25 Best Seafood Restaurants near Shelter Island

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe Seafood Markets • $$
41 Smith St, Shelter Island

Customers` Favorites

Fried Shrimp

“Absolutely the real thing just like I remember fish shacks on Long Island years ago! This was my first time to Commander Cody’s and I had an amazing experience. The fish was fresh and perfectly cooked, and I had 2 very large pieces! The pistachio/ricotta cake was incredible. The prices are so reasonable too!The chef and the owner were both very sweet guys.
I’ll be back!!“

4.8 Superb31 Reviews
Little Fish Seafood • $$$
50 N Sea Dr, Southold - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blackened Fish Tacos with Mango Sauce
Grilled Chicken Croissantwich
Avocado Toast Grand Bazaar
'the Shack' Lobster Roll
Blackened Fish Mon Tacos
Blackened Fish Montacos
Monk Fish Tikka Masala
'not Your Mamas' Mezze
Fritto Misto Della Casa
Korean BBQ Duck Wings

“little Fish has the best fish and chips. we found this gem on our Tour of Ireland. excellent staff and excellent food!!“

4.6 Superb114 Reviews
Bell & Anchor Seafood • $
3253 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 5.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Guava Baby Back Ribs w Baby Spinach & Pine Nuts
Old School Lobster Garganelli
Flat Iron Steak Frites
Home Port Chowder
Fish of the Day
Bouillabaisse
Caesar Salad
Almond Cake
Guava Ribs
Frito Misto

“Food and service was wonderful!“

4.7 Superb73 Reviews
The Dock House Seafood • $$
1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor - 5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll All Lobster Meat
New England Clam Chowder
Oysters on the Half Shell
Fish \u0026 Chips
Fresh Seafood
Waffle Fries
Fish & Chips
Crab Cakes
PO' Boy
Langosta

“Really great tasting fish! I got the fish and chips and both were fired perfectly. Tartar sauce was good but ask for an extra one as one is not enough. Be careful on weekend lunch hour as it gets packed and also the food seems to be rushed and doesn't come out as great which would give the rating of 4.5. But overall lovely food and I always come here every summer.“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews
Captain Jack's On The Coast Seafood • $$
1109 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 8.46 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Waffles

“If you haven't been to Captain Jack's yet... what are you waiting for?! Their food is phenomenal, everything is priced very fairly, the atmosphere is relaxing, and the service was wonderful!“

4.4 Superb97 Reviews
Waypoint Restaurant Seafood • $$$
400 Old Main Rd, Southold - 3.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters and Clams on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Hand Crafted Meatballs
Pistachio Sponge Cake
Organic Half Chicken
Chocolate Layer Cake
Faroe Island Salmon
Steakhouse Burger
Aussie Lamb Chops
Lobster Ravioli

“Our new favorite NoFo restaurant. Has great service. Delicious food. Great atmosphere. We loved it. Highly recommend. 😊🙌🏻❤️ @twinstastethetwinforks“

4.2 Good80 Reviews
Sophie's Seafood • $$
730 Main Bayview Rd, Southold - 5.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marinated Strip Steak with Steamed Vegetables and Mahesh Potatoes
Baked Seafood
Pretzel

“I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
A Lure Chowder House & Oysteria Seafood • $$$
62300 Main Rd, Southold - 3.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Local Oyster Selection on the Half Shell
Fresh Catch Whole Fish of the Moment
Macadamia-Coconut Crusted Flounder
Shrimp and Pork Meatballs
Baja Style Fish Tacos
Grilled Sea Bass
Shrimp and Grits
Chicken Milanese
Pasta with Clams
Seafood Platter

“Great food and Views!! Always fun to sit at the bar before dinner!!“

4.1 Good19 Reviews
The Halyard Restaurant Seafood • $$$
58775 County Rd 48, Greenport - 3.61 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beer Battered Fish and Chips
North Fork Lobster Roll
Grassfed Halyard Burger
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
Shinnecock Sea Scallops
Grilled Swordfish Tacos
Summer Truffle Tartine
Oyster Ponds Oysters
Whipped Ricotta
Fluke Ceviche

