50 Best Sandwich Shops near East Rutherford

“I work in the mall where this Charlie’s location is and I always set my order with one of their employees named Dulce. She’s extremely polite and nice. She always greets me with a smile and remembers my order. Kudos to her she deserves a raise“

“I’ll give this location 10/10 in all aspects 👏 staff are amazing, very nice and professional. My sandwich was top tier and they strictly respected my food restrictions. I highly recommend this place and will definitely keep going there“

“Recently I watched an episode of “Comedian in Cars Drinking Coffee” with Jerry Seinfeld and Sabastain M. On this particular episode they went to Faicco’s Itailian deli. They talked about how good the sandwich was. Since we were heading to NY from Chicago, thought this would be a great place to stop . Let’s just say it didn’t disappoint. We had the Italian sandwich - it was so amazing. People should put this on their list to visit when coming to NY.“

“This place is great! Atmosphere is chill and cool but the staff is also really friendly. They know what they're doing and what they're talking about, and you can tell making the customers happy is their main priority. Food is stunning!! Some italian classics and some twists, amazing wines and for their prices it's 100% worth it. Love this place and I can't wait to return and wouldn't hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for somewhere to eat in NYC.“

“I taked to there "my kids" (im a babysitter) to have a açai bowl with a lot of tops. they loved so much and they tried the pao de queijo too, The Best.“

“I had the Pastrami sandwich it was delicious. My husband had the Italian hero, says it's the best one he ever had. Friendly entertaining sando guy. We are visitors to NY, and this is exactly what we were looking for. Thanks guys! Will definitely come again“

“Arrived around 12:30 and was seated immediately in the bar. Delicious pastrami delight. Not too heavy compared to other greasy pastrami sandwiches. Really liked how the pickle was really sour. Sadly they didn’t have the house fries that day.“

“This is by far my favorite restaurant. Every item on their menu is amazing. The owners and staff are friendly and welcoming as well. I make the excuse to visit the restaurant once a week from Manhattan“

“Dopo una settimana in giro per NY, l'ultimo giorno, ahimé, ho scoperto il bar/gastronomia/shopping Best Sicily. Il miglior caffè!“

“The Sandwiches just like in Florence !!“

“The Sandwiches just like in Florence !!“

“Everything on the menu is delicious! The service is fast and staff is amazing. My children love their empanadas! It’s cozy, welcoming and relaxing ambiance…“

“OMG! I enjoyed such a fresh sandwich! So excited this sandwich cafe has been created in my area!“

“We stumbled upon this sandwich shop while walking around the neighborhood and decided to stop in for lunch. The owner was incredibly kind and welcoming, which made the experience even better. There are a few tables both inside and outside if you’d like to dine in, and takeout is also available.“

“I went to a this deli on my bday trip, and I’m not exaggerating when I say it completely ruined every other deli sandwich for me.

Small place but seriously mighty. No fluff, no gimmicks, just unreal, farm-to-table food done right.

The meatball sandwich? I think about it daily. Perfectly seasoned, rich, and messy in the best way. The kind of sandwich you don’t forget. And the Burrata sandwich was just as incredible, packed with flavor and made with so much care you can taste it in every bite.

You can tell the ingredients are fresh and thoughtfully sourced. It makes a difference.

This place puts every other deli shop to shame. If you know, you know.

Already planning my next trip back, mainly for that sandwich.“

“I taked to there "my kids" (im a babysitter) to have a açai bowl with a lot of tops. they loved so much and they tried the pao de queijo too, The Best.“

“Subway, Is truly the best place to come in and gets a snack or sandwich. I love it and the Service is even better I would definitely recommend coming here and get yourself something to eat come stop by and get yourself something yummy to fill your stomach“

