Bagels Restaurants near East Islip, NY

“Do not go was best best place for a sandwich one day got a egg sandwich with 2 hairs in it Talk to the boss nicely he gave me money back and said don’t call back to the store his name was paul“

“Great food and amazing staff that remembers it's customers and what they normally order. Even in heavy storms this place has been open and able to refuel me at the end of a long shift. Greeting me with a smile and helping lift up the end of a long overnight shift. The best of your "essential" heroes besides Emergency Staff.“

“Bagel are good!! Service needs an upgrade. Usually bagel shops have 2 lines so that when u just want a dozen bagels there is no need to wait for all of the deli orders to be taken and then rung up. Wait today was crazy ! I only wanted bagels to go. Everyone in front of me was ordering sandwiches or toasted bagels. I am thinking those items must be good too because of the crowd size.“

“Just tried this spot, as the newest bagel shop in area. We have eaten bagels from all over long island and these are in the top we have had, period. Very delicious feel and taste. The store is very minimalist, basically setup to get in and out. Staff was very friendly as well. Highly recommended“

“BEST BAGEL "DELI" IN AREA . FRESH FOOD, POLITE STAFF. LARGE VARITY OF CHICKEN SALDS PLUS BURGER PLATTERS AS WELL. FRESH MADE SALADS AND THE BEST HOME FRIES ANYWHERE !!!“

“Bagels are always fresh. They have a great selection too. The Rye is my favorite!!!“

“I have been going to this place for years and I've never had an issue with the food, pricing or service. The bagels are delicious: large, crusty, but with a nice chew and taste. (and this is coming from a bagel-snob). The people behind the counter are always very nice and organized even when it's busy.

I also like the locals/regulars who always eat here; they are very colorful and interesting to listen to. This is one of the few places remaining where you can sit down and get a nice bacon, egg, potato platter without having to wait for a table or endure slow table service or ridiculous prices. The home fries with ketchup are an acquired taste but I've grown to love them. FYI-The grill is on a little too high; sometimes eggs are cooked right but over on the outside.“

“my husband and I went there yesterday the food was amazing the staff was so respectful and friendly The Establishment was spotless we actually got to meet the owner Sylvie what a wonderful woman I recommend this place to everyone if you haven't seen it haven't been there go check it out you won't be disappointed“

“Best bagels in town ! Customer service is awesome ! Please give them a try you won’t be disappointed!“

“Wally’s Bagels is hands down the best bagel spot around! The bagels are always fresh, perfectly chewy, and have just the right amount of crisp on the outside. They have a fantastic selection of flavors and spreads, from classic cream cheese to more unique options.
The staff here is also friendly and efficient, even during the morning rush. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast or enjoying a leisurely brunch, Wally’s creates a welcoming vibe that keeps you coming back. Highly recommend!“

“I recently visited this delightful bagel shop and was thoroughly impressed! The bagel sandwiches and croissants were absolutely delicious. My son said it was the best bacon, egg and cheese sandwich he’s ever had. The staff is super friendly as well. I highly recommend this bagel shop!“

“I have not been here in a long time. This bagel loving girl gives them a 10. Perfect crunch, seeds on both sides. The gentleman that helped us this morning along with the other staff were very friendly. I will definitely be back. Oh and the inside is cute..“

“Delicious, made to order bagels, at a reasonable price. The shop was clean and well stocked. The staff was kind and efficient. I would highly recommend this bagel shop. We ordered egg and cheese bagels and they were delicious. You can customize it anyway you like and it comes with juice or coffee. There is no seating for eating in, but that was fine with us because we wanted to take our food to go.“

“I must say this place brought there bagel game! Bagels are delish! Nice to have another bagel spot in town. Welcome!“

“Wish I knew about them sooner! !! I would have gone there for years! They should open one by us in kings park! !“

