50 Best Sandwich Shops near Brentwood

“I'm a regular at this Subway and I have been for over 10 years. I have seen employees come and go over the years. They're like the Pirates, They become a great Sandwich Artist' Like that" and then their shipped off to another store. The gentleman they have now does a great job and he doesn't get rattled when its busy. Keep up the great work!“

“5/5 Stars — Easily one of the best sandwich spots in Pittsburgh, hands down.

I have been around for over 40 years and have eaten at sandwich shops all over, but Peppi's blew me away. Not only is this my absolute favorite sub spot now, it easily earned a spot in my top 3 favorite restaurants anywhere. It might even be number one.

The Highlights:
* The Food: The subs my wife and I ordered were unreal. Fresh, loaded, and hands down the best we have ever had.

* The Value: The portion sizes are massive for what you pay. It feels like a throwback to the days when you actually got incredible value for your money.

* The Staff: Some of the friendliest, most welcoming people you will meet. You can tell they take genuine pride in their food, their history, and taking care of their customers.

* The Atmosphere: Plenty of comfortable, clean seating and a huge menu with tons of great options to choose from.

If you are anywhere near the North Side, this place is an absolute must-visit. We will be back on a regular basis.“

“This is hands down the best fish and chip spot in Pittsburgh. The fish, shrimp and fries were excellent. Perfectly crispy on the outside and the inside just melts in your mouth. The house made donuts are also to die for. Highly recommend checking them out and the owner is super nice too!“

“We visited your establishment for the first time last night, I insisted on finding a more gourmet tasting Italian hoagie and oh man did I find it. Your food is amazing BUT I apologize as I did not catch his name, the employee up front basically running your establishment WOW!! What a fabulous individual you have as the face of your business. I just want you to know that he is an absolute asset, the world needs many more of these kind of people. (Professional, knowledgeable, happy, all around wonderful person) THANK YOU! We will be back!“

“EXCELLENT DELI GREAT FOOD VERY CLEAN ANS FRIENDLY SERVICE THE BEST IN PITTSBURGH“

“We love this place; great food! Thank you for NOT supporting MAGA Republican Scumbags.“

“Sandwiches are awesome, salads look great, and the staff is VERY friendly! You will not be disappointed if you get a hoagie there.“

“best sandwiches in Pittsburgh.“

“Food is amazing. Owners is a j*** to the employees, though. They work so hard and he just yells at them.“

“Greatest food in America is right here. I'm a die hard, black & gold bleeding fan from Columbus, Ohio and visiting Peppi's for a RothlisBurger is a staple of my visits to Pittsburgh. I absolutely will always make time to eat at this restaurant. The only downside is it's cash only and the ATM in the restaurant only allows withdraws in increments of $20s, other than that, this is a 5 star restaurant. Go Steelers!!“

“Great lunch! Fresh sandwiches😃“

“A fun setup! Our first time at this location. We were seated upstairs. Was definitely a little snug for our party, but food was amazing as always with Primanti. My only complaint was that we may have been overlooked a little, not being on the main floor. Drinks took a bit to get refilled. Other than that, a nice experience. Would return!“

“We found Breadbox on (happy) accident and I'm so glad we did!
The Steakhouse Panini and Italian Panini were nothing short of amazing! I absolutely love a good panini and these were the best I've ever had. We also grabbed a cinnamon roll and brownie - 11/10, no notes.
The staff were also so friendly. I get overwhelmed easily and I did not feel rushed into picking my order.
I wish we didn't live so far away - Breadbox would be a regular stop for us.“

“great food. spicy relish was awesome. meatballs are to die for“

“The people working at Jersey Mike's on Saturday evening, July 18 2020 went above and beyond for us. I placed an online order and on our way to get the order the vehicle we were driving in broke down. I called and explained the situation because I knew we wouldn't get there before close. The person I spoke with was so kind and assured me I could still get my order. Unfortunately, we weren't able to get there at all and when I called to explain and offer my order to the closing team, the person who answered was again so kind and offered to refund my order even though I had no intention of asking for that. It was just a nice gesture and the care they showed for our situation was amazing. I will make sure to order from them more often! Thanks guys!“

“You absolutely can't miss this place! The food is incredible, and the cozy, welcoming atmosphere makes you feel right at home.“

“The best Sandwich in Pittsburgh“

“The staff is excellent and very caring. They are the perfect business for that plaza, especially because it's near one of Allegheny Health Networks treatment centers. People that come and go from that plaza need love and a smile. Thank you for making our day when we come to eat. On top of the great service the food is always fresh and excellent. The store is always spotless.“

“The girl who made my sandwich tonight was such a positive person. She made conversation and interacted with me like an actual human being who takes pride in how she treats other human beings. So kind. Above and beyond service because she wasn't bothered to do her job. It's so rare these days that you get to interact with another person positively, especially someone who is so young and is at their job working. Thank you for being such a good person.“

“From Michigan and had to experience the Sandwich..😊 Very good!!! Heading to a Steeler and Penguin games tomorrow and Tuesday.“

“I order from here all the time because the sandwiches are delicious! Today, they forgot the mayo and pepper relish on both of our sandwiches so they were very dry and boring. I like to order online to customize my sandwich but what's the point if they skip the ingredients you want to add??“

“If you don’t eat the prime rib on Tuesday and Thursday, you have yet to find your inner peace.... After every sandwich, my life feels complete. For at least an hour and a 1/2.“

