Restaurants in New Castle

“First time eating here and it was fabulous!! The food was delicious & the best that we have had, we will most definitely be eating here again. The portions were generous & the prices were very reasonable. The staff was very nice & attentive. Highly recommend!”

“The Sherma sandwich and chicken salad were delicious! Everything is fresh, taste good, and looks good. Brian our waiter was so friendly and kind. This restaurant is a diamond in the rough. I loved that almost ever person that came in was happy to be ordering food from them. We will definitely come back. God bless this cafe!”

“This is a great place and the service is amazing! The owner and all of her staff are wonderful, they are so friendly and take very good care of you! We have been here quite a few times now and have also made reservations for birthdays a couple of times, have never been disappointed with the service or the great food! Highly recommend! ❤️”

“2Fg&aO has been a weekly work staple. Offering a great variety of options and the best sweet treats in town. Highly recommend!!”

“Wonderful wine, food and atmosphere!”

“Where do I start... I have to eat Gluten-free and I am able to have about 80% of what is on their menu! I have NEVER had a bad meal there. I have suggests had very good service. Their pricing is very reasonable. Thank you to Edward's Restaurant and to all of the staff, from the kitchen to the bar!”

“The best Chinese cuisine in town! High quality and consistent in taste. Great price and large serving. I look forward to visiting this place once a week. The spring rolls are awesome! They put a lot of love into their food. Amazing food and amazing people. Eat local and support our restaurants,”

“One of the best pizzas I have ever eaten! Love the buffalo chicken and Cane Lady pizza! Never disappointed!”

“We love this place and it never disappoints.....the Florentine Pizza is absolutely amazing! The staff is very friendly and Stacie is an awesome waitress!”

“The Sweet Potato Chili is the absolute best! I've doubled the recipe seven (7) times now and my friends and I have enjoyed it monthly since December. Instead of the water, I use unsalted chicken stock and I've even added several other ingredients to the recipe such as a can of Rotel, a can of whole corn, a can of kidney beans, and a can of garbanzo beans. When serving, cheddar cheese and a dollop of sour cream on top are both an absolute must. I highly recommend if you like chili.”

“Tried the açaí bowl here and really liked it. Fresh food and friendly staff”

“Great food and friendly staff. Our family go to for hot dogs and sandwiches.”

“Mary’s is my personal favorite among the top three restaurants in New Castle which specialize in Mideastern cuisine. I have always been very pleased with the quality of food, service, and atmosphere, as well as the reasonable pricing….whether dining in or ordering take-out meals.”

“food is homemade and delicious”

“Have not tried Elham’s recently, but had friends say it was improved. Decided to give them a try. We were pleasantly impressed with our meals. The meats were tender and juicy. The rice was excellent!
Everything tasted fresh. Definitely better this meal than other similar restaurants in town. Will be our first choice next time around.”

“Took my family here on a recent visit . Was totally surprised by the exceptionally good food at this restaurant. Have traveled and dined in many many major cities and countries. The food preparation, the menu, the service and the ambiance at Le Resto could compete with the best of them. I suggest you give it a try -- you'll be very pleased. It's a shame that the residents of the town don't eat out on weeknights though. It was empty except for our table. All that delicious and interesting food needs hungry customers ! It would be a shame to possibly lose such a first-rate restaurant. Le Resto also provides something new and different from all the excellent Italian-based eating establishments the city is best known for.”

“i love PITA! my parents usually pick this up for me to take to work… and i can tell you that i wait all morning until i get to eat this 🤣❤ the chicken is delicious… my go-to meal is the Roman!! the toppings on this one are delicious!!!!!!!! 🤤 definitely a great place to stop to eat for lunch… it’s literally right in town for me so it’s super convenient!! 10/10”

“Our server was wonderful! The food was very good, I recommend the fish tacos and the sirloin wrap. No beer this time. Overall very enjoyable. Usually enjoy our visits here.”

“Delicious every time and quick delivery for our hungry employees!”

