50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Hamilton

“The wife and I drove from Brampton to Hamilton just to try Tony G's pizza. I'll tell you....the heavy traffic and an hour and a half drive was welllll worth it!! The pizza was totally awesome and the guys working that day were so friendly. Awesome place....atmosphere....employees... And most of all....Awesome pizza!!! Well done Tony G's We'll be back for sure!!“

“Excellent pizza and great service, I give it a perfect review“

“NATIONAL PIZZA UPPER JAMES. Umpiring a baseball game and needed food on way home at 1145 PM.. Call National pizza and boss says he will wait for me as they close at 12 am. Haven't been here for over 20 years. Pepperoni and onion and extra cheese. And it was extra cheese. No skimping on the cheese. Just a fantastic pizza and this guy has owned it for 18 yrs. Even my daughter who is not a lover of pizza but will eat it, just thought this was fabulous. Great service and super friendly. The whole staff. HATS OFF TO NATIONAL PIZZA UPPER JAMES IN HAMILTON“

“First time in today! AMAZING FOOD! I had the falafel and lentil soup! Very very good! They also have a great menu!“

“Great pizza. We have come to Hamilton twice for pizza sampling. We visited 7 pizza the first time and came back to try 5 more including the champ again. Flora's has come out on top both times.“

“ASIDE FROM OUR SURVICE BEING VERY POOR. THE FOOD AND DRINKS WERE AMAZING ? AND WELL WORTH ANOTHER VISIT ?“

“I visited the pizza store where Joban works, and I had a great experience. The pizza was fresh, hot, and delicious, with plenty of cheese and toppings. The staff, including Joban, were friendly and helpful. The store was clean and organized, and the service was fast. I felt welcome and enjoyed my meal. Overall, this pizza store is a great place to eat, and I would recommend it to anyone who likes tasty pizza and good service.“

“Awesome family run pizza and wings Lots of parking“

“Had to try Bonito's with my lady. We tried different pizza's so we can share and all I can say is, once you try the awesome goodness of true Italian flavor, you will be going back. Oh and don't forget the Gelato. All exquisite!“

“Absolutely amazing, my husband and I only recently came across Sasso and decided to give it a try, we were very impressed. From the staff to the food and everything in between we have had nothing but an exceptional experience, however it helps that our server Erika is beyond amazing at her job and is really one of the best servers we’ve ever had.“

“Freaking amazing pizza - my daughter and I came here to try the pizza and we were blown away. We had a couple of drinks and the bee sting pizza and the meat mountain pizza, both were fantastic, and the crust - oh my god - they get their wheat from some specialty place. They also have gluten free options I saw but I have not tried that. The staff was very friendly and helpful with suggestions. It was nice to see staff that cared. I wish I could remember the server's name to give them credit.“

“Order came quickly with no fuss and was so great that me and my daughter both ordered a second.good stuff,the staff was attentive to my daughter's food requirements and provided excellent solutions to accommodate her.very happy with the service and quality of the food“

“I absolutely love this pizza store. They are fabulous people. They always treat me so good. They are so loving and warm and are so genuinely happy to see me when they do. And plus the food is AMAZING. Great people great pizza.

-Brittany 🩷“

“Family-owned gem with amazing pizza and deep fried panzerotti. Always fresh and made with love!“

“Tonight, we went to East Side Mario’s Winona Crossing to celebrate our son’s 3rd birthday, and we had such an amazing experience from start to finish!

We were greeted at the door, and every staff member we encountered was happy, welcoming, and genuinely friendly. Our server, Sydney, was absolutely top-notch! She was bubbly, attentive, and right on time with everything. She even brought out bread right away when she noticed we had two little ones with us — such a thoughtful touch that didn’t go unnoticed!

The food came out hot, fresh, and delicious. I was honestly shocked by the size of my chicken Parmesan portion, and it was so tasty! The salads were also a great size, even as refills.

Every other staff member we interacted with was equally kind and friendly to both us and our boys. The birthday song and special birthday cake were such a hit! It made our son’s day, and the cake was delicious, too!

Between the outstanding service, generous portions, delicious food, and the kids-eat-free deal, we felt like we got incredible value for our money.

Honestly, it was refreshing to go out and experience a team of people who genuinely seemed to care about their jobs and the families they were serving. That kind of service makes all the difference, especially when dining out with young kids.

