33 Best Ice Cream Shops near Wellesley

“Very good and really tasty. if there is a line . its worth waiting don't leave.“

“Delicious ice cream!!! Can’t beat it:)“

“Shake Shack in Wellesley is a convenient addition for a quick burger and shake stop, especially if you’re looking for a familiar fast-casual option in the area. The restaurant has a clean, modern layout with a simple ordering setup where you place your order through kiosks and the food is brought out when ready. The space feels casual and easy for a quick meal, whether you’re stopping by for lunch, dinner, or just a dessert run.

The burgers are the main attraction, with the classic ShackBurger being the go-to choice. The patties have that signature crispy edge with a juicy center, and the combination of the soft potato bun, cheese, and sauce gives it the recognizable Shake Shack flavor. The fries are also a popular choice, especially paired with one of their shakes. The shakes are probably one of the strongest parts of the menu, with seasonal flavors like the banana pudding shake getting a lot of attention. The drinks and desserts help make the meal feel more like a treat rather than just a standard burger stop.

My experience here was mixed depending on expectations. The food was consistent with what you’d expect from Shake Shack, but the pricing can feel high compared to other fast-food options. The portions are on the smaller side, so it may not feel like the best value if you’re looking for a large, filling meal. Service can also vary, with some visits being quick and friendly while others have had longer waits.

Overall, Shake Shack Wellesley is a solid option when you’re craving a reliable burger, fries, and shake combo. The biggest strengths are the clean atmosphere, friendly staff, and consistent flavors. It’s a good casual spot for a quick meal or dessert, but the higher prices mean it’s more of an occasional treat than an everyday burger stop.“

“Excellent! The best gelato I have ever had. All the flavors I tried were superb.“

“Cabot's has great food, including all-day breakfast, in addition to their delicious ice cream. The McGonagal Benedict was the best corned beef benny I've ever had.“

“One of the best around. Tons of flavors. Reasonable prices. Great staff.“

“The most amazing and creamy ice cream. Best I’ve ever had!“

“I recently bought the Earl Grey Tea and Berry Cornbread at my local Kroger store and was blown away! The richness and the flavor profiles were out of this world, especially the latter flavor of the two. It’s dangerous to know the Kroger store is only five minutes from my house. I’ll definitely be trying other flavors.“

“First time there. Milk shakes were sweet nostalgia. Had that flavor that reminded me of home made ice cream as a kid.“

“Yesterday I was in to get a birthday cake and was inspired by an act of kindness. A young woman with some cognitive disabilities came in asking some unusual questions. The owner, who was working the shop by himself at the time, was so patient with her and kind. He treated her with respect and even gave her a free drink. These sorts of moments need to be recognized!“

“We recently ordered a large quantity of hot fudge for our sons wedding in Delaware because Rancs has the best hot fudge anywhere!! It was a huge success! We can’t thank the owner Joe enough. He was able to get us that large order and package it for our drive to Delaware! Thank you Joe for everything!! You’re the best!!!!“

“A Sweet Surprise Along the Way

We stopped by just in passing, on our way to visit a university — and what a pleasant surprise it turned out to be!

The ice cream was delicious, with just the right balance of flavor — not overly sweet like many others. It was refreshing and satisfying.

What truly made the experience special was Mónica’s service. She was empathetic, kind, and patient — qualities that are becoming rare these days and that we deeply appreciated.

The place itself was spotlessly clean and beautifully presented, adding to the charm of the visit.

All in all, a wonderful little discovery. Thank you for such a delightful stop!“

“Consistently great ice cream fun environment. Great service too.“

“very good food decent price . will return for more...“

“We recently ordered a large quantity of hot fudge for our sons wedding in Delaware because Rancs has the best hot fudge anywhere!! It was a huge success! We can’t thank the owner Joe enough. He was able to get us that large order and package it for our drive to Delaware! Thank you Joe for everything!! You’re the best!!!!“

“super amables yo les doy un 100“

“Stopped in Friday with my kids after school and everyone was beyond kind and the donuts were delicious!!!“

