50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Tenafly

“I just had the best afternoon with my girls! I took them to this place for frozen yogurt and the lady working here brought out toys for my kids to play with while having the best frozen yogurt in town! I must have spent a good two hours here, my kids didn’t want to leave! They were very entertained, and that means the world to me since it’s been hard with the weather to take them places without having to spend crazy amounts of money!! Will definitely come at least once a week!“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“This place is fantastic! Real quality gelato. My favorite flavor is the dark chocolate. Mariana and Selena working behind the counter are superstars! Very friendly and personable and they really get you excited about the gelato they are preparing for you. Excellent service! Thank you Mariana and Selena! We will be back!“

“Delicious Italian ice and very friendly young men behind the counter. Great to have Rita’s back in the area!“

“My daughter loved the cupcakes, and i loved their price as well as the decor and feel of the bakery. Home has changed lots since ive moved. The only thing that could be better was the person at the register, he was highly engaged in his phone so his responses/interaction was quick short, kind of like he didnt want to be bothered. Overall the place the is 😍“

“•Very pretty store!
•Gets crowded so expect some lines but it moves quite fast.
•Kind and approachable staff.
•Delicious candies! So fun to mix and try varieties of flavors.
•The hot cocoa is a must-try too. Unique presentation and perfect on a chilly nyc winter weather!“

“The ice cream is great and although parking is hard it’s worth the visit at least once! Their ice cream flavor selections are pretty unique. I will say their hot chocolate didn’t hit. There was no piece of marshmallow it was a tiny dollop with a squirt of whipped cream.“

“Best ice cream in New Jersey highly recommended .. try the Dubai chocolate its addicting 🥰“

“My only complaint is that the lone worker today, when I was paying with a credit card (without tap) took my card and tried to use tap. Before she took my card I was going to put it into the card processor. When I pointed out that it doesn’t have tap, she (2x’s) typed my card information into the register screen and it was declined (plenty of credit was available because I got gas with it shortly after). I then used my debit card which she just took from me and again tried to use tap (again not a feature on that card either). She was finally able to put my card information for the debit card and it went through. If she had let me put my card in in the first place there would have been no problem with the original transaction attempt. I feel some of the staff might need better/more training on using the register.“

“I’ve been here multiple times and always have a good experience, but Jess was the absolute best today. She’s so welcoming, inviting, and just an overall sweet person. The ice cream is amazing regardless, but having her be as bubbly and personable as she was really was a cherry on top.“

“We really enjoyed the ice cream — the flavors were delicious and super fresh. The guy working there was very friendly and helped us choose the right flavors, which made the experience even better. There’s also plenty of space inside, with tables where you can sit and enjoy your treat. A cozy spot for a sweet break! 🍦✨“

“Had a delicious hot chocolate affogato here today and an absolutely wonderful experience overall! Linda and Blu were incredibly welcoming and patient while we decided what to order which made the visit even more enjoyable. It was such a fun stop—great treat with genuinely kind, helpful people. The outstanding service alone makes me want to keep coming back, and the gelato and hot chocolate were the perfect bonus!“

“Best Grapefruit ice cream ♥️“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“Fresh enjoyable used for business meeting“

“Service was warm and friendly, always a huge plus. The Toffee Caramel, I believe it was, was phenomenal, very creamy and wonderful flavor. The Straciatella not so great, not very creamy or flavorful, wouldn’t recommend. I tried the Crème Brûlée after the fact and that was lovely as well.“

“We happened by last Friday and I asked for a recommendation. I tried the cookies and caramel and it was the best ice cream I've had in a long time! I have thought about it multiple times since returning home from our trip! It's so good!☺️👏“

“� � loved it so did my kids great experience and fun .“

“Our youngest daughter is home for the weekend from college, she wanted froyo. We searched a few places 1 that was closed and the 2nd had no froyo.
We found Frozen Love. It was further than we expected but let me tell you.
Was more than worth it. First let me start with the small clean shop. I always check for an uncleaned spill or garbage spilling out the can. The counters are excellently kept. No dust anywhere that I can see (even behind the register)
2nd of all let me tell you about the family member welcome that my wife, Daughter and I received from Moe.
His warmth, genuine smile and charm made us all 3 relaxed and comfortable in asking to try all of the 6 flavors they have(but flavors change every 2 weeks)
The 1st one I tried was the coconut.
And it was coconut. Not overly sweet but just enough.
Then I tried the lemon. Tasted like it was scooped right from the fruit.
All in all I give this small in size but huge in heart establishment Froyo place of the year...
Did I mention they make the froyo in-house and it's Greek style!
I love frozen yogurt. I like the franchise ones. But this little spot has won me over in just 1 visit..
Thank you Moe for your beyond excellent service.
We will be back..

