Recently I had a not so wonderful experience but I also was in a foul mood that day. No cheese on my sub. But I chose this restaurant again because they take coupons and gift cards with QR codes. It was a wonderful experience this time. Jacob made my sandwich. The only issue was I wanted the halves wrapped separately and when I got home they were not. But the sub was wonderful absolutely! Made to my specific requirements. Thank you Jacob!“

“We took our lunch here today while enroute home. It's a clean facility, bright and fresh. Associates are professional and very efficient. They were fast in taking and getting the orders. Cleaning up crew was fast and clean too. We enjoyed our lunch.“