24 Best Sandwich Shops near Thiensville

“Never seen the place get so packed and emptied out so quickly! The quality of the food has gone up and the hospitality is great since NEW MANAGEMENT!“

“amazing food, but we ordered croissants sandwiches and the staff all acted like it was a burden and they hated it when they had to make croissants. it made me feel like I had to ask if I can order what I want and if that was going to be okay with them. it was very rude behavior.“

“If I could give this location more stars I would! The staff is super friendly and knowledgeable! I always get a custom sub, and they have made some great recommendations on new combos to try! The food quality is always great, I have never had any soggy lettuce! This location is my favorite spot to stop and get some lunch!“

“The subs are always hot, fresh, and packed with flavor. I generous they are with the ingredients—every bite is satisfying. The staff is friendly and quick, and the restaurant is clean. My go-to is the Hook & Ladder, but honestly, everything I've tried has been amazing. Definitely one of my favorite sub spots. Highly recommend!“

“Excellent service. Has catered a number of events for us. Food is always great and service is always impeccable. Highly recommended.“

“Love this place, staff are class.“

“We stopped here at lunchtime so it was quite busy, and the staff was very efficient and helpful so we didn't have a long wait. The meats were sliced to order, wheat bread was available, and everything tasted fresh. We will definitely return here in the future.“

“The best subs anywhere. Delicious!“

“I've stopped at many of their locations, all for takeout. Their quality is reliable.
Hot/cold subs, soda, shakes, fries, chips, subs in a bowl, etc.
Their Club is my goto.
They do have a ordering app and points program.
They do have inside seating.
Parking has never been a problem.“

“YOOOO! S/O to the staff in here. I work at the T-Mobile next door and we have some Muslim staff who enjoys subs from time to time. My boy Sully came to grab his sub and asked for a glove change. They went ABOVE AND BEYOND and cleaned the slicer for him. When he came back to work, he was almost in tears telling me how nice they were to him. 🥹 THANK YOU!!! This is what America SHOULD LOOK like. Thank Ariana for being AMAZING! We love you next door girl!“

“Delicious!!! I’ll likely be a regular! Food is so good! FRESH! Restaurant is CLEAN!!!!! I love that I donated $3 to Special Olympics Wisconsin and received a FREE regular sub! I’m so excited they’ve come to Mequon!“

“I just love their bread and seasonings on the sub. Good service too!“

“This is the best Subway I’ve ever been to. Always consistently good and they always get our call ahead orders right. On top of that, they have excellent customer service! My 8 year old son left his iPod at the store and the owner remembered that he was headed to a baseball game at 5 Corners and he walked over and hand delivered the phone to us! Thank you Subway!“

“Greatest Cousins around. Staff is spectacular. Food is always great and made with care.“

“1/29/24. Omg had the best delicious chicken today, seasoned just right crispy golden brown chicken. Taste just like my mom @grandmother chicken. We ordered the 14 piece chicken it was hot when delivered. Who ever cooked that chicken, i hope when I order again you cook it..“

“Went beyond rules hidden by chips stand to help me pay during freezing pm & my help crew starving. Orders were filled w/extreme attn. to have return biz & we alllll did return! Coupons honored & staff is beyond polite & helpful. Great smiles & they handled rushes & adverse distractive events empathetically, accurately & ever so kindly! I stop every time we can traveling 40 mins back & forth for Caregiver duties! Well worth your $$$!!!“

“The Brisket is delish! Service was fast and friendly!“

“Food was fresh. UPDATE!!!!! 5/3/26 ordered a hot ham and cheese on Parmesan Aisgo bread. As you can see from the picture that is not the bread that I ordered and that’s the second sub. The first one was cold and I asked for A hot Sub. When I brought the sub back, nobody apologized nothing. These subs are not five and six dollars a half inch Sub is running every bit of 10. Not cool“

“Kid-friendliness: We always like to interact with the kids. I want to thank all of you for your reviews, for some reason I can’t log into the google business account to reply to your comments. We love this community and my wife are in the store everyday and we love seeing your faces daily. We appreciate your support so much. God bless everyone one of you!!!!“

“My family and I mobile order from this Subway all the time. Has to be the best Subway I have ever been to (and I’ve been to a lot across the country while traveling.)They make the sandwiches so well, nothing ever falls apart. The bread is always fresh and so are the toppings.The staff is always super polite and helpful.“

“Ordered from this location for corporate lunches the last couple weeks. Love that box lunches are an option, especially during the pandemic. Our orders have been absolutely perfect and the service even better. Way to go Bayshore! 👏🏽“

“Wonderful food and the service was prompt, professional, and friendly!“

“Excellent sandwiches and the lady behind the counter was amazing.“

“I like this place except for 1 thing. They don't prioritize online orders. The app says 20 minutes until your order is ready but they don't start your order until you get there and then you have to wait for all the people who might be in front of you. Kinda frustrating but the food is always good.“