Sandwich Shops near Carnegie

“My family and I waltzed into Subway today and were greeted by the wonderful Marrion. Despite having a co-worker with the charisma of a deflated balloon, our Marrion was the epitome of composure. Now, while Marsha (the aforementioned balloon) re-entered the restaurant with all the grace of a bull in a china shop, accusing Marrion of stealing her forgotten tips, Marrion continued to serve us with a kindness that'd outshine any 'Employee of the Month'.

It was quite the spectacle, really. Marsha demanded Marrion remind her about her tips in the future and then muttered foul words under her breath that should not have been said in front of customers, let alone my 10 year old son.

Now, I was tempted to knock off a star for the free side-dish of drama, but I really want the 5 stars to reflect the wonderful customer service experience provided by Marrion.“

“"You've got to refresh to be fresh. One of the best thing Subway has ever done. Their new line of sandwich are very good. Trust me. I tried them all. And customer service is very great at this location. I got everything I asked for including extra cheese and bacon.Go Subway!! You rock“

“Not only are these some of the best subs we have ever had, but this place has one of the coolest atmospheres we have ever experienced. We just moved to Pittsburgh and were looking for our go-to sub place and Peppi’s was recommended multiple times. Walking in and you’re instantly met with real hard-working Pittsburgh people and a culturally rich atmosphere that highlights local celebrities, area history, and all around Pittsburgh pride. All this on top of an incredible sandwich and fries every-time and we have our spot for many years to come. We recommend trying the whole menu over time, but our favorites are the Santucci and the mushroom cheesesteak.“

“We visited your establishment for the first time last night, I insisted on finding a more gourmet tasting Italian hoagie and oh man did I find it. Your food is amazing BUT I apologize as I did not catch his name, the employee up front basically running your establishment WOW!! What a fabulous individual you have as the face of your business. I just want you to know that he is an absolute asset, the world needs many more of these kind of people. (Professional, knowledgeable, happy, all around wonderful person) THANK YOU! We will be back!“

“EXCELLENT DELI GREAT FOOD VERY CLEAN ANS FRIENDLY SERVICE THE BEST IN PITTSBURGH“

“awesome people, awesome food!!!“

“If you're looking for a local hangout and local sandwiches this is the place to go. We are visiting from out of town and were looking for a place to have lunch after the Heinz museum. Just as short stroll away in an area of town that's for the restaurants. My wife and I both had cheesesteak sandwiches which were delicious“

“Food is fresh, tastes great and is absolutely delicious! Staff is exceptional! HIGHLY recommend“

“Yummy food, had wonderful service and we will forsure return. Everything was out fast and we enjoyed it all.“

“This is hands down the best fish and chip spot in Pittsburgh. The fish, shrimp and fries were excellent. Perfectly crispy on the outside and the inside just melts in your mouth. The house made donuts are also to die for. Highly recommend checking them out and the owner is super nice too!“

“It is a great place to be, and the employees have a good attitude.“

“Got the grilled chicken club 🔥🔥🔥 10/10“

“The best Sandwich in Pittsburgh“

“I haven’t gotten the subs from here in a long time, maybe over a year. I had a craving today for their “Everything” bread. I headed to the store around lunchtime, as I walked in the door, I saw a sign to get a free 5 inch sub when you join there online program, I scan the QR code and decided to place my order online. The app did not redeem for a free 5 inch sub, but I went ahead with my order anyway. I didn’t see the “Everything” bread through the online portal (only: plain, sesame and multigrain) so I chose another bread type and guessed that they had discontinued the “Everything” bread since I hadn’t been here in so long. I sat at a booth and submitted my order, then a lady walks in and places her order at the counter and I hear her ask for the everything bread. I walked over to the counter and I see that it is still a bread option on their board. Then I asked the attendant at the counter if it was possible to change my bread type for my online order. Cadence clarified if I wanted the change for both of my subs and I said yes, she fixed my order without any issue. When she brought my order to me, I apologized for the inconvenience and she said that it was no problem and that if I had any issues with the online order in the future that I could give them a call at the store. This review is kudos to Cadence and her great customer service. As far as the DiBellas app, it’s still needs worked on.

Parking: There are a lot of businesses close together, so although DiBellas may not be busy, the parking lot is.“

“Came here after work to order takeout because I wanted a bite to eat. I got the turkey sando and the tots and let me tell you I was impressed! I was skeptical about the hummus being on the sandwich and originally asked for it to be made without but i’m honestly glad that they ended up putting it on there because it took it to a whole new level! The vibe of the place was also a plus, really down to Earth!“

“By far well worth the price which wasn’t as bad as I thought it would be. I’m not sure what the waitress name was but man was she awesome. She was so attentive and super kind. The atmosphere was great too. Next time we have to come to the drs we will definitely be back. Thanks for a great experience.“

“Best Reuben I’ve had. Great bread. Sauerkraut was on point. And the tang of the dressing was perfect.

