46 Best Sandwich Shops near Whitefish Bay

“always good food and service. would highly recommend“

“Packed as hell so give them credit for that. But was the thinnest sub ive ever gotten from there. Usually sub is packed full. Got the ak47 and had like a slice of beef snd cheese. Missing the shrooms and onions. Looked like they were swamped at 1am and not enough staff. All tables were dirty and gross. So hopefully managment brings on more staff when local events are happening. Not sure what event but had to be something.“

“Unbelievable sandwiches, can’t wait to go back! Was in town from Chicago and dropped by before heading home, best decision ever! Even got a sammich to go!“

“Went for the first time today for a doggo lunch date with muh fur baby. Wonderful staff and quick service. I noticed negative reviews complaining there was dogs, well no crap it’s the business model and there’s an actual picture of a dog on the door and logo. ANYWAYS price is a little steep but when I got my food holy cow it was delicious. And I love that they have dog friendly menu items available as well. The place is super clean for the amount of guests and animals that come through. Loved that the food pickup and service area is separate from dining. The only downfall was I did pay for pickles and there wasn’t any but I didn’t even notice it until I devoured the first half of my food. No big deal. I ordered the steak sandwich and strawberry limeade which I also love is made by hand with fresh fruit. My dog is now sleeping in a food coma as am I.“

“Take out deli that makes their sandwiches fresh to order. Known for their corned beef and pastrami but there are many more offerings worth your visit. The prep of your order takes time, be patient. You can wait in your car as they call your order over a speaker outside the restaurant. Delicious sandwich hack: order your sandwich on toasted Texas toast, thank me later. The sandwiches are great, the portions mirror the times, but it is a lunch sandwich you will find memorable. I highly recommend, I would visit again and again. Mark this on your must go.“

“I and My Crew have been to quite a few different Subway Sandwich Shops. The Mequon Store is BY FAR THE BEST. Rupal and Her Father are sooo welcoming. They run the Cleanest of any Food Purveyor I have ever seen. And I will tell you...... These Good People Know How to Make a Sandwich. Perfectly Proportioned, Generously Garnished and Fresh, Fresh, Fresh. When We Need it to be really good, really fast and really Good? Every Time.? Subway MEQUON“

“Silvia is the best great personality answered all questions for me made a great sandwich so helpful great ideas for the subs we eat we will absolutely be coming back shes the best 👌 she needs a raise lol thank you so much the best person to help you and make your sub fresh bread fresh veggies great attitude thank you again“

“Love the Chicken, Rice, and Gravy.🥰“

“We can also count on Charleys for Over The Top Great Food, including Milwaukee's Best Sundae. Better than Leon's! We can count on David for great service. He replaced Angelina, another Service Superstar. We are longtime Senior Citizen Customers whom love the High Quality Great Tasting Food for Less which Charleys Always Offers. This is why we keep coming back, driving a few miles to get there. Go Brewers!“

“The traffic is so noisy you can hardly converse when sitting outdoors. Also, we had to move indoors cause of so many bees. These things are NOT the restaurant’s fault. *It is a nice ,clean,place, with good food & friendly staff. I highly recommend it! As tempting as their large patio is, think about eating indoors instead.“

“I've stopped at many of their locations, all for takeout. Their quality is reliable.
Hot/cold subs, soda, shakes, fries, chips, subs in a bowl, etc.
Their Club is my goto.
They do have a ordering app and points program.
They do have inside seating.
Parking has never been a problem.“

“First try was in AZ. Then Nv.i visit both areas often and always still have to get a bite. Fresh every single time. I was so stoked to find yall in WI. 420 vibes and full bar at a sub shop is a dream. Never disappointed. Ever! I have tried every single sub on the menu. Added extras. Pay for the quality. Happy every time. Super satisfied with the seasonal ipa on tap! Yes
On Tap!“

“I had the pleasure of being served by RJ. When I say that this young man totally understands what it takes to be great in customer service, it would be an understatement! Not only did he make my sub fast, he had the conversation of a seasoned veteran. Salute to him and the establishment for hiring him!“

“it's good foods and great service“

“Delicious!!! I’ll likely be a regular! Food is so good! FRESH! Restaurant is CLEAN!!!!! I love that I donated $3 to Special Olympics Wisconsin and received a FREE regular sub! I’m so excited they’ve come to Mequon!“

“That crew knows exactly what they’re doing. They’re always working quickly and efficiently. Their customer service is top tier. It’s always a treat to stop in and get a delicious #7 sub mikes way with no onion tomato and with pickles. They always know how to put a smile on my face and I walk out feeling a part of the crew. That’s a family.“

“Exceptional place! Super clean and kind staff! The food was fresh and I will definitely be a returning customer at this specific location. Great job! And attention to details! The windows were so clean it looked like there wasn't even a window there! Good job everyone! :)“

“The staff at the store on 92nd & Lincoln are great. They make great sandwiches for me and cheese curds just the way I like them. If I get a shake, they give me an extra pump of chocolate 😁 They ROCK!“

“1/29/24. Omg had the best delicious chicken today, seasoned just right crispy golden brown chicken. Taste just like my mom @grandmother chicken. We ordered the 14 piece chicken it was hot when delivered. Who ever cooked that chicken, i hope when I order again you cook it..“

“Never seen the place get so packed and emptied out so quickly! The quality of the food has gone up and the hospitality is great since NEW MANAGEMENT!“

“I can’t imagine a better partner for this event. A-plus 600 East Cafe. If there were a Nobel prize given for awesome events your team would be on a plane to Stockholm tonight!“

“Fist off, my girl is awesome. Everytime I go she’s always friendly and welcoming. I’m very particular about how my sub made and she didn’t make me feel like she was annoyed to service me. She remembers my order but still asks me if I want it that way each time. Her and her husband are friendly and the atmosphere is amazing. I don’t become a repeat customer to anywhere I’m not welcome. THIS IS NOT THE PLACE. 10/10 recommend. GO SHOP THERE . 💕“