“Let me tell you something about the man that owns this business. I used to be really strung out on drugs living behind the gas station right across the street. Most of the time I never had money for a meal but this guy would still always feed me. Sometimes it was the ONLY thing I had to eat for days. When I did have money, he wouldn't let me pay because he knew how rough of shape I was in. Fast forward a year later, I have a year clean and went in to buy the breakfast he used to make me. When I tried to pay with my card, his machine didn't accept AMEX and without a second thought he STILL just gave it to me. When you talk about community and delis on Long Island, this place is and will always be at the top of the charts. God bless this man and his family. AMAZING FOOD. AMAZING SERVICE. BUT MOST IMPORTANTLY HE CARES, which is more than people can say about most others.“

“hubby's in there now buying bagels and cream cheese“

“Absolutely the best bagel place on Long Island that I know these bagels are absolutely delicious. This place is great. Staff is great. Service is great. The atmosphere is great. Everything is great about this place. Definitely go here and give it a try.“

“Everything Bagel in Commack is a fantastic spot for fresh, delicious bagels! The bagels are always perfectly baked—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. But the real standout for me is their lox. It's some of the best I've ever had—fresh, cut thin, and just melts in your mouth.
The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is that the service can be a bit slow during busy times, but it’s well worth the wait for the quality you get. Definitely a go-to spot for bagel and lox lovers!“

“One of my favorite bagel cafes on Long Island and easily the best place in East Northport. They have a great selection, some highlights include egg, egg everything, tidied, everything, garlic, and salt bagels. Their lox cream cheese is amazing! This place is always busy for a reason so get here early.“

“This is a nice friendly breakfast spot. Great bacon, egg & cheese sandwich on an everything twist this morning! I have been going to this place for several years and I am always happy with my breakfast sandwich. I'm in and out in less than 8 minutes. Good flavorful sandwich, with crispy bacon, and soft bagel. Every time I go to Dunkin up the road because it's across from my office, I'm disappointed and delayed. Yesterday at Dunkin, it took 20 minutes for me to get a PREMADE chorizo and egg wrap, that was still ice cold in the center. I will GLADLY take the slight detour to NY Bagel, as it's worth it.“

“I've always been going to this location due to its convenience but now that it's under new ownership this year, not only is it better but you get more for your dollar. The prices now are actually better than they were under previous management. Great combinations for breakfast or lunch, many fresh cream cheeses and bagels/flagles. I highly recommend this location. If you cannot find it, go right past the Walgreens if you are heading north on Terry and turn where it says massage envy because it is easy to miss. If you hit Maureen's, you went too far north. It will be on your right.“

“Super friendly service, the BEST bagels on Long Island and a warm, cozy "greasy spoon" atmosphere - Avenue Bagels has the small town charm so hard to find these days. Always clean and comfortable if you choose to sit in and stay, it almost feels like hanging out at a friend's house - my mom and dad (Bob Walsh and Margie Holly Walsh go whenever they can - and they sold me, too. Avenue Bagels is the BEST! <3“

“Best spot for sandwiches!! I love this place. Been coming here for years. Great staff, great service! Their “Big One” hero is the best I’ve had anywhere. It’s the literal the Hungry Man hero with all the goodies. Recommend this place to all long islanders ??.“

