21 Best Italian Restaurants in Barrie

“Good food and great service definitely will be back“

“Amazing food! Great waitress“

“Outstanding!!!! Everything was outstanding! Thank you Marco.“

“We had an amazing dinner . Pasta and meatballs the best . I remembered when I was in Reggio Calabria Italy , the pasta and meatballs they served same taste , it's great pasta and meatballs❤️. The staff and place amazing . That night I feel like I was in italy with my family . I highly recommend this place ( Barrie)“

“What a great experience tonight! We had an earlier appointment downtown, so, an additional trip would have been required to pick up our pizza. Instead, we ordered and and asked for the pizza to not be fully cooked and OH MY... Once we reheated (on a pizza stone), it tasted exactly like the original! Will DEFINITELY do that again! Highly recommend! Thanks again, Pizzeria Italia Restaurant!“

“Food was great. BOGO Wednesdays.
We did wait about 10-15min for someone to take our initial drink order.

Once they realized what happened, our server Jake did a fantastic job. Acknowledged the issue and made us feel very welcome and attended to.“

“Friendly staff, amazing food!“

“Lots of Italian options in Barrie these days, but this location isn't one to sleep on.

Prices, portions, and service are all stellar. Every dish we had was classic in presentation and taste. Nothing left on any plate by the time we were through with the meal.

Servers were all extremely friendly, accommodating, and prompt. Couldn't ask for more as a patron.

After we were done we grabbed some desserts from the small grocery front they have on the other side. Lots of awesome authentic Italian desserts and pantry stock options too.

Can't wait to go back and try the pizza and other pasta options.“

“I live just up the street. Foods always great. Owners are very pleasant.“

“Just tried my first Jimmy Chews pizza; it won't be my last! It was yummy. :)“

“Best Italian sandwich in Barrie hands down. So good I'm already craving another!“

“September 16 our party of 5 visited Bacio Trattoria for the first time. What a delight! The menu is authentic and elegant Italian. The service was attentive but not over bearing. We enjoyed a complimentary Lemoncello with the Chef/owner for the perfect end to a great evening and dinner. We'll be back!“

“Always a great experience at Pizza Hut! The pizzas are hot, fresh, and full of flavor. I really like the stuffed crust and the variety of toppings. Staff is friendly and service is quick. I usually order online and it’s ready on time every time. Garlic bread and wings are also worth trying. Definitely one of my go-to spots for a pizza night!“

“We called ahead and ordered for a family pizza night. We got there the order was ready, no line up, all other customers were addressed and getting their food. Easiest experience and great customer service.

The pizza was so fresh too!“

“Great for a quick, affordable bite! The crust is crispy, toppings are fresh, and there are plenty of options, including gluten-free and plant-based. Delivery is usually fast, but quality can be inconsistent across locations. Cheese could be a bit better, and dips are pricey for the size. Overall, a solid choice for casual pizza lovers! 🍕“

“I’m in the mood and the nose rader has been on highl!!!!“

“love this place and we treated our daughter and her boyfriend for a birthday dinner .Janine our server is so amazing and attentive and even remembered our names! we all had a few laughs and of course the food was perfect. you can always count on Rick the chef to deliver and Janine for going out of her way to pamper us ! great time“

“One of the best Pizza Pizza locations I’ve visited! 🍕 The place is always clean, the staff are welcoming, and service is quick. The owner really takes pride in making sure every customer leaves happy, and you can taste the quality in every slice. Fresh toppings, perfectly baked crust, and great deals too. Highly recommend this spot whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or ordering for the family!“

“I tried the Butter Chicken Pizza at Pizza Pizza on High Street in Barrie, and it was honestly amazing! The flavour was perfect — rich, creamy butter chicken sauce, tender pieces of chicken, and just the right amount of spice. The crust was fresh and crispy, and everything tasted super well-balanced.

The staff were friendly, service was quick, and the pizza came out hot and delicious. If you’re craving something different from the usual options, this is definitely a must-try. Highly recommend!“

“1st time ordering from Cocelli - had food delivered - fast and courteous service, and food was outstanding - will definitely be ordering from here again“

“These days it feels like everything is going up in price, down in quality and portion sizes are getting smaller. Pizza Nova at least seems like they have been pretty consistent. At least I think they have. 🤔..... Most of the staff are polite and helpful. Owner is a solid guy. And food is on point 98% of time.“