“Awesome Cousins! Super clean, great staff, and the owner ROCKS!!! LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!“

“Best corned beef in Wisconsin. Don't come more than once a week, however, as your blood will feel thicker even after one sandwich. Absolutely recommend, my dad introdu ed me to this place and it is the best Reuben you'll get for a long ways.“

“Food was fresh. UPDATE!!!!! 5/3/26 ordered a hot ham and cheese on Parmesan Aisgo bread. As you can see from the picture that is not the bread that I ordered and that’s the second sub. The first one was cold and I asked for A hot Sub. When I brought the sub back, nobody apologized nothing. These subs are not five and six dollars a half inch Sub is running every bit of 10. Not cool“

“The Brisket is delish! Service was fast and friendly!“

“I'm not from Milwaukee but everytime I come to Milwaukee that's all I eat is cousin subs“

“I arranged a catering order with the owner and/or manager for 21 people. They were so helpful and accommodating to my needs, making sure I had their phone numbers for easy communication. They took the time to write individual names on each box and make sure each one had their choice of chips and cookies. Food was great and what we asked for. They were also able to drop off the order, which was so helpful.“

“The food and service is amazing even with only 2 people most of the time with great pizza, footlongs, and sandwiches. The atmosphere is very dull and bad with no music or noise since most people don’t eat inside. They also accept every app that I can think of that delivers.

Vegetarian options: Subway is very vegetarian friendly but I’m not vegetarian but I worry about cross contamination since employees don’t change gloves and keep meat and vegetables next to each other.

Dietary restrictions: You don’t have to worry about dietary restrictions since you make your own sandwich but if you have a deadly allergy I don’t recommend since cross contamination.

Parking: Very easy to find a parking lot but might have to walk a bit.

Kid-friendliness: As long as you keep your kid under control it should be fine and is very kid friendly as the workers are very understanding.“

“Ordered from this location for corporate lunches the last couple weeks. Love that box lunches are an option, especially during the pandemic. Our orders have been absolutely perfect and the service even better. Way to go Bayshore! 👏🏽“

“very great subs always fresh“

“The young lady that used to be pregnant was so sweet for my first visit!! She helped me build my sandwich and explained to me every part of the process! I was nervous walking in because I am autistic but she helped me get a footlong and I was able to walk away happy and full :) will definitely be returning to this location“

“I'm proud of them for keeping this store open.
I lived in the area over 10 years ago..Everytime I'm in town I go here. Never disappoints. They add on new items which is neat. Just watch out for random ppl walking around say no for change most will keep it moving“

“I like this place except for 1 thing. They don't prioritize online orders. The app says 20 minutes until your order is ready but they don't start your order until you get there and then you have to wait for all the people who might be in front of you. Kinda frustrating but the food is always good.“

“1st and NationalSlow serviceCalled in ahead of time for 2 whole subsItalian Special with no lettuce and they put on alot of lettuceMeatball and provoloneHad to wait an extra 15 minutes in their lobby while they made my subs. SMH2 whole subs $35 ... won't be going back“

“By far the best sandwiches I've had. They blow subway an cousins an even jimmy johns out of this world 🌎 ❤️💯“

“My family and I mobile order from this Subway all the time. Has to be the best Subway I have ever been to (and I’ve been to a lot across the country while traveling.)They make the sandwiches so well, nothing ever falls apart. The bread is always fresh and so are the toppings.The staff is always super polite and helpful.“

“Thanks Carlos m

The guy said that I will receive my food in 10 minutes. That was out 458 and at 5:08. I’ll receive my food. Thanks for telling me the truth. Any really do have good customer service this name is Carlos m. It was two females in there as well. They also greet me. Offered to serve as soon as I entered the building. What crazy is that He said 10 minutes and I thought it was gonna be like 15 and I was gonna get him a four star because I don’t like being lied to this was my first time visiting. This is the only picture I got, but believe that from the ceiling to the floor was clean. I did not want to be weird and got the taken pictures.“

“I love everything Cousin’s offers, although no two individual franchises are alike. This one’s got the goods.“

“Great Customer Service, freshest veggies, meats, cheeses & soups. I've been getting Subway for decades now all from a wide range of locations, since Subway is a very large and well known restaurant and I will admit there are a few locations that barely reach 3 stars within the "Subway" franchises. Luckily, at 98% of my home States have all been 4 stars or more. I usually call ahead, place my order for specific pick up time. I've been going nearly every day for several years to a handful of locations and they top 3 are my 1st places to call. If you have any problems with the stores and the actual Manager isn't there, please complete your due diligence to ensure fairness to the store & the employees. This is to ensure you're not cheating yourself while keeping a shotty store afloat.“

“we were looking for a place downtown that was open for lunch.“

“The best location ever.... 68th n state always makes my sub's the way I like it...The staff is great,friendly, and welcoming. Great work! Keep it up 🙂“

“Yes I do recommend the Steak and Cheese with Mayo. they are so YUMMY 😋😋😋😋😋“

“# 13 was delicious😋😋😋😋 Definitely going back!!!!“

“Picked up lunch for friends!

Vegetarian options: Can create sandwich how you want!

Dietary restrictions: Persons requested certain meats and veggies on sandwich! Subway will prepare according to customer's request!

Parking: Parked out front of subway! No long wait or lines!“

“Not really sure what all these Karens are talking about with their reviews. This is the only Subway we will go to. We go here before every Brewers game when we aren’t grilling. Every single time our subs are made well and taste great. When we ask for extra of something they give us extra, we ask for light of something they give us light. Great subs and experience every time.“