“The pastrami is really good“

“Travels great for any tailgate!! 10/10“

“I Love this place because the food is Really Good Here I Like the Workers At This Restaurant And I make a new friend at This Restaurant his Name is Mohammed And it's A Very Nice Place and The People and Everybody is great here and it's very clean and yhr place is Nice“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“Love the sense of community, it's a great space. A local friend suggested we check out Culture Lab and we'de glad we did. We caught a free concert and the gallery space had a ln exhibit on drag fashion. It was a fun early evening, our kids enjoyed the music.“

“I order online regularly & I have never been disappointed in the quality of the food, speed & efficient delivery from Sandwell. Will continue to order online & I have referred Sandwell to others with a wide variety of preferences. My new favorite go to delivery place!“

“1st time to New Jersey. We decided to order from a deli, so we ordered from Poppies, best decision we ever made. We ordered through a delivery service and it was still hot when it arrived. We ordered the hot roast beef sandwich on long roll and a bacon cheese burger on long roll with 2 bags of doretoes. They did not disappoint they were big, hot and very tasty. I will recommend to friends and family if they are coming to New Jersey from Texas anytime in the future.“

“Everything was so fresh and delicious“

“Sandwich was delicious. Loved the 70’s & 80’s movie posters on the wall. And the staff was helpful and had great vibes!“

“This was our first time trying this famous sandwich place. Thus, we were not sure what were the options. Unfortunately, they do not have a list of menu. However, they were very patient with us and told us what the special sandwiches of the day were. We got that day's special which was roastbeef. It was quite delicious. Next time, I would like to try a sandwich with bresaola (if they have).“

“Great lunches very accommodating for small lunch gatherings. Friendly atmosphere and staff. Delicious home cooked food and Italian specialties“

“I came today and tried Pietro sandwich and it was amazing! Tasteful and huge! It’s definitely one of the best sandwiches I ever had and I totally reccomend it! I live in Greece but I visit often NY and from now on I will visit Capone’s every time I will be in the city!“

“I’ve been here several times. Each visit did not disappoint. I’ve ordered soup and sandwich each time. Each time I ordered a different sandwich. All of them were quite tasty. It’s always the same nice lady working here by herself. I definitely recommend if you’re out for a quick lunch.“

“We catered a picnic for 25 people from them. The team went above and beyond, very communicative, thoughtfully asked how and what guests enjoy, worked with us to craft the perfect set of sandwiches… then came the actual day. They put together a very easy to transport box setup. I was just as enamored with that as I was with the food itself. Nothing shifted, spilled and arrived exactly as was packed.

The sandwiches were a huge hit with creative combinations that hit your taste buds in all the right ways. We had all ages enjoy them, from
5 yr olds to 70 yr olds. Huge thank you to the team for making my wife’s 40th picnic birthday a success!“

“Finally made it .. after a few weeks trying to go when it wasn't crowded ( yes it does get crowded) .. pickup a Tori katsu Sando .. which was amazing,the bread was soft , Tori katsu was moist and the sauce simply amazing.. now I would have given a 5 stars if they would have sprinkle dashi furikake ( which they did offer it to ) on the ribbon fried potato 😢 .. non the less I will return for that tamago Sando .“

“Always a great experience at the deli. The owner is very personable and accommodating.“

“While eating my 2 slices of wonderful Pizza, a slice of Margarita and a slice of Buffalo chicken, I had a most pleasant conversation with a beautiful young lady there named Ruby, who made me feel very comfortable and welcomed... what a great atmosphere. And what a great employee you have there. I enjoyed my experience there very much. Thank you, Ruby for making my experience there even better. Mark Amy. Salisbury Maryland.“

“Delicious wraps! We go to the one on 102th st and Broadway.The only bad thing is poor service,workers have bad attitude! Makes your wrap taste bitter!“

“we loved it!“

“Omg the sandwiches are great and big 20$ it’s worth every penny!!!!“

“Took the kids to Jersey Mike’s after soccer practice today and it was a total win! They loved the turkey sub and I went with the Italian Mike’s way. The staff was super nice and fast, which is a lifesaver when you’ve got hungry little ones. Way better than typical fast food feels like a real sandwich shop. Highly recommend for busy moms and families! We’ll be back soon. 😊“

“Holy crap the sandwich was good it was bursting with flavor and everything in between. The guy helping me gave me 70 free bags of chips and free cookies, of course. My life has been changed forever. The sandwich was so good, for a second I thought my dad returned.“

“Amazing , it’s a cashless place“

“Update on Review!!

