21 Best American Restaurants near Shepherdstown

“Just had a lovely brunch/lunch at Bistro 112. The food was excellent and the staff was wonderful. This restaurant hits all the marks!! Great dining experience!“

“Undoubtedly one of the most delicious experiences we’ve ever enjoyed. Atmosphere, service, and quality is presented in a perfect way. Worth the trip, no matter how far your journey.“

“Such a wonderful place! Delicious food, inspired chef, creative ideas in different events...I would love to go there daily...“

“One of my favorites! The food is fantastic and carefully prepared. If the weather is fine, definitely get a table outside. The trickling of the water and the shade of the trees is so charming and will bring an already great meal to perfection. The people who work here are wonderful and make everyone feel welcome. Simply, this place is a real gem.“

“Fantastic, scrumptious food! Def go here when in Shepherdstown.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Rumsey Tavern for the first time, and it was an amazing experience! The food was absolutely delicious! I got the Smash Burger and the Brussel sprouts, Let me tell you, they were bursting with flavor. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a memorable meal. Christine, our server was friendly and attentive, ensuring we had everything we needed. I can't wait to go back and try more of their amazing menu. Highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience! This place is a hiding Gem!!!!“

“My husband and I can put for lunch today and the waitress was on point we came the night before for dinner and had a great waitress Even the manager was great he came over to us last night and the same manager was there today and said hi and made us feel like we were important the food was very good and the portions were just enough Thank you to a great lunch and dinner“

“Beautiful quaint and cozy place with an AMAZING view of the town!! The food was awesome too!! Will definitely be eating here again next time we're in town. 😌“

“Haven’t been in a while, years to be quite honest. The food was good! The restaurant was clean! The booth seat was not comfortable and unfortunately needs redone. The service was ok. I’m not sure if it’s just me or if their waitresses are unhappy. This is what kept me from coming back for years. Then at the end we asked for “to go” containers for our left over soup that we just couldn’t eat all of. The waitress said “we usually charge for those containers but I won’t charge you all today”. I was shocked. Who charges for to go containers for your leftovers (that you pay for)? This is weird. And I’m hoping that the owner sees this review and makes changes. If you want the consumer to pay for “to go” containers then add that into the cost of your food and keep it hush hush. We don’t want to know every little fee nor should we have to pay for a “to go” container. That is absurd. Again, food was good. Even the lady at the register seemed irritable. I get it. Some days I don’t want to work either. I hope they have better days. We will come back because it is a pretty drive and good food! Please don’t charge for to go containers.“

“Great breakfast, coffee and service. Would definitely go again.“

“If you aren’t going to Kitzie’s— what are you doing!! This place is a local gem. The food is fast and fresh, the staff is so very nice, and they even do takeout. We love this local spot and all it has to offer. Be sure to check facebook for their specials :)“

“Great food, atmosphere, and drinks.“

“Great food and great live music on the weekends! Service by Kaileyne is always exceptional! Best server ever!“

“Excellent! Food and staff are fantastic. Comfortable and relaxing dining.“

“I recently had a fantastic meal at this restaurant – the ribs were delicious and beautifully presented with sides. The service was also excellent and the ambiance was cozy and inviting. I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a great BBQ.“

“I was looking for a different place to eat today and came across Sycamore here on Google. It's a nice place with nice views of the golf course from the outside seating area. The waitress was excellent, friendly and very responsive. I had the steak n shrimp and my fiancé had the pork belly with rice. Everything looked very presentable and colorful. Although the steak was nicely cooked to medium, was tender and juicy but just lacked flavor. I love steak and have eaten many places. This steak wasn't bad it just wasn't worth the price tag. The asparagus were a little on the dry side and also not much flavor. The potatoes were really good. My fiancé's plate - the pork belly had no crunchy skin on it even though on the menu it said crunchy pork belly, also was bland in flavor. My fiancé didn't like the rice much. I haven't tried anything else on the menu so I'm just judging by what we ate. I think for almost dropping a Benjamin with no alcohol by either of us I expected more. All in all it was a nice experience...they do have other less expensive items on the menu which we might give those a try on the next venture out there.“

“Just stopped in for lunch with my boys. The chicken cheese steak was on point. my youngest is picky with his Mac n cheese him and his brother devoured it. Great local spot for food.“

“typically good but tonight not so much. very disappointed with the Can tactic nachos. In theory it sounds good..but so dry. Felt like I paid $16 for a bag of nachos.“

“Food court with several options, burgers & fries, pizza, Chinese, baked goods, etc. Most everything is cooked to order, so there will be a little wait time after you order. They also have a full bar in the center. Average prices. Friendly employees.“

“Great atmosphere and the food is simply fantastic! The White Mushroom and grilled chicken ziti is easily worth the price. plus, the servers are very knowledgeable and helpful. 10/10“

“Wings on Thursdays are the BEST!“