“Was looking for an exceptional butter cream cake for my wife's birthday. Started searching on Google for bakeries and Penelope's caught my eye. I stopped by the shop to get a sense of what they were about and spoke with Penelope's husband who was so passionate about his wife's cakes, I ended up ordering an 8' vanilla butter cream cake. Per their instructions I let the cake sit out for what turned out to be a little over 5 hours before serving and I have to say, this is, without a doubt, the best cake I've ever had and it's not even close. There is really nothing that you can't love about this place.“
“Let's start with the chocolate nutty sandwich. Two flourless peanut butter cookies with chocolate buttercream in the middle. I'd rate it a 3.5 - the chocolate is pretty sweet, and my cookies were quite crumbly to the touch. Overall, not my favorite, but, not my least favorite. On to the strawberry cake... WOW!!! Absolutely delightful! The strawberry purée buttercream really is the star of the show here. I'm sad they won't offer this after this month, but also happy, because I would be tempted to get this all the time. If you get a chance in the next few days to try this, I would. Moist, super tasty, and oh-so-strawberrylicious. Solid 5 stars. As for the service - couldn't tell you who helped me. She barely spoke to me outside of, "anything else?". And when I paid, I was the one who had to say, "Have a good day!". 1 star. The cake boosts my overall rating - it's just so good.“
“I showed up last minute meeting a cake to be iced. And they were willing to do it even though they were getting ready to close. They were willing to take care since I had called beforehand very professional and courteous. And of course, the cakes are always fantastic!“
“Amazing European experience with the best cappuccino around ! The pastries are delicious and the service is attentive, professional and caring & the cakes look beautiful.Dietary restrictions: There are gluten free optionsParking: Plenty of open parking“
“Simply Sweet Cakery was one of the wedding cake vendors through our wedding venue University Club by Wedgewood Weddings. Brooke and Christina were a delight to work with and so organized! To be completely honest, we actually did two different cake tastings because we were a little concerned with the cake texture during our first tasting and we wanted to try some additional flavors. We ended up choosing two cake flavors: lemon raspberry and red velvet. Let me tell you...I was completely blown away by the final product on our wedding day. The wedding cake was actually a priority for us, but let me tell you...it was delicious!! During our cake cutting, I stuck my fork in the cake for another bite because the initial bite was THAT GOOD. It wasn't overly sweet and the texture was spot on and so moist. So so happy that they were one of the preferred vendors of my venue!!“