50 Best Bakeries near New Milford

“Five star Baklava!!!! Highly recommended“

“If you’re ever in the Bronx and you don’t stop at Gino’s Pastry Shop, you’re missing out on a piece of real New York history. This Arthur Avenue staple has been serving up authentic Italian pastries for decades, and it’s exactly what you want from an old-school bakery — no frills, just flavor and tradition. The cannoli? Legendary. They fill them fresh to order, and the shells are crisp, flaky perfection with creamy ricotta that tastes like it was whipped up by someone’s Nonna in the back. The sfogliatelle and lobster tails are equally iconic — sweet, buttery, and loaded with filling. Don’t sleep on the rainbow cookies either — they’re dense, almondy, and always spot-on. The shop itself is cozy, with that classic Italian-American charm. Gino and the crew treat you like family, whether it’s your first time or your fiftieth. Prices are super fair for the quality, and it’s cash-only — so come prepared. Bottom line: Gino’s isn’t just a pastry shop, it’s a Bronx institution. Worth the trip, worth the calories, and worth every bite.“

“The best macaroons. The crème brûlée and Ferrero rocher were my favs!“

“Great cupcakes and excellent service!“

“Wish Upon a Pastry is a great Disney Inspired bakery in NJ. Michele and Torre, the owners are so nice and great to work with. They have really unique baked goods that are all absolutely delicious. They also take special orders. They are not dedicated gluten free but they offer a lot of gluten free options that are just as delicious as their other bakery items. I highly recommend this business.“

“Delicious empanadas, and desserts! More than just cakes, stop in for a delicious treat like I did!!“

“these are incredibly delicious and the staff is so fun and friendly!“

“I got a dairy free cake for my future daughter-in-law's shower because she has a severe dairy allergy. Delicious! Everyone was amazed that it was dairy fre..“

“La Promenade is awesome , food is amazing staff very helpful“

“My opinion is 8.7/10. Is it the best Jamaican beef patty I've ever had? No but overall our place that makes handmade Jamaican beef patties with a good overall flavor I recommend it. Best thing definitely has to be the crust I just wish for $3 it was a little bit more meat / seasoning. Check out my in depth video reviews on any of the platforms below. TikTok: TheUrbanLegend4 Instagram: UrbanLegend4 Facebook: Panayoti Kokalis YouTube: Urban Legend“

“My friend picked up an assortment of treats for my birthday, everything was so delicious✨Red velvet cupcake and The pistachio thingy were my favorites❣️Have to go soon & try more treats🥰“

“Such an amazing Turkish breakfast experience. The spread was fresh and delicious, but the kuymak was the real highlight — rich, perfectly stretchy, and tasted just like my grandma made it. The staff were so kind and welcoming, truly peak Turkish hospitality. Definitely recommend!“

“Thank you for your generous donation to Glen Rock High School! The desserts were delicious! Can’t wait to go back and pick up some more desserts for my family!“

“Best mochinuts I’ve had!! Great place, super friendly staff and amazing food and drinks!! I love this place!!“

“Great people and the best rugelach on the planet.“

“Fantastic Detroit style pizza with a twist. Here's a photo of her Argentinian Detroit style pizza (onions and cheese with a sourdough crust). I heated it up in the toaster oven for lunch. It was so delicious, I can't figure out what to eat for dinner ... anything else would be a disappointment.“

““Life is tough sometimes. This experience always gives me JOY. The people are amazing and the treats are the best I have ever had.”“

“The kunafe is so good with the ice cream on top of the kunafe you should try it especially with Zubeyir 5 star service“

“I had a wonderful experience at this bakery! The pastries were incredibly fresh, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious. You can really taste the quality and care in every bite. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and made the whole experience even better. It’s clear that a lot of passion goes into what they do. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to friends and family!“

“This place is absolutely amazing . I drive almost an hour away to get cookies from them . If your in the area or want to take a ride you should stop by and give them a try...“

“I’ve been living in the U.S. for 15 years and I still can’t believe I never heard about this place before. The baklava was incredible, and the syrupy dessert with clotted cream inside (I forgot the name) was absolutely amazing. Definitely one of the best dessert spots I’ve tried.“

