50 Best Sandwich Shops near Nutley

“I ordered 2 hero platters from here on very short notice and they were able to accommodate my needs quickly. They had great customer service and even offered me a drink on the house as I waited. The meat, veggies, and cheese were very good and tasted incredible fresh. However, I would love to see them explore different bread options for their sandwiches. If they decide to explore different bread option Hero King would definitely get more business from me. So because of the bread id give the food 3/5 and the service is definitely a 5/5 in my opinion.Parking: The block seemed a bit busy when I got there. There’s plenty of space on the side blocks if you aren’t against a bit of walking.“

“Very good place, excellent food, treatment. From the waitresses Ask for Yelissa. An incredible deal, I felt at home!!!!!The best burger. From NJ when you go I recommend ordering some empanadas as a starter called the 3 hits are the Maximum and an oatmeal juice with orange wow. DeliciousThe chimi and the mofongo are the end“

“Easily one of the best sandwich shops in JC. I've been through almost everything on the menu and have yet to be disappointed. My go to these days is the #5, breaded chicken lettuce tomato hot peppers and Chipotle mayo. Can't go wrong with the chicken vodka Parmigiano, one of the best vodka sauces I've ever had!“

“My favorite place in Hoboken! The owner is one of the kindest people I have ever met, and every delicious dish is made with love. Great coffee, omelettes and breakfast sandwiches! Cozy ambiance, good music and cool local artwork on the walls. Definitely give this place a try!“

“Very friendly staff. Their Falafel sandwich is to die for, and their fries are truly on point.UPDATE: I finally switched it up and got the Mordi's Breakfast Pita, no meat...OMG it was so good and perfectly messy. I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. And yes, the staff is still amazing!!“

“Was not disappointed!The roast beef was incredibly buttery soft, but the brine in the marinated red peppers w/garlic was off the charts with an almost olive like pop.The bread was great too...Yes totally worth the drive for the sandwich and scenery.Parking: Parking behind the building.“

“I have lived around the area for many years, and never have I tried a better Itlian hero than at Nick's. You are paying for quality - you can tell by the second you take the first bite. A sandwich is as good as the bread, theirs is fresh and perfect. Nick's is a MUST TRY!“

“I was casually walking down rainbow road when Mario, Donkey Kong and Shy guy grabbed me and brought me to this Subway. A guy whose name I think was maneater told me I had to eat 100 cookies or else Donkey Kong would turn me into a banana. I said ok and began this grueling challenge. I started chowing down on the cookies and when I reached the halfway point Machoman told me that the rest of the cookies would be footlong cookies, I said "radical" and continued. I was enjoying the last two cookies when all of a sudden Rick Grimes and superman walked in and blew up Donkey Kong, Mario and Shy guy and told me the walkers were coming and I had to leave. I said goodbye to Magic Mixing Machine and he said that wherever I go I could just reach into my pocket and pull out a free footlong cookie.10/10 would recommend, if you survive the walkers roaming around.“

“So I went in undecided, all I knew was how hungry I was at the moment. Told the women behind the counter you make me what you think is the best. Damn she delivered. I had a steak sandwich with lettuce tomato and sum on a warm here roll. It was like a chopped cheese but even better. Great job guys! Ill def be back.“

“I work in CT but placed an order on the phone with them (turned out to be DoorDash). When I called to confirm the lunch order, they didn't have any record of it. But Alexis (Asst GM) assured me that my executive and his team would get their lunch today. She researched my order and had me send all the details I could provide, took my phone number, and called me back several times to ensure we were all set. This was not a huge catering order, but she treated me with the same courtesy as if it were. I want to thank her for all of her assistance. I'm sure the team will enjoy their lunch!!!“

“Never disappointed! I am a repeat customer and am glad to see they have expanded the menu today I had the Dagwood and it was delicious! Added photos from last time as well. There is also a park next door to walk around in or even picnic, love this place!Vegetarian options: Sandwiches“

