Sandwich Shops near Newburgh Heights

“This subway is inside a gas station. The staff was friendly and had no push back on the toppings for your sandwich! Keep in mind that this is a gas station so sometimes it gets a little packed.

Vegetarian options: You may buy Veggie sub sandwich

Parking: Plenty of parking

Wheelchair accessibility: This is a wheelchair accessible gas station“

“📍 Deanatella’s Italian Deli – Valley View, OH 🧀🍕🥖 A true hidden gem that screams classic Italian deli the second you walk in. If you can name the deli meat, trust us—they’ve got it. Shelves packed, fridges loaded, and a full lineup of Coke products to wash it all down. We stop here 2–3 times a month, and for good reason. The food never misses. Here's what we had today: 🍕 Pepperoni Pizza – 8.1/10 Hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor. A crustless, center-cut slice of cheesy joy. No edge, no problem—it hits hard where it counts. 🍕 Sausage Pizza – 8.4/10 Same amazing base, but the sausage takes it up a notch. Big, juicy chunks of sausage packed with flavor. Definitely the MVP slice today. 🌶️ Mild Pepper Sub – 9.2/10 This one’s my go-to. Not super spicy, but absolutely loaded with flavor. The combo of peppers, melty cheese, and rich sauce makes for one giant, unforgettable sandwich. Perfect from the first bite to the last. The staff? Always friendly. The vibes? All Italian. If you’re anywhere near Cleveland, do yourself a favor and stop by Deanatella’s. You’ll thank yourself later. 🍽️ Two food lovers, one page—justifying our epic food binges, one bite at a time. Follow along at @joeandjrkfoodreviews for mouthwatering meals, honest scores, and the best hidden gems you need to try. Come hungry.“

“Was hearing so much about Charley's cheesesteak, the article in the Call and Post is what really pulled me in. Came and got Philly cheesesteak and Old school cheesesteak with classic lemonade, the sandwiches was delicious and the lemonade excellent. Will be returning. Welcome to the neighborhood 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽“

“Had a great lunch at La Bodega! I ordered their Pizza Sub 59—super tasty—and my friend and his mother had Sub 45, which was very filling. The staff were friendly and welcoming. My friend had been wanting to visit for the past 3 years but couldn't due to timing issues, so it was special to finally go together. They also served chips with the sub, which was a nice touch. Overall, a lovely dining experience!“

“On Tuesday, June 17th, 18 old ladies and gents "dropped in" for lunch, thinking arrangements had been made for us. Someone slipped up. The restaurant already had a healthy number of customers but the staff hustled tables, chairs, setups, etc. and in no time, we were soon seated and making our food choices. Instead of any of the staff having an "attitude", we were treated with Simon's usual good cheer. Bravo Simon's!“

“Best of the best! Live in Youngstown but everytime we travel for work, it is a guaranteed stop for our team. The staff is great and the food is beyond consistent if that makes any sense. The bread is unique but familiar. Have a hard time not getting the turkey so I’ll usually snag a sandwich for when I get home. DONT SLEEP ON THIS PLACE AND IF THE LINE IS BUSY KEEP CALLING IF ITS NOT PAST 2pm. Good chance they are sold out if that’s the case 😉“

“The food here is so good and so reasonable! My son had the lamb Gyro and he could not stop raving about it! The rest of our party had breakfast sandwiches and they made them fresh right in front of you and I specifically said I only wanted bacon if it could be crispy, very few restaurants understand what crispy bacon is supposed to be But they nailed it! He told me he would make sure it was crispy and it was the best. He cracked the egg in a pan right in front of us went into a little oven and it absolutely perfect. We ate there in the morning before going to the football game and we highly recommend West 3rd Deli!!!“

“I never thought I'd have another italian sub sandwich again after I stopped eating meat in the late '90s (yeah, people can do it for that long and still be alive. Amazing, right?). And then I saw that Dave's Cosmic Subs has vegan options. Well now I'm enjoying them again thanks to this place. I can't believe I've waited this long to try anything from them, but I'm making up for it now.“

“Always hits the spot!
Honestly, you can't go wrong here. The steak is perfectly seasoned, and that melted provolone is the real deal. I’m a huge fan of the strawberry lemonade, too—it’s the perfect combo. It’s my go-to spot whenever I’m craving something filling and fast.“

“Good Customer service and very affordable food!“

“The staff here is extremely kind and accommodating. The restaurant is clean and has plenty of seating available if you want to enjoy your meal inside. The food is fresh and it is definitely one of the best cheesesteaks in town. Highly recommend the Chicken California and the Bacon 3 Cheese as must try options.“

“I used to live in Cleveland hts and started going to Grums when they first opened. I now sometimes drive all the way from Westlake just for a Grum’s sub. In my opinion the Grums Turkey Ridge sub on French bread is the best sub ever, anywhere!!!“