A huge thank-you to Sydney and the entire team for making our son’s birthday so special! We will absolutely be back, and we’ll definitely be recommending East Side Mario’s to our friends and family. Keep up the amazing work! ❤“

“I have patronized this store for over 8 years. The previous owner was in the store every morning at 5:00 to make the pizza dough for the day. It was great.
During COVID times, the walk-in special of a medium pepperoni pizza was only $5.00 as the restaurant struggled to survive!

After COVID, a new owner took over the restaurant and quality of the crust declined immediately. I stopped going there.

A few weeks ago as I was walking home, I thought I would give them another try. I was pleasantly surprised that the crust quality had improved - not quite as good as it originally was but it was quite a lot better. The walkin special is now around $9.99 which is still competitive for Hamilton. If it keeps improving I will increase my rating!“

“This is a pretty solid pizza joint! Owner is a great guy. The inside of the store is very cool, lots of decorations to admire while waiting for your food.

The pizza is great. I had no complaints

The only thing is that they are pricier than other places around, but if you have some extra dollars to spare, its definitely worth it!“

“Last night we tried Chicago Style Pizza in Hamilton ontario, we had the combo bread appetizer, which is half garlic bread and half bruschetta, it was PERFECT! We ordered the deep dish pizza, which I think was called the stuffed pizza, with one half of the pizza having pepperoni and green peppers and mushrooms on the entire pizza, and it was also PERFECT! The waitress was the BEST waitress I have ever had in my entire life, all the staff were smiling, happy, so kind, and so professional, felt like we were with family 💖 The restaurant was cozy, the right temperature, so clean, and the volume of the music playing was perfect, you can hear each other talking ☺ Thanks so much to Chicago Style Pizza in Hamilton ontario for the amazing service!“

“That pizza was awesome. Thin crust. Big slices. Cupped pepperonis. And sesame seeds around the crust. I've never had pizza like this before and it was great.“

“Great food great service very friendly staff Bita“

“1st time there since 2019. Our server (Kaylie?) was attentive, sweet and friendly. The white wine sangria was to die for!!! I'll be back.“

“Love ginos pizza.
Didn't have it for years due to going through hamiltons pizza spots, but finally went back.

Great crust especially when thick, healthy amount of cheese and toppings put on each pie. And the dips are a little on the small side, but have a great taste with some spice.

And its not crazy expensive.
Definitely worth a try, and some locations have after 9 deals which are great when you want a pie late at night.“

“Best food ever“

“Love there pizza and wings“

“I ordered 6 different pizzas for a group, and everyone seemed quite pleased. While i didnt try each of the pizza selections, the ones I did try were flavorful and cooked perfectly. Will definitely be returning
Already craving another slice of the Jerk chicken pizza ;) Delicious!“

“Plaza Pizza and Wings is a Hamilton favorite for good reason. The pizza has a crispy crust with a soft interior and a generous layer of fresh toppings, balanced nicely by a tangy sauce that never overpowers the cheese. The wings are just as good — crispy skin, juicy meat, and a great range of sauces to suit any spice preference. Portions are generous, service is fast and friendly, and the whole experience is consistently solid. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!“

“Loved the tandoori paneer pizza at Freshly Slice! It was delicious and full of flavour. The customer service made the experience even better—the gentleman who served me was friendly, polite, and welcoming. Thank you for the great food and wonderful service! I’ll definitely be back.“

“They make a really good old school pizza 😋 🍕“

“I'm on Lawrence road and my family orders here pizza and pasta Friday nights sometimes. it's never not been good, like not even once. always great food and the best service, phone and delivery. Thank you!!!“

“Bakers Corner catered pizza for our late night snack for our wedding August 26 2023. Everyone complimented the pizza and asked where it was from! The staff were great to build the order with and stayed open late for our request. We live right outside of town so it was great to support a local business and have them so accommodating for our wedding. Thanks so much! It made our farm wedding complete! K&D“

“We ordered from Bronx Pizza for delivery and were pleasantly surprised by the quality. The pizza arrived hot, the crust had a nice texture, and the toppings were fresh and generous. The portions were good, and everything was packed well for delivery. It’s a solid option when you’re looking for a good pizza without having to leave the house. We would definitely order from here again.“

“We enjoyed our golf day yesterday but the pizza experience has changed since the previous visit a few weeks back . Will not order pizza on our next outing.“

“This pizza store is absolutely fabulous my coworkers and I at Queens Garden long-term care love it“

“This is our favorite pizza and Wing place. I will try the shawarma at some point. We love the service the staff it's prompt the pizza is delicious the wings are delicious and we will highly recommend them for food and exceptional service“

