4.1
Good
714 Reviews
4 Park Avenue, New York · 4.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Caesar Salad with Our Caesar Dressing
- Porter House for Two or More
- Porterhouse Steak for Two
- Sizzling Canadian Bacon
“An unplanned dinner, out of curiosity for 2 when we happened to park right in front of Wolfgang Steakhouse. This was after my dental appointment across the street. We walked in past 6 pm and were accommodated right away. Onion bread was served with chunks of butter. 3/5. I always prefer a warm bread. We ordered a dozen of fresh Bluepoint oysters, with a mid-brininess taste. The flesh was glistening, plump but the saltiness is in-between. 3.5/5. I always look forward to the oysters in Norfolk, Virginia, right at the back of my friend's summer house. Its thick, high salinity flesh would let you slurp non-stop until your gastronomic craving is fulfilled. We shared a Caesar's salad. The lettuce was fresh with grated parmesan cheese and a few pieces of croutons. The sauce is always the star in a salad. Their sauce was light, simple and less creamy. 3/5 For me, a little more acid, touch of saltiness from anchovies and the right portion of Worcestershire, mayo and Dijon would perk up the depth of flavor. Then came the star of the dinner. We had a porterhouse for 2. It was a big sliced portion served on a hot metal plate with the meat sauce and butter. The meat was so tender. and rightly cooked, medium rare as ordered and not salty, which I like. I miss having a rosemary on top. We didn't finish only about 3 pcs. each though we both like it. 4.5/5 We have to have a space meeting some friends at about 9 pm. This was paired with the big onion rings, which were crunchy with a thin batter. 5/5 We preferred a lava cake but it wasn't available. So we had pistachio tartufo instead. It was covered with a tinge of truffled chocolate with a whipped cream in the middle. The sweetness was just enough but the cream in the middle was so gross that made the 4 slices of tartufo so small. Lessen the cream to make the tartufo stand out. 4/5 No wine at this time as we still have to meet some friends at 9 pm for a drink. Settled for a bottle of a sparkling water instead. The steak was $75 per person. The tables were near to each other that you could hear about their talks. Some customers talked so loud to a waiter that you could hear their voices even about 4-5 tables apart. Maybe due to a low but a nice well-designed arched ceiling by a famous Spanish architect. The waiters were nice and the service was prompt. Overall, it was worth a try. Will try their other branch/steaks next time.”