“This Mr. Hero’s gets a full 5 stars from me. They always make the food fresh whether I’ve gone in person or ordered through DoorDash. Sure, it can be a little pricey, but what fast food place isn’t these days? If I’m spending extra, I’d rather do it somewhere that serves higher quality meat instead of the mystery meat other spots use. Definitely recommend eating here.“

“This is an excellent Mr. Hero. Very clean, good service, and friendly staff. Be sure to try their Jalapeño Poppers and online ordering.“

“I just want to give a big thumbs 👍 up, I've been here 5-6 times and it never disappoints, Today I ordered the small original cheese steak as I was waiting on my sandwich and it was accidentally given to another customer, so they upgraded my sandwich to a large and gave me a free Fry, That's what you call great people working there and you guys didn't have to do that I understand mistakes happen, Thank you“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“Underrated spot that deserves way more love!! Need it to stay here! Great vibes and the BBBLT is so tasty. Definitely try the potato salads when visiting this place. The jalapeno one is AMAZING.

Their bakery is selection is really good too! Yet to try it but looks very tempting 😄“

“It's fairly new, so while passing by, I decided to get a sandwich. It's pretty clean and has a nice roomy dining area! They put in a bullet-proof protection barrier, too! That's the 1st thing I noticed coming in the door. That's sad cause none of the other Charley's that I've been to don't have this feature lol. But its in the hood, so I dont blame them for being extra safe. My Food was fast and fresh,
My California sandwich was on point! I'm glad it replaced the nasty burger king!“

“Was very good! We will be back!“

“In a 'Land full of sandwich options, it takes a lot to stand out. Little Cloud does just that and they're in a league of their own when it comes to it. The food, attention to detail, customer service and welcome feeling from the moment you walk in the door are stand-out qualities from my first visit. I got the Nashville Hot and took it to go. Nothing in the sandwich was soggy and the packaging of it made sure the quality was just as good as it would have been at a table in the shop. I need to explore the rest of this menu because it was so difficult to choose just one.“

“I'm new to the area and wanted pizza. But after reading all the bad reviews on most of the places here, I opted not to. I found Mr. Hero by accident. I'm glad I stopped. Their food is delicious. The man at the counter was very nice and polite. He was right when he said I would like it. Definitely will be back. ?“

“Just reviewing the service of this location. You know what you’re getting when going to Charley’s for food. But the service was great yesterday. Cashier was so nice and attentive. And by the time we made it to the car and realized we were missing a fry, an employee was already walking to our car to bring it to us. Not often anymore that you get workers that seem to actually care about their jobs to that extent.“

“This location has friendly staff and the food has always been cooked well. The location and outside leaves much to be desired but since the food is good we don't care as much about the outside 😆. Most likely you will want to get food through the drive-thru or order on the app and pick it up.“

“Food was great, only reason I dropped a star was the $.50 they wanted for my ranch to go with the poppers. Should/ used to get one for free. I guess I understand getting charged more for extra. 2 people already cost $29 without drinks. ( 2 regular sandwiches, 1 fry, 1 popper.😑“

“2 people working a buttload of customer's and everyone was takin care of quickly we had the value pack and the order was correct and made in good time. So thx for a giid experience and friendly service and giid food. A right around the corner customer 😁“

“What can I say. I've always liked there Roman burger and fries. I always say no cheese on anything and they would repeat what I say but I some how I end up with cheese on my sandwich. I am lactose intolerant which makes it hard on my stomach.“

“Served by 777 on 09/05
The staff member was nice, attentive and quick. She handled everything so smoothly. I didn't have cash on hand to leave a tip unfortunately but she definitely deserved one.
The store is clean and tidy. Everyone there does a tremendous job.“

“I have not had Penn Station in years, so we thought we would give it a try. I had the regular cheesestake, we shared a large fry, and I had the sweet tea. The sandwich was very good, the fries were even better, a large fry can feed three people, and the sweet tea was really good as well. Staff was friendly and the food came quick. Highly recommend this location“

“Hanini Subs on Woodland isn’t just another sandwich shop—it’s a neighborhood staple. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the energy: the grill sizzling, the staff moving with purpose, and customers who clearly know this is the place to be. The subs are stacked heavy, the corned beef is legendary, and the loaded fries are the kind of comfort food that hits every time.“

“Clean. Friendly. Letter from owner on wall said it well. They appreciate our business: nothing less than great product, happy service and clean environment is acceptable

Vegetarian options: More would be better. Would visit more often if more unique options.“

