28 Best Sandwich Shops near Hartland

“Great subs and the owner is a super nice guy. Cash only“

“Had the best double cheese steak I have ever had. Servers were friendly and helpful. Manager was sweet! We were in town dealing with a lot. Had to use the laundromat next door twice for hours so ate here many times!! Very nice clean place! We dined in and took out for lunch and dinner.“

“Amazing ice cream!! No scrimping on add ins. Love it!!“

“I recently visited my local Jersey Mike's and I was impressed from the moment I walked in the dining area and prep line look clean and organized which gave me confidence about how the food was handled the staff greeted me right away and asked if I use the app or rewards before which I appreciate it because it sure they were paying attention and trying to be helpful.

For my order I went with the regular sub on White bread sliced fresh for the order plus chips and a drink. The meats and the Jesus were sliced to order and the top things were laid out neatly on the line not dried out or messy I had it made Mike's way with onions lettuce tomatoes oil vinegar and spices and everything tasted fresh and will balance rather than overly salty or greasy. The bread had a good texture with a slight crunch on the outside and softness inside which is one of the main reasons I like Jersey Mike's compared to some other sandwich chains where the bread can taste processed or stale.

Service was fast but still friendly there were a few people ahead of me but the line move quickly because everyone on the line had a clear role one person sliced another built the sandwich and someone else handle the register and drinks even with the speed they still took the time to double-check my toppings and confirm whether I wanted my extras my order came out accurate with no missing items and the sandwich was wrapped tightly so it didn't fall apart when I opened it.

I also like that Jersey Mike's has an easy-to-use rewards program that the mics account and the shore points you earn points and almost every item subs drinks chips cookies and those points add up to free subs at different sizes 48 points for a mini 72 for a regular and 144 for a giant.“

“Great service! The owner made me feel welcome. He introduced himself, talked to me about the restaurant and took the time to get to know me. I’m loving the new management and this is definitely the location I’ll be using from now on.“

“Best food! Great crew! Thank you!“

“The only subway location I will go to. She makes the best subs and adds a healthy amount of toppings; I've had issues at other locations that give the smallest amount of lettuce but she fills my sub up. Absolutely the best subway around.“

“We absolutely love this Cousin's location! Our orders are always right, food is fresh, delicious and made to match the pictures in the ads! Staff is great and always friendly. 5 stars!!Please pass this on to the staff, they make that location great!“

“Great food and service parking kinda sucks but food And service are outstanding“

“I came in today 9/24/26 about 12:45 I ordered the hot Italian! The girl that took my order was great and knowledgeable. I noticed that someone had been training and I believe he made my sub! IT WAS DELICIOUS! He did an amazing job! Great job everyone and keep it up!“

“Today was my first time at a Jersey Mike's. (I've always gone to $ubw@y or €ou$in's.)

Never again. I'm a Jersey Mike's guy now! The flavor, quality, and service blow all others out of the water!! I could not have made a better Philly at home.“

“Pulled up 10 minutes before closing. Called, ordered, asked for help with curbside, I am temporarily disabled. Christian was a huge help, polite, great service. Thank you for helping me. God will bless you in many ways. ?

Parking: Open parking lot

Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap parking“

“Today- Delafield Chocolate Factory did a fantastic job filling a 55 bag lunch order for a luncheon we planned for the Wales Elementary Teachers and Staff!! Justin and Heather worked hard to complete our order and even helped assemble the lunch bags w/brochures!! Very professional and super friendly staff!! Thanks, Mark and Sheila Smith“

“I don’t ever do this. But I just felt it necessary to tell the world how nice the staff is at this jersey mikes. The manager is always busy yet smiling and cracking jokes. I throughly enjoy going in there. 10/10 recommend just for the incredible team.“

“I LOVE THESE WORKERS, they were nice, caring, quick, and very helpful, I can’t believe they were this nice in this area is kind of hard to find that I will be coming back here, the food is always fresh……..🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🔜🔜🔜🔜🔜🔜🔜🔜……..“

“Met the owner, and advised I was completely shocked at the customer service provided at this location - in a good way! We go in often to pick-up a quick dinner from this location because of Josh! He's amazing and really loves his job! He's funny, and makes my night just a bit better when we are blessed enough to get him. AND - he makes a fantastic sandwich to boot! SUBWAY you should use him as a trainer! Way to REPRESENT Josh!!“

“I love the Rachel subs and the Christian music 🎶 is great 👍. Love raspberry ice tea and chocolate chip cookie 🍪 as well. Cousins is my favorite sub shop. Great food!!“

“Due to their location, I doubt this place is ever overwhelmingly busy. I was greeted as I entered the store by who I assumed to be the owner / operator. He and the female employee with him were very pleasant, and had my food ready to go in less than 5 minutes! Delicious sub sandwich! Pleasant atmosphere, clean store too!“

“The gentleman was professional and there were quite a few customers while I was eating my footlong Subway sandwich at his establishment. Knowing there were so many customers on a Sunday spoke volumes about that establishment. The restaurant was clean and the sub was superb as well as I had it toasted also. The ingredients were fresh and well placed on the sandwich as well and plentiful.“

“I always order ahead to get the deals on the app The one in Pewaukee inside Walmart is the best always the say guy working and he makes the best subs my granddaughter and I say this is the best subway in the area. The one in Delafield is not good they put a ton of lettuce on to hide the fact that they don't use enough meat and not very friendly. The one in Sussex across from Meijer is also horrible the subs never taste as good and restaurant is always a mess all tables dirty and so is the floor do not like this one at all. I highly recommend the Pewaukee one inside Walmart always delicious“

“This jersey mikes has been by far the best experience i have ever had at a jersey mikes! I have never had any poor experience with food and has always been accurate with what I ordered. Also every time I have been in two girls have been working and are very kind and helpful and truly help improve the experience!“

“Friendly people who work there. Great service. Clean“

“There's one nice gal in there I believe her name is amber. The other staff seem not to care much about anything at all but every time I come there she is always juggling everything. There could be a line of 10 people and she has them all gone in the matter of seconds very impressive. Keep up the good work you need more like her.“

“This is my favorite subway in the city. Ariana (blonde, sweet, always has lovely nails) always makes my sub to Perfection and I can't sing her praises high enough. She remembers me and my order, hold a conversation like no other

I almost stopped coming because of an older shorted haired employee but the other employees make up for her behavior in theirs :>“

“Great experience!! I used to come to this subway a few years ago when it was under a different owner and wow has the management changed. The new owner and team of employees are much kinder and provided me and my family excellent service. Although they don’t accept coupons, I feel like the price is cheap enough compared to other places. Would highly recommend!!!“

“The young man who made my sandwich at 5:15pm(ish) 9/22 killed it. Spot on how I ordered it online. This almost never happens. Following directions with the details should not be taken for granted. “Big things have small beginnings”. Much appreciated!!“

“I love it,Eat it 3 times a day 🤪“

“EDIT: Their GM Jenny got ahold of me and was very apologetic, very nice and helpful about the whole situation. I changed my 1 star to a 5 after that interaction. Thank you

Walked in, attempted to order but the guy behind the counter couldn't look up from his phone to notice us standing there. Waited 5 minutes and ended up leaving. January 5 2026. Walked in at 7:55, left at 8.“