“Food was good. The host was great and so was the waitress.“

3.9 Good187 Reviews
Billys by the Bay Seafood • $$
2530 Manhanset Ave, Greenport - 3.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll with Tater Tots
2 lb Lobster Corn and Slaw
Oysters Rockefeller
Cold Lobster Roll
Seafood Platter
Fish and Chips
Oyster Platter
Fish Sandwich
Fried Seafood
Baked Clams

“Excellent seafood and service“

3.8 Good47 Reviews
11

Anker

Anker Seafood • $$$
47 Front St, Greenport - 2.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Fish Merguez Sausage
Side of Home Fries
Mussels Marinara
Watermelon Salad
Fish and Chips
Seafood Tower
Hambúrgueres
Tuna Tartare

“Stephanie! She runs the greatest happy hour in NoFo!! She is so friendly and informative. Made great cocktails and the oysters are only $2! It’s a no brainer.“

3.8 Good64 Reviews
The Frisky Oyster Seafood • $$$
27 Front St, Greenport - 2.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Friskafella with Garlic-Scented Spinach Chipotle and Parmigiano Aioli
Braised Beef Short Ribs with Celery Root Puree Chantrelles and Candied Pecans
Seared Sea Scallops with Roasted Pumpkin Risotto and Pumpkin Seed Tuiles
Grilled Lobster Quesadilla
Roasted Duck over Risotto
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble
Duck Confit Spring Rolls
The Best Key Lime Pie
Freshly Baked Bread
Shineapple Express

“Amazing food, casual dining superb staff.“

3.8 Good72 Reviews
Claudio's Tavern & Grill Bar • $$$
111 Main Street, Greenport - 2.53 miles

“Excellent from beginning to finishing my meal. Joseph our waiter was spot on recommending the wine and specials. We enjoyed our meals ,water view and best service. This is our go to restaurant when we visit Greenport. See you next trip in from Queens.“

3.6 Good43 Reviews
Estia's Little Kitchen Latin American • $$
1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor - 6.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chili Chicken Burrito with Rice Beans & Avocado Salad
Grilled Fish Tacos with Tequila Sunrise Salsa
Guacamole & Corn Torilla Chips
Pancakes and Eggs with Bacon
Shrimp & Corn Tamales
Breakfast Burrito
Crispy Chicken blt
Gringo Hash
Chilaquiles
Quesadilla

“Great for vegetarians and vegans. It was really good. It’s tiny inside. This is like a great quality Mexican inspired diner. I will totally go again. It’s fast paced inside, and they are on it.
I had one of the best vegetarian meals I’ve had in a long time. They do a lot of take out orders, I might do that next time because they are very busy and I don’t want to be rushed to finish my meal.

Vegetarian options: Great for vegetarians and vegans!!“

4.2 Good73 Reviews
Minnow At The Galley Ho Seafood • $$$
650 1st St, New Suffolk - 8.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Speared Blackfish Almondine
Smoked Liquid Gold Old Fashioned
Line Caught Fluke Oreganata
Lobster Roll
Fish

“Everything on the menu is first-rate. We had a great time at Minnow at the Galley Ho. Andrea Tese has done a great job with the restaurant.“

4 Good141 Reviews
Braun Seafood Co. Seafood Markets • $$
30840 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 8.19 miles

“great seafood always fresh caught“

4.3 Superb44 Reviews
Armin and Judy Bar • $$
1970 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton - 9.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Cookie Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Ruby Red Grapefruit Brûlée
Flavigny Orange Blossom
Eggs Benedict Supreme
Smoked Salmon
Fried Chicken
Croissant
Bakery
Soup

“I have always enjoyed this restaurant. They are offering a great deal for a weekend in September in the Hamptons. $45 3 course prix fix. Excellent choices on the menu and every weekend the menu changes. Our food was delicious. Good portion sizes. The Apple Tart Tatin was excellent. And as an added bonus, they gave us a baguette when we left. The restaurant was full. I wish more restaurants would offer great deals like this, especially on the weekends. I hope Armin and Judy continue their weekend prix fix throughout the winter.“

4 Good44 Reviews
Front Street Station American • $$
212 Front St, Greenport - 2.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie - Made from Scratch
Fresh Oysters on the Half Shell
Beer Batter Fish & Chips
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich
Iceberg Wedge Salad
North Fork Chowder
Mozzarella Sticks
French Onion Soup
Burger and Fries
Fried Shrimp

