50 Best Bakeries near New Milford

“Unfortunately the restaurant changed its name again and also the type of food. Now it is a Turkish restaurant called Alería Bakery & Cafe.Excellent variety of options for breakfast: cakes, Arepas, fritters, croissant. Also sweets and sweet breads, coffee, hot chocolate. Everything delicious and excellent service. Recommended empanada de ropavieja, arepa with cheese and pork rinds. The chicharron was excellently crunchy. And the hot chocolate is on point. ? Recommended“

“Delicious bagels! Went there on a Sunday morning ~11AM and pleasantly surprised that the line wasn't too long. Waited for around 10mins and staff were super efficient. Ordered a whole wheat everything bagel (untoasted) which was super fluffy on the inside and had a nice crunchy exterior. Garlic and chive tofutti was also flavorsome and uber generous with the serving size :) Will be back if I'm ever in the UWS!“

“We went here for the first time and had the most amazing experience. The espresso was great, pastries were phenomenal, and the owner made us feel right at home. 10/10 would highly recommend. Can’t wait to come back next time we’re in the area.“

“I ran into Steph at one of her pop-ups and fell in love with her macarons. Not only are they adorable, but they are DELICIOUS!! I reached out to her for a custom order for my bridal shower favors and they came out so perfect. Everyone was raving about them! Steph was very responsive via email and helped to create an order that fit within the budget I specified. I can't wait to order from her again!“

“This cake was an absolute masterpiece!! All three tiers were a different flavor, one even better than the next….my personal favorite was the coconut cake. Planning a wedding is so overwhelming and there are so many decisions to be made. Polkadot Cake Shop was well organized, quick to respond and so easy to work with. Also loved being able to support a business local to me. Thank you so much!!!“

“Not only was customer service on point but from one Chef to another one baker to another. Well done Chef Maria Caputo. Even Hannah was great and knowledgeable. Even the Tik-ToK cookies we over the top. Big smile here! Yum Yum was well worth the visit!“

“"Antepli Baklava delights with its rich flavors and authentic taste. Each bite of their baklava transports you to the bustling streets of Gaziantep, where this traditional treat originated. The perfect balance of flaky pastry, crunchy nuts, and sweet syrup makes Antepli Baklava a true indulgence. Whether you're a seasoned fan or a newcomer to Turkish sweets, Antepli Baklava is a must-try delicacy."“

“I called keremo cakes with a last minute request to make a custom cake for my wife’s birthday. They had the cake ready in one day and we couldn’t be happier. I sent them a picture of what I was looking for and they made it even better than the picture!“

“Just visited New Jersey for the first time on Friday in February 2024! Stopped by this shop with some colleagues and it was phenomenal. Rafael is very passionate about his craft and the food is beautiful! Stop by here and grab some pastries. The croissant had dozens of laminated layers (I think he said over 40!) Highly recommend.“

“A damn good burger! ? Seriously I’ve had a lot of burgers in my life and burgers happen to be my favorite food but this all American cheeseburger from @cake_burgers has to be one of the best burgers I’ve ever had. I mean from the top to the bottom the soft, perfectly toasted brioche bun, to the perfectly crisp and fresh lettuce and tomatoes and melty cheese, and their special burger sauce?! Whenever a restaurant has a special sauce I have to try it because I have high expectations and this one exceeded it. The grilled onions made it even better! The meat was perfectly cooked and so juicy. It was like my dream burger had finally come to fruition. I am also a big sweet potato fries lover and they make the PERFECT sweet potato fries, everything is balanced so nicely from seasoning to texture. It’s no surprise the chef has past experience working at Michelin star restaurants and even received compliments from THE Anthony Bourdain!!!! I can’t wait to come back and try their specialty cakes and other desserts! My new favorite burger joint ??Plus the owners are so sweet and kind and provide amazing service and fun and welcoming atmosphere!“

“They did an amazing job on my daughter’s unicorn birthday cake, it literally took my breath away when I saw it! My 4 year old had the same reaction! My daughter is allergic to sesame and tree nuts, so I’m thrilled to have found this bakery for all of her celebration cakes!“

“Lovely and cozy cafe! Croffles are delicious; the specialty coffee drinks I've tried so far are not my favorite but they're creative and unique and I'm going to keep trying them. Sometimes they'll run out of certain drinks though but they've always been very apologetic. The staff are super sweet and kind. The sitting area is tiny so it's better to go there by yourself or with up to two other people. One of my new favorite spots to go and read“

