New American Restaurants near Garnerville, NY

“In addition to many delicious family dinners over the years we have hosted two wonderful parties at Beni’s in the last year and we couldn’t be happier with the food and service! Always rave reviews from our guests and they are so accommodating!“

“Great indoor and outdoor dining“

“We ordered the boneless wings, sliders and chicken wraps. All were very tasty. The drinks came out fast and cold. The hostess tried to sit us at a dirty table, bench seat had oil and crumbs and table had crumbs and sauce all over. Made her change tables, she did not seem happy. Our waitress was awesome she made up for lazy hostess. Overall we will be back.“

“We came for a saturday brunch and it was nothing short of excellent. The manager greeted us and we had some drinks at the bar. The bartender gave us some great recommendations for the menu and the owner even came over to us and introduced himself which was very nice. We got the meatballs, rockshrimp and calamari, lobster guacamole, and burrata which were all incredible and great shareables for us. 5/5 and will definitely be back.“

“I played here for Blank-Fest 2022... great room! Great Staff ...Great Fun!!!“

“The Windsor Bar and Grille is phenomenal. A must if you're in the area!“

“Everything I’ve ever gotten here is delicious, but the green goddess dressing I picked up today? AMAZING. I don’t know what they put in this stuff, but it’s worth every penny. I put it on every component of our dinner tonight — chicken, broccoli, roasted potatoes — and it’s perfection.“

“Enjoyable lunch experience“

“The name is misleading...we were hoping for a waterview, but there was none, maybe before all the buildings went up around this spot. Too hungry to keep searching, we stayed. Burgers and service were good.
Extra charge for lettuce, tomato, mayo, etc...“

“We had a fantastic dinner at Sweet Grass tonight. The food was perfection and the service was impeccable. Our first time here, but will not be our last.“

“Hidden gem!! Food, staff, music fabulous.“

“I came in tonight around 6:30pm and I had the best experience. I had to be in and out and was still well taken care of. The bartender I believe was by himself and was running everywhere but didn’t miss a step! His bar was full and I think I saw him handling to-go as well!? If I’m not mistaken his name was Deshon? I will most definitely be back to see him, he is great. He truly made my Bareburger experience.“

“Taco Thursday’s! Who doesn’t like a taco? Food is very fresh and best Mexican food around. Margaritas are made fresh with squeezed limes not a mix. One of my favorite places for Sunday breakfast! Everyone is very friendly and welcoming.“

“Today we held an After celebration of life luncheon. Family and friends were brought together , the wait staff plus (Delicious Food) and attention were above and beyond attentive to everyone’s wants and needs. We cannot Thank You enough. The Anstett Family“

“We had my daughters wedding here last night. I cant say enough or praise this business. Evan was always there to help from the begining of the planning and right up to the end. even when our orginal date had to be cancelled and eventually rebooked for a year later. The venue. We couldnt of asked for more. Food was fabulous, drinks plentiful and service great. Thank you evan!“

“There's a good reason you see so many 5 Star reviews - this place is awesome! The food is fresh, menu is creative and the staff are v nice. I promise anyone that goes that it won't be their last visit.“

“Chef Elmer is highly skilled and talented. The quality of the ingredients, the methods of cooking/raw and the spectacular presentation is world class! The tasting menu is one of the best I've had. Highly recommend!“

“The food is absolutely delicious. Beautiful presentation and menu has a lot of variety. Love their brunch and special events. Jackie makes everyone feel welcomed and like an old friend. Staff is extremely attentive and accommodating.“

“I love everything about this place! The food is outstanding and the staff are amazing! Shout out to Christa, who is the soul of the place, and Cory, who goes above and beyond (crayons & paper for my little one). The cafe is a second home to me :-)“

“I have been coming here for years. I consider myself a good cook but when I need good food that I don't have to prepare, this is my go-to place. The staff and owner are great! Try the stuffed peppers, Chicken Milanese and Lasagna. OMG!“

“We are at The Burger Loft on a Friday night. it was very busy, but the service was good and the food was outstanding!“