“good location with ample parking space.inside was neat and clean; and the staff were pretty good during our visit.we has the usual philly steak and it was hot and fresh just the way we like it. Add some chips and wewere quite satisfied with such simple butdelicious meal.“

“I always drive by this place and since my son is off, took him there. The staff was nice and made sure that us being there for the first time knew exactly what we were ordering. I got a turkey sandwich and my son got the chicken cutlet. Both sandwiches were amazing and my son complimented that this was the best he had and like wise same for me. I asked him what would u rate it he gave 5 stars out of 5. So for a ten year old think he knows what he's talking about. Will be coming back here often.Parking: They have a parking lot in the back but didn't get a chance to go in as that street is busy so I parked on a side street.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️I recently visited Jersey Mike's and had an outstanding experience! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the staff, especially Matt, who went above and beyond to ensure I had a fantastic meal. The sandwiches were fresh, delicious, and made exactly to my liking. The atmosphere was clean and inviting, and the service was prompt and friendly. I'll definitely be returning, thanks to Matt and the entire team at Jersey Mike's for providing top-notch service and scrumptious sandwiches!“

“Very clean, fast, & friendly employees were very welcoming and accommodating to what I was looking for if it was not put out amazing food if your passing thru on the highway definitely give this place a stop and get some gas while your at it lol“

“Hey I live in McGinley Square, in Jersey City and the local Subway sandwich shop is just a block away, but Super Hero Sub Shop blows Subway out of the water! The bread is always soft, fresh, tasty and their meats are NOT processed, but cooked/roasted whole and you taste the seasonings in the meat beautifully! I just got a Medium size hot roast beef, with Muenster cheese, onions and mayo and it is DELICIOUS. I wish they stayed open past 4pm but they truly are a lunchtime treat! Highly recommend!“

“When Claudia is crafting your sandwiches, you can rest assured that they'll be absolutely delightful. This place offers great value, reliability, and speed. Despite their efficiency, the food still retains that comforting homemade taste and feel. I wholeheartedly recommend it with a perfect score of 10/10!“

“Some of the best sandwiches in town. There is a board near the deli area with some listed suggestions, but they’ll basically put whatever you want in a sandwich.There are some interesting pantry style items here, but I wish there was more of this available.Wheelchair accessibility: Sloped entrance to get in. A bit tight with the door set up, but still manageable.“

“Take out always fresh!! I use to go there and I always asked for smoked honey turkey, and they wouldn’t have it, later on in life I started going back and it’s a sign “ honey turkey “, lol thank me with a smoke honey, turkey, and Swiss on wheat bread with everything on it except salt, I want pepper, lettuce, tomatoes, light, mayo, mustard, oregano,light oil and vinegar????“

“Exceptional experience at Jersey Mike's! The customer service was outstanding, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The staff's friendliness and efficiency stood out. Moreover, the food was consistently fresh and delicious. A great place for a satisfying meal with top-notch service.“

“This Subway restaurant has the best prices, the best tasting, fresh bread and the crunchiest veggies. The workers are friendly and prepare the food well. The owner is so pleasant and kind. The place is clean and organized. I wouldn’t eat Subway anywhere else.“

“I have been visiting Did Amigos for over 20 years. Highly recommend the flavors in this steak sandwich. Make sure you get cheese and onions. Batido de trigo is also delishious. Cash only local spot.Parking: You can park in the lot above the restaurant for 1 hour , just make sure they stamp your card.“

“Pretty good breakfast sandwich (eggs, cheese, sausage in a roll) but found it a bit pricey (~$8). It seems that a signature sandwich worths more. Saw the orange juice machine making juices and had one since they looked delicious. It was delicious but also pricey (~$7) For a grab'n'go I expected paying a bit less but overall good choice“

“i love Jersey Mike’s . my Favorite is the Route 17 location. my least Fav is Hamburg Turnpike. The employees are rude and sloppy and wasn’t wearing a mask correctly . I literally heard the guy talking about me with another employee. it took me 35 minutes to get my 3 sandwich’s . PS i said no oil and vinegar !!!“

