50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Winnetka

“Fresh and delicious attention to detail. Just had a deep dish pizza with red onion and yellow peppers. Perfect balance of flavors.“

“We stopped today as a family for pizza before hitting up all the Home Alone sites. The pizza was incredibly delicious! The staff were friendly and the building itself was small and cozy. Fast service too! The neighborhood is delightful as well! Would absolutely stop again when in the area.“

“Has to be the best pizza I have tried in awhile. Just tried yesterday and had the meat pizza. With garlic dip AMAZING!!! Will try all there other pizza, sides, and deserts.“

“We LOVE ❤️ Milly’s meticulously hand crafted pizza! You can absolutely taste the love and care that goes into their food-well worth the wait to experience this deliciousness!! Keep up the great work we’re customers for life!“

“I tried the pizzas last night. We had 4 different kinds and they were honestly soooo delicious! Can’t wait for you to open! This is GREAT pizza!!!“

“Was excited to finally try this neighborhood gem. An excellent choice for my birthday dinner. The arancini were phenomenal! Can’t wait to come back.“

“Stopped here for a quick bite during my road trip and was impressed with the quality of their pizza. One of my favorite slices I tried was the Shawarma pizza. It’s very unique, different and packed with flavor . Def recommend giving them a try.“

“We're from out of town and stopped in for dinner after visiting a nearby museum and our pizza was delicious. The staff is extremely friendly and took excellent care of us. Cannoli we're great as well. We're over an hour away, but we will be back!“

“We always look forward to takeout (during COVID) and look forward to seeing you in person. Pizza is always fantastic!!! Always!“

“Amazing place and the staff are awesome“

“Absolutely delicious! I would totally recommend. 🫶🏻“

“This pizza is so good! I wish they were open more often“

“Delicious, sparkling, clean, very friendly owner and staff! This place is a gem.“

“Great food and top notch service. A must have when we are in the city.“

“Good thin crust and good ingredients, cooked perfect“

“Our pizzas were fantastic! The gluten free crust was delicious (per the two that ate it). The deep dish was wonderful as well! So many options, super friendly service! Lots of locals were eating here so that is a good sign.“

“Ordered catering for a 40th birthday party and it was excellent! A great value and everyone enjoyed the food! Huge portions of chicken and salad and guests devoured the beef! And of course the pizza never disappoints! Highly recommend! Great service!“

“My experience with this restaurant was very good and wonderful. The people who work inside are clean and advise you on special things. There is also a wonderful taste in the food and it is very clean. Everything is halal here and the prices here are very good at the lowest prices. You can eat your meal for one person and you do not need to order anything else.“

“Always on point wood the good eats“

“amazing staff, incredible food, and prices are great. definitely better than your local pizza place, check them out“

“Great atmosphere and food!“

“We've loved Joe's for over a decade and decided to rent the party room at their new location for an event. It was fantastic! The food was great as always, and Kim and Eric took wonderful care of our party throughout the event. Thank you for making everything perfect for our friends and family!“

“Great tasting pizza and friendly staff. Hadassah was very helpful and accommodating :) Pepperoni tastes very accurate despite it being vegetarian, my boyfriend didn't even realize it wasn't true pepperoni. Would recommend and we will be back!“

“Great small place to get pizza! Bread was fresh and tasty!“

“Short of Rome the food is great great great@!@
The specials are a real treat the lasagna is delicious!!! LUCY is great the owner is friendly and cares for his guests.

The best for more than 30 years!
Roseann“

“delivery order alittle later but more importantly both pizzas were cold.Tasted ok but if hot would have been better. they should use pizza hot bags to keep food hot.“

“The Best food in Chicago,delicious food,good prices,and the nicest owner in the world,Franco“

“AMAZING pizza, pasta, cheesecake and cocktails. 10/10 rating. Service was fast, and our server was so kind and accommodating. Honestly considering moving to Chicago just for this food. Haha!! +very kid friendly“

“We dined in tonight. The staff was friendly and helpful and the food was amazing. Will definitely stop in again next time we are in town.“

“Been coming here for years. Even though I moved out of neighborhood to Des Plaines, I still come here. Everything is awesome! 👍👍 two thumbs up!“

“Straight up my favorite pizza place in Chicago. This is a full blown endorsement from a slightly overweight living musical legend. Check my credentials. �“

“we have gone here 2x in the last 2 months - the 1st was for carry-out and it was fantastic - the 2nd was for dine-in lunch specials and it was fantastic.“

