7 Best Seafood Restaurants near Port Jefferson

Joey Z's Restaurant Italian • $$
217 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Z-Pita's Signature Filet Mignon Quesadilla
119 Fried Calamari with Marinara Sauce
Strawberry and Cream Cheese Crepes
Chicken Souvlaki Pita Lunch
Sweet Potato Fries
Chocolate Brownie
Chocolate Fondue
Stuffed Mushrooms
Lemon Potatoes
French Toast

“Fantastic meal tonight. We had several food allergies including gluten and dairy. They were amazing at making sure that we had several options to meet all of our dietary needs. The owner came out and explained the menu to us. They were unbelievably helpful and the food was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend the gluten-free/dairy free pizza with dairy free/vegan cheese. Our server, Jenna was fantastic! Everything was wonderful.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free and dairy free“

4.8 Superb105 Reviews
Joey Z's Brooklyn Pizza Pizza • $$
217 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Joey’S Special Pita
Grilled Crab Cake
Garlic Knots
Greek Salad
Gyro Dinner
Pizza

“Joey Z's has some of the best breakfast around! I always enjoy coming here for consistently good food and quick service. I had the banana pancakes (which are my go-to) and my mom had the Eggs Benedict which came with potatoes. The staff and owner are so kind and make you want to keep coming back!“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
Tara Inn Bar • $
1519 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe and Chicken Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
We Need More Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Canadian Lobster
Buffalo Wings
Chilli
Burger
Pretzel
Clams

“We stumbled across this place while waiting for our ferry during a New England road trip. Upon seeing prices that looked like they were from a bygone era (it's not just the lobster), we had quite a few items from their eclectic menu. Everything was made to order and our food was delivered much more quickly than the average fast-food joint by a server who treated us like old friends. The atmosphere is unpretentious and super chill - perfect for sports fans looking to hang out alone or with friends. It's a must-visit place if you're passing through the area for any reason.“

4.5 Superb78 Reviews
Grumpy Jack's Sports Bar • $$
28 Oakland Ave, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Mozzarella Sticks
Popcorn Chicken
Steak and Eggs
Fish and Chips
Buffalo Wings
Grumpy Jack
Garlic Bread
Ahi Tuna
Burgers
Sauce

“We have a tradition of coming here for st pattys day because my hubby does not eat red meat. He always getfs his turkey burger and is happy. I was estatic to see fried pickles on the menu. I got the pickles, seafood bisque, caesar salad and a corned beef sandwich. EVERYTHING was fresh, came out hot and was delicious. It can get loud but it was st pattys day after all. Try it, you will go back.UPDATE 3/17/2020 had to get our feast to go. My corned beef dinner was the best EVER. Hubby's Turkey burger was perfect. Miss our fireside table today.UPDATD coming here is also our New Year's Eve tradition. We do a late lunch, early dinner. Dinner choices are plenty and delicious. You can't go wrong no matter what you order. Love the staff.UPDATE AGAIN. March 17,2021. Had to get our dinners for pick up again. Grumpys chicken and my corned beef and cabbage dinner. Oh yeah and a pretzel. Each year is better than the last. Perfect food and so enjoyable Thank you Trevor and the entire staff at Grumpys.UPDATE MOTHER'S DAY 2021...the reason we come for special occasions is Trevor and the entire staff AND the food. Thank you Grumpy Jack's.UPDATE New Years Eve 2024. Has to get take out since mynhusband had a cold. He gets Grumpy's chicken with mashed potatoes and string beans. I got onion soup, a shrimp cocktail, sm Greek salad and fish n chips (hey it's a last meal after all!) Everyone is so friendly and helpful. The food came out SUPER HOT and PERFECT. We don't go anywhere else for our special occasions. THANK YOU GRUMPY JACK'SUPDATE. ST. PATTY'S 2024 husband got his chicken and I got a small Greek salad and the corned beef platter and a non alcoholic bloody Mary. Staff is always pleasant and keep in touch with you. Food came out hot and plentiful. Oh yes perfectly cooked and delicious. We come here for major holidays and person events. Don't intend to change as they are all the BEST.“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Nantuckets American • $$
9 Traders Cove, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Crab Crusted Salmon
Blackened Swordfish
Seafood Risotto
Seafood Paella
Grilled Oysters

“Went New Year’s Eve had an awesome meal off their special menu. Started off with a nice glass of German resiling wine, Shades of Blue, excellent! Then for appetizer had the crab cakes, loaded with crab topped with Aioli sauce, best I’ve ever had. Then had the fillet mignon with lobster tail, fillet had a good amount of gristle in the middle that I had to work around, other than that it was very good. Lobster tail was presented and seasoned very well in some sort of marinated butter, wine and garlic which I thought was top notch of flavor and tenderness. Came with the mash potatoes another good choice some of the best made. I can’t forget their delicious homemade multi grain bread which was very good. For last desert opted for the Crème Brûlée topped off with fresh made whipped cream, awesome. Let me also mention about our waitress very friendly and accommodating, great customer service.Overall had a very enjoyable and unforgettable experience at Nantucket's other than the fillet not being completely satisfied I give it the Cardillo Scale Rating Review of 4.8 out of 5. Will definitely be back again. Happy New Year ? ? ?“

4.1 Good90 Reviews
PJ Lobster House Seafood • $$
134 Main St, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Muscles in White Zinfandel
Hot Lobster Roll
New England Clam
Mashed Potatoes
Creamed Spinach
Shrimp Cocktail
Lobster Bisque
Seafood Paella
Fried Shrimp
Baked Clams

“The food was extremely delicious and very fresh. The service was great as well. We were very happy and had enough to bring home for seconds. Definitely recommend.Dietary restrictions: We have different dietary restrictions and all found delicious things to eat.“

4.1 Good116 Reviews
The Steam Room Seafood • $$
4 E Broadway, Port Jefferson

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Mac & Cheese
Seafood Platter
Catch of the Day
Seafood Paella
Seafood Bisque
Fried Scallops
Fried Calamari
Lobster Roll
Fried Clams
Bread Bowl

“This seafood restaurant is located at Port Jefferson, Long Island. The atmosphere is good and I like the green house which is warm, and can enjoy the sea view. The food are delicious yet not too expensive. The seafood pot is tasty and the fish platter is excellent. The lobster roll is ok and the market price today is $26. The salad is good too.Parking: N/A“

3.5 Good98 Reviews
Loading...
map Map