“I just tried Agamie for the first time (i’ve been meaning to come here for a while, and I finally got there) and it did not disappoint. Great sandwich! Next time (which will be soon) I will bring my police patch so they can start a patch board collection. Keep up the great work guys. Awesome food I’ll be back real soon.“

“I don't remember the person's name but he was Asian and was really good. He messed the order but it was really nice to go change it. Even the other lady who was taking the order was also really good and recognized the order being wrong. Great customer service.I am sorry I am bad with remembering name.“

“This is the ONLY Blimpie I go to because it’s the only one that actually makes your order right and most importantly STUFFS your sandwich good, other Blimpies I’ve been to don’t makes sandwiches so good and thick like this one does. I come here with my friend religiously once a week and we both order Tuna melts and they always come out perfect every single time.These negative reviews I see are written by pompous idiots I swear, this place is always clean, the workers are friendly and the food is always good, don’t pass this place up it’s the best. The only negative thing about this place is finding parking on central Ave but other than that this place is perfect.“

“Great food I love the baked ziti very delicious, one sister loves the pork chops while the other enjoys the ribs. The food is always freshly made and delicious. The owners are very friendly and give great customer service. Highly recommend Subs Galore for any meal. The walls are decorated with old licence plates and nice friendly atmosphere.“

“I moved into the area recently and have gone to this location multiple times over the last year two years. Honestly, I’m not sure what it is, not sure who is doing what, but everybody who works behind the counter are some of the friendliest people in food service I’ve ever met! They are genuinely sweet people. Seriously, when you go in there, just strike up a little light conversation. They’re so nice! A pleasure! Every single one I’ve ever encountered behind the counter! Good job!! ☺️“

“It's been my second time in Hudson Grille for breakfast and have enjoyed it both times. Great selection and prices are good. Their regular coffee is good as well. They also do lunch and have a great selection for many different kinds of diets.Dietary restrictions: They have vegetarian and vegan options.“

“Food and service is always great. Right off a main road so it can get pretty busy. Establishment is always very generous with their servings and usually pretty quick. The only thing I dislike about this place is that their bread is very soft. I usually like my subs on a crispy roll. This is my go-to option when Cappelluti's Deli in Kearny is closed“

“Never disappoints. I get the club with turkey and pepperoni. The pepper relish is awesome. I really like their cheesesteaks it's pretty good probably one of the best cheesesteaks around. if you know of a better cheese steak around please comment back on this post, i love cheese steak. The stubborn brand cream soda is some of the best cream soda I've ever had. The kids in there are pretty friendly. All in all they make a good sandwich their meat is good quality not cheap stuff.“

“Best pizza!! I have about 50 pizza places closer to me then Comet, but their pizza is beyond worth driving 20 minutes away!! The staff here are also the nicest people! 20+ years later and still one of the best tasting pizza's in New Jersey!!“

“This store is my go-to after a day of driving and shopping. It is on my way home. I always look forward to seeing the workers with their smiles and pleasantness. Prices are reasonable and the store is clean. Plenty of seating. There is a large parking lot, but sometimes I'm not able to get a spot near the store and have to go to another part of the strip mall. Great location for this store and has been there for a long time.“

“Great place owner is pretty cool . I had a reuben and a Italian sandwich. The Italian sandwich was my favorite more than the reuben very fresh. Parking is very hard to find I would recommend calling in advance and placing an order. For two Reuben’s and a Italian sandwich came to $39. I would definitely say give it a try!“

“My coworker suggested this place for lunch as he used to visit the previous owners a lot. The food is incredible! I got the chicken salad sandwich highly recommended. For the price you cannot beat it. They load the sandwich up! Will definitely be back “

“Fresh food from the bread to the meats and vegetables. Nicely made sandwiches that aren't sloppy. Needs to put more condiments, oil, vinegar and oregano on sandwiches to make them taste more like a sub. Make sure you ask them for those things if you prefer them.“