Also had the blondie and it was legit.

Will definitely seek this place out again when I’m in the area. Try it out. Prices are also very good for what you get. $10-15 for a quality sandwich.

Small shop inside with just a few tables but can easily take to go and eat at the park across the street.“

“awesome people, awesome food!!!“

“The people working at Jersey Mike's on Saturday evening, July 18 2020 went above and beyond for us. I placed an online order and on our way to get the order the vehicle we were driving in broke down. I called and explained the situation because I knew we wouldn't get there before close. The person I spoke with was so kind and assured me I could still get my order. Unfortunately, we weren't able to get there at all and when I called to explain and offer my order to the closing team, the person who answered was again so kind and offered to refund my order even though I had no intention of asking for that. It was just a nice gesture and the care they showed for our situation was amazing. I will make sure to order from them more often! Thanks guys!“

“I order from here all the time because the sandwiches are delicious! Today, they forgot the mayo and pepper relish on both of our sandwiches so they were very dry and boring. I like to order online to customize my sandwich but what's the point if they skip the ingredients you want to add??“

“The staff is excellent and very caring. They are the perfect business for that plaza, especially because it's near one of Allegheny Health Networks treatment centers. People that come and go from that plaza need love and a smile. Thank you for making our day when we come to eat. On top of the great service the food is always fresh and excellent. The store is always spotless.“

“Delivered subs fancy tatse“

“From Michigan and had to experience the Sandwich..😊 Very good!!! Heading to a Steeler and Penguin games tomorrow and Tuesday.“

“Always wonderful experience and recommend everyone absolutely best place to eat .“

“I visit different Primantis, and I just have to say this location knocks it out of the park...
Best food taste ever, wings were phenomenal.
Hostess was great. The GM was super friendly over the phone when I called to give them a compliment.
Thank you for the great experience.“

“I stopped going to Subway a few years ago because of quality was terrible. A couple of years ago I moved and was very close to this location in Westview plaza. I don't know if it is just this location or all subways have stepped up their game but I have never gotten a bad meal at this place!
Everything is fresh and it fills me up. The best part is I order through the app and they always have at least buy one get a second for 50% off and run a buy one get one free promotion very frequently. Currently they are doing the buy one get one free promotion and I have gone there three times in the last 5 days. All three times the food was delicious and did not take long to get. I highly recommend this place.“

“Ashley and Amanda swift and friendly service. They pivoted with grace when I decided I wanted to make my salad a sub halfway through the creation. I must say as an out of towner frequenting the Greater Pittsburgh ares the put Bethel and South Hills on the map and booked this spot as a place to return. Double AA's powering this Sunway with A1 service.“

“Dude! Mike is the guy!! Talk about incredible service, kind energy, good at his job, and someone thats just personable as heck. Thats the one. I came because I had seen other reviews talking about how good the guy behind the counter was, and ill never go to another subway again as long as hes there. Dude always puts exactly what i ask for, not any less, not any more, just perfect. Not to mention, we can just chat while he makes it and hes fun to talk to. Seriously, dude deserves a raise Mr. Ownerman, get to it.“

“The best sandwiches around! The younger staff working are super fast and friendly with their service. Side note for my coleslaw lovers- it's amazing, none of that dry shredded cabbage it's saucey and chopped perfectly! Highly recommend the Audie.“

“stopped here for lunch when attending a conference. They were short staffed and hit with a rush of people from the event and they handled it so well. The service was amazing and the food was great and totally worth the wait. Shoutout to the two ladies working their butts off today!“

“Convenient and helpful. A great asset to the neighborhood“

“I am somewhat new to the area and have been in this location twice. Yes it is more expensive than Subway but there is no comparison. I think if you are willing to spend the extra dollars you’ll be happy here. I know what $10 buys me at Subway. And they’ve been going downhill for years. I’d rather spend the extra money at Primo’s or just do without! The quality is much higher and ingredients seem a lot fresher. IMO. I don’t think you could go wrong with anything on menu. I usually skip the cheese but not here. Anything with turkey is lower in calories so I’ve only had that so far. A lot of women could probably get two meals out of the primo size sandwich if you get a small side. Their potato salad is different but very good. They were out of rice pudding today so they substituted dirty pudding. While I don’t need the extra sugar, it is very good! Store seems very clean as well. The saying ‘You get what you pay for’ applies here!“

