Sandwich Shops near Sheffield

“I’ve tried the Chicken Philly at various Mr. Hero locations, but this branch truly stands out! The sandwich here was exceptional perfect. The cheese was melted to perfection , blending beautifully with the tender chicken and caramelized onions. 😋😋😋

The staff was friendly, and the service was quick, ensuring the sandwich was served hot and fresh.“

“We took our lunch here today while enroute home. It's a clean facility, bright and fresh. Associates are professional and very efficient. They were fast in taking and getting the orders. Cleaning up crew was fast and clean too. We enjoyed our lunch.“

“There was a sweet girl working the drive thru tonight dishing out compliments while working on my dinner order. A wonderful experience because of her, and of course yummy sandwiches too.“

“One word… outstanding! The beef sammich, the corn chowder, the chips and homemade dip and the star of the show lol the peanut butter cookie! All of it was amazing!! 11/10 ⭐️“

“I first visited this Quiznos location about 10 years ago when working for a client in the area. The owners are always friendly, polite and professional. They also have a great memory - despite my not working in this area as much lately they remember my usual order. The food is consistently excellent and prepared accurately. I'm happy to be able to continue to patronize this location, and look forward to being able to do so for another 10 years!“

“Ate here on a whim on our way back from Columbus. We decided let’s choose a local restaurant instead of a big chain. Glad we did because the oh boy burger was awesome! That sauce is amazing!“

“Great food and kind employees!y My daughter dropped her ice cream and before I said a word they were waking over to her with a fresh cone! 🥰 it’s the little things!!! And kindness makes our world go around!“

“Everything about this restaurant was great. The place was clean and smelled good. The staff and greeter was very nice. The food was fresh and awesome. Then we also had brownies and that was really good as well. Great atmosphere with really nice people.“

“I would have given them a 5 star service but the young lady forgot my cheese sauce! However, my Roman w/Crispy BACON was 5 STARS! Waffle fries were hot too but, no cheese (at .99) landed them in the garbage.

Parking: There are several businesses in this area that share the same lot.

Wheelchair accessibility: There’s handicapped parking and no steps.“

“Did online order because we get so hungry waiting 😂. Everything was awesome. the order was correct. the staff was nice. They're in a tough competition with the Broadview brookpark store ♥️ some of the stores I visit have not been so correct per say but these two are definitely spot on... Elyria and Broadview brookpark store ♥️
🏴♥️🇺🇸💥🎉🥳“

“First time I have ever been here. The food is fresh and delicious! I had a small gyro and fried pickles. My bf had a large gyro. I recommend ❤️“

“McAlisters provided a wonderful lunch spread to our Eastview Elementary teachers. We are grateful for the assortment of sandwiches, fruit and cookies they delivered. Thank you McAlisters deli, we’ll be back soon!“

“The lady behind the counter was all by herself. And we happened to stop in after church,before heading to a play nearby. This lady was not only cool under pressure of a line,but she was really good at her job. She got all of our orders right,and did so with a smile. This location DEFINITELY needs some cosmetic upgrades,but it's a clean, convenient location for a quick bite!!“

“I had their food for the first time today. The staff were super helpful recommend8ng things for me to try. It seemed kinda empty when i went in but picked up quick as i sat there eating.awesome food, super clean, great staff i will 100% be back“

“I had never been to a Jersey Mike's until today for their day of giving. I expected the long line and busy atmosphere. I did not expect the staff to be SO efficient. they were a very well oiled machine. I watched them hammer out order after order while taking more orders and did not see a single snafu or mistake during my half hour of watching. Very impressive !!! on top of it I really liked my sandwich. while this location is not convenient for me on a normal basis I would seek out another for another yummy sandwich.“

“Jacob, the GM at the Crocker Park location of Dave’s Cosmic Subs, made our recent catering order so easy. We were hosting a gathering of friends and family the evening before my son’s recent wedding. Our order was not a complicated one, but involved a lot of sandwich construction! 18 platters of subs were neatly and carefully prepared and packaged for pickup without any problem. I really liked Jacob’s positive and friendly, ready-to-please personality when I came in to inquire about such a large order. The sandwiches were a hit the night of our party and we have Jacob and his staff to thank for the great service and delicious taste. Thank you!“

“been eating at this subway for 5 years now, and i can say with joy it's very nice. Although some trash from past customers are sometimes left around - that's not to say it isn't a great place for fresh tasty food. The staff are very kind as well and are very patient !!“

“I live near Vermilion . I called this deli for assistance. My Aunt just died. I wanted to send her family food to ease their daily burden during this difficult time. This deli showed up and put out. They are compassionate understanding and showed up for my family. My family expressed to me how delicious everything was. If you are in need during a family life event you should consider this establishment. They truly, went out of their way to accommodate my family during a time of grief.“

“Quick and tasty. Made to order with a few changes that they executed perfectly. Our first time going to a Penn Station will definitely be returning. Just don't expect it to look like the website as with any fast food marketing. Staff was very friendly quite“