UPDATE: It’s been about five years since my original review, and Mordi’s has definitely earned our business back. The food is still fantastic, and ordering through the app has made the busy lunch rush much easier. It’s once again a go-to for our office lunches. 🥪🔥

The Chicken Parm, Buffalo Chicken, and Crazy Cuban are some of our favorites. There can still be a wait because this place gets BUSY, but our recent experiences have been much better. Glad to have Mordi’s back in the lunch rotation!

Old Review

I was torn over writing this review. I have eaten a Mordi’s a number of times since it is extremely close to my office. They are a busy place the food is always good. However they need to take a moment and work on their customer service. We recently placed a big order for our Friday lunch, when we returned to the office we realized one sandwich was missing. We immediately called the shop as we got into the car. As soon as they picked they placed us on hold for five minutes without even given us a chance to tell them why we were calling. When they returned to the phone they said they are not taking any phone orders because they were busy and hung up the phone on us again without even hearing their customer our.

When my partner entered the shop and asked who hung up on us the woman behind the counter half heartily apologized. I’m sorry with so many great lunch options in this area Mordi’s will have to treat their customers with more dignity and respect before my office gives them any of our business.“

“Ordered delivery a few times. This place is a savior when you need dinner working an overnight shift. The cheese burgers are amazing and the coffee is amazing as well. The delivery guy are amazing. This place is amazing and I wish I could give more than 5 stars. Highly recommend.“

“I highly recommend this place! The brunch was fantastic. I tried the Nova Omelette special, and it was absolutely amazing. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. My kids are already planning to return and order the blueberry and orange pancakes.“

“Amazing place! Quality food, everything fresh, very friendly environment, multilingual staff and enough space for lunch/dinning. Prices very low and food portions are huge! Returning daily during my stay in NYC!“

“Deliriously delicious shop in the East Village! The sandwich rolls were the best I've tasted in NYC and perfectly toasted. My love and I enjoyed The Hog, a vermicelli and meat salad with the best fish sauce, and a lamb taco. I especially was impressed with the cleanliness and food handling. Go to "about us" to read the interesting story of the two friends/owners who we were so fortunate too meet at Wheelers in Sheepshead Bay.“

“I had a wonderful experience at this local subway the customer service was truly excellent i was served by Shravya who made my meal with such care also Peter at check out was fast friendly and courteous!! Excellent customer service at this “

“Best sandwich shop in North Jersey area hands down! Never disappoints!

I constantly order from this place and try new things—even though I don't always like to switch it up—and honestly everything on the menu is beyond amazing!“

“My wife and I are visiting from Tampa, Florida. It was just a short walk to the sandwich shop (1/4 mile) or so. I can't rant and rave about this place enough. My experience was amazing and the food was better. 100% recommend anything meatball 🤤. The cheese steak 😋. I need to eat every sandwich 🥹.
Ate to fast to take a Pic of the food, I'll try next time to snap one but don't count on it.“

“The sandwiches here are top tier. The mortadella is shaved perfectly fine (in front of you, on a restored slicer from Italy), and the bread / other ingredients are fresh. Sandwiches are made to order, so doubling down on fresh. The vibe feels like you’re visiting your zia’s cafe. Will come back to eat my way through this menu.“

“A kind young lady by the name of Ruby attended my mother and I at the start of her shift today. She was very helpful, offered great suggestions and was diligent. Thank you sweetheart for the great customer service :) never let anyone dim your sparkle“