4.3
Superb
118 Reviews
1791 Central Park Avenue, Yonkers
“If I could give an extra half a star I would definitely give this place a 4.5! I love the idea of a locally owned fish market in the area, however this review is more for the cooked menu and food options. This market use to close its kitchen closer to 5/5:30pm a few years ago, but recently it changed to “Kitchen closes 30 minutes before store closes” and that makes getting a meal from there much more accessible! I have no idea if this is a permanent change but I really hope it is. The fried food is actually really well seasoned and cooked. The fish didn’t taste dry at all and I honestly didn’t even need the tartar sauce. The french fries were pretty good too. Their “Lunch Combo” was still available at 5pm and my meal came to just over $13. I’m no expert on the fish market, but getting 2 big fillets of Whiting already cooked with fries under $15 feels really good. The staff was very nice and friendly. Despite what other reviews would lead you to believe, it was very pleasant to talk to them and they were very patient with me as I made my decision of what to order. The reason for the half star off is the atmosphere. My issue is there’s just “stuff” everywhere. The food displays are fine, but underneath them are just boxes of containers and equipment. I don’t know about you, but I feel a little uneasy seeing the containers I’m going to be eating out of being stored on the floor. Granted they’re still sealed in the box, but the view is a bit unpleasant to me. They also use wooden pallets on the floors behind the counters. I can understand if they need a new platform for the staff to reach over counters, but I would assume untreated wood inside a moist fish market would attract mold somewhere. Now again I’m no expert and maybe this isn’t a real issue, but those are my thoughts as I wait for my food to be done.”