Oh and by the way.
I got the Lemon mixed with Coconut and the original Tart flavor topped with Passionfruit and pomegranate boba..
And got one to take home...
If you like Froyo, forget the pink people and the 16 doorknobs(names changed to protect privacy) go get some real Frozen Love! 10/10!“

“Great homemade ice cream.Great assorted flavors.You won't be disappointed.“

“They have the best lemon ice cream 🍦🍦“

“This is an outstanding place to get ice cream. Not only do they have a large variety of delicious ice creams, but they also offer a number of really high quality dairy free ice creams AND toppings! We had a very nice time. I had the brown sugar cookie dough, which was very good, and he had a dairy free sundae with dairy free chocolate sauce. We can't wait to get back!“

“My daughter had a play date and her new best friend lives near by this ice cream place, it's a hidden gem they prepared the rolled ice cream and the bubble crepes fresh right in front of you, you got to be a little patience as sometimes there is a line and the 2 servers is doing their very best to prepared all orders according to what received, we ordered Nutella rolled and strawberry banana crepes and both devoured by our kids and both loves it so much, my daughter already asking me to comeback so we can try a different ice cream menu, inside the place is organized and clean, both server is really helpful, I have no complaint with service and everything is delicious, we will definitely coming back soonest.“

“Ok, so photo don't look good because I had to dig in quick during a hot summer day. I don't like sweets in general, but DAMN!!!, the blueberry lemon basil is really good. The Oreo, chocolate and nocciola flavors are on point. Will be coming back for sure.“

“So pretty and so delicious!!! Too bad I forgot to take a picture of my dad’s birthday cake.. I made an online order(it was easy!) of chocolate lava cake and it was one of the most delicious Choco lava I have ever had!! I have a picture of some other ones….“

“Every time the door opens the owners are always smiling and very welcoming. A warm wanted feeling is nice for a customer to feel. Especially these days. The ice cream is ALWAYS fresh. The place is always clean as well.“

“Never been before today but so happy we stopped by! Kids were thrilled with the flavor choices and I really liked there was a vegan option! We’ll definitely be stopping in again. 😃“

“The ice-creams are delicious. They have many egg-free/vegan options as well. And the staff members are very friendly. My son dropped his ice-cream on the floor, but they refused to charge us even after us insisting.“

“The first time I stopped recently, on a 85 degree day, the service was great!
I ordered a vanilla ice cream soda; vanilla soda with vanilla ice cream and whipped cream. The next time I went last Saturday at night the girl didn't have the faintest idea of what vanilla soda was. Finally I got what I wanted but it was annoying. I understand if she was new
But teach her. Otherwise I love their ice cream!“

“Want to see more of my experience? Check out my Instagram @lawyer.traveler.dreamer! 🍦🔥 Ample Hills Creamery – A Chocolate Lover’s Dream! 🔥🍦 I stopped by Ample Hills Creamery in NYC, and their Death by Chocolate Hot Chocolate is a must-try! 🍫✨ Here’s why it’s amazing: 🍦 Served in a crispy, edible chocolate-dipped cup with nuts or spearmints. ☕️ Filled with rich hot chocolate and flavored syrup. 🍡 Topped with toasted marshmallow whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and edible gold—delicious! 🤩 We also tried their ice cream and loved it! 🍨 Here’s what we got: 💜 Egg Carton Sampler – 6 flavors to taste it all! 🍦 Waffle bowl with 3 scoops – All for just $52! Our favorite flavors: 🍪 Cookie au Lait – Creamy and full of cookie goodness. 🥭 Underneath the Mango Tree – Sweet and tropical. 🍫 Death by Chocolate – Rich and perfect for chocoholics. 🍌 Banana Pudding – Smooth, creamy, and dreamy. If you’re looking for the best ice cream in NYC, head to Ample Hills Creamery!“

