14 Best American Restaurants near York Springs

“Highly recommend! Great service and food! My personal favorite menu item is their taco salads and my Mom always gets their shrimp quesadilla. The owner comes out from the kitchen every time we are there to say hi and see how our meal is. It’s a true mom and pop establishment!“

“Stopped by Wolfe’s today as I just happened to be passing through the area on an alternate, non interstate highway route from Maine to FL. This place is an absolute, authentic gem of an old school diner, inside and out. Completely iconic right down to the table side jukeboxes. Super friendly staff, smiling customers and great food. 10/10“

“If there anyplace better in York or Adams county Pennsylvania I’d like to know where everything is great The Chef Culinary art institute of New York tops in American plus a Greek and a NaturalI really like their Alfredo sauce with pasta . Denise and Charlie are great people and owners always serve the best in food …. Love the place“

“The pork was tender and the amount was generous for the pork BBQ sandwich. I enjoyed each of the offered BBQ sauces with the mild BBQ being my favorite for this sandwich. Hushpuppies were perfectly crispy without being dense inside and the baked beans were a flavorful blend of beans. This was a lunch stop during a brief roadtrip. If you're in the Harrisburg area you need to stop at Road Hawg BBQ.“

“I've been coming to the Pickle Nickel since 2016 when I started a summer job back in college. The burgers and shakes are amazing! The staff is always friendly and it's such a unique dining experience.Since college I've moved to the area, and I'm so excited to be able to eat here more often! I only wish they were open more during the week, but that's just wishful, hungry thinking!“

“This is our fourth time at Sidney. Each time has been unique and fantastic! I had the monkfish upon recommendation of our server (who was awesome) and it was beyond my expectations. I'm just sorry we don't live closer. We will be back the next time we are in Gettysburg!“

“I went with family for Easter dinner. Reservations only. There were 15 in our group. When we arrived we were seated immediately, table was ready, no waiting. Limited menu for Easter. All entrees included baked potato & salad. I chose broiled scallops for my entrees. A dozen jumbo scallops cooked to perfection. I had to take half home. Service was outstanding. Restaurant was packed, even with the reservation only policy service was great. Food terrific.“

“We were in Abbottstown to get new wheels for our van at L&M. It was dinner time and we decided to stop at Altland House Grill & Pub on the way home. Excellent. We sat on the porch and had a nice relaxed time. Our server was friendly and attentive. We had the flatbread and fish and chips. The food was tasty and it was fun to watch the traffic navigating the traffic circle as we ate. The price was reasonable.“

“A gem ! Great little coffee shop.Coconut key lime pie is delicious. Cappuccino was excellent and service with a smile. I highly recommend. Nice selection of muffins. Also offers gluten free selections. If I’m ever in the area again I will stop “

“Fun throwback to yesteryear. The hot food is good. Youngest said the chicken nuggets were the best he ever had. Chili cheese fries were ok. Might try the bacon cheese fries next time. Cowboy burger was tasty. Portions are just about right. The seasonal tests were awesome: cinnamon roll sundae... wow. Pumpkin pie shake... wow. Oldest said the apple cider shake was very good... different but very good. Youngest loved the Graham Slam hand dipped ice cream.“

“Such a neat place! My Aunt and Uncle took me here for breakfast and I was really impressed!For starters, the coffee cups are huge, so for someone like me that drinks a lot of coffee, I was enjoying the big coffee cups. The food portions are generous and the prices are very reasonable.The staff was very friendly and seemed to treat everyone as if they were part of the family.I was very impressed and would love to dine here again if I get the chance!Thank you for such a great experience!“

“Love this place! Food is great, priced right, and always have had exceptional service! We sat at the bar a few days ago and a long haired gentleman really took care of us well. One of the owners is also right there getting you anything you need. Sometimes they are out of certain beers but what do you expect with a small batch system. Oh and chicken and waffles on sundays is killer. Overall great place, cool atmosphere in the nicer days! Keep up the good work guys!“

“Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon with 5 friends. I can tell you this is good eating.I ordered the Hog Wild Platter. Great flavor on the pulled pork; lightly sweet, smokey and moist. The pit beef was sliced thin and very good. The baked beans were plenty and the slaw cold and crisp. The grilled roll made the perfect foundation for a sandwich. Everything was served as expected; hot hot and cold cold.Parking is on the street and there is plenty of room.Staff along with the owner very all very welcoming.All seating is outdoors. Our weather was perfect but the afternoon sun was a bit in my face the entire time; there are tables with umbrellas, but it would be better if there were more shaded tables. There were also plenty of yellow jackets looking to eat your food and drink your drink.You order at the window, there are only a few menus to go around so get in line. From ordering to delivery was about 20 minutes. Each platter was served in the order received. Don't drink too much while you wait as I will warn you, there are no facilities here for use by the customers; not even a hose bib.After my meal, I asked for a sink and i was given wet wipes. You might know them they are the ones grandmom used to carry.Overall, this is very good BBQ so use the toilet before you get here and do your best not to get messy eating or order aheadand take it to the local park to go eat. Enjoy the food.“

“Stopped by again for a weekday lunch - this time we had a Short Rib Grilled Cheese & an Old English Melt .......aaannnd of course the signature basket of chips with Balsamic Vinaigrette drizzle & sprinkled Parm. Could go there for nothing but the chips! But I must say both sandwiches were AWEsome! We made reservations since it was the Monday of Valentine's week but, although busy, the place wasn't slammed. Our server was attentive & everything came out in a timely fashion - love the ambience! Lot of dark wood & copper which lends to the historical feel or the venue (Inn goes back to 1763) - always enjoy stopping in! (still) Highly recommended!“