“had ali's for the first time today. not only was it the best pizza ive had in a long time, if not ever. but it was a delight to talk to ali. truly a great place!”

“Best pizza in New Castle!!”

“I never knew about this place im from nyc and this is by far my favorite local place in newcastle! Great value amazing taste and customer service. I can't wait to go back!”

“I work for a adult special needs company. And we took clients out for lunch today. And our server Roberta was very accommodating and polite. Sometimes we don’t get treated in that way. The food was good and prices reasonable. Thanks for the great service”

“very friendly staff and great food.”

“Cedars needs to step up a little. Waiting more than hour for food is ridiculous. Cooks are outside smoking while the dining room is full. I usually go Friday and Saturday. I watch people walk out waitress are frustrated. There is a girl that is there every Friday and Saturday trying to make everything run smoothly. She goes from the bar to the dining room to the kitchen trying to please the customers. The last two month have been crazy here. I don't know if I will be back. Sir, you are losing your in-house customers over the new system. That system won't make up for your lost customers. it's a shame you have a great business Mr. Pagley and you are destroying it.”

“Ashley was such a great and attentive waitress. she went above and beyond to make sure that all of our needs were met and that we had a wonderful visit 😊”

“I have no idea how good of a banquet hall it is, only can assume it is. But warning to anyone else: it is no longer a coffee shop. Their website and signs must still need to be updated.”

“I was just passing through town and honestly didn’t expect to find a spot like this. Seeing a big Southern Italian last name on the sign immediately caught my attention, so I had to stop in, and I’m glad I did.
This is a genuinely authentic Italian-American place with that warm feel that makes you feel at home the moment you walk in. I ordered a capocollo-ham sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing. Fresh ingredients, well made, and very satisfying. I also tried the garlic knots, something I always judge Italian places by, and they were very good. Fresh, soft, and flavorful. If I had one tiny suggestion, I’d say a little extra garlic wouldn’t hurt, but that’s just personal preference.
The spinach stromboli was excellent. Fresh, clearly house made dough, and exactly what you hope for. I finished with cannoli, and they were absolutely on point. Small, authentic, and delicious.
I also loved that they had all the little extras that make a place feel real. Cookies, jars of pickled garlic and peppers. specialty items, packaged pasta to take home. The whole atmosphere just felt welcoming and genuine.
A really pleasant surprise in a town where I wasn’t expecting much. Definitely worth stopping if you appreciate authentic Italian-American food.

One fun suggestion: add a Nutella stromboli to the menu. If you do, naming it “The Stefano” would only be fair. 😄”

“Ammmmmazing place to enjoy a nice quiet evening with some of the best in town!! Come try it out you will not be disappointed.”

“we love out pizza joes, best pizza in grove city, good menu selection and have had their pizza for decades and it never disappoints.”

“good food and good service nice atmosphere”

“One of the best places to eat in New Castle!! We LOVE the Friday fish, but the burgers are amazing, too!! Nice that there is a side room if you have a larger group or prefer a bit more quiet.”

“Just wanted to give a special shout out to Mama Jane's Eatery in Greenville. My mom and I brought my son there today for his 4th birthday. Our wonderful waitress gave him a stuffed squirrel (now known as “Tom”) and the whole staff took the time to come out with a cookie and sing to him. This was very unexpected and special for our little guy, and for us. Thanks for an outing we won’t soon forget!”

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!”

“I love Fox's, have been ordering since the 1970s in the original shop. Best pizza anywhere!”

“The best salads in town! I get the Sicilian Caesar salad about once a week. 👍👍”

“I've been wanting to try New Castle Nutrition for a while and they DID NOT DISAPPOINT! Clean cafe setting, friendly staff, super delicious energy drinks and shakes! We will be back!”

“Great place and staff. It is a must visit.”

“Food was very good and service was excellent.”