“The cookie butter bomb is so good! I enjoyed it so much I’d definitely recommend this ice cream place! Very tasty!“

“My daughter loves it , she says music and all is amazing. She was Surprised thats the bubble gum ice scream had literally candy inside 😅“

“delicioso 🤤 buena atencion 🎉“

“Excellent gelato! Very nice staff! Lovely outdoor patio.“

“Such a beautiful little spot, with delicious home made ice cream at affordable prices, and really kind staff. I got the chocolate cherry and mango flavours twice already.
Importantly, also pet friendly with delicious ice cream for doggies. It seems that, judging from the reaction of a couple of them, even some doggies are regular customers! :-)
I love the atmosphere and colours of this little gem, which has a long bench and quite a few spots to sit down and enjoy your ice cream, as well as the colourful metal tables outside at a vibrant and friendly neighbourhood, so close to Central Park and in the wider Columbia University lively neighbourhood.
If I lived in the area long term, I would visit it every day!“

“Malibu with cherry Italian Ice. May I saw the service is above & Beyond. Fast and very respected. Makes the customer feel good and its a guarantee of coming back with the entire family and share with others. Lots of different choices and there are little tables to eat outside the ice cream shop. I will say a family in front of me: the mama dropped her ice cream by mistake while carrying the others for her children and they literally gave her a brand new one with no charge! Other places they will charge 😆 but not Ralph's so go check them out this summer you wont regret it. 😉“

“Thank you for your support of Eastbrook’s class of 2021!“

“Excellent shave ice and ramen!“

“Crepehouse is honestly one of those spots you walk into once and instantly know you’re coming back. The food hits every time. The crepes are fresh, soft, and packed with flavor, and they don’t cheap out on the fillings either. The place is always clean, the vibe is cozy, and the workers treat you right. Whether it’s a sweet crepe, a savory one, or even just grabbing a drink, everything tastes on point. Definitely one of the best spots around and worth every visit“

“First time there today at the Nyack store, chose my personal favorite black raspberry and it was awesome! I am kind of a connoisseur of this flavor, and this was super delicious! Staff was also very friendly and the store nice and clean.“

“Amazing tasting ice cream at great prices accompanied by great service“

“Got the matcha latte with ube soft serve and really enjoyed it as I was craving both of those things today and was very happy to find a place that actually serves that. Overall impressed with the amount of combinations they have to offer. I’m 100% coming back to try their banana pudding matcha!!!“

“The new ressee ice cream thing (forgot the name) it’s like a sundae/blizzard combo sorta, you eat with spoon… it’s shown as brown ice cream (not vanilla) which it is, just vanilla soft serve with peanut butter syrup.. I thought that it was peanut butter ice cream (which would have been better) it was still pretty good though but pretty expensive for a small cup of averaged ice cream.. $8 an some change ?‍♀️?‍♀️“

“amazing place. Want to tae my friends here! awesome!!!!!“

“Was in the area and decided to try this place out. So happy we did, it was aaaamazing!!! Great variety menu, we had the jojo burger and the mushroom burger with an order of fries. Everything was super hot and fresh and delicious. It was super clean and I believe the man there was JoJo himself, he was extremely attentive, friendly and even brought our food over to us. Will definitely be coming back to this place. Wish I lived closer lol“

“I’ve been to this franchise only twice and love everything from the flavors to the toppings! Just so yummy, highly recommend“

“Absolutely delicious! The flavors I chose today on a waffle cone: Pistachio & Piña Colada. The shop also has a small & nice sitting area in the front, with 2 swing benches, umbrellas, 1 iron bistro table & chairs.“

“We used to walk there from the house over 50 years ago. Pick up a dozen Dilly Bars (I think they call them Buster bars now). I always knew the staff because we grew up together. So much more than memories !“

“Have a chat with Santa he is a treat ! 🥰“

“I've always loved Carvel. This location everybody is pretty cool. Always great times when I go there. My only problem with Carvel is that they STILL DON'T HAVE rewards points. Everybody wants rewards points, COME ON ALREADY CARVEL!! WE WANT REWARDS!!“