33 Best Sandwich Shops near Cary

“I was running out and needed a quick sandwich when I placed an order through the app, I accidentally made a mistake by not choosing toasted, however, the service was fantastic.And when I got into the restaurant, they were able to work with me. So I was able to get the sandwich, the way that I wanted.“

“I visited the Cary Jimmy John’s on Thursday, August 7th, 2025. This was my fourth visit to the Cary JJ’s following my last visit in July but I have always loved this chain of food. My sandwich was really good and it was easy picking it up after work where I just got to enjoy myself and nothing better than JJ’s to do so. I recently joined Freaky Fresh rewards and it is so worth it! The staff were friendly, respectful but soft spoken and good at their job. I am sure I will be back soon! (Written 8-15-25)“

“Really enjoyed my visit to this Subway! From the moment I walked in, the staff was friendly, welcoming, and very helpful. The store was clean and well organized, and everything looked fresh and nicely prepared. My sandwich was made exactly the way I wanted, and the ingredients tasted fresh and delicious.

I really appreciate the attention to detail and the great customer service. It’s not always easy to find a place that consistently provides good food, cleanliness, and friendly service all together. This location definitely made a great impression on me. I’ll definitely be coming back and would recommend this Subway to anyone looking for a fresh and quick meal!“

“This place was delicious! one loaded Italian 6 inch sub turned into 2 meals! 😘 Great prices too!“

“Nice sandwich shop but $17 for a sandwich with very little meat? We had the #1 with mortadella, basically tasteless and again, hardly any meat. The bread is amazing! Cheese and other fixings were very good. Very nice staff and excellent service. Nice casual seating to dine in.“

“Love the Subs!!“

“while they usually do great I ordered 2 of the big Kahana tubs today. I've never had one but as the sandwich and pictures show, it's not supposed to have lettuce. I had half my teeth removed a few weeks ago and lettuce is just not doable for me. highly disappointed.“

“We have started coming to McAlister's Deli more frequently. We are seniors and usually order the Choose 2 off the menu which is just enough for a good lunch choice...a half sandwich and a cup of soup. The ladies who work there are very kind, helpful and respectful. We enjoy the variety of sandwiches offered and the food is great!“

“Food is great made fresh. Owner and staff are awesome. Very clean and neat atmosphere. They treat you like family“

“We have been coming here since at least 2005. Love Quiznos toasted sandwiches in general, but this is an exceptional location. Everyone is always very friendly, the restaurant is very clean, the atmosphere is relaxed, the food is made fast, and the food is *very* good.
Excellent, clean, consistent, and friendly--exactly what you want in a restaurant.“

“my local jersey mikes is trash. this one in crystal lake is awesome. very friendly staff. last time my card wasn't working and the girl hooked me up. I like her the most at that store“

“I had the kahuna sub it was fire 🔥 I will be going back“

“Great quality food! Everything was fresh, tasty, and made just the way I wanted. The ingredients were crisp, and my sandwich was delicious. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and provided excellent customer service. Overall, a great experience, and I'll definitely be coming back. Highly recommend this Subway location!“

“The sweet owner walked across the tracks this morning to give my daughter an avocado egg sandwich before taking the train to Chicago. He heard my daughter wanted one and he was so kind to Bring her one. Btw my daughter enjoyed it on the train! Thank you again for your hospitality!“

“I had a great experience at Firehouse Subs! I ordered the New York Steamer sub with chips and a soda, and everything was fantastic. The sandwich was hot, packed with flavor, and loaded with perfectly melted cheese and plenty of meat. The bread was fresh and soft, which made the whole sub come together perfectly.

The chips were crisp and a great side, and the soda was nice and cold. The restaurant was clean, the staff was friendly, and the service was quick. You can really tell they care about quality ingredients and making a great sandwich.

If you’re looking for a delicious, filling sub with great service, Firehouse Subs is definitely worth a visit. I’ll definitely be coming back again!“

“First time trying a McAllisters. Loved it. Friendly staff. Soup, sandwiches great! Omg. Loved their sweet tea!!“

“Employees very nice and #6 very good.“

“very friendly fast service, nice atmosphere and always very clean place, food is always great.“

“Absolutely love the soup and sandwiches! Head and shoulders above both Subway and Panera. And a shout out to the young man who made our sandwiches today. He dropped the mustard bottle on the floor while making the sandwich. What really impressed me was he picked it up and placed it in the sink, and grabbed a fresh one. It didn't matter that there was no way any dirt got in the bottle, he did the right thing.“

“It was my first time coming here. I received an email for a fund raiser for my daughter's school and decided to pick up dinner for my family and try it out. Tina was extremely nice and helpful. She made an ice cream cone for my daughter which she loved.

I got the large BBQ cheese steak with cheese fries and the peanut butter milk shake. I also ordered a regular beef cheese steak. The portions sizes are big and we had enough for two meals. I also got six boneless wings with there hottest sauce and they were very good.

The food was excellent and the service was great. I will definitely be coming back again to try more of the menu.“

“I always go to this Subway because they remember my order and my name every time I go in. The owners do a great job of keeping the restaurant clean. The veggies are always fresh as well as the bread. This location is much better than the one in Cary.“

“Placed two separate online orders for a total of three sandwiches. Arrived to the restaurant early and was greeted by the nice man behind the counter. He verified the names on my orders and was preparing the sandwiches. He was very friendly and pleasant. Sandwiches had plenty packed into them and were delicious. Everything in both orders was correct“

“The steak and cheese sandwich was good and I get it all the time but the problem was when i used those drink fountains not the bottle one but the one you have pure drink in the cup there was something in the drink. Although I changed my mind that I will just buy a drink for the bottle.“

“I always appreciate the fresh ingredients and Jack’s kindness. He always checks in on how my family is doing and provides a personal touch one doesn’t often get on the fast food industry. Veggies piled high and don’t forget the bacon.“

“I ordered lunch and needed to have it within 15 minutes and Jonathan happened to be the delivery guy for the job and arrived in perfect time and was very polite! I will definitely be calling back and hoping Jonathan will be delivering again! Thank you so much!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Five Stars

I ordered Subway online and got the Meal of the Day — the tuna sandwich — and it was fantastic. Everything was fresh, made exactly the way I requested, and ready right on time. The tuna was creamy and flavorful, and the bread was soft and perfect.

The online ordering was smooth and easy, and my food was packed neatly and stayed fresh. For a quick, affordable, and satisfying meal, Subway really delivered. I’ll definitely be ordering this again!“

“Great place and awesome sandwiches! Location was clean with a friendly and courteous staff. Sad to see reviews like the one posted December 2021, personal beliefs on such a controversial subject should be left out.“

“Great experience overall! The place is very clean and well-maintained, which really makes a difference. The service was excellent—quick, professional, and friendly. There was a staff member there who clearly has a lot of experience; she knew exactly how to handle everything smoothly and made us feel very comfortable. You can tell they care about quality and customer satisfaction. Definitely worth visiting!”“

“Love the Chocolate Shake...and I add banana 🍌...just to be me!!! 😍👸🏽“

“We came with a mobile order, we had to wait for about 5 ish minutes. They were super apologetic which was nice. After we got our food went home. When we checked the bag my bowl was missing. We called the store and the manager was super problem solving, and considerate. He compensated us with a pastry. Honestly one of the best restaurant experiences I've had“

“Fantastic job on the $1 Special today! Line kept moving quickly, and workers were pleasant and upbeat (at least while I was there)!“

“Excellent fresh made sandwiches and the chili was also very good. Very friendly and accommodating people behind the counter. Will definitely return.“