11 Best American Restaurants in Middlebury

Jessica's Restaurant at the Swift House Inn American • $$$
25 Stewart Ln, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

14th Star Brewing St Albans Vermont Valor Ale 53 Ibu – 5 4 ABV
Chicken Liver Pate Appetizer
Brussels Sprout Salad
Side Belgian Fries
Classic Caesar
Duck Two Ways
Caesar Salad
Sorbet
B&B

“Amazing food and location. Beautiful space and impeccable service. We were a large party and in middle of the main dining room. In the future I would ask to be seated in a quieter side room so that we could hear everyone at the table. Older members of our group had a difficult time hearing anyone not seated directly next to them.“

4.5 Superb134 Reviews
Middlebury Bagel Bagels • $$
11 Washington St, Middlebury

“Food is amazing, the staff works hard, this place is a goldmine for Middlebury..been going here since i was a kid..definitely worth it to check this restaurant out, if I could go every day I would :) go try them out! Local, friendly establishment. They also offer more than just bagels but also breakfast sandwiches, so happy they’re still around :)) also great coffee selections“

4.6 Superb48 Reviews
Fire & Ice Steak House • $$
26 Seymour St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Maple Bacon Cheeseburger
Slow Roasted Prime Rib
Candy Cane Beet Salad
Maple Old Fashioned
Maple Creme Brulee
The Bar Room Steak
French Onion Soup
Champagne Chicken
Woodchuck Salad
Moose Pub Wings

“Really nice restaurant. A gem in the middle of nowhere, just kidding about "nowhere" ?. The food was excellent and the service as well. I ordered a filet mignon, medium, and it was perfect. Pink in the center as it was supposed to be and very juicy. The server came over a number of times to make sure we had all we needed, as well as to ensure that the food was to our liking. Thumbs up!!!“

4.2 Good100 Reviews
Grapevine Grille Sandwich Shop • $
610 US-7, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich
Cheesesteak

“The sign and building are easy to miss, so note the landmarks so you don't drive by it as we did as well as the friends we were meeting. But the menu had lots of choices, the food was delicious, and the overall experience was like having been hosted by family.“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Noonie's Deli Deli • $
137 Maple St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Purple's Pleasure
Noonies blt
Italian
Cookies

“SUCH a great find! I agree with the reviewer who asked how it's ever not five stars? The people were so friendly and cheerful, and the sandwiches are some of the biggest I have ever seen! What great value, and the atmosphere is super fun. The bread is homemade and the size of your face (huge!), and the fillings are generous such that both my friend and I had to bring our leftovers home. High recommend!!“

4.4 Superb47 Reviews
Two Brothers Tavern Bar & Grill • $$
86 Main St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Poutine with Bacon
French Onion Soup
Cheddar Ale Soup
Tavern Wings

“Very helpful and attentive waiter. The only issue was the Poutine. It was good, but the fries were soft, and the gravy was different. Good, just not what I'm used to. The Lamb pot pie and the desert were very good. I would definitely visit here “

4.3 Superb107 Reviews
Rosie's American • $
886 US-7, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Pancakes with Bacon and Home Fries
Fish Sandwich Deluxe Plus
Chicken and Biscuits
Macaroni and Cheese
Sweet Potato Fries
Biscuits and Gravy
Vegetable Ravioli
Corned Beef Hash
Homefries Toast
Reuben Sandwich

“We travel an hour to get to this awesome restaurant because there is no other place in Vermont that treats you like family. There is not a bad dish on any of their menus. Their proportions are great and you will always come away full and satisfied.Vegetarian options: They will work with you on your vegetarian needsParking: They have ample parking and their parking lot is big enough for a few commercial tractor trailers.Kid-friendliness: Our children have never had a bad time at this restaurant. All the servers were friendly and engaging with our children.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a crazy amount of space for wheelchairs.“

4.2 Good117 Reviews
American Flatbread Pizza • $
137 Maple St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

New Vermont Sausage Pizza
Bacon Apple Cheddar Pie
Revolution Pizza
Evolution Salad
Lime Lite

“When picking up my pizza last night, they discovered the kitchen had my order wrong. They offered to make me another one (it was ready within 10 mins) and offered me a beer while I waited. The young man who assisted me was excellent. Definitely will be back!!“

4.2 Good38 Reviews
Otter Creek Bakery & Deli Bakery • $$
14 College St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Panini
Otter Creek Sub
Half Sandwich
Sticky Bun
Croissant
Vermonter

“Yummy pastries! It can get crowded sometimes inside but that's to be expected! Make sure if you don't like the way vegan or gluten free pastries taste that you look at the tags because I accidentally ordered a gluten free pastry one time lol! The bread is very good and the danishes are to die for! Super cute ambience in the spring/summer!“

4.1 Good53 Reviews
The Grille Pizza •
14 Old Chapel Rd, Middlebury

“Located in the student center of Middlebury College. Open to the public but geared more towards serving the on campus community. Hours will vary depending on the college calendar.Wheelchair accessibility: Elevator in the building . Doors are ADA compliant.“

3.9 Good20 Reviews
Waybury Inn American • $$
457 E Main St, Middlebury

“I didn’t realize the historical significance of the Inn when I booked it based on location from RT100 for leaf peeping. Overall, the establishment is in great condition considering the age. The rooms have no TV or radio and have a window air unit. My reason for a lower rating was the carpet. It was extremely dirty. They had 3 different kinds of rugs around the bed, and I didn’t look under them, but the exposed areas were gross. The shower is very small if that could be a concern. We had dinner and breakfast there and they were both really good. The staff was friendly, although obviously short staffed.“

4 Good57 Reviews
Loading...
map Map