“My third time there in 2 months...the steak is a great hometown taste for a franchise or chain restaurant. People are friendly funny and take pride in what they do I haven’t got past the steak yet because it’s that good. I am going to try something next visit (at least try to)“

“We haven't been to this location in years. Came in this Sunday and it was busy. (A large group of 6 or 7 adults plus kids before us, and another one after us.) Only one person working. I think his nametag said "Twig" which was unusual, but the food prep area was clean, he was quick and professional and I even saw him change his gloves. When the sub he was making for me got a bit wet he took the time to wrap it again in a new paper which I appreciated. (We were taking the subs hiking.) Totally solid experience from a rockstar and I hope management of the store appreciates what a great employee they've got. We were having a rough day so having a good experience for lunch turned it around. We'll be back.“

“Everyone who works at this location makes DELICIOUS sandwiches. I’ve been here 4 times in the past week because of how good my sandwich was. It was not only good but fulfilling not stingy with toppings at all. Probably the best location in Pittsburgh! Thank you all!“

“Favorite subway everrrrr…never had any issues besides it’s not closer to home 🥹lol
The gentleman who runs this store? Amazing ! I come too often for those cookies and fresh bread . Never had to complain about the food or service like I deal with at other local subways“

“Great happy hour specials!“

“I had the freshest hoagie at this location this week and WOW, game changer. Thanks alot.“

“Cant go wrong here we stopped in for lunch and got a meatball hoagie with a chicken bacon ranch hoagie and tried the new foot long cookie, churo and pretzel. The cookie and churo were probably tied for being pretty good and the pretzel was ok“

“The crew at the South Park Rd in Bethel Park closed 40 min early and was closed and dark at 7:40pm
I had to go to the McMurray Subway
The crew there made me a delicious meatball sub perfectly. This review is for the McMurray crew. They're 👍“

“My wife and I stopped at this Firehouse Subs for the first time. We split a large Italian sub, which was plenty of food for a light lunch. The sandwich was not bad, but there was nothing special about it either. Most of the meat was just ham, with a wisp of salami (??maybe?), and there was very little cheese, lettuce and tomato, making it really just a warm ham sandwich. The only thing that made it somewhat Italian was the little bit of dressing they put on it. (NOTE: by the way, I didn't realize that all subs are HOT subs, unless you specifically ask for cold.) I may go back someday to try their cheesesteak, but not in a hurry to visit again. Final Verdict: Not bad, but nothing to write home about.“

“My boyfriend Noah and I love this store. He comes here a couple times a week. It is the best around and the crew is on point and really doing such a great job! Just wanted to show some love to our favorite store ! Carlos is a great manager. Couldn’t ask for a better local sandwich shop!“

“I'm giving this a 5, because of the excellent way the young lady handled the situation. It was later at night and every other Subway was closed. This location said open. What the site DIDN'T say was that it was for pick up orders only... My phone wouldn't complete the order for some reason. Even though the owner for some reason had this poor girl working by HERSELF AT NIGHT IN OAKLAND at the only open Subway and she was SUPER busy, she took a second to take my order and made sure I was taken care of and did it with a great and positive attitude. I felt so bad that they had her there by herself... She was excellent and courteous. And the food was good as well. I'm appreciative of her.“

“If you don’t eat the prime rib on Tuesday and Thursday, you have yet to find your inner peace.... After every sandwich, my life feels complete. For at least an hour and a 1/2.“

“The service and atmosphere was great. I’ve been here a few times but last night was different. I felt bad for arriving so late but the one female Chelsie insured me it was fine. Very sweet and polite staff very friendly and the place is always clean. This is the best JM around and I come all the way from McKnight.“

“Amazing subs and love the chips!!!! George is awesome!!!!!!!“

“Food is always good, I just wish they'd fix their menu so it would allow me to order fountain drinks on the app. Also, seems like the AC hasn't worked in months, or maybe it's just on the weekends when I always go. Last 3 or 4 times there has been no air and it was so warm I was dripping sweat the whole time I was in there (was in the 90s outside that day). Today it was so warm my cookie was floppy.“

“This is the best subway I have ever been to! Everything is so fresh and extremely clean. The owners are always so nice and welcoming. I have come twice with my 2.5 year and 8 month old and they are always so sweet to the kids and the woman has given my older one a free cookie twice which she really appreciates. I saw other customers come in and the owner remembered everyone’s order if they had been in before which I find super impressive. I highly recommend coming to this subway! I’ll be back!“

“Extremely quick and efficient pickup from online ordering. Delicious food and nothing wrong with my order.

Vegetarian options: Vast amount of options for vegetarian

Dietary restrictions: Vast amount of options

Parking: Only 2 stores for a lot of parking.

Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs from parking lot to store front“