Home
CT
New Haven
Sandwich Shops

9 Best Sandwich Shops in New Haven

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Sandwich Shops in New Haven.

Showing 9 of 15 restaurants

Sandwich Shop · $
1 Olmo

4.8 Superb 498 Reviews

93 Whitney Avenue, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Mussel Toast with Caper Mayo Escabeche
- Small Combo w Schmear of Cream Cheese
- Bagel with Salmon and Cream Cheese
- Lox Bagel with Cream Cheese
“Been wanting to try yalls bagels for a while and they are amazing!! The everything everything bagel is everything you could ever want in a bagel! Also everyone was super nice and greeted me as soon as I walked in which is sometimes not always the case now. Will definitely be back to try other things!!”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
2 Munchies

4.8 Superb 225 Reviews

957 State Street, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Jerk Chicken Chopped Cheese
- Chopped Cheese Sandwich
- Vegan Steak and Cheese
- General TSO's Chicken
“Munchies makes the BEST cheese steak in CT hands down!! Sooo good!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
3 Del Monaco's Italian Market

4.8 Superb 161 Reviews

475 Townsend Avenue, New Haven
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Rost Beef Grinder with Mayo Salt and Black Peppet
- Mozzarella Red Peppers and Chicken Sub
- Chicken Cutlet Grinder
- Pastrami Nightmare
“Been going here for yrs for the subs which are top notch but i tried a chef salad yesterday it was the Best Chef salad ive ever had!! do yourself a favor and try one! Believe me you wont regret it”
Menu
Sandwich Shop · $
4 Johnny Salami's World Class

4.6 Superb 118 Reviews

205 Food Terminal Plaza, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich
- Breakfast Burrito
- Cuban Egg Roll
- Roast Beef
“One of my favorite places to stop for lunch for almost 20 years . . A true hidden gem. .. Always flavorful , fresh food & amazing hardworking staff . .”
Menu Order
Fast Food · $
5 Ninth Square Market

4.7 Superb 77 Reviews

72 Orange Street, New Haven
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Mojhadara Syrian Dish
- Stuff Grape Leaves
- Falafel Sandwich
- Baba Ghanoge
“First found Ninth Square at CompassionFest! Food SO delicious & healthy - now that we’ve found their New Haven place we can get the food more often. The pictures & videos make my mouth water!!!😋”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
6 Koffee Katering

4.7 Superb 96 Reviews

104 Audubon St, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
“Finally, a coffee shop where the baristas are as excellent as their coffee. Great spot.”
Menu
Sandwich Shop · $
7 Meat & Co.

4.3 Superb 90 Reviews

285 Nicoll Street, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Wayne Johnson Sandwich
- Chicken Sandwich
- Haute Tuna Melt
- Steak & Cheese
“The food is always made fresh right in front of you. William and Freddy are both friendly and excellent at what they do! Highly recommend!”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
8 Super Sandwich

4.3 Superb 71 Reviews

302 Crown Street, New Haven
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Single Mini - Chicken Cutlet Pesto
- Single Mini - Spicy Chicken Cutlet
- Skinny - Chicken Cutlet Italiano
- Super - Sweet & Sour Chicken
“Usually their salads are delicious. But today i came by, right when they opened up (prob a mistake) and ordered a crispy chicken salad … My salad was done in about 5 mins …. ( how can chicken be cooked that fast?) Anyway, i tried to eat the salad for dinner. My croutons were stale, the bread was stale and tomatoes along with the cucumbers tasted like theve been sitting out from the night before. I doubt chicken was freshly made. I’m so disappointed. Next time i know not to come right when they open up.”
Menu Order
Sandwich Shop · $
9 People's Choice Grocery and Deli

4.1 Good 119 Reviews

734 Dixwell Avenue, New Haven
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Steak & Cheese with Pepperoni
- Grilled Chicken & Cheese
- Grilled Cheese with Bacon
- Sausage Egg & Cheese
“MY FIANCE WAS THERE ON 3/4/26 & GOT A LARGE HAM AND CHEESE SUB.. HE GAVE ME HALF AND IT'S DELICIOUS.. IT HAD LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CHEESE, PURPLE ONIONS BUT I TOOK MINDS OFF, PEPPER & MAYO! I BELIEVE I TRIED IT ONE OTHER TIME BUT THATS WHEN I WAS DOWN SOUTH! I LOOK FORWARD TO GOING BACK TO CT TO GET ANOTHER SUB! WE WETE HERE ON 4/17/26 & I GOT A STEAK & CHHESE SUB WITH MUSHROOMS AND KETCHUP.. MY OTHER HALF GOT A HAM & CHEESE WITH THE WORKS! DELICIOUS 😋 😋 😋 8”
Menu