“Great owner and staff. Made us feel very comfortable and welcome.. Food VERY GOOD! My wife, who is NOT a fish eater almost finished ger entire plate of flounder. Owner told her if she didn't like it he would take it back! Didn't happen. My dish was excellent Would highly recommend!“

4.1 Good38 Reviews
Claudio's Waterfront Bar & Grill • $$
111 Main St, Greenport - 2.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Claudio's Famous New England Clam Chowder
Local Clams on the Half Shell
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Baha Shrimp Tacos
Lobster Cobb Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Shrimp Appetizer
Dockside Raw Bar
Lobster Bisque
Fish and Chips

“very nice experience! we were a group of 8 who had a reservation for 4 pm but were early in Greenport so we decided to see if they could accomodate us earlier. And they did! thing that stood out was the great service! Our server Nicole was very upbeat, friendly and efficient. So were the others, the hostess, etc. who made it seem they were happy to work there. Food was OK and we were a bit disappointed because the band that was supposed to play canceled so there was no live music. But the service made it a very gratifying experience. looking forward to next time.“

4 Good565 Reviews
20

Noah's

Noah's American • $$$
136 Front St, Greenport - 2.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Crescent Farm Duck Confit Hash
Warm Flourless Chocolate Cake
Nofo Calamari Frito Misto
Lump Blue Star Crab Cakes
Cinnamon Sugar Beignets
Filet Mignon Sliders
Steamed Pei Mussels
Crispy Duck Confit
Kobe Beef Burger
French Fries

“We had a great lunch at Noah's, but the clam chowder was the one that stuck out the most...“

4 Good153 Reviews
Bobby Van's Steakhouse Steak House • $$$
2393 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton - 9.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Rib-Eye Steak
Asian Chicken Salad
Gorgonzola Steak
Caesar Salad
Banana Split
Clams Casino
Porter House
Baked Clams
Fish Taco

“I have a great experience every time I dine there.“

4 Good82 Reviews
22

Legends

Legends Fine Dining • $$
835 1st St, New Suffolk - 8.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ale Steamed Wild Maine Mussels with Garlic and Dijon
Roasted Za'Tar Dusted Cauliflower Steak with Hummus
Brownie Sundae with Blackberry Goat Cheese Swirl
Copper Creek Black Angus Grilled NY Strip Steak
Clams or Oysters on the Half Shell
Legends Half Pound Burger
Hawaiian Chicken Salad
Pad Thai with Shrimp
Grilled Skirt Steak
Eggplant Appetizer

“Great food service & amazing Dirty martinis!!!“

3.8 Good87 Reviews
The Restaurant at Baron's Cove American • $$$
31 W Water St, Sag Harbor - 5.09 miles

“I had an absolutely incredible time at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor! From the moment I arrived, Kristen, Kymari, and the rest of the staff welcomed me with warm smiles and exceptional hospitality. They were phenomenal hosts throughout my stay, making sure every detail was taken care of and ensuring I had the best experience possible. The ambiance of the place is simply magical, and it's a perfect spot to unwind and relax. The beautiful surroundings and the top-notch service make it a must-visit destination. I can't wait to return to this amazing place! Highly recommended for anyone seeking a memorable getaway. #BaronsCove #SagHarbor #HospitalityExcellence #RelaxingGetaway #MemorableExperience“

3.3 Good68 Reviews
Duryea’s Orient Point Seafood
40200 Main Rd, Orient - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Baked Bread Basket
Grilled Lobster Pasta
Eastern Bay Oysters
Cheeseburger & Fries
The Lobster Tower
Catch of the Day
Hot Lobster Roll
Shrimp Cocktail
Chilled Lobster
Snow Crab Claw

“Fantabulous place but bring a blank credit card!“

3.4 Good122 Reviews
Arthur and Sons NY Italian - Bridgehampton Italian • $$$
203 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton - 8.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cavatelli Sausage Broccoli Rabe
Chicken Parmigiana
Eggplant Stack
Calamari
Meatballs

“Had a spectacular meal. Came in last minute on a Saturday night. Lara, the hostess, was able to find us a spot at the bar. Gino served us a delicious meal (and drinks!) The must try items are the eggplant stack and spaghetti w/ meatballs. Save room for dessert!“

3.3 Good107 Reviews

You May Also Like