14 Best Sandwich Shops in Peoria

“Food Is The Best And Plenty! Vacationing By Family- Will Definitely Go Back ! Manager was Friendly!! Delish!“

“awesome service 👏 great food and clean dinning area“

“My husband and I stopped by after seeing Eddie Izzard's Hamlet right down the street. I got the Damon Bruce and my husband got thr Hollywoo. Both were fantastic (though I tried both and think i picked best). The dirty sauce was surprisingly sweet, and the only complaint I have is that it was sweeter than I would have liked. Did not stop me from devouring the deliciousness, though. I will be back if I am in the area again.“

“Consistently good every time!“

“My go to place when I'm in town“

“We found the female manager rude in rushing the few people in there choosing a sandwich. Reaching over another employee adding meats to his build to hurry him up very rude. Plus, the menu board is very small high up on wall. Store was clean, we didn't like the manager and how she reacted to the few people in there.“

“GIVE BELLA , COLLIN AND DIMITRI A RAISE PLEASE AND THANK YOU!, super amazing staff I always ask for a mystery sandwhich and they are so cool and take so much joy in making a cool sandwhich and having fun with it best jersey Mike location I every been too !. The lake pleasant location ruined jersey Mike's for me until lone mountain opened up and met these 3 awesome employees!!“

“I recently visited a Subway location that completely raised the bar for what I expect from this chain. Rob was such a delight from the moment I walked in, the place was spotless, and the smell of freshly baked bread instantly made me hungry. What truly stood out was how fresh everything was—from the crisp lettuce to the perfectly sliced meats and cheeses.
The staff was friendly, efficient, and clearly took pride in their work. They prepared my sandwich exactly how I asked, with just the right balance of sauces and toppings. The veggies looked like they had just been delivered that morning—no wilting, no browning, just bright, vibrant produce.“

“This subway location stepped up in every way since Nick became the manager and the sleek updated furniture and soda machine. Nick is very professional, engaging has a great work ethic and he really is a great representative for this subway location. I always look to see if all the veggies are available and fresh that makes a difference in your business. I have to say most of the employees are wonderful, but I have to give a shout out to Connor. He is one of the best workers for his age group I’ve seen in a while. His parents raised him right— he’s very accommodating, professional and provides one on one interaction with each guest and is there to help you in your selection of your sandwich or meal— keep up the great work subway— you’re in a great location and you have a wonderful staff.“

“Amazing experience, and this Jersey Mikes has now become our new go to sub sandwich place. Never had them before, but easily outshined jimmy John’s and subway across the street. Fantastic sub with fantastic flavor. Everything tasted so fresh and enjoyable. Ordered on the app for pickup, so I can’t comment on the staff/environment, bu the food was fantastic. Reasonably priced, as my wife and I shared a giant size sub.“

“Very clean atmosphere!
The service was very wonderful. I cannot say that for any other location other then the location in Peoria Walmart supetcenter. The food is even made BETTER than any other location we've been to. WE WILL COME BACK!!!“

“Ive been stopping in for the Tuna Tuesday. I get a foot long meal for ten bucks! Thats a pretty good deal considering prices are on the rise everywhere. The bread is fresh (they fixed the oven) and the displays are clean as well as the dining area. The manager, Austin, is a great guy, he really listens to custimers concerns and knows how to address them.
Ive been coming in every week and its nice to hear and see things improving at this location. Kudos!
I recommend this location. Its feels very welcoming and laid back. I enjoy dining in here now.
5* AAA
A place to hang loose 😎🤙“

“We have been ordering our subs here for years. Rose is always pleasant and always takes such good care of us. Employees like Rose are hard to find. By far the Best Subway location in the Valley. We always receive quick, and efficient service . We will not order from anywhere else.“

“This is the best jersey mikes, hard working teens doing their best! Be patient with them guys they have rules under 18, throwing a fit as an adult is pointless and that’s what your teaching them, keep it up kids yall are doing amazing, and the gm is fantastic , there are a couple new kids an I am impressed“