“love it, good food good atmosphere, my go to place. happy birthday congrats. 🥰”

“I went here for dinner and was immediately greeted by the owner himself. He welcomed us with open arms and recommended his favorite dishes. It has a warm atmosphere and the food is great. I enjoy going here for a meal on any occasion.”

“Good vibes w a great environment. Older, younger generational combination of good looking, happy people. Food was decent, prices reasonable, pool tables are really nice and fast, pool sticks provided aren't all beat up or bent to hell and back. Darts board is a blast. TV's all round for sports. Drinks are reasonable as well. Not the best at mixed drinks but that doesn't apply to me as I dont rly drink alot except a few beers. All and all I wld recommend and I myself will most def go back.”

“Nice place great food. Good service”

“Service was amazing!!!! I really enjoyed the pierogi pizza”

“nice place awsome staff will return again”

“My family loves to come here. I've been a patron since they came into the old Wendy's further down the road, and continued to come as I started and grew a family. Antonio is the best and we will be forever customers at this family restaurant.”

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!”

“Best wings in town. And some good pool players.”

“favorite place for wings !”

“Great food and friendly staff. Our family go to for hot dogs and sandwiches.”

“I am a hot dog connoisseur. These Chili dogs are A+ Just the right about of kick to the Chili! 5 stars!! I’ll be back!!”

“Great place highly recommended💯🙏🏼”

“Just left these girls were awesome today so very friendly helpful and patient the display case was so clean everything looked so fresh. I visit subway often I wish they all had this staff and atmosphere Great Job”

“I wouldn't go out of my way for this dive but it's in my city that i love and everyone who is there taking a break from the world for a coldie.Guarauntee you will feel welcome.”

“Delicious and good Specials!”

“Had a very bad experience at this store thinking about posting experience on Facebook, My daughter and I visited the location above on the date and time shown on receipt above. I specially asked the cashier names Alex that I wanted my order made fresh I didn’t care how long it would take I just wanted all my food cooked hot and fresh. 1 minute after I placed my order they are calling my name. I spoke to the manager Betty and explained there is no way that this could be my order I wanted my food made fresh, she tries to tell me that it was made fresh which was insulting because I am very intelligent not to mention I used to manage Wendy’s in Cleveland Ohio before so I know it takes 10-12 minutes to cook something fresh. So after the replaced the order I asked the manager Betty if I could have a word with her when I finished my meal, upon completion I went to talk to the manager Betty to explain that only the chicken sandwich was hot and the burger wasn’t satisfactory my intention was to request half my money back being I wasn’t satisfied. It was at that point I was asked to leave and I was still eating a frosty and my daughter was still eating at this point because it wasn’t resolved at the store level I do not ever plan to visit Wendy’s again and now requesting a full refund. I do not want and gift certificate or any thing like that , you can keep your apologies because the manager Betty should have been the one to provide it. Please send a check for the full balance of my order to.”

“we love out pizza joes, best pizza in grove city, good menu selection and have had their pizza for decades and it never disappoints.”

“The two employees had just received a large online order and were understandably a little overwhelmed. They worked quickly and efficiently to make sure we got our subs- which were great! Awesome demonstration of time management and customer service.”

“Everyone is just as sweet as can be! I feel right at home ! Live entertainment sometimes and a rockin jukebox when there isn't! Two thumbs up!!!”

“Great place come from out of town to see bartender Johna sweetest person in the world great bartender. And customers , regulars make you feel at home.”

“This is the only Subway I’ll order from. Always fresh meat and produce. Spotless dining room. The workers are top notch, helpful and friendly… every single time!”

“I'd most recommend the subs, especially the tuna, nice that it comes with a drink included in a really good price, daily specials!”

“when will you start delivering your menu to folks belly?”

“I went to this Wendy’s today. The employees were nice and the food was excellent, the only thing is my sprite was a little flat. I don’t mind though ha ha it was still good.😆
My kid got a kids meal and they let my kid switch the toy which was very peachy 🍑. My oldest got a junior baconator meal but said her fries were too salty, but you know, teenagers, they complain about everything LOL. The costumer servers was excellent!”