“My best friend of over 30 years introduced me to this spot. She passed away in Dec. Of 2022 But I continue to go to Montclair DeliIt's become my favorite place to eat. Their food is amazingly delicious and the service is great. They make you feel like family.“

“Turkey Diablo is one of the best I ever had! The buffalo chicken.. extremely questionable.. you know how subway's chicken tastes like fake nuggets? That was exactly it.. not fresh at all. However, i do love the taste of their bread and they have a great amount of options. Staff are always nice “

“Great spot with a friendly staff and good food! Even was digging the Arabic music that was playing. Tried the açaí bowl (one size and base toppings), chicken empanada, and 2 different energy balls. Highly recommended and will definitely stop in again when I’m in the area.“

“This was one of the best sandwiches my fiancé and I have ever had! And a very reasonable price! We just finished the sandwich a minute ago and immediately had to hop on here and leave a great review. Amazing! Very cute place, such nice people, and the food was fresh and made with love. We hope to return soon!“

“Been going here since I was a kid when it used to be a Blimpie. The inside of the store looks exactly the same as it did 30 years ago when my dad used to bring me here and the quality and cleanliness has remained the same. I've spoken with the owner a few times and he said he still uses the "Blimpie" bread and the same condiments. Also, the sandwiches are made as quickly as you finish saying what you ordered! I stop by here once in a while and I am never disappointed with my order. The roast beef with yellow American is still my go-to after all these years!“

“If you want old school Italian, this is the place for you. My family heard about the Belmont Tavern and decided to drive 40 minutes to check this place out. We arrived early on a Friday night, around 5:45PM. It is in a little bit of a rough area and finding parking on the street can be a challenge. The interior does not look like it's changed since it opened. Red and white checkered table cloths, wood paneled walls, and even a phone booth that lights up when you shut the door! All of the customers are all locals. The Tavern is known for their Shrimp Beeps and Chicken Savoy. My recommendation is the Shrimp Beeps over spaghetti. If you order more than one serving, it is served family style. Some of my family members ordered the Chicken Murphy and Chicken Savoy which are more like chicken parts rather than chicken breast. They both thought it was on the dry side. The service is good although we did feel a bit rushed since it was getting busy.“

“The meal that was had was pretty good even t 11 pm at night. The employee was very accommodating, kind, and patient as my friend and I were ordering.Wheelchair accessibility: The entrance provides accomodation for people who travel through wheelchairs.“

“I went there with a lady who's very fussy about what she likes to eat I use the word fussy in a good way since she was very satisfied I'm glad to write a review the Reuben sandwiches and the selections always have fresh ingredientsVegetarian options: When you get there you see what you need appetizingly presented.“

“Been to a lot of Jersey Mikes and i was pleasantly surprised by the incredibly friendly service i received at this location!I Highly recommed it during these days of drive through voices and numb personality service you receive elsewhere.Food was good and the sewrvice fast.I will surely be back.“

“My name is Adam Muhammad I from Denton Texas in USA I am Muslim I go to subway every morning and every day I went there this morning it was closed I leave at 8:45 a I didn’t go to subway this because it was rainy and my subway card has no money I have to wait for my dad get back from vacation subway supposed to be open 8:00 am Monday“

“Excellent sandwich, very courteous and knowledgeable staff. I was there to get a sandwich but I also picked up nice reasonably priced greeting cards and balloons too for my nephew. The place is bright and clean. This will be my go to stop when I am in the area making deliveries. Huge parking lot to park my truck, easy in and out.Also I saw they had a sign that say Buy 2 get 1 Free pizza. Next time I should try the Subway pizza too.“

“Great place for Peruvian food.Parking: No set parking for El Mamut. It's hit or miss on getting a place to park close. Some of the family members parked 2 long blocks away on the Main St. municipal lots. Great restaurant but parking is not good.“