“D’era House is such a hidden gem in Clifton, NJ. We came in for a custom cake and left completely impressed. The cake was fresh, creamy, and absolutely delicious.The space is cozy, clean, and welcoming, and their desserts and coffee are top tier. You can feel the passion behind everything they make.If you’re searching for a great bakery near me or need cakes for special occasions, this is the place to go. Highly recommended!“

“They are a cozy place (not huge) and the vibes were perfect for a cold Sunday. Food is ABSOLUTELY amazing and worth a drive (and wait if needed). Everyone was extremely courteous and accommodating, will absolutely travel the 2hrs to visit them again!“

“Best tres leches in the world so soft & well made that you can really enjoy the flavors! The cake itself is Delicious I been a big fan of this tres leches for many years now & wouldn't change it for no other.“

“Everything in Rispoli is delicious! Can't beat their lobster tails! We drive 90min each way every time we have a Rispoli craving and bring their cookies and pastries to our friends in central jersey. Next week we're shipping cookies to Oregon! I have a feeling it will become a regular occurrence. Thanks for never disappointing us!“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“Thank you so much for making our engagement cupcake cake! Not only was it beautiful, it was SO delicious!! 😍“

“walked by this bakery when I was wandering around the Bronx and the cake display case caught my eye because they had such a great variety! we had a hard time deciding what slices to get and the clerk (who is also the wife of the cake whiz on the kitchen) was so nice and patient. she told us about how their business started and it's about to be two years at this retail location after years of running a cottage kitchen.

we got the chocoflan and tres leches slices and they were SO delicious! the chocoflan had a perfect ratio of choco cake and flan, and the choco cake was also moist (sometimes people make it too dry). the tres leches is creamy and dreamy and everything one would want in a tres leches.

highly recommend!!!!!“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“Erie is amazing. Highly recommend - coffee is absolutely the best - lattes and all different flavors - hot and cold! The banana bread is my favorite but All of the different baked goods are to die for! Never had anything but excellent here. The owners and the baristas and ALL of the staff are friendly and truly provide the BEST service! If I lived in Rutherford I’d be here every day!“

“Great sweets and very friendly knowledgeable staff answering all our questions. Highly recommend and I will return.“

“The best cookie I have ever eaten in my life minus my grandmothers! Huge cookies that are organic and gourmet!“

“My son was recently diagnosed with EOE and is dairy, nut and egg free. Someone recommended AltEats so I contacted Laurie and she worked her magic! My son was able to enjoy an amazingly delicious birthday cake for the first time! She also created the most delicious cannoli filled cake for my guests! I can’t say enough about how easy Laurie was to work with and how lucky I feel blessed I feel to have found this establishment!“

“Everything is delicious and the place is so welcoming.“

“Besides the beautiful presentation, these cakes taste amazing!! They are moist, fluffy and the perfect amount of sweetness. I ordered the yellow cake, triple chocolate and the strawberry swirl and I am in love!! I really appreciate that Gardner's Gourtment clearly makes completely homemade cakes and luscious frosting.“

“I wanted to leave this review to highlight the amazing service by the barista Gabby (or spelled Gabi?). Every time I visit this shop me and her have a pleasant interaction/convo and I just really appreciate that her demeanor. She always goes above and beyond to make sure my drink is exactly how I prefer it and asks me about the little details ❤️ thank youuu! She’s the reason I will stay coming back!!“

“The Pie crust cookies are amazing and I loved the toffee cookie even more!!“

“Don’t be fooled by the smallness of the place. The breakfast sandwiches are some of the tastiest I’ve ever had. I was looking to order a cake for a birthday, and I was impressed by their photos on Instagram as well as the flavor of the slices they had for sale (one of which I received as a gift). I provided a picture of what I wanted and they did not disappoint! Besides looking beautiful, the cake was moist and flavorful, even days later. Highly recommended!“