“We recently had breakfast at the New Castle site. Even though the waitress was the only server there she was pleasant and friendly. Thank you Denise for making our experience a good one. You deserve a raise.”

“The best Chinese cuisine in town! High quality and consistent in taste. Great price and large serving. I look forward to visiting this place once a week. The spring rolls are awesome! They put a lot of love into their food. Amazing food and amazing people. Eat local and support our restaurants,”

“Mary’s is my personal favorite among the top three restaurants in New Castle which specialize in Mideastern cuisine. I have always been very pleased with the quality of food, service, and atmosphere, as well as the reasonable pricing….whether dining in or ordering take-out meals.”

“Farone Brothers Catering did my son's wedding this past weekend. Fred and Anthony made sure everything was absolutely perfect! The guests just raved about all the wonderful food - and the catering staff and bartenders went above and beyond to make sure it was a perfect day! I thank them all so much for everything. If you want a beautiful wedding give Faraone Brothers Catering a call for a five-star event!!”

“I came here for my Granddaughtes birthday. My husband was a chef for a hotel in Pittsburgh so I eat good food. Well I loved the food here. The servers were great too. I recommend this place to everyone. Thank you I will be back.”

“Service was amazing!!!! I really enjoyed the pierogi pizza”

“Cedars needs to step up a little. Waiting more than hour for food is ridiculous. Cooks are outside smoking while the dining room is full. I usually go Friday and Saturday. I watch people walk out waitress are frustrated. There is a girl that is there every Friday and Saturday trying to make everything run smoothly. She goes from the bar to the dining room to the kitchen trying to please the customers. The last two month have been crazy here. I don't know if I will be back. Sir, you are losing your in-house customers over the new system. That system won't make up for your lost customers. it's a shame you have a great business Mr. Pagley and you are destroying it.”

“Food was very good and service was excellent.”

“Great place come from out of town to see bartender Johna sweetest person in the world great bartender. And customers , regulars make you feel at home.”

“First time eating here and it was fabulous!! The food was delicious & the best that we have had, we will most definitely be eating here again. The portions were generous & the prices were very reasonable. The staff was very nice & attentive. Highly recommend!”

“I live in an assisted living facility in the Cleveland Ohio area and one of our residents has a daughter living in New Castle. Recently she drove up to visit her father and brought a dozen of MAY'S DONUTS. They were OUTSTANDING - especially the glazed ones. If I had a car and a valid driver's license, I would be a regular customer! Larry”

“We love this place and it never disappoints.....the Florentine Pizza is absolutely amazing! The staff is very friendly and Stacie is an awesome waitress!”

“Was there for the first time tonight with my family the food was really good waitress was polite and quick decent prices and portions we will be back again”

“The Sherma sandwich and chicken salad were delicious! Everything is fresh, taste good, and looks good. Brian our waiter was so friendly and kind. This restaurant is a diamond in the rough. I loved that almost ever person that came in was happy to be ordering food from them. We will definitely come back. God bless this cafe!”

“Took my family here on a recent visit . Was totally surprised by the exceptionally good food at this restaurant. Have traveled and dined in many many major cities and countries. The food preparation, the menu, the service and the ambiance at Le Resto could compete with the best of them. I suggest you give it a try -- you'll be very pleased. It's a shame that the residents of the town don't eat out on weeknights though. It was empty except for our table. All that delicious and interesting food needs hungry customers ! It would be a shame to possibly lose such a first-rate restaurant. Le Resto also provides something new and different from all the excellent Italian-based eating establishments the city is best known for.”

“Amazing experience all around! The food was delicious, the atmosphere was inviting, and the service was top-notch. Staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel so welcome. Easy 5 stars—I’ll definitely be back!”

“We always have a great meal & dessert at Soni’s! Love their red sauce - my favorite dinner is the Italian Platter! We had Brian as our server tonight- he is fantastic- he always has a great demeanor!!!”

