4.4
Superb
190 Reviews
1786 Sheepshead Bay Road, Brooklyn · 9.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Half Ham and Swiss and Roast Beef with the Works
- Ham and Swiss with the Works
- Fresh Roast Beef on a Roll
- French Roast Beef Sandwich
“Jimmy's Famous Heros, situated right along the bustling Sheepshead Bay and Avenue U corridors in Brooklyn, is a legendary neighborhood sandwich shop that has long been celebrated for serving up massive, overflowing, and incredibly flavorful hot and cold subs. I stopped in for a hearty lunch and ordered one of their classic Italian hero sandwiches packed with premium cured meats, provolone, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and a generous drizzle of oil and vinegar, and every single bite was an absolute triumph. The bread was wonderfully crusty on the outside yet soft enough to hold all the rich, savory fillings without falling apart. The establishment features a classic, unpretentious, and welcoming old-school deli atmosphere that makes it a true local institution. The counter service was exceptionally friendly, fast, and efficient throughout my visit. It is a phenomenal local gem whenever you are craving an authentic, top-tier New York hero right in the area.”