“WOW! I have life long dairy allergies and recent celiac diagnosis and I am so happy with this bakery! Since Erin McKennas bakery closed in NYC I’ve been on a hunt for a bakery that meets my allergen needs as a lot of vegan bakeries are not also nut free or don’t offer gluten free baked goods. I got a cookie and some of the No Whey chocolates and my partner got a cake truffle and cupcake. The cookie was amazing and my partner said the cake truffle was really good too (they didn’t get a gluten free one). I am happy to know that I have a safe bakery that I can go to and recommend to my family. Will be going back here!“

“Beautiful pastry and coffees!! Just remarkable and the friendliest and polite staff!! Always my pit stop on my bike rides 🚴up to Ramsey!!“

“I found Bertha after doing a search for two tier custom cakes in the Bronx. I was unsure and a little skeptical about ordering online from someone I couldn’t physically meet but I took the chance and ordered 7 dozen cupcakes and a two tiered chocolate cake with chocolate filling for my daughters sweet sixteen and they came out so beautiful and delicious. She asked me to send a pic of a cake that I liked and she replicated the cake so well with my own lil spin on it. She did an awesome job and I would definitely recommend her and buy cakes from her for any event I may have in the future. Also, she is much cheaper than most bakeries that usually would charge $800 for the cake I wanted. I only paid $280 and the cake was just as beautiful as the cake another bakery quoted. Highly recommend her if your looking for beautiful and great tasting cakes!“

“I need to say that Renee and Carrie are amazing! Very amazing service, being able to be answered in French at the boutique was amazing! I drove twice in 2 days to grab cupcakes and cookies… I cannot say what’s my favourite out of the cupcake, the brownies, the cookies etc because everything was decadent and not too sweet. You taste the quality of the ingredients and the love they put while cooking them. The fact that Carrie was answering me while the business is close is a sign that she’s passionate and that she care about her client. They’re on the expensive side compared to other bakery, but once you compare you understand why… You taste the butter in everything! If you like some fluffy, moist, creamy cupcake this is your place… While planning my wedding, I’ve compared a few bakery and non are as good as this one… Thank you for the amazing experience and taste!“

“Seems to be a newer business in downtown Ridgewood right on the corner across from the post office. Probably the best orange scone and oatmeal raisin cookie I have ever had. Everything is fresh and homemade. Nothing imported or stale. The setup is a little weird with how they have some of the baked goods because it's hard to see them all. I wish it was a little easier to see the selection. Maybe it's a good thing you can't really see everything because I would buy it all and be 900 pounds. Great addition to the area!“

“This is hands down the ABSOLUTE BEST BAKERY in the TRi-STATE AREA!!! Everything is always super fresh and delicious. Their variety of Cheescakes, Carrot cake, Fruit tarts, Cookies, Biscotti, Lobster tail pastries, and birthday cakes are to die for! I travel from anywhere to bring these along for any occasion and they never disappoint. It has become my family and friend's favorite as well. HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!“

“Wow this place is awesome!!! I bought the magic bar and a donut and both were amazing. I can't believe they were sugar free. I am often disappointed by gluten free dessert bakeries, but this place is the real deal. I will definitely be back.“

“I am NYC born & raised but moved out of state. Happened to find this amazing bakery on a visit to NYC. I am beyond pleased with ALL the treats I purchased.“

“Thank you Again Tee. The cake was delicious , I loved the design and coloring. Got 6-7 more orders I’ll be placing very soon. Thanks again sis your the Goat.“

“My son’s Lego Birthday Cake was a home run. The cake was delicious and definitely fresh. The cake was moist and the filling was smooth. All of the guests commented how great the cake tasted. The design of the cake exceeded our expectations. Thank You, We Bake Fresh for making my son’s birthday extra special. We will be recommending you to our friends and family.“

“Absolutely the best bagel there is. Each one no matter the flavor is a delight. And their food that they put on the bagel is delicious. Get there before 3;30 PM if you want sliced cheese because they close the slicer at 3;30. I know if I get there at 3;32 PM the slicer is off. So I get tuna fish instead and it’s about as good as it gets. The staff is friendly and do a good job. What a place!“