“I love this place � everything is so delicious“

“Has a great seafood platter fried clams Were especially tender“

“MyChiel Michael + Me use to go there the hot dog combo was much less expensive back then it's a great value But these days I don't have a good time very much without him everything tastes bland My husband Pay attention to details I'm safe with Jim and Elana are married to each other There's nothing like good friendships.I trust in God.I have hope with the Trinity is a Great matchmaker Artist PT mb Just got a little better today but I'm not sure what to do with her who here is a Great place to live.I mb able to cruise eventually mb August.I pray for a nother apt.right where we are.We need God's time +* space.Giving Thanks prayer peace hoe And ☘️🌵.Seed.Wr are females.As strong as we may be we Re little Gals Be honored serious Gold Leafs Clovers Give me a call when you get a free e straight When you love to see 🙈 Sunglasses Oh ok.Filters.Fillers.“

“Awesome! Having a Del’s lemonade push cart from you was easy, fun, and memorable. Thank you again.“

“So incredibly disappointed that yesterday was the last day... FOREVER. It was always a nice treat to walk to on my lunch break.“

“I always have such a great time there! The milkshakes are amazing, and my favorite is always the coconut with chopped Reese’s pieces, I have already recommended it to a lot of people. It’s where I like to hang out with my friend after school to enjoy something delicious.The price is also pretty affordable.“

“Loyal customer, grew up in Norwood & I was coming here when Facebook reviews were called Word-Of-Mouth… still has the best Orange Sherbert around, glad I can take my kids here & keep a tradition rollin’ along 👍“

“MMmmmmmmmMm, very yummy and reasonable prices, happy I found you“

“Was visiting friends when i came upon wally’s

What really sets this place apart is the love you can taste in every scoop. You can tell the people behind this shop genuinely care

about the quality of their ingredients, about their customers, and about making something truly special in their community.
The vibe is warm, fun, and welcoming. Honestly, it’s the kind of local gem you want to keep secret but just can’t stop yourself from telling everyone about. Do yourself a favor: get there, get two scoops (you’ll thank yourself), and become a regular. Wally’s Wicked Good Ice Cream has absolutely earned a permanent spot on my must-visit list. 🍦“

“Ordered an ice cream cake for Easter. It was delicious!!!“

“Coffee, deli, & ice cream are all amazing!! Highly recommended!!“

“Yogurt Beach is the kind of neighborhood frozen yogurt spot that does not overcomplicate things and is better for it. The self-serve format keeps the experience moving without much wait, which makes it an easy stop after an activity or whenever the dessert craving hits without wanting to commit to a longer sit-down experience.

The frozen yogurt and custard are both worth exploring depending on what you are in the mood for. The original tart yogurt is the baseline order and a good reference point for the quality, tangy and slightly sweet in a way that pairs naturally with almost anything you pile on top. The watermelon sorbet is a lighter option worth trying if you want something more refreshing, and the rotating flavors give you a reason to try something different each visit rather than defaulting to the same combination every time.

The topping selection is where Yogurt Beach earns its repeat visitors. Fruits are fresh, the variety is wide, and the pay-by-the-pound format gives you full control over how loaded you want to go without being locked into preset combinations. Mango popping boba, coconut flakes, and cereal are all worth reaching for when building out a bowl.“

“OMG yes! Highly recommend Orange Leaf. The employees are all so professional and kind. They are accommodating and so pleasant when you call. And for the Yogurt and products? OMG THE BEST! My favorite is the no sugar added chocolate yogurt but my hubby's favorite is the strawberry cheesecake shake! He loves the smoothies too but the shake is his fav! Bottom line you have to try them. Their customer service is AMAZING staff are all wonderful and the products are delicious❤❤❤“

“Wow. What a gem you have here in Boston. Some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. If you ever decide to franchise sign me up.“

“The owners are incredible, the atmosphere is amazing and the food is so good. The açaí is literally the best Ive ever had, and they had a zero sugar açai option that tastes the SAME as the regular and makes you feel less guilty for the toppings🙈 I wish I could give more than 5 stars honestly.“

“Ron’s is truly a hidden jewel, the ice cream is amazing and you’re going to love the bowling alley.“