32 Best Seafood Restaurants near Sea Island

“Nice beachfront place with mediocre food and solid service. Shrimp were fine, fish was mushy, and fried oysters were a soggy clump. Fries were ok, coleslaw slaw was fine but small portion, for $52. Lots of better places to go! Deviled eggs were very heavy with closing pimento cheese spread. Drinks are good, but $18 to $20. Skippable.“

“The Georgian Room at Sea Island was a truly fantastic experience from start to finish. Everything about the meal felt thoughtful, polished, and beautifully done. The food was delicious, the setting was elegant, and the entire atmosphere felt special without being stiff.

Willy was amazing and really made the night memorable. He remembered every detail about us, was incredibly thoughtful and personable, and made the service feel warm and genuine. The rest of the staff were excellent as well — attentive, professional, and seamless throughout the entire meal.

The space itself is beautiful. The renovation feels immaculate, with a lovely atmosphere that matches the quality of the food and service. Everything felt refined, comfortable, and very well executed.

Highly recommend. It was one of those meals where every detail added to the experience, and everything was 10 out of 10.“

“We went for Valentine’s Day. Our server Reid was very friendly! The food was amazing and the drinks were delicious. 10/10“

“We just had an amazing meal and Jason the manager was amazing! They were so friendly, food was quality, and not only fresh but delicious! All around a great restaurant and I recommend as a must visit if you’re in the area.“

“Absolutely delicious! I am so glad we decided to give this place a try while on vacation in the area. I love that they are dog friendly for outdoor dining.“

“This is the best restaurant on Saint Simons Island. Great foods, service and pricing. I’ve been there many times and it is always consistently the best. Brigette the bartender is always the best.
You won’t be disappointed.“

“Visiting from St. Augustine in February. Best seafood meal we’ve had during our trip!! Soft shell crab special and Scallop bowl amazing. Service and view top notch. Great value definitely eat here.“

“Great spot for food, drinks, and the view. Highly recommend.“

“Cocktail special on the burger and oyster made it affordable, otherwise prices are a little steep: great atmosphere and excellent service.“

“Great date night. We ate on the patio, which is dog friendly .“

“My family and I could not recommend St. Simons Seafood highly enough after a fabulous experience from the moment we walked through the door.

We were visiting this week with family friends and enjoying all of the beauty that the Golden Isles have to offer. This being a beach trip, we knew we had to prepare a few seafood dishes to round out our days relaxing seaside.

Greeted by a wonderful local selection, we narrowed down our decision to shrimp & mahi mahi. The service was excellent, with staff very willing to advise and ensure we received the highest quality seafood in town at a very reasonable price. We highly recommend the peeled & deveined shrimp for ease of preparation.

Out of our St Simons Seafood purchases we enjoyed a lovely shrimp étouffée, and grilled mahi mahi paired with a quinoa salad and greens. Both fish were fresh and delicious! We will definitely be stopping by again when we return to the area.“

“Another amazing dinner at Mudcat Charlie’s. I’d give a food recommendation (mahi, gator bites, burger…etc.) but honestly you can’t go wrong with anything on the menu! Bring your friends, enjoy the view, the relaxed atmosphere and the drinks!“

“Tate was great. So was his co worker, we just didn't get his name. The food and atmosphere were fantastic. I want to thank those 2 young men for a great experience. The food was fantastic as well. Shrimp and grits for me, fried shrimp for my husband and half a dozen steamed oysters. The draft beer were as cold as I have ever had. Will definitely be back!“

“We were staying on the island five days and discovered this restaurant the last night. It was the best food we tasted, the service was great, and the prices and quantity! Oh - and a great view! There were four of us and we all order something different along with appetizers!!! Everything was delicious!!!!! The only negative was it was our last night and we couldn’t go back the next day!!! We will definitely go again when visiting the island!!!“

“Eating breakfast here was a glorious experience, echoing grandeur of the Gilded Age through the opulent Roaring Twenties.

My family and I had breakfast reservations for four at 8:30am on a weekday. The dining room was set to perfection as we were greeted with a welcoming smile and offered to pick any table we preferred. We selected a table by the window. It was wonderful to see a dining room set with fine China again. It seems rare nowadays.

