50 Best American Restaurants near Old Forge

“Excellent food, great service and always pleasant!“

“First time trying Club 17 tonight 3/17/23. Absolutely awesome. The red pizza was some of the best I’ve had in Old Forge. Light, crispy and flavorful sauce. The fresh tomato and garlic pizza was equally amazing. Super fresh ingredients and the garlic was the perfect amount. The star of the show for me though was the Rigatoni Abruzzi with hot sausage. It’s done in a light creamy tomato sauce with roasted red peppers, hot Italian sausage and just the right amount of chili flake. Everything was awesome and we got it to go. I’m sure it would be even better sit down in the restaurant which we will certainly be trying in the near future. Highly recommend.“

“The wing bites are amazing and the penne vodka was delicious (I asked for mine to be spicy and it was nicely done). The portions are incredibly generous. The employees were kind and helpful with suggestions. The environment was great especially if your a sports lover (I am not) only downfall was no jukebox or pool table and you can't smoke or vape and thats understandable. I personally will be getting my pasta from there from now-on.....“

“I got 2 trays of red pizza with anchovies & the pizza was Absolutely Scrumptious. Pizza was phenomenal. Loved it! Everything was perfect even though I ordered out. Order was ready when I got there & just the smell, I couldn't wait to get home to have a piece. Sheer Perfection.“

“I'm naturally a very fast eater, but not here. It was so delicious I wanted to savor every single bite. I'm coming back here as soon as I can, like tomorrow. Phenomenal and I don't ever write reviews but I just had to write this one.“

“Outstanding Service - Fabulous Food. Highly recommend the Peanut Butter Smash Burger. Great atmosphere, they were streaming Next Level Chef episode when Chef Von won with his smash burger. If I lived in Scranton I'd be there once a week for lunch.“

“To start the service I received was above and beyond excellence. I placed a take out order and from the moment the man behind the counter learned my name he addressed me as such there forward. That simple act made the experience go from being a normal customer to feeling like I was a local and I had been coming here my whole life. When placing my order any question I could have was answered before I could even think of it. The order was made in great time even though the place was pacted. The food itself was delicious and perfectly cooked.“

“Pulled pork was fantastic. 10/10 recommend“

“Went here on Valentines Day and it was Great!!! Food, service and atmosphere perfect!!! Another fantastic restaurant in Pittston!!!“

“The food is absolutely incredible. I went twice this week and was blown away each time. Will definitely be going back. Family owned and very clean.“

“The absolute BEST footlong hot dogs!!!! The people there are so nice, too...“

“10 out of 10 recommend Fork N Bowl. My grandson has celiacs and it was a stress free experience. No worries about cross contamination because EVERYTHING is gluten free. The staff was so friendly and patient. Did I mention how delicious the food is?“

“First time there. Loved everything. The food was phenomenal. The service was the best. The waitress and kitchen staff were the friendliest I've encountered in a very long time. Very accommodating for wheelchair use. Can't wait to go back.“

“Great Food And Atmosphere“

“Food is always to die for! Unique flavors & attention to detail. Gotta make this place one of my regular spots!“

“Went to lunch here with my mom during an extremely busy lunch time on weekend and it was still such a great experience. The staff were all so pleasant even though they were running around like crazy. They took a bit to get my tea and I didnt even mind but yet they gave us free cookies at the end of our meal just as an apology, which they didn't even need to do, I understood fully they were just busy. We will absolutely be back!!! Wonderful customer service, worth every penny.“

“A + service and food. The fresh unsweetened tea was delicious. I had three. My salad was stellar. We were a party of six and everyone enjoyed their food. The chocolate chip cookies were recommended and We know why!!! I will return for another one of these salads.“

“Rustic Kitchen truly lives up to its name with a warm, inviting atmosphere and food that feels like it was made with real care. The standout of the meal was without a doubt the chicken parm—absolutely outstanding. The chicken was perfectly breaded, crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and topped with rich, flavorful sauce and just the right amount of melted cheese. Every bite was packed with comfort and authentic flavor.
The portions were generous, the presentation was great, and everything tasted fresh and homemade. Rustic Kitchen is the kind of place that makes you want to come back again and again. If you’re a fan of chicken parm, this is a must-order and easily one of the best I’ve had. Highly recommend! 🍽️🔥“

“I have many special memories here with family. The best memory was in July during a holiday celebration. I brought my boyfriend Abdullah to meet my family and it was one of the most special memories that I cherish deeply. Most recently when I came, I saw many peers from high school who may or may not have noticed me. Most distinctively, I saw a former athlete. This colleague used to be one of the best North Pocono football players as well as North Pocono track & field athletes who had his year book picture iconically taken on the railroad tracks. I would highly recommend coming here if you want to see North Pocono School District legends as well as have amazing food.“