“Order a dozen from Ohio. Fast and Great! Thanks“

“If you’re in the East Northport area, and you’re looking for a real bagel, this is the spot! It’s a gem! A whole in the wall, mom and pop, old school shop, with a lack luster sign, in a tiny parking lot, makes this place easy to miss, but don’t miss it!! I’ve been getting my bagels from here for about 8 years, and it’s always been consistent.
After living on the Queens border for many years, I was shocked after moving to East Northport that many bagel shops in town don’t really make bagels. They make donut shaped bread. And most locals are so accustomed to eating this donut shaped bread, that they actually have no idea what a real bagel should taste and feel like. It’s strange. Or maybe locals settle for a less-than delicious bagel, so they can sit in a trendier setting, which I also find weird. But, I digress.
The point of all of that is to say that at Stuff-A-Bagel, you will get the closest thing to an authentic city bagel that I have found anywhere in this general area. Yes, I have tried every bagel shop in East Northport, Northport, Greenlawn and Commack. And none of the ones locals brag about even compare to this one.
When you visit Stuff-A-Bagel, your bagel will be perfectly cooked, slightly toated and “al dente” on the outside, while nice and doughy on the inside. It will have that “pop” that a bagel should. (If you know, you know.) Their bagels are delicious and addicting! Also, their cream cheese tastes homemade, as every bagel store’s should be. If you’re not making your own cream cheese, are you even a bagel store? (Tangent again, sorry.)
Also, the owners here are such lovely people. They are warm and welcoming. They value getting to know their customers, which is a rare thing nowadays. Their prices are fair, and they’ve thrown in a few freebies a couple of times, when my order was larger. And, they keep the line moving. You never have to wait long for your order. I cannot say enough about how wonderful their customer service is. Warning to those who do not like kindness and socialization: (as a previous reviewer stated) you may feel an unfamiliar feeling to interact with your fellow man. But it’s okay. You can do it.
Stuff-A-Bagel is delicious! Next time you’re on Larkfield, driving by, stop in and see for yourself. Better yet, next Saturday, grab your weekly dozen from there! When it comes to bagels, THIS is a place that people should be talking about!!!“

“If you’re from the area, you already know. And if you’re not—let me put you on. JeJoJo Bagels is THAT spot. From the second you walk in, the vibe is welcoming, warm, and just real. It’s not one of those rushed, cramped places where you grab a bagel and run. There’s actually room to sit, chat, and enjoy—like the Sunday morning ritual we all deserve. And the food? Let’s talk about it. The bagels come out warm, fluffy inside with just the right crunch on the outside—the kind that makes you close your eyes for a second on the first bite. Whether you’re a classic bacon egg and cheese lover or you go rogue with lox and scallion cream cheese, every bite hits. The crew behind the counter? Terrific people. They know their regulars, keep things moving, and still manage to smile like they’re genuinely happy to be there. That energy matters. JeJoJo’s has officially become my Sunday morning cheat meal haven. I sit, sip my coffee, tear into a hot bagel, and let the world slow down for a minute. It’s more than a bagel shop—it’s a little pocket of comfort.“

“Use to live in Brentwood years ago and was in town visiting, so I Googled Bagle Shop. and I found one very close, and the Korean women that was helping me and my brother was so nice and friendly, and I was even able to get a poppy seed bagel with cream cheese which I love.Thanks for making me feel at home! Dave!✌️❤️?“

“The best place for bagels and food!!! The friendliest staff!!!!“

“I’ve eaten here a few times and can’t say enough good things about them. The food is delicious! Their delivery is quite quick. The menu is full of creative choices. They offer more just your standard deli fare. Not to mention they have the BEST chicken cheesesteak anywhere around!“

“Just had a chicken cutlet sandwich on a roll with tomato, lettuce, cheese, bacon and a special homemade spicy sauce. The best sandwich ever!!! Please try it! You will love it!“

“Picked up bagels to take to Ohio with me and a sandwich for lunch the day for myself. Sandwich was delicious!! The bagels were a huge hit in Ohio, the kids especially loved the French Toast Bagel.“

“While visiting family in the area we kept seeing cars pulling in at various times of day and knew we had to check out their bagels. They were amazing and the owner was super friendly! We won't waste time getting back on our next visit.“

“This place is literally my all time favorite. The staff is always so wonderful and fun to joke with! lt has my favorite food on the island by far. I’ve grown so close to them every time I come in to the point where they feel like family :)“

“es un excelente lugar de trabajo extraño a mis jefes buenas personas TONY“

“Just catered a lunch from there for 45 people and Tony did an outstanding job. Food was plentiful, fresh and delicious and the presentation was beautiful. I would highly recommend them.“