“Came here after work to order takeout because I wanted a bite to eat. I got the turkey sando and the tots and let me tell you I was impressed! I was skeptical about the hummus being on the sandwich and originally asked for it to be made without but i’m honestly glad that they ended up putting it on there because it took it to a whole new level! The vibe of the place was also a plus, really down to Earth!“

“A treasure we are grateful for ! A family business continuing with excellent food, amazing interaction with their customers and keeping Rudy's legacy thriving 😊 If you want a sandwich that you'll remember, this is where to get it!“

“Love this place. Amazing food and atmosphere. Highly recommend!“

“MEAT THIEVES! WHERE IS THE MEAT????“

“It is a great place to be, and the employees have a good attitude.“

“This JJ wasn’t terrible. The counter person was slightly condescending. She didn’t understand that I eat a Jimmy John’s multiple times a week because she felt the need to tell me what comes on the same sandwich that I ordered every time.
My instructions were not followed, and my sandwich did not meet my expectations. Even though they did not meet my expectations, I will go and give them another chance.
You know how distracting it is when you’re on your phone and there are no other customers, and instead of cleaning, maintaining your Restaurant following the one and only order you’ve probably gotten in one hour. You dropped the ball.
Not thrilled with this visit, but I will allow them to redeem themselves on my next visit.“

“Great happy hour specials!“

“Wow! The three African American men working today were EXCELLENT! Respectful, courteous, and made my grams day. They deserve a raise and more. Keep them on board. This is what good customer service looks like. Thank you fellas 🙏🏾“

“Always wonderful experience and recommend everyone absolutely best place to eat .“

“Aiden’s a really cool server. Listened keenly to what I needed ordered and went out of his way to get my Cheese Steak extra toasted! It’s the little things in customer service…but Aiden did it all well! Bless him! :)“

“Always wonderful experience and recommend everyone absolutely best place to eat .“

“Delivered subs fancy tatse“

“Cant go wrong here we stopped in for lunch and got a meatball hoagie with a chicken bacon ranch hoagie and tried the new foot long cookie, churo and pretzel. The cookie and churo were probably tied for being pretty good and the pretzel was ok“

“Everyone who works at this location makes DELICIOUS sandwiches. I’ve been here 4 times in the past week because of how good my sandwich was. It was not only good but fulfilling not stingy with toppings at all. Probably the best location in Pittsburgh! Thank you all!“

“Almost a hour to get food, others seated after us waited and served. Another table close by also complained of wait time. we were given the excuse that a large party came in ( not true) and large number of take outs (?). Not sure what type of meat tge burger was but was totally tasteless, took home and threw away. Most disappointing meal ever!! Jefferson Hills/Pleasant Hills“

“Best in the Burgh!!! Steak subs 😋 yummy!“

“I travel all around Pittsburgh for my job. Every time I’m over on this side of town, I make sure to stop and get food from here. This is by far the cleanest subway I’ve been to, with the best service. No wait times, and early pick up if you order on the app. I highly recommend going here over any other one.“

“I was in on June 9th, 2022 and was waited on by a lovely woman named Carissa. I was unsure on what to order and she gave great recommendations on what sandwich to order. She suggested the chicken and bacon ranch, which was amazing. I never buy chips or a drink either but she was able to sell me on those too. If she’s not manager yet she needs to be. Stellar service!“

“I stopped going to Subway a few years ago because of quality was terrible. A couple of years ago I moved and was very close to this location in Westview plaza. I don't know if it is just this location or all subways have stepped up their game but I have never gotten a bad meal at this place!
Everything is fresh and it fills me up. The best part is I order through the app and they always have at least buy one get a second for 50% off and run a buy one get one free promotion very frequently. Currently they are doing the buy one get one free promotion and I have gone there three times in the last 5 days. All three times the food was delicious and did not take long to get. I highly recommend this place.“

“Best gas station in town. Owners are extremely friendly, staff is wonderful, and prices are fair.“

“Best gas station in town. Owners are extremely friendly, staff is wonderful, and prices are fair.“

“I had the freshest hoagie at this location this week and WOW, game changer. Thanks alot.“

“Visited this location for the first time at lunch today. There were probably 4 people in front of me and one behind me. Plus, one person came in to pick up 2 delivery orders. The ladies waiting on us crushed it. I was in and out in less than 10 minutes. The person directly in front of me ordered 3 sandwiches with all double meat. Also, their hair and makeup were flawless. Masks worn properly, changed gloves between orders. This will probably be my go-to location from now on.“

“The best sandwich/food shop PERIOD! Very tasty, big portions and a great price! You cant ask for more! Don't cheat yourself, you gotta try it! I GUARANTEE you'll spread the word because you can't keep all that goodness to yourself! #HIGHLYRECOMMENDED“

“You can order curbside or go in. I drive 3 miles out of the way to order from this Subway. Very clean, servers friendly and consciousness in making each order. Food is fresh, neatly made, wrapped and tasty. Consistent in your order and expectations every time. Great job guys!“

“I was trying to order hoagies for a Halloween party and I tried the website. It wouldn't take my credit card
It kept saying fraud.So I tried three different credit cards.Would not accept them.They were the only store that would answer.Their phoneI tried the one in bethel park on industrial.The girl was very lovely at the.Mcmurray valley book store.She was very helpful.. Unfortunately the amout of meat that SUBWAY puts on there hoagies, just not worth the money anymore...such a shame“

“This is probably the best Jimmy John's I've been to. My order is always correct and tasty. And I don't know what they're feeding the staff but they are always very kind and considerate. The employee at front counter with a frog crocheted bandana was incredibly sweet when I came to pick up dinner for my wife and I. Always happy when I pick up food here“