“Enjoying a pleasant meal out is always a treat, and Stirna's never fails to impress. My husband and I chose it for our anniversary dinner, and from the moment we stepped inside, the wait staff provided top-notch service, making us feel genuinely welcome. The food was delicious, and those legendary Stirna's brownies are always a must for a sweet treat. Much thanks to Cathy and her team.“

“best double cheeseburgers 🍔 ❤️❤️“

“I attended a Bridal shower, for my future daughter in law, at the Apple Tree House Restaurant. It was wonderful! The food was excellent! I can't say enough about how great the entire staff was! Michelle and Lauren made sure everything ran smoothly! Thank you all on a job well done! I highly recommend the Apple Tree House Restaurant!“

“Always a great lunch and fabulous service!!“

“do not let the location fool you, great place to stop“

“Great food. Wonderful people.“

“I've lived around the corner for a year, but never tried their place 'til last night. Got a pizza for my upstairs neighbor and myself to split. It's unique, and for 5$, you can't beat it. She and I (mostly me) almost ate the whole 12 cuts too!“

“We recently hosted a funeral luncheon at Bukatini. The food was delicious and the service was Phenomenal! I highly recommend!!“

“A huge thank you to Donna and her staff for another great event for us! This is the third time we’ve used Center City Cafe to cater a party and she did another amazing job. Everyone raved about the “build your own taco bar.” My favorite part was that Donna came to set up for us (every time), which took so much pressure off of us the morning of our event so we could concentrate on other things.“

“Hope is the best & always knowledgeable“

“Stopped by for chili dogs after winning a giveaway contest through Facebook group, 100% recommend. Nice crisp in each bite & chili sauce was packed with flavor!“

“Extraordinary is an understatement. This establishment is phenomenal in every aspect, from its atmosphere to the family ownership, cuisine, and pricing. I highly recommend Anthony's with absolute certainty, and I appreciate supporting small, family-owned businesses.  #LoveMyFamilia“

“Just came from there got an Italian hoagie two days in a row hoagie meat fresh and ample a great hoagie for a great price great service place is roomy and clean lots of parking“

“great food great service“

“Love the food, drinks & overall vibe!“

“our drinks were delicious & the all you can eat tender meal is seriously such a great deal. our server Kayla was so kind and attentive, i also thank her for her patience with waiting for our brother to join us ! also have to give Emily a shoutout because she’s amazing too !“

“Always great service. Food is always great. Love the gift shop. Have never been disappointed.“

“Absolutely a must try!! All the food was cooked to perfection, staff is friendly and attentive. We had such a fun time! Definitely plan to return.“

“Great service, fantastic food!“

“We used Grico’s to cater our wedding and they were fantastic to work with. The catering manager, Marissa, was so easy to communicate with and promptly answered any questions that came up. They had a great selection of meal options and we chose the chicken francaise, blackened salmon with raspberry sauce, and filet mignon. All food choices were INCREDIBLE and all our guests were raving how great the food was. The service was top notch and the bartenders kept our drinks full all night. 10/10 service. We recommend Grico’s to anyone looking for an affordable wedding caterer!“

“We went to the pub while stay at the hotel since it was close by. The food was AMAZING. Service was fantastic! Our server, Tiffany, was very attentive and kind. Made sure we had everything we needed during our entire dining experience. The prices are not bad either! Definitely would return again when in the area!“

“Great hospitality! Totally best experience.“

“Popped in the Wilkes-Barre, PA TGI Fridays for lunch. Great, fast, friendly service. The sampler platter was delicious.“

“Excellent service. Quality menu & food.😊“

“My first time eating at a chili's and I was amazed. I'm 51 and I think that was the best burger I've ever had. Kaitlin our server was incredible. We were there for my daughters birthday so there were a few of us so the wait was a bit but totally worth it.“

“We have come here many times. Every time it has been great. I'd like to call out Kyanna for being our server and bartender more than once. Great service to great conversations, if you have her as the bartender or the server then you're in good hands!“

“Absolutely amazing service and such great food. I couldn’t recommend enough. Every single person we interacted with was extremely nice. The food was literally AMAZING. I love it here so much.“

“Great meal AND it was FREE ! Thanks for honoring teachers !“

“I actually went to purchase a car wash neighboring this restaurant ,there not linked to them in any shape or form, I didn't know that upon entering, however, They assured me and helped me feel better about being charged and not receiving a service the owners Rich and Lisa and warm people, there food looks amazing!!“

“Great meal for a large group, all meals and appetizers were shareable and delicious! Can't go wrong here, especially for the low price!
Drinks were superb as well!
Friendly staff took care of our needs quickly, we needed to eat and run to a show!“

“The best lemon greek chicken orzo soup ever. Drove up from New Jersey to buy two quarts for my boyfriend who was sick 🤧 with the flu 😷..“