13 Best American Restaurants in Middlebury

“The whole family enjoyed an excellent meal tonight start to finish. Service was friendly and quick. The setting was beautiful. Salads were fresh and flavorful. Had the kalette appetizer which the whole table enjoyed. Entrees were fantastic! I had the rib eye. One son had the steak au poivre; another had haddock with heirloom tomatoes, and my husband had the pork chops. We all agreed it was a perfect meal. We ended the meal with wonderful desserts - maple creme brulee, marscapone cheesecake, banana bread pudding, and ice cream with a praline topping. Just the right size and sweetness to finish this wonderful meal. We hope to be back soon.“

“The food was absolutely delicious. The best food ever and impeccable home fries. People should definitely come here in the future. Henry H. 11 years old“

“I cannot thank Paris and the team enough for all the help with a surprise birthday party. There was 20 of us and they made it look easy. The food came out tasting perfect and within great timing. Our server was very attentive and kind. They helped set up decorations before we arrived. I’m so grateful it went as smoothly as it did. Thank you so much!“

“A beautiful historic building with friendly wait staff and delicious food“

“Best BLT in the world. 😋👏“

“Update: chatted with Danielle (owner) and they must have been having an off day when I went the first time. I returned with a smaller group and the flatbreads had plenty of toppings and service was very good!

Old review: Not a great spot for groups or value. Our waitress was really annoyed we were ordering small flatbreads. If you have an issue with it then just don’t take large reservations? Pretty much forced me and another guy in my group to share 1 large rather than make 2 smalls, which ended up being an awkward dance because even though the food tasted great, like a 3rd of the flatbread didn’t have any toppings so we just shared a lot of bread. Finally, they don’t split the tab more than 3 ways, which is wild in 2026.“

“Best place around! They are so friendly, and make amazing food, with great prices!“

“I've been going to Middlebury bagel and deli for decades now. I've never had a bad meal, and as someone allergic to corn, I really appreciate that the bagels are all made traditionally without corn meal. I honestly think these bagels and donuts are the best in VT. They are certainly the best I've ever had in New England.“

“Great, healthy food. Fast, courteous service. Cozy atmosphere.“

“Beautiful Cozy Inn! Gorgeous decor. Friendly staff. Perfect for a small wedding 😊“

“Located in the student center of Middlebury College. Open to the public but geared more towards serving the on campus community. Hours will vary depending on the college calendar.

Wheelchair accessibility: Elevator in the building . Doors are ADA compliant.“

“Amazing atmosphere service was okay she said she was short staff and you can tell she was under stress and we can feel it as customers. Thursday lunch time. Food was good. Overall great experience but the service needs to be a little bit better“

“We were there over the holiday, it was busy and smells were amazing. The croissants were so flakey and filled with ham and cheese. The apple pastry was by far my favorite. The staff were super nice.🍎🍏“