“near where i work i think? gonna check it out!“

“Awesome food. Awesomer people. I know its not a word but says it all“

“It’s my favorite breakfast sandwich spot. You can text in and have ready usually by the time you get there. They are always busy which is a good thing. I love this place and the staff there. Chris, the owner’s son, is really nice and has a good personality.“

“Fresh food friendly service...“

“My family has been getting breakfast from this place ever since we’ve moved here 8 years ago and almost everything we’ve got were delicious. The bagels are soft and warm, you could choose from all different types of cream cheese and the breakfast sandwiches are amazing. I would highly recommend the Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich which is my favorite item and it’s unbelievable. I definitely recommend going here and you’ll most likely not be disappointed.“

“🥯 Bagel Toastery = Bagel Heaven! 🥯

This place is bagel magic! Fresh, toasty, and loaded with all the good stuff. Super friendly staff and the perfect spot for a quick bite. If you haven’t been, you’re missing out! 😋💯“

“The Breakfast egg and cheese sandwich on a jalepeno bagel was really good and I came back a 2nd time before leaving New York /New Jersey“

“A Tic Toc food reviewer suggested Prestanos. I was looking for an awesome breakfast sandwich that wasnt a Kaiser roll. Prestanos rolls are AMAZING. Ive been there the last 2 days for breakfast, bringing my out of state sister and brother in law. We all loved the sammies. Also got a couple of jelly donuts. Also Amazing. My husband stopped by after work today at 3pm to get Italian bread. I was hesitant about getting any kind of bread late afternoon but it was so fresh. ! Will be checking out their sweets. Great job Prestanos !!“

“I ordered egg salad, lox spread and scallion cream cheese with a dozen bagels for the office. Everything was delicious and fresh. The new owner Sabira is so friendly and really makes sure you are being taken care of. The bagel store is so clean and they are really organized. We are so happy to have such a great place for bagels in town!!“

“Here's a review of Bagel Hero in Oakdale, NY based on My experience:
Bagel Hero - A Heroic Breakfast Experience!
If you're looking for a reliably good breakfast in Oakdale, Bagel Hero seems to hit the mark! You had a fantastic experience with their Hungry Man Hero, getting it just the way you like it. It's always a win when a place nails specific requests, and they clearly did with your order: toasted on both sides, perfectly runny over-easy eggs, and that extra kick of raw onions.
Beyond the customized order, I highlighted a few key things that make Bagel Hero stand out. Silvia helped me, quick and easy service is a huge plus, especially when you're looking to grab a bite on the go. And knowing it's a clean place definitely adds to the appeal.
It sounds like Bagel Hero earned a loyal customer with this visit! What other breakfast spots in Oakdale have you tried?“

“I catered a brunch this weekend with Bagel Buzz. This was my second catering order with them. I spoke with Gina over the phone to place my order and alerted her to the many food allergies in my party. I trust Bagel Buzz with making sure no cross contamination takes place in making my order. My wrap platter arrived on time and beautifully arranged and was delicious. The veggie cream cheese for the bagels was rich with fresh vegetables and salads were perfect. Thank you Bagel Buzz and Gina for another awesome catering order. I'll always be back when the next party rolls around.“

“I strongly recommend this place. The soups are phenomenal. My sandwich is made perfectly ever time. The staff is wonderful. Managers Nick and Ricky are extremely caring about customer satisfaction. I have never had such a consistently delicious experience at any other place. I've gone in and had food delivered“

“ABSOLUTELY THE BEST BAGELS!!! Other bagel stores on Long Island are good… these are GREAT!! If you haven’t been there, you don’t know what you’re missing!!! Thy them!!“

“My husband used to go there every morning on his way to work. Can’t tell you how many times he enjoyed a nice hot breakfast and coffee. We moved to NC 9 years ago and this is one of the few gems on Long Island that we truly miss. Thank you for the many years of great breakfast sandwiches ❤️“