“Everything is delicious at this bakery! They always have new items and flavors so I try to go often to see what's new. They also have interesting vegan snacks on the shelves as well as a vegan cbd section with awesome products. I really enjoy the vegan sleep gummy.“

“Great place for breakfast or lunch, the food is incredible and made with fresh ingredients. Some of the best service I had and the prices are more than fair! They really care for the quality of the food, hard not to go back! Coffee is great!Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance plenty wide, spacious enough to sit at any table with a wheelchair.“

“We were craving for pastries from Chocnyc which was recommended by Yelp Top 100 Croissants. It’s kind of far from where we live but no one can stop us from eating.We were satisfied with their line up. We got their Plain Croissant, Caramelized Croissant, Pecan Sticky Bun and Savory Biscuit as first try. The portion was great with reasonable price.Our favorite was the Pecan Sticky Bunwhich was satisfying with soft and rich texture. Their croissant wasn’t our type but it’s still worth a visit.“

“I really love this place. Food is always on point and their coffee never disappoints. Unfortunately I’ve been trying to avoid ordering food to go due to the wait time. Today I only ordered funfetti pancakes for my little one (to go), and we waited over 20 minutes for it ?. When I arrived there was only a lady in front of meKid-friendliness: They have a really cool kids corner with a good amount of toys to keep little ones entertained ?“

“I left a 5 star review but updating to share a few videos. The knafa has more of a savory sweet taste vs. other bakeries that drench it with syrup. Anytime I go, I get the znoot el sit, which is soft on the top and middle, and crispy at the bottom. So good!“

“One can only appreciate the Disneyland of supermarkets when you bring along a child or two. It certainly is one way of keeping their little minds busy while you shop in peace with the many animatronics scattered throughout the store. I can finally shop! ? ?Not to say you cannot shop without a child and definitely easier with the fishmonger ?? or in the isles of wine and spirits ???“

“Myself, my family and extended family have been getting Cakes, cupcakes, etc. from Grace for many years. Any cake you choose is made fresh, with the very best ingredients, they are so delicious. If you want something sweet and very special, don’t hesitate, call today, you will never be disappointed in anything you choose! P.S. Every member of her staff are knowledgeable, they want to help if you need help with an order. Very helpful and courteous! The best!“

“Quaint, friendly, family-owned café with delicious offerings all around.I've been going once a week the past month, and I've tried almost everything this place offers. The food is incredible (I'm most partial to the croissants). From the coffee to the breakfast offerings to the truffles, I haven't had something I didn't think was excellent. And they make it all in-house!The staff is great. I've been in during busy times and slower times, and they're always working hard and friendly. (And the cute barista behind the counter is always nice to see.)I've worked in service in the past and so it's impressive to see them in action when the lines start forming. Really love going there. Can't recommend this place highly enough.“

“alhumdulililah! this place is so underrated! the owners smile & energy instantly drew us to his store & we were greeted with a warm welcome & he gave us multiple sweets to try before purchasing. what shocked me is how fresh the baklava was it was amazing! me & my family took some for breakfast after dinner, so excited to try it!!“

“Ordered a birthday cake for my 1 yo's birthday party. Went strictly based on the reviews, and was not disappointed. The party was s'mores theme'd, and we were a little nervous with the recommendation on filling with marshmellow and chocolate ganache, if that would be something everyone would like. Well everyone raved about it. The whole thing was amazing and so were the party themed cookies we ordered. Will definitely be back!Kid-friendliness: Fun cookies on display and different cake bars in glass display“

“This was an amazing experience. My family is originally from Chile, the dishes were delicious and authentic, the wine was excellent and I can say enough about the torta mil hoja(dessert). I went with a large party and the staff was wonderful about give recommendations. Excellent experience.Kid-friendliness: My child is 10 not a picky eater. Enjoyed everything“

“I searched for a quick dessert for a friend and found this bakery through Google suggestions. It turned out to be the perfect choice! The service was excellent, the atmosphere inviting, and the assortment of delicious treats was the best part.“

“Sweet & Flour is such a great bakery. Gina was so kind and responsive. I ordered a Communion cake for my daughter and it turned out beautiful. Everyone loved it and it was sooo delicious. I can’t wait to stop by again and get some treats. :) Definitely will be ordering from them again for any future events.“

“This kind of donut is not the same thing you are getting at DD or Krispy Kreme. It is a rice batter and has a really unique and tasty flavor. The topping are also very good too and add a lot. However, this location has sales that help support the local school systems and I really appreciate their community involvement. Bravo!“