“I don’t ever really write reviews on restaurants unless they are consistent with their food quality and standards. So with that being said, this is the third time I’ve ordered with Timmy’s and I definitely need to acknowledge this place. My husband and I order the same thing every time (we don’t really like change lol) and every single time with the two kebabs and rice it is ABSOLUTELY perfect. They don’t miss. The food that comes out of their kitchen is obviously made with love and care because they never let a bad plate go out. I’m not big on rice. At all. But this rice, I can eat all day, every day. They put a type of red sauce on it and a white sauce too. But it’s not what you think. It’s not the typical shawarma red and white sauce you get when you order a wrap or a plate. It’s savoury red sauce with tomatos and a little bit of kick. The white sauce seems yogurt based and it pairs absolutely perfect with the rice. And the rice, isn’t your typical white rice. It seems marinated in a way that is exploding with flavour just on its own. And don’t even get me started on the kebabs!!!! They’re juicy and big and packed full of flavour. And they give you two massive kebabs! TWO! This meal is not only filling but absolutely delicious and I’ve been addicted to Timmy’s Tanur since the moment I tried it the first time. Whether you’re dining in, taking out, using Uber eats or door dash, this restaurant will NEVER disappoint. They even throw in a delicious pita to make sure you’re full! Absolutely wonderful! I recommend this place to everyone and anyone!!!“

“Wery good food, must go and try“

“i love this pizza i got it for free!!!“

“I have come to this place a more then a handful of times. The Pizza and the wraps for me is a 10/10. There is a older lady that works here and she is wonderful but when I am helped by anyone else here that is not her, ordering here feels a bit intense and the personalties abrasive. For example last time I was ordering and picking up my food the attendant kinda tossed my food to me. Because I tend to get multiple items too it would have been nice if the attendant at the time took maybe just 5 seconds to explain how they differentiated them. The details matter, good customer service matters. All and all tho great jobs on the food as always.“

“Just wanted to give a shout out to Johnny. On Friday 1-16-26 my silver ladys had the experiece of having Johnny as our server. What an amazing young man. Very personable attentive to our needs and conversed in our conversation when we asked about life and dreams..Excellant server“

“We ordered from these folks last night for the first time and while delivery took awhile....... Might have been busy I don't know....... The pizzas were worth the wait. The price was the best I could find online too. Hot and fresh LOTS of pepperoni and cheese 😊 will order again.“

“Always Fresh and great tasting“

“Great pizza for a little take out spot, the garlic dip is good to.

But those spring rolls are a whole other level, not sure if they are made in house or not, but they are the best spring rolls I've had from any take away spot“

“Fantastic pizza, wings & garlic bread Top notch customer service for pick up and delivery Friendly family run business If you haven’t tried Pisa Pizza yet you’re missing out 😊“

“This is the best neighbourhood pizza place. They have such affordable prices and great food. Their pizza crust is always fresh and has great texture. The family who runs the business is so sweet with wonderful customer service. By far my favourite pizza in the neighbourhood!“

“Delicious healthy Pizza Pasta options“

“Amazing staff! Amazing shawarma!! My number one go to when visiting the area!!!“

“Recommended by ChatGPT. We are visiting and wanted authentic fresh Italian. When we arrived it was very quiet, we were the only ones. We weren’t sure but we waited and were greeted by a friendly gentleman who was the owner.
I very much wanted authentic veal in lemon and caper sauce. It wasn’t on the menu but he said he would make it for me. My husband had the shrimp Alfredo.
We didn’t know what to expect but to our delight, his food was exactly what we wanted. To start he made us fresh pizza bread that was devine. Fresh homemade pasta and gnocchi in beautiful fresh sauces. My lemon veal with the homemade butter, lemon, caper sauce was superb!
I would definitely recommend this restaurant.“

“Probably the best "chain store" pizza in Canada! Love to get a slice or two when visiting Toronto. Hope they open branches in Ottawa soon (we need better pizza slices in the nation's capital).“

“We recently ordered Poppi’s for pickup because they had a great March break special. I hadn’t heard of this place before but was pleasantly surprised. The staff were extremely friendly and welcoming upon arrival. The pizza was ready fast and was very good, hot and fresh. The price matched the amount of food we purchased and did not seem overly inflated like a lot of pizza places. The drink selection was unmatched and definitely the star of the show! My only downside was the garlic sauce could be a little more garlicky but that’s just personal preference. We will definitely be ordering from them again in the near future“