“All was amazing for our first visit.“

“Best Pizza in Evanston. The dough, the unique ingredients. I. Am.Hooked👌“

“I ordered a square pizza consisting of four pieces. It was a deep-dish pizza and the appearance is debatable. But the taste convinced me, because the pizza with extra jalapenos was really delicious! You even could refine the preparation of the crust in terms of flavor, so I decided to have garlic in the dough, which was very good. I made my order through a third-party app that had a promo, which means pay one, get two. All in all, I was very satisfied with the value for money of my order.“

“Absolute lovely! Great service, fantastic food - highly recommend!“

“Very nice food fresh .must go“

“The best tasting pizza! Delicious and flavorful! Great customer service!“

“Great food! Great times! Tommy is the best behind the bar. Always makes us laugh and feel welcome.“

“Friendly phone person to start out . Thank you, Katy . ( Some restaurants have lost sight of the importance of the first person to represent their business . No one wants to deal with a cocky and rude high school girl who can't get their order right. ) Excellent Pizza! Nice CRUNCH on their thin crust dough . Only very slightly thicker crust than most. And not burnt or charred . ( Not that I mind a good char taste ) The cheese is perfectly caramelized, so I wouldn't risk losing that by ordering a well done pizza . The crunchy dough stands up well to the slightly generous amount of sauce that is perfectly balanced . Extra thin sliced fresh veggies are also much appreciated .“

“If you haven’t had Pizza Mania you are missing out! Warning- this is the type of pizza you crave! Cool little neighborhood gem, this small little shop knows how to throw down on a pizza, walk in and you can just tell they love what they do, music is playing and the smell hits you, you’re in for a treat! I started with a slice of Cheese, and dressed it up with some honey and black pepper, after I burnt the roof of my mouth off inhaling this I quickly ordered a sausage and pepperoni, and bam I thought I was on an episode of Triple D, cause I was cruising through “Flavor Town”! I was out the door with a DC (Diet Coke, if you know you know) cause I’m a gentleman! l had this amazing experience for under 10 bucks! Go here- eat here- and then repeat.“

“My favorite here is the Speck Di Luna. I've done the other ones (pep shrooms, margherita, etc) which is good too. I like this place because it's pizza by the slice, open late, and they have vegan options too.

I haven't tried their sides but they look good too.“

“Highly recommended for halal food with the taste of italian pizza & middle east chicken tenders with rice. Scrumptious food“

“Love Barnabys...There thin crust pizza snappy crunch of the crust is perfect when dining in like any pizza way better dining there in person than having it get soggy /cooler transport home etc. Plus they serve Green River soda pop at the bar, a real treat in Chicago. Went out the norm for me and ordered half pepperoni and half cheese..I am a pizza snob and i actually think this is one of the best thin crust for the north suburb Chicagoland area 100% recommend!“

“Fantastic restaurant in the neighborhood serves excellent food and donuts and takes care of the neighborhood and the world. So grateful for their presence in Rogers Park. Also the peach spicy Sammy is to die for.“

“Goirdano’s left our area and I stumbled on to NPC. I ordered and was surprised they deliver to Skokie. I called an hour later and they informed me due to busyness our pizza was accidentally delivered to the wrong location. They quickly credited me the amount and still made a new order for us. The pizza was fantastic. Deep dish and margarita. They totally owned the situation and did their best. Pizza felt cleaner. Less additives or chemicals than Lou’s or Giordano’s. Will definitely return.“

“Not the best single slice place in the area, maybe it depends on the time of day because mine were not crispy and had probably been sitting on the warmer for too long. The other food looks good so would maybe go back to try another item but the slices are meh.“

“Ho-lee-shit, we had dinner at Pequod's Pizza tonight and I am insanely impressed by the quality of this deep dish. Dough is amazing, cheese is high quality, and all of our ingredients were fresh and fantastic. We had strong drinks, and some nice garlic cheese bread. Pequod's lived up to this foodie's expectations, despite me being a critic about deep dish at times. Just wow, what a meal! I will make sure I come back every single time I return to Chicago. Don't miss out on seeing and tasting this iconic Chicago spot. Also Pete is a great waiter, request him!“

“I love the pizza and the soup. Always very good. Good service.“

“Catered from Villa Rosa for another Family Party. The food is simply outstanding!!!
The sausage and peppers literally melt in your mouth. Great Service, easy ordering process, great food. Another great Northwest Side establishment.“