50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Elmsford

“My wife and I arrived in Tarrytown for a family wedding too late for lunch and several hours early for an 8 pm welcome reception, so along with my sister and her husband, we decided to go out for some light eats to hold us over. The receptionist at our hotel recommended Pete's Saloon.

We loved it immediately.

The vibe was a step back into the past. In a good way. It's a welcoming place -- the kind of local bar and grill where regulars gather for good food, good friends, cold drinks and (from the looks of the drum kit set up in the back of the room) some great live music.

As for the food, it definitely hit the spot. My wife had a bowl of french onion soup and I had the fried chicken sliders with a tangy Korean BBQ sauce and tater tots. My sister had the baked potato soup while my brother-in-law had the fried chicken sliders with Buffalo sauce. The beer was cold, our server Kim was intentive and friendly and the experience was a great start for an enjoyable weekend with family and friends!“

“Terrific, but pricey. About $250 pp with tip.“

“I went with a group of friends for my birthday last night. It was AMAZING. The service was great, everyone was so friendly. The place itself was so clean and cute, really cool vibe. The Apps were great, Hush Puppies and Fried Calamari, yum. I did a make-your-own Seafood Boil. OH MY GOD. The New Zealand Mussels, King Crab and Dungeness Crab was out of this world in the Cajun Butter Sauce. I HIGHLY recommend this spot and will be going back.“

“We came here craving some good sushi rolls and lobster rolls in Westchester, and it definitely exceeded our expectations! Everything was delicious, and the prices were very reasonable. Our server, Maya, was also incredibly friendly and attentive, which made our experience even better. We’ll definitely be coming back whenever we’re craving seafood!“

“Oxtails, j*** wings, Rasta pasta es muy bueno. Cabbage, collards, rice and peas are great compliments to the mains..Prices are extremely reasonable and staff makes everyone feel welcome“

“Chef Elmer is highly skilled and talented. The quality of the ingredients, the methods of cooking/raw and the spectacular presentation is world class! The tasting menu is one of the best I've had. Highly recommend!“

“Fresh tasting seafood with excellent service in a warm and welcoming environment.“

“Don Jito is our ‘go to' neighborhood restaurant. The food is delicious and the ambiance is lovely. Most nights they have a very reasonable SPECIAL dinner suggestion. Their diverse menu makes it easy to keep returning and enjoy a wonderful dining experience.“

“Very good service. Food was very flavorful and had an overall great experience.“

“Es un lindo lugar para compartir con la familia, los empleados son muy atentos y amable, la comida muy buena y llega a la mesa aún caliente 🔥, lo recomiendo 💯.“

“I first visited this restaurant when they opened in 2016. A decade later, I happened to be visiting the area and stopped off here for lunch with my boyfriend. I can honestly say this place hasn't lost their touch.
The restaurant is dark and cozy with a fireplace in the back, making it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner or nice lunch. The servers are all well-versed in the menu items and oyster selection. The restaurant usually has some great specials that are always worth trying out.
This visit was somewhat brief so we only got mains. The special of the day was swordfish. They offer the option to choose your prep style so we each got the swordfish; I tried the lemon butter sauce and my boyfriend got the red pepper sauce. Both were perfectly prepared and delicious. We also shared a side of the grilled asparagus which was perfectly cooked.
A solid 10/10. Highly recommended for any foodies as this place also has some fantastic non-seafood options.“

“Great food and atmosphere“

“First time dinning- first off the pita with cheese and grilled green peppers is an amazing start to the meal. I had an aperol spritz also great to start. For apps we had oysters- was really good but would love if they would add a mignonette. For my main course though the red snapper was FANTASTIC. And the chicken martini was also fantastic. We didn't stay for dessert but will certainly be back, the service was very kind and attentive. The ambiance was nice with the view of the fountain.“

“Had dinner their last night. Food was fantastic! We've been looking for a good place since Izla closed in Yorktown and we've found it :)“

“Great and affordable food. They did my wedding and all events for my family’s gathering. The owner and staff are very personable. Highly recommend it.“

“The best lobster roll around!!! Delicious shrimp cocktail!! Can’t go wrong….Super easy curbside pick up“

“Had to be one of the best pastrami sandwich I had in a long time. Staff was friendly and quick.“

“we ordered 2 orders of fried catfish, 1 with sweet potatoe fries and 1 with Mac&cheese, and also a side of collards. everything was made FRESH. crispy and delicious fish & fries, super cheesey Mac and the collards we're great! not the first or the last time I will order from here. reasonably priced for fish around here.“

“We’ve gone to DIVE a bunch of times now and it never disappoints! Nice presentation of food, great portion sizes, and solid wine and cocktail menu. A special shout out to John who goes out of his way to make things easy for our daughter who has Type 1 Diabetes. LOVE!!!“

“We went here for the first time last night to celebrate our anniversary. The service was stellar, the atmosphere was lovely and the food was simply spectacular. I highly recommend this place to everyone. We will be back“

“Honestly one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in a while. The food was incredible, especially the steak, but what really made the night stand out was the service. Everyone was so welcoming and attentive. The atmosphere was also super comfortable and made it easy to just relax and enjoy dinner. You can tell that Lenny and his staff really care about the experience they give their customers. Definitely a place we’ll be coming back to.“

“Went today with 8 coworkers. What a great time! Food was delicious, staff was great! We even got one free because it was someone’s birthday. Sign up for offers! I will definitely be back soon.“