“We went to Penn Station in Avon tonight, where we met Logan. I haven't seen such genuine, friendly customer service in years!! We ordered a chicken teriyaki sub with ghost pepper cheese, a cheese steak sub with ghost pepper cheese, and fries. The ghost pepper cheese had an amazing kick and perfect flavor, and we really enjoyed it! Absolutely delicious and fresh!! Also very generous with the fries! I've already gone back to the menu to decide what I want next. Thank you for a wonderful experience, Logan!!“

“I order here alot during the work week. It's almost always quick & on time! The delivery lady is ALWAYS friendly! During COVID they were short staffed as everyone was/is she would always apologize if she was late even though it truly wasn't her fault it was late. Keep up the great work!! Please remember to tip well- it's usually not the drivers fault your food is incorrect or late“

“I called about ordering like over the telephone and they literally were getting ready to close and said it's saying you know and now you you can't I said so can I come in and order she was like oh yes they literally waited for me to come in and order another closing to me that's great customer service and she was so sweet“

“Good place to eat nice staff, and great sandwiches.“

“The lady that serve me today was excellent she was so professional the place was spotless she gave me a sandwich that was exactly what I wanted and I haven't had a Subway and a couple years I will definitely be returning there very soon having just moved to this area.“

“It was great nice workers and food was warm“

“My order was not taken. It looked like the whole restaurant was being run by one worker. That is so unfair to them. They were veryyyyy polite and said sorry about the wait. What is going on with staffing here? The food is amazing but you can’t expect one person to do everything.“

“Excellent as usual and freaky fast !! 😊😊😊“

“When I first went, my sub was very messed up, the majority of the vegetables weren’t even in the bread, but in the paper. Plus the bread wasn’t even cut in half. After I went back and mentioned the issue, Darcy not only made me a new sandwich, but apologized for the other employees mistake. Darcy was phenomenal and extremely helpful.“

“Staff was great and seemed to work well together. They took my order for four subs and waffle fries, made the food, and I was back out the door quickly. Everything in the order was perfect, even with special requests on each sandwich. The whole place looked clean, including the restroom. Excellent experience!“

“Just had my first sandwich, very good! The cosmo sauce was really tasty, had the big Dave. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Employee was great with a positive attitude. She was the only staff on duty and busy as all get out. They need a second person. The wait was long but service was great. I could see i few others in line behind me getting antsy. Two staff should be on duty.“

“Probably one of the better subways I've been to. Bread was super fresh, it made the entire building smell great. They put the perfect amount of meats and extra toppings on it. The girl at the register was super kind. Place was very clean.“

“The food is amazing, this is the only place that you are going to find this taste it's delicious, be careful though if you order a large meal it will be 20 dollars but you'll get 2 burgers the size of a double Q lbs with cheese at mcdonalds, a full basket of fries and a delicious cup of cheese, more than enough cheese trust me for the fries and a large drink, more than enough food for the price for sure. The customer service was also decent, they seem like good people.“

“First time here. On a Sunday around 12:30-ish. They were busy the cashier was a younger girl who went out of her way to answer questions I had and explain anything else. I ran my drinks out to my car and here comes the young lady from the kitchen with my food! She was the absolute sweetest super long black hair I wish I had caught her name. Literally it took 5 minutes or less for them to have it ready! Got home both my husband & I agreed the Phillys were fantastic! Everything was fresh as were the fries. Will go back as we only live about 4 minutes up the road!!! THANK YOU!“

“Every single time I've ordered from here, it's been a worldly difference than any other Subway I've dined at. I'm 36 and have been chowing on Subway since I was a young fella, so I've eaten at quite a few of these establishments in the U.S.

Yesterday, 02/28/2025, I picked up an online order and even though the interaction was short, the gal and gentlemen working were having fun, hard at work, gave positive engagement and of course when I got home, the sandwich was made to quite literal perfection.

I do remember the store was very clean and like the other visits, you could feel the warmth in the atmosphere when walking in. Surely will be using this location as my to-go-to. Management should be very proud.“

“Food was good but I have to say an employee named Tara made my day. I had a super long and complex order and she was extremely patient and helped to make sure my order was correct. She was so kind, welcoming, and engaging. Honestly was best experience I've ever had at a subway period. Shout out to Tara you made my day and the sandwiches were delicious :)“

“If you go to this location early between like 8:45 - 11 You're gonna get a good sub even if you order it on the app. Their is a older woman who has been working mornings for over a decade here and she actually cares about making the sandwich good.“

“I always get the same sandwich at every subway I go to. This was BY FAR the best one I have ever had. proportions were exactly what I wanted and it just tasted SO good. The woman working there was so nice and friendly. Overall amazing experience.“

“I placed an order with Andrea the Manager and what a lovely experience I had. I was stressed with the holiday rush and I ended up ordering cookies last minute for my family party. Andrea made me feel at ease and I can’t be thankful enough.“