“I was back in my hometown for a short trip and wanted to work remote from a cafe. I did a quick Yelp search and stumbled across Marimba Cafe - the new name caught my eye and the aesthetics and offerings here solidified my decision. I don't think I've ever come across a sit down Latin cafe here in Bergen County so to me, since moving away, it's the first of its kind. Also first of its kind to proudly offer CBD infused menu items. I believe they just opened in November! The vibes in here are immaculate. My favorite feature is the stone floor - it just transports you somewhere new! The color scheme in here is also appealing, and the Latin music made me want to dance while I took on meetings haha. Overall, really solid branding and concept. Since I was working west coast hours, I spent the whole afternoon into close here. It's a really great place to work as there were other people working remote. They have comfortable seating and outlets conveniently located along the booth. I will say though that the booth seating was just a tad too high for the table so it took some time getting used to. Also, they do play the music fairly loud (a must) in here so it can be a tad distracting if you're taking meetings and have to speak. Since I stayed here for over 5 hours, I was able to observe the sense of community Marimba has fostered - they greet customers like friends! I also saw on their Instagram that they host community events like paint nights and dance nights and support other local businesses with their La Placita Sundays. I love everything this business is about. I ordered the coquito latte hot and a pan de bono. The latte was solid and I wish the pan de bono was just a bit bigger! I would love to try more here. Congrats to the owners of Marimba, I wish the cafe tons of business and success! I definitely want to visit again when I'm back in town.“

“We can't say enough things about our beautiful and very delicious wedding cake! Still amazed by the flavor and looking forward to our 1 year topper. A little cake delivered our vision and took note of all the details in our inspiration picture - making it a reality! Thank you to the team for our beautiful wedding cake! We can't recommend them enough!“

“The server Was very nice. Some of the Donuts were really good except that they are a little tiny for the price. If you are in the area give them a try. I went towards the end of the day and so the donuts were not so fresh but they were still good. I tried the apple cider and that was that great it had a funny taste to it.“

“We have been getting our cakes from here since our baby shower in 2019 & this is now our son’s 5th birthday cake. I have never been disappointed. Communication is always on point and we always get exactly what we ask for. So clean, so professional & amazing customer service. We will continue to be a forever customer. Thank you guys for always being the perfect finishing touch to our celebrations!“

“This place is amazing! It's always clean, nice, and neat. They offer delicious options for desserts and grab-and-go meals. I love that they have a simple yet fulfilling menu. The atmosphere is super chill and totally worth it. My family and I love to grab a few pastries to take home, and now it has become our go-to gift store. Whenever we have an event or an office meeting, we travel all the way from New City to Englewood without hesitation.The only details that sometimes disappoints us is that at the end of the day, the staff's attitude or vibe is not as nice as in the mornings. We totally understand that it's the end of the day and they want to go home, but it would be great if they could maintain their friendly attitude throughout the day., and that it only opens at 8 am, so work commute to grab a coffee becomes hard. However, around 90% of our experiences there have been nice, and we look forward to visiting again soon“

“Loved the cake made for my husbands 50th birthday party. I got a two tier cake and two dozen cupcakes. Wonderful customer service and reliable delivery. I was in awe at the ease of how ordering went. I was most impressed that I was able to communicate with a person rather than filling out a form online. I will def order again when I need a cake. All the cupcakes got swooped up so fast I didnt even get a chance to have any.“

“I can't be more impressed with the owner herself ie Christina and her beautiful creation of a yacht cake that she made for me at the very last moment. The cake was perfect and it was melting in the mouth and really yum. I will surely return for any future orders.“

“Cute cafe located in the Inwood area. I usually get a dirty chai with oat milk and it always hits! If you get there early enough you might get lucky and be able to get a pastry. I'm a little obsessed with the everything bagel seasoning cream cheese filled croissant (sounds like a mouthful). It's just perfect; salty, rich and filling little snack you can take on the go with your coffee. My fave on the weekend. Staff is also pretty friendly and patient because if you're anything like me you will easily get distracted by all the goodies near the counter.“

“The pastries have been and always are phenomenal. Tasty, fresh, and of the highest quality to meet everyone's taste preferences. I ordered an assortment of pastries for a work meeting, and the team of nearly 20 people absolutely loved it and even took some for colleagues as well. I will definitely be ordering again in the future!! In the past, I have also ordered a box of muffins just for myself to enjoy ?Dietary restrictions: Even provided vegan options that taste just like any other muffin. Best place to order.“