“One of the best places to eat in New Castle!! We LOVE the Friday fish, but the burgers are amazing, too!! Nice that there is a side room if you have a larger group or prefer a bit more quiet.”

“I got the blackened chicken ceaser salad and it was excellent! My son got a kids cheeseburger and it was exactly how he ordered it. We got it Togo and it was excellent! Also, the server taking the order was very friendly and helpful.”

“The food is great and the atmosphere is excellent. Keisha is the best bartender/server that I have ever experienced. She not only gets orders right by but she remembers you. Amazing!”

“I love this Popeyes location. I used to hate Popeyes and would literally never go there. I recently moved over here and had some food from this location and it totally changed my opinion on Popeyes. Food is always fresh and cooked to my liking and done in a timely manner. Recently had an issue with my order and they fixed it no questions asked. The service at this location beats any fast food in the area. Do yourself a favor and stop by. You’ll love that chicken from Popeyes”

“I went here for dinner and was immediately greeted by the owner himself. He welcomed us with open arms and recommended his favorite dishes. It has a warm atmosphere and the food is great. I enjoy going here for a meal on any occasion.”

“love it, good food good atmosphere, my go to place. happy birthday congrats. 🥰”

“Mr. Pizza will not convice you to end it all because you've had the best pizza ever. It's real pizza, in the middle of a residential neighborhood, and is about the best you can hope for. Ive never had an exceptional customer experience there. They act just how you would expect them to act. Support mr. Pizza, and friendly competitors.”

“Just wanted to give a special shout out to Mama Jane's Eatery in Greenville. My mom and I brought my son there today for his 4th birthday. Our wonderful waitress gave him a stuffed squirrel (now known as “Tom”) and the whole staff took the time to come out with a cookie and sing to him. This was very unexpected and special for our little guy, and for us. Thanks for an outing we won’t soon forget!”

“I am a hot dog connoisseur. These Chili dogs are A+ Just the right about of kick to the Chili! 5 stars!! I’ll be back!!”

“We recently had breakfast at the New Castle site. Even though the waitress was the only server there she was pleasant and friendly. Thank you Denise for making our experience a good one. You deserve a raise.”

“2Fg&aO has been a weekly work staple. Offering a great variety of options and the best sweet treats in town. Highly recommend!!”

“Mark was a great server… food was amazing! Great dinner with mom on a Friday!!”

“Wow, usually Taco Bell employees put way less effort into my burrito. A+ for not putting the sour cream in only one spot that I suddenly encounter after digging through the desert of dry rice.”

“There is always a linr, but it moves quickly. All of their ice cream is made right in the ice cream shop. They offer many flavors that are hand dipped, but it's a soft ice cream. They offer cones, waffle cones, dishes, shakes, sundaes, and they will make your sundae with any ice cream you want. We got two sundaes and two waffle cones with two scoops each for under $20. The price is right, the ice cream is amazing, so just go!”

“love Sophies ice cream caked. we tried new tangerine the other dsy it was SO GOOD.Love all your flavord. you are the BEST.”

“I am a hot dog connoisseur. These Chili dogs are A+ Just the right about of kick to the Chili! 5 stars!! I’ll be back!!”

“1st time here. Ordered the #13 The Original Italian Mike's Way. EXCELLENT. The 3 employees on today's shift 05/27/26 1:09 pm did a fantastic job of making everything fresh & delicious and as quickly as possible because it was a busy afternoon! The choices of sandwiches to choose from are a nice selection, looking forward to going back. This Jersey Mike's Sub shop is CLEAN. When departing, the employee who sliced the meat for our subs Thanked us for eating in & told us our business was appreciated. Class Act employees. KUDOS Jersey Mike's Subs 8104”

“If Camron isn't the the manager at this location, he should be. Great customer service with him! Honestly he should get a promotion to a district or regional manager! I will be contacting the corporate office to recommend him. .”