“We had my daughters wedding here last night. I cant say enough or praise this business. Evan was always there to help from the begining of the planning and right up to the end. even when our orginal date had to be cancelled and eventually rebooked for a year later. The venue. We couldnt of asked for more. Food was fabulous, drinks plentiful and service great. Thank you evan!“

“Went to Four Star Cafe last night and it was amazing. Great atmosphere and food!!“

“We ate there today and there was a slight snag with my dish. Our waiter (Dan) was quick to make it right and we had a great time!“

“Delicious food, inexpensive and comfortable environment!“

“The Nachos are authentic & in my opinion a top 10 item. Carla was an impressive staff member who professionally worked ambitiously“

“Love the good and the service, all excellent!“

“went there for my boyfriend's birthday. it was so good. the staff is friendly and accommodating, the food is absolutely delicious and the ambience is beautiful as you are right by the river“

“The brunch and the twin waitresses where amazing. I can’t wait to come back“

“love this place! food is great! ambiance very hip!“

“The Tapp is the quintessential local bar. The staff are very friendly, the burgers are phenomenal (as is everything else on the menu), and the prices are more than reasonable. If you find yourself in Tarrytown for shopping or seeing a show at The Music Hall, make a stop at The Tapp a part of the experience. Better still, make the trip just to visit The Tapp alone. It really is a great place to hang out with friends, catch a singer, play Tuesday Night Trivia, or have a terrific meal.“

“Had the #1 sashimi and my wife got the tiger shrimp scampi.

Server was Miguel and he was AWESOME!!

We will 100% be back if we’re ever in town.

Location is great, we walked down to the Hudson River after dinner.“

“Beautiful venue, attentive staff, excellent food! One of Hudson Valleys best places for a wedding.“

“Just had one of those nights you wish you could bottle up and relive 🔥

Stopped by this bar for their open mic night, and WOW — the energy was unreal from start to finish. You could feel the mix of raw talent and pure passion in every performance, but the absolute highlight of the night was the band featuring Matthew Rapelye.

They didn’t just play music — they owned the room. Tight, dynamic, and completely in sync, with vocals and instrumentals that hit every note perfectly. The kind of performance that makes you stop mid-conversation and just listen. People were cheering, vibing, and completely locked in.

The atmosphere? Laid-back but electric. Great crowd, welcoming vibe, and the kind of place where you walk in a stranger and leave feeling like part of something.

If you’re even remotely into live music, open mic nights, or just discovering insanely talented artists before they blow up — this is the spot.

Already counting down until the next time 🎶“

“My favorite outdoor bar in the area! Fun, laid back vibe! Great drinks! Great food! Amazing and the most hospitable staff and manager! Very family and very pet friendly! They bring water for the pups and everything! 10/10 recommend! I miss this place all winter!“

“Very good, excellent sandwich 🥪...“

“I just had my daughter’s Baptism party at the HWC and I would HIGHLY recommend!!! Everything was exceptional. The food was phenomenal and the service was amazing. Our guests are still talking about the food and the cake is definitely one of the best we have ever tried. The restaurant is beautiful but the staff and owners make you feel like family. They were so helpful throughout the process and made it such a pleasure to work with them. They really treat you like family. Thank you Chris, Monica and all the staff for making our baby girls day special. We will definelty be having a lot more future parties here. Anyone looking for a place to host a party, don’t think twice and book the HWC🩵🩵“

“Tarry Tavern for dinner: Mom had Seared maine sea scallops with local corn and leek risotto and I got the roasted Hudson valley duck breast with pecan cranberry wild rice and sunchoke purée. Unreal. Mom cleaned her plate at a restaurant for the first time in ages and mine was to die for. We shared the pumpkin pecan bread pudding for dessert. Outstanding experience with excellent, friendly service“

“Everything is just amazing“

“La comida es muy exquisita a pesar que el servicio no es súper bien.“

“Stopped off on our way to Pennsylvania. Didn't realize it was in a hotel but pleasantly surprised when we got inside. You can sit outside or dine in. Good size bar and the chicken sandwich and burger were good. Definitely get yourself the sweet potato fries.“