Once settled, we were promptly offered tea, coffee, or a collection of juices before embarking on the breakfast buffet and omelet station. There were no lines yet being so early on a weekday, but my oh my, what a beautiful feast! I was apprehensive that the food would be generic given the continental selection, but I was pleasantly impressed by the tastes, presentations, and twists to the menu. The French toast and overnight oats were my favorite, with a close third place by the bacon.

In addition to the delicious food, the wait staff was attentive and happy. The tables were nicely spaced to keep the dining room at a quiet noise level. And the coffee and pots of tea kept flowing. A big plus!

The only negative I can find with my dining experience is that I was mistaken that the extra fruit juices I ordered a la carte were part of the breakfast buffet. I wish I had known that only the juices on the buffet tables were included. However, when you are dining at such a fine dining establishment, you do not mind the extra price.

I encourage dining here and will be a repeat customer! Thank you to the staff of the JIC for a splendid morning!“

“Had a couple of shrimp baskets to go tonight! Superb!! Sweet Potato very good but a bit overdone. I wish your site bragged on local shrimp , But if they weren't they were certainly very good!“

“So good! Everything we had was delicious, service was extremely fast and the Frose (frozen Rosé was delicious!“

“Great food and service! Highly recommend!“

“Exceptional food and service plus our fury friends can sit outside.“

“Delicious filet and fresh vegetables!“

“By far , we had the best meal we had on St, Simons here! Fried flounder was fantastic and the home made key lime pie was the best I have ever eaten“

“Best restaurant in Georgia Everything on the menu is fresh, delicious, healthy and reasonably priced. I live on Saint Simons Island and eat there almost every day. Everyone from the management to the staff are hard-working, friendly and do a fantastic job. If you give it a try it will be your favorite restaurant. You will not be disappointed and Barbara Jean and Jim Barta Will see to it that you are super satisfied.“

“Love this restaurant! The food is always great and the staff is very friendly. Our son has several food allergies too, and they are so accommodating to prepare safe meals for him that he enjoys!“

“We had the Korean tacos and they were amazing! Chef Quimet does a great job on everything he makes and creates.“

“Rafters is a one of a kind bar with a cozy music venue that offers variety of vibes for any kind of event 5 stars ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“For the exception of ruining my Anniversary celebration that I had planned, everything else was okay. The food was good! Drinks were just strong enough and not just watered down! View was stunning! Service was average, I had called days in advance to reserve indoor window seating to celebrate our Anniversary. I had planned a whole “thing” I was going to do near the stunning view of the window for the wife. When we arrived they pulled our information and one lady asked us “indoor or outdoor?” The other hostess told her the system said “indoor with window seating” and gave her a look of disappointment. As they walked me to my sitting area it was not window seating and table was wobbly. I was unable to do my whole “thing” I had planned and just started off the evening not on a good start, but drinks made up for it 🤷‍♂️😒“

“Food and service were excellent, Misty took great care of our group. Will always make sure a trip to Jekyll includes Tribuzio.“

“Was excited to try after reading reviews. Seated quickly and server took drink orders. Then the world stopped. After waiting 55 minutes we inquired about our order and learned from the hostess there was no “cook” in the kitchen. This became apparent when we noticed only one table in the entire restaurant, both inside and outside, had food on the table. Sadly, the food we did see didn’t look particularly good either. Plenty of other dining establishments nearby…do yourself a favor take a pass on this place! 1/17/23“

“We had a cocktail, French fries that we a cross between potato chips and French fries, salad, patty melt. All very good with great attention from staff.“

“Come to Bennies red barn best steak in all of Brunswick ga !!! Come get you a raccoon it’s a delicious dessert with some nice brandy in it !!!!“

“Finally went to The Ocean Lodge last night with my great friend, and we were both so pleasantly surprised. The views are simply spectacular, and to be honest the food,music, and drinks were totally amazing! I was expecting very little with the food and the service, but it was phenomenal. I was very impressed and can’t wait to go back.“

“We had dinner at the Beach House and had a lovely evening! I got the shrimp boil and my husband got chicken tenders. Both were very filling and the shrimp boil's seasoning was amazing! Probably best I have ever had! Only suggestion is they need a designated hostess. People wait several minutes to be seated, but other then that the waitresses were very nice and did great! Dog friendly as well with a closed in patio!!“