“I thought it was wonderful that instead of selling me drinks and walking away the owner asked what my large order was for. He arranged for us to have them delivered instead. They were there and fresh. Everyone loved them.I really appreciate that.“

“The desserts in this place are fantastic! I don't know much about Turkish bakery, so I'm judging this purely based on my tastes. The rice pudding and the Turkish custard are my favorite. Perfect sweetness and flavorful (love the natural caramelization). Definitely give this place a try!“

“I highly recommend Goldelicious Cakes for custom cakes and cupcakes. Not only is Jennifer so skilled at baking, she is also thoughtful, friendly, and super easy to communicate with. For my son’s first birthday, she helped create the most memorable orange cake with coordinating cupcakes. Pick-up was easy breezy and the packaging was great and kept the baked goods perfectly in place for the hour drive back home. Jennifer’s creations were such a hit with our friends and family. The blueberry compote filled vanilla cake was scrumptious. I wish I ordered a larger size! The cupcakes had an elegant touch and were incredibly tasty too. You know it’s delicious when there are no leftovers! Goldelicious beyond exceeded my expectations and I’m already looking forward to future orders.“

“Adorable, delicious and friendly! Ordered their out-of-this-world chocolate chunk cookies for a birthday party and they were a huge hit! Staff is great-- Jolanta in particular has such a wonderful, can-do attitude and is always smiling and welcoming customers by name.This place is a winner!“

“Such a cute bakery/cafe... Just the right size and ambience for a chat with friends! The lady in front was so sweet! It looks to be family-owned? I could be wrong... I love that they have a variety of pastries... It's a true delight seeing the love they put in their craft. No frills and homey. :)“

“Never had anything less than a delicious experience. The bagels are always fresh, the filings are perfect - white fish, pork roll egg and cheese, chicken salad… really the best bagel joint in the area. Quick, efficient service in a classic storied bagel house. Simply the best.“

“Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!“

“Kingston Bakery has been my spot for beef patties since they’ve opened and I’m never disappointed. It wasn’t until I tried the actual entrees that I was completely hooked. The oxtails are so good and the stewed chicken is absolutely bussin!! If you haven’t stopped by now I’d the time and the portions are great too.“

“One of the more unique bakeries I have ever been to. This place is an operation! They have everything with the show to go with it. The bagels come out on a conveyor belt! Awesome place. If there is something you are craving they will have it. The oreo cookie was delicous. The crumb cake was great. I wonder how fast they go through everything but it did look busy. The bread also came out hot and fresh. Would highly recommend checking out!“

“Tres Leches Cake is THE BEST omg. I’ve been trying tres leches cake everywhere until I found this place by so many recommendations from other people, it’s truly amazing. The best I’ve ever had!Sayra helped me and she was so so sweet!!!“

“We come here often for authentic Italian pastries, gelato and granita. Everything is fresh and delicious. We took a class recently and made delicious ravioli, arancini and pistachio cookies. The class with Chef Andrea (owner) was so much fun and I highly recommend it for a fun night out with friends or family or even a date night. There are a maximum of ten students (so not crowded at all) and you get to sample what you have made and take enough home for a meal the next day. Chef Andrea explains the ingredients and technique and then you proceed to prepare the items under his supervision. He explains how to source the items you will need to make items at home and gives you printed easy to follow instructions to take home. He is funny, patient and great to work with. We can't wait to take another class with him!!“

“I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes for my baby’s 100 day. The cake & cupcakes look amazing, those ware exactly what I want. Also tasted very good, not too sweet, our guests loved them. I picked the right place for my special event ?“

“What an amazing place! Friendly and nice location. Their cookies and Spanakopita are fresh and taste straight out of the oven. Soft, fresh and full of flavor! After becoming extremely sick and hospitalized early this year from visiting Zai’s Dessertery in Bergenfield and forcing myself to eat disgusting, stone hard, and sugar packed desserts, due to not being able to get my money back from the cashier, Athens Bakery has been a great find for sure. Thank you Athens Bakery for being great to your customers!“

“I got an assortment of gourmet cookies for a party and they were a hit!! The oreo cookies, red velvet and crème brulé was amazing and everyone who tried them kept asking where I got them from. I look forward to trying the other pastries ?“

“Great hidden cookie spot. Better than any of those chain cookie places like Insomnia, or anything like that. Staff is very friendly and it’s a great local business to support. Typically I’m a chocolate chip guy, but the Oreo ones are fantastic.“