“Great NY Pizza. We have fresh pie, Excellent“

“Amazing food and great hospitality. Definitely gives you that family feel.“

“FANTASTIC. This small but cozy breakfast nook was poppin on Saturday morning! I loved the hustle and bustle. We were sitted fast, greeted fast and the food was hot and just as quick!“

“Poke is VERY good! Yummy to my tummy :-)“

“Amazing food! My husband and I stopped by for Friday night dinner. We tried the fried calamari, Pad Kana Moo Grob (Sautéed crispy pork belly with chinese broccoli in garlic sauce.), Pork Chops Vegetable Garlic Sauce, crab fried rice and for dessert, the mango coconut sticky rice. All of it was just delicious! Highly recommend coming to try. Plus: BYOB“

“Friendly owner/manager and great service“

“Peruvian House is awesome. The food is delicious, the staff is super welcoming, and everything tastes fresh. Their ceviche and lomo saltado are must‑tries. It’s one of those places you go once and immediately want to go back.“

“Love the good and the service, all excellent!“

“This place is a hidden gem. We were looking for place to make our go to spot. Once my foodie fiance tasted the catfish it was goto spot approved. The service is outstanding as they took very good care of us. The food is very tasty and nicely seasoned. We will be back.“

“Go there often & always enjoy the beautiful ambiance & the delicious food! Service usually good as well. Definitely recommend it!“

“An unexpected seafood find in Mamaroneck! This place has it all—fresh seafood, prepared seafood, a sushi counter, and seafood cooked to order.

I usually prefer a Connecticut-style lobster roll, but since I was taking it to the pool, I went with the Maine-style cold lobster salad. It was delicious! BIG chunks of lobster, just the right amount of mayo, and a buttery roll toasted perfectly—crispy, golden, and sturdy enough to hold all that lobster.

I also tried the Lady Dragon Roll (I believe that was the name), made fresh while I waited. Shrimp tempura inside with spicy salmon on the outside—so good!

There are a few tables inside and outdoor patio seating, making it a great spot for a casual seafood lunch. I also noticed they run specials, so check their social media. The day I visited, a lobster roll with fries and coleslaw was around $29.95.“

“I have held several personal & business events at the Sailhouse. Excellent service & food yet again…Owner Sean is extremely accommodating & staff is attentive/professional. Highly recommend for parties or just a night out!“

“First time trying their breakfast dishes here and I ordered mashed plantain called mangu with pickled onions, chicharron/fried pork and fried mozzarella cheese. I also tried the fruit orange drink with milk forgot the names. Will come back to try their lunch options. Only thing I hate about going here is the difficulty finding a parking spot. Not easy lol“

“Guillermo and Mike were very attentive and friendly. This is such a nice and cozy restaurant with a warm vibe. The linguini and clams were great. The dessert of a twist on coffee cake was delicious. The bread roll was fluffy and fresh. Looking forward to coming back.“

“The owner is great, customer service is amazing, the food is delicious! Everything about this place is just awesome! I got the buffalo shrimp which comes with fries as well as the mac and cheese and let me tell you, it was delicious!! I drove from Rockland county and it was for a fact worth the drive ! I definitely recommend this place!“

“We had our son’s graduation dinner there on June 25,2022. The food was delicious and the staff was amazing. Couldn’t have asked for a better day or place. The staff was “on point”,so accommodating, extremely nice and made our day more enjoyable. Will definitely be back. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“On December 12th my law office had their holiday luncheon at this wonderful restaurant. I also ordered a tray of meat lasagna for Christmas. If you have never had the pleasure of eating at this restaurant, I suggest you run - do not pass go - and get your butt there and eat the most delicous food on this planet. The chef created the meat lasagna - a simple dish - and elevated to something that just melts in your mouth with deliciousness. LOVE LOVE LOVE this restaurant!!“

“Food is good location sucks. If this place does not last I know it is because of parking. I tried to place an order online, their online system seems to be broken. My card was charged but the transaction did not go through. I then called and placed the order with intentions to prepay but that was not an option for pick up orders, I was told you have to pay at the store. The staff was kind. However there is NO parking in the area and this was a big negative. Their site offered curbside pickup however there is no standing in front of the business.

Parking: Street meter parking as well as distanced parking garages located in busy downtown white plains.“

“We had another wonderful family dinner at Mardino's last night. After 30 years and innumerable wonderful dinners I never get tired of the excellent food and service. It's like going home again. You're treated warmly and with respect and everything is always great, especially the stuffed lobster. I would rather dine at Mardinos than any other restaurant I have ever dined. Whenever we want to please a friend or relative, we always bring them to Mardinos. They always as to return.“

“Pete's Steakhouse is superb — the food, the ambiance, the service, all absolutely amazing. We always look forward to dinner here. Everything on the menu is delicious, and the service is unbelievable, they truly go the extra mile to cater to your needs in such a pleasant, friendly way.“

“Great food, service and atmosphere. Service is like the “good old days” and the Portuguese dishes are very traditional, love them. Also love all the beautiful murals throughout the restaurant.“

“It really just doesn't get any better“

“Food is Delicious and the service is great. Overall a good place to sit and have really good food“

“Wonderful food Lovely owners and wait staff Social distancing Great sangria“

“We are so lucky to have this shop in Westchester! Before discovering Mt Kisco Smokehouse I had to drive into Manhattan to have smoked fish this good!“