“5-star service from Gabe and Andy all the way! I got there at 10:19 starving after a hot yoga class and yearning for a Beach Club Unwich (and pressed for time due to an 11am work call). Without a blink - no problem at all "whattya need ma'aam, happy to help"! These guys are awesome. I've had other places like Kohl's, Panera, Nail places, Qdoba, etc. wait until the EXACT moment standing on the other side of the door with a line of people until they would unlock the door.I'm glad to see in 2024, there are people, especially in the age bracket of 18-24 that have a good business sense. The owner of this Jimmy John's should know these guys are hard workers and are going the extra mile to keep customers happy.Thank you Gabe and Andy!“
“Mark (Owner) is a great guy. Will talk with you while he works and has a great product. Bread made fresh daily, meats used are quality and he is willing to alter subs slightly upon request. No cheese. Add peppercinis. Or hot peppers. A beverage. Chips and a giant sub for $11! Can't beat that.“
“We stop here for dinner whenever we visit Pewaukee. (It's not a candy store, as the name implies.) Right across the street from the water, it is a convenient place to get a tasty sub, fresh salad, or mouth-watering ice cream. We’ve had the delicious roast beef, turkey, and ham and cheese subs made with their fresh, lightly-crusted, Italian sub rolls. The oregano gives them a unique, pleasant flavor. And of course we get their delicious ice cream that comes in many flavors, such as Moose Tracks or Strawberry Cheesecake. Parking is on the street or at their spacious lot in the back. We look forward to our next meal there!“
“I ordered a toasted roast turkey on Italian bread, with yellow peppers, raw cucumber, a little purple onion, tomato, pepper jack cheese and no sauce. It was great. The kettle cooked salt and vinegar potato chips were delicious, too, with Minutemaid lemonade.This restaurant is next to the new Sendik's grocery store, currently under construction.“
“This is by far is my favorite cousins subs and sub shop in Wisconsin! Staff are amazing, subs taste amazing, and they are always taking care of their customers. Shout out to Matt and his crew who do an amazing job managing this store and always having smiles on their faces.“
“Such wonderful service! This franchise is well managed by understanding, involved owners. My family ordered a large pickup order with special notes. We got a call to confirm the specifics. Our order was perfect on pickup, including a great discount offer. We will go out of our way to support this business.“
“One of my favorite sub shops and ice cream parlors. Great sandwiches and a nice selection of ice cream flavors you can have made in a cone (plain or chocolate dipped), sundae, or shake. If you decide to grab one of their many small condiment containers they offer, filled with pickles, jalapenos, banana peppers, or black olives, please check the contents before putting on your sandwich. My sisters black olives were moldy, which were brought to the attention of staff members.Vegetarian options: There is a veggie sub on the menu, but you could easily turn any sub veggie just by holding the meat or building your own sub.Parking: This location is in a strip mall with a large free parking lot. Disabled parking is an issue because there are more spots for pick up orders for multiple restaurants in the same mall. They also don't have the spaces between spots for a side ramp that may be on a vehicle to assist with a wheelchair.Kid-friendliness: Many sub options including a kids menu for children with a smaller appetite. Plenty of ice cream flavor options.Wheelchair accessibility: One pull open door to get in. Women's restroom is NOT accessible if you need to take your wheelchair inside the restroom. My daughter's chair did not fit, but luckily, she is able to take a few steps if holding onto her chair and sink ( the door was open by me). I waited outside the door for her to finish, then helped her get back into her chair when she was done.“
“I always have a great experience here. Idk why these people bash this place and say that the workers are rude. I mean seriously how would you like dealing with nasty customers all day and making sandwiches for picky nasty people? Lol idk how this place has any bad reviews it is a clean and great subway location. Honestly one of the better ones in the area“
“Their excellent chocolate malt turned the world around for me after 6 hours of a tough morning & afternoon! The sun even came out for the rest of the day when I left & the earlier horrors were done & gone. Really nice employees, young & old! Some friends said their sandwiches are great & I can't wait to try them next time!“