“I received bad customer service today around 6pm. There were several customers ahead of me ordering multiple sandwiches that were made by a young man. When it was finally my turn, a friend called me on the phone. It was ringing loudly, but I answered and got rid of the call in 10 seconds max. When I looked up a young lady appeared and was making multiple sandwiches for the two people at the end of the line who arrived quite a bit after I did and were behind me in line. There was no disputing this fact. The young man and woman tried to figure out why I was standing in line in front of those being served. He asked me if I wanted to order. Why did he think I was standing for 10 minutes waiting? No apologies from anyone. The young woman told me that she had said “next customer” and the guy behind me quickly spoke up. She said that I was on the phone, but that is no excuse as I ended the call rapidly. The food was fine, but the service was terrible and I felt ignored. The woman seemed to be picking and choosing who to serve first.“

“People r nice n food is great I would go here🍔🍟👍“

“The chicken salad was delicious. A nice large amount was distributed. Chicken wells seasoned very good . I noticed the mushrooms were canned, not fresh. You can tell the difference. Instead of putting certain items on your salad, you may want it on the side, for example, jalapeno peppers, pickles, etc.. they will charge you for putting those items in a side cup. I didn't agree with that, the choice of salad dressings, you can get those on the side free. If you want an egg on your salad you have to pay for it. I've noticed lots of great things on the menu. I will continue to go back there and also try new things as well. The overall price, I think, is reasonable. The customer service was great and pretty fast.“

“I love going into this subway all the workers I get they give me the best service. I love the random sandwiches I get when I go in there I the workers make me a random sandwich. I will keep going back there for any subway sandwiches I want to get.“

“the best burgers and waffle fries :)“

“Went there yesterday to get tobacco and tubes somehow every time I go go there lately the price of my hot rod tubes go from 2.19/2.49/4.31 yesterday, I’m on a fixed income !! The tobacco hasn’t changed but if the owner/manager isn’t there they charge me what ever they want“

“Awesome little deli. I have not had anything there that I did not like. I would definitely recommend it!“

“This is the best Mr hero! Growing up always loved Mr hero. Used to eat from there every Friday when dad got paid as a kid lol. In all the years, I have found that this particular location is my favorite . Excellent with food! Very clean place! And friendly staff. Every single time!“

“This is the best cheese steak I EVER had!!! ❤️❤️❤️“

“The guy working was extremely nice as can be everything is always good the stores always clean and fresh ? best subway still for years and years“

“Placed an order for 4 sandwiches. Each was special order and they were ALL perfect and delicious. They were friendly and welcoming…will DEFINITELY go again.

Vegetarian options: PESCATARIAN

Dietary restrictions: Tomatoes, onions,peppers lettuces restricted and veggie sub was GREAT for a pescatarian.“

“My first time to any Jimmy John's. Guy behind the counter was really nice. Good food. Will definitely be back. 4 stars.“

“Hadn’t been to this location in a while as I live out of the state now, so I didn’t realize there was new ownership, which I was nervous about, but the service and food was still as wonderful as ever! Dave’s Cosmic is still as delicious as I remembered it, and the staff was very friendly.“

“May not have been the best sandwhich I’ve ever had, but it was large and I enjoyed it over two days.

I was more impressed with how helpful the cashier was, and how quickly the food was made. Would definitely come back to this location.“

“I was here on 10-11-25 after a previous negative experience and both the service and food were outstanding. There was a team member working in the grill area who noticed me waiting and asked the front counter person to find out what I was waiting for. I hadn't been waiting long, but it was nice to know that they were paying attention. My food was fresh, which I appreciated because I previously had cold fries and overly toasted bread. I felt like a valued customer and I hope they keep this standard of service.“

“I only rated four stars because I can't personally go and purchase their Swiss American cheese at a regular store because Mr Hero itself is the only ones with that brand of cheese!! So I am mad and jealous LOL!! I love their Swiss American cheese!! 😋😋💖💯.... The food, service, & atmosphere was all great though honestly!!“

“HORRIBLE! Waited over an hour for COLD, SOGGY, inedible NASTY food! The pics they post look yummy...mine look like hog slop!“

“Always get the Philly sammich, sometimes it's better than other times, but for the most part they're consistent and one of our regular spots, the kids even like they're subs, so that's saying something because they're picky eaters! 😊 This last time, they forgot my sub, I called and they said they'd have it ready in 10 minutes and they loaded it, it was definitely one of the better subs, maybe it was because I was more hungry from the wait or the anticipation 🤷, but whatever the case, it was good. We usually get a large fry and it feeds the 4 of us well, so it's a perfect size, I'm not crazy about how they put them in a cup with napkins on top because the top layer always sticks to the napkins and they get cold quickly, so it wouldn't hurt if they actually came up with a better container to put them in, but I still order them, they remind me if fair fries! 😊“

“The sandwich artists at Toasty Subs make the most epic sandwiches. The food is fresh, the prep looks clean. I'm always happy to visit this area. Atmosphere is only three stars because, well, it's a gas station, not a dine-in experience.“

“Nice food come enjoy specially Roman burger so delicious and yummy“