10 Best Sandwich Shops near Oconomowoc

“Best food! Great crew! Thank you!“

“I came in today 9/24/26 about 12:45 I ordered the hot Italian! The girl that took my order was great and knowledgeable. I noticed that someone had been training and I believe he made my sub! IT WAS DELICIOUS! He did an amazing job! Great job everyone and keep it up!“

“Great food and service parking kinda sucks but food And service are outstanding“

“Such wonderful service! This franchise is well managed by understanding, involved owners. My family ordered a large pickup order with special notes. We got a call to confirm the specifics. Our order was perfect on pickup, including a great discount offer. We will go out of our way to support this business.“

“Met the owner, and advised I was completely shocked at the customer service provided at this location - in a good way! We go in often to pick-up a quick dinner from this location because of Josh! He's amazing and really loves his job! He's funny, and makes my night just a bit better when we are blessed enough to get him. AND - he makes a fantastic sandwich to boot! SUBWAY you should use him as a trainer! Way to REPRESENT Josh!!“

“Great experience!! I used to come to this subway a few years ago when it was under a different owner and wow has the management changed. The new owner and team of employees are much kinder and provided me and my family excellent service. Although they don’t accept coupons, I feel like the price is cheap enough compared to other places. Would highly recommend!!!“

“EDIT: Their GM Jenny got ahold of me and was very apologetic, very nice and helpful about the whole situation. I changed my 1 star to a 5 after that interaction. Thank you

Walked in, attempted to order but the guy behind the counter couldn't look up from his phone to notice us standing there. Waited 5 minutes and ended up leaving. January 5 2026. Walked in at 7:55, left at 8.“

“Today was my first time at a Jersey Mike's. (I've always gone to $ubw@y or €ou$in's.)

Never again. I'm a Jersey Mike's guy now! The flavor, quality, and service blow all others out of the water!! I could not have made a better Philly at home.“

“Today- Delafield Chocolate Factory did a fantastic job filling a 55 bag lunch order for a luncheon we planned for the Wales Elementary Teachers and Staff!! Justin and Heather worked hard to complete our order and even helped assemble the lunch bags w/brochures!! Very professional and super friendly staff!! Thanks, Mark and Sheila Smith“

“The young man who made my sandwich at 5:15pm(ish) 9/22 killed it. Spot on how I ordered it online. This almost never happens. Following directions with the details should not be taken for granted. “Big things have small beginnings”. Much appreciated!!“