30 Best Seafood Restaurants in Key Largo

“Expected a greasy diner experience - instead had a 2 star Michelin dinner. Service was prompt and courteous. Will definitely be coming back.“

“Excellent service, delicious food, and great atmosphere! Highly recommend! If you’re vegan, they have options! 💜💚😻“

“My family and I were headed on our way out of The Keys. We were looking for waterfront with some good reviews. We were so surprised to find this hidden gem. From start to finish, all of the staff were friendly and welcoming. The outdoor dining is creative with little water fountains and cute decor. The food was some of the best and freshest we found in the Keys. My husband loved the ribs, said they were “on point”. My sisters fish tacos were so fresh ..they had to have caught it that morning!? She raved about it. I have to say that my salad was one of the freshest I’ve ordered at a Seafood restaurant. Props to our waiter Steven, he was refreshingly funny and exceptionally attentive even though they were very busy. Some of the best service I’ve ever had to be honest! I don’t know how this place isn’t 5 stars? People Need to rate when it’s great too!! We will definitely be back!“

“We stopped here for lunch on our way to Key West. The meal was delicious, and the key lime pie was out of this world! Ronald Williams provided the best service. I highly recommend Sal's Ballyhoo's!“

“Food was outstanding and great atmosphere. The waitress was fantastic. Will visit again.“

“Great meal! I loved that they had a light fare option for most options. The food and service were great! Will definitely ref them again on our next visit“

“Thank you for the wonderful meal and service. We will back and keep the quality up🤩🤩🤩 We loved it!!!👻“

“My husband and I ate here and selected a couple of their specials, Prime Rib and the Seafood Senator. Wow! Very impressed! The food was delicious and the service excellent! We highly recommend this place!“

“The food was soooo good, service was exceptional.. Highly recommend!!!“

“Wonderful view, friendly server (Anton). A wonderful experience“

“We had out boat at the marina for about 6 months. The guys were very helpful and very easy to deal with. The marina is very sheltered and well maintain. Will stop there again if we are passing through,“

“great food, great service and ice cold beer. Best value in Key Largo“

“They were very packed during the first day of of the lobster event where it was 20 bucks for the meal. They were so busy and and the workers continue to keep up with the very hot heat. This was my family‘s first time going out there. We going out there again on Sunday because we enjoyed the music and the food was great. The pricing for the lobster meal was a good price.“

“This place is a great hole in the wall. It has a no frills ambiance, but our server was fantastic. We had the legendary conch fritter. It is huge and so perfect, with tender conch and a sweet type of batter. If you are an uptight picky pants, move right along.“

“On vacation in the keys and my son wanted to try fishing. We stopped into this shop looking for tackle. The staff were more than welcoming and very helpful. They put us on the right gear to use to catch fish. They also gave my son a tour of the live baits they sell. Amazing place, if you’re in the area I highly recommend you stopping in there!“

“highly recommend. beautiful sunset overlooking the beach and the scallops were really good.“

“Great place! The tropical drinks were fantastic. I would recommend the blue fresh. It was clean and crisp. We had the smoked fish dip as an appetizer. It was a little dry but had a great flavor. For entrees, we had the watermelon salad, mahi club and jerk bbq chicken. Watermelon salad was 7/10 it had a healthy amount of watermelon and topped with pistachios. The jerk chicken was absolutely phenomenal! However, the mahi club left something to be desired. The flavor was good, but they really gave a small portion for what it should’ve had.“

“Jamila was our very attentive server who definitely made our experience at this establishment a lovely time. She met our every request in a pleasant way.
Six Stars for Jamila. Give this restaurant a try, you won't be disappointed.“

“Great place, great service, very clean, the best restaurant in the keys ! We love it everything about it“

“Went with the family. Everybody was very happy with the food and service.“

“Awesome food and great service“

“I've lived in the Keys 6 years and never knew about the Siren. I was blown away by the service and the food. Definitely my new favorite place!“

“Delicious food!!! Friendly staff! Great prices! HIGHLY recommend! The best brunch on my trip!“

“Wonderful experience. Beautiful place and the food was awesome.“

“They were very packed during the first day of of the lobster event where it was 20 bucks for the meal. They were so busy and and the workers continue to keep up with the very hot heat. This was my family‘s first time going out there. We going out there again on Sunday because we enjoyed the music and the food was great. The pricing for the lobster meal was a good price.“

“Not only do they provide excellent food but they always have great entertainment. Most importantly, the owners have huge hearts and are always willing to support the Keys community!“

“The resort has beautiful grounds and well maintained. The drinks at sunset is a really lovely touch, and the pizzas at Dry Rocks were exceptionally good. However, the room we stayed in (which has a kitchenette) needs work and fails to provide the basics which I would think is a health issue ie. no dishwashing or handwashing liquid. There is also no kitchen plug to wash dishes. Considering the daily cost, I would have thought that these would have been provided. Between booking the resort and arriving, the resort changed from self parking to valet parking and failed to communicate this and the increased cost. I wouldn’t have booked knowing it was valet only parking as we would rather be self sufficient and have easy vehicle access. On this basis, although we enjoyed ourselves, we wouldn’t stay again at the resort and would consider another option.“

“Amazing experience. Burgers were 🔥. Green beans were 🔥. Even though it was raining, the music and view was on point. Key lime pie was delicious. Our new goto stop in Key Largo“

“amazing food. ate here 3 times on my vacation to Key largo.“

“Visited Sharkeys this past Sunday and had a great time. It’s like a sports dive bar that had TVs around the whole place which was great for us since we came to watch the UM game. I will say our visit started off a bit crazy cause our server had to throw people out for yelling and cursing at her about a tv she couldn’t change. From what we heard the people wanted her to change a tv but another table was watching it and they were there first so she couldn’t change it. And I totally get wanting to watch the tv closest to you but the game was on two other TVs and it’s not the servers fault that someone else wanted to watch something different. Other than that our food and drinks were amazing and our server was very nice and attentive even with all the craziness that happened. We ate wings, chicken sliders, and the Baja bowl with shrimp and everything was delicious. I would definitely come back to watch some more football games.“