Pet Friendly · $$$
1 Deer Mountain Inn
790 Co Rd 25, Tannersville
“If you look up “cozy” in the dictionary, I’m certain there would be a photo of Deer Mountain Inn. We haven’t stayed there, but have enjoyed two stellar dinners. The sourdough focaccia is an all time best bread and an absolute must order. The straciatella , burnt carrots, chicken liver pate, and butter were all among with the bread. Honestly, you can’t go wrong with any of the dips so order a bunch. The cheeseburger is special ( well seasoned, juicy, and the cheddar cheese and caramelized onions work perfectly) and the fries are some of the best. Deer Mountain does seasonal vegetables about as well as anyone can, the kabocha squash and heirloom tomatoes were outstanding. The smoked half chicken and Wagyu Bavette were both delicious. And don’t skip on the sundae, they have a mini version if you’re too full. But the s’mores are also wonderful. I don’t know, get both! Overall, just a gem in the Catskills everyone should have on their list.”