50 Best Bakeries near Old Tappan

“Great selection of breakfast and lunch options in addition to some hard-to-get grocery items. Friendly staff and they also have a text option allowing you to place your order ahead of time.“

“Wonderful experience- I ordered 2 beef patties VERY GOOD!! The meat taste so different from a golden crust patty. Of course with a coco bread and took whole loaf 😊 if in the area stop by it’s worth it:) parking is tough, street meters.“

“The best macaroons. The crème brûlée and Ferrero rocher were my favs!“

“Delicious empanadas, and desserts! More than just cakes, stop in for a delicious treat like I did!!“

“these are incredibly delicious and the staff is so fun and friendly!“

“My friend picked up an assortment of treats for my birthday, everything was so delicious✨Red velvet cupcake and The pistachio thingy were my favorites❣️Have to go soon & try more treats🥰“

“I got a dairy free cake for my future daughter-in-law's shower because she has a severe dairy allergy. Delicious! Everyone was amazed that it was dairy fre..“

“La Promenade is awesome , food is amazing staff very helpful“

“Used to go the Mount Vernon shop when I was a kid, then after the fire and they moved to the Bronx..followed them down there- EVEN when the current owner bought from the gentile older man from MV... "Paul" has kept up standards. The Coco Breads are THE BOMB - I'd know, I was taught to make them at the bakery my Granny worked in Mo'bay every summer! A MUST HAVE !!!! Go out of your way. Brave the parking situation. DO IT, you will not regret it!“

“The fresh off the rack help yourself bakery was a cool experience but the eating of the huge everything bagels, pretzels and pastries was heavenly 🥯🙏🥰“

“Fantastic Detroit style pizza with a twist. Here's a photo of her Argentinian Detroit style pizza (onions and cheese with a sourdough crust). I heated it up in the toaster oven for lunch. It was so delicious, I can't figure out what to eat for dinner ... anything else would be a disappointment.“

“Best mochinuts I’ve had!! Great place, super friendly staff and amazing food and drinks!! I love this place!!“

“I had a wonderful experience at this bakery! The pastries were incredibly fresh, beautifully presented, and absolutely delicious. You can really taste the quality and care in every bite. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and made the whole experience even better. It’s clear that a lot of passion goes into what they do. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending this place to friends and family!“

““Life is tough sometimes. This experience always gives me JOY. The people are amazing and the treats are the best I have ever had.”“

“They are a cozy place (not huge) and the vibes were perfect for a cold Sunday. Food is ABSOLUTELY amazing and worth a drive (and wait if needed). Everyone was extremely courteous and accommodating, will absolutely travel the 2hrs to visit them again!“

“In 2024, the Monsey area is filled with catering establishments, take-out store, and bakeries, and yet Glaubers, which has been here forever, is still the best. They have catered kiddushin and a wedding for us and we were always greatly satisfied. When you go to the store you will find fresh and delicious food, and the people serving you are even more delicious! If you haven't been to Glaubers yet, go tomorrow.“

“Thank you so much for making our engagement cupcake cake! Not only was it beautiful, it was SO delicious!! 😍“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“Excellent sitting inside,A/C very comfortable.Excellent food as well.Love this place.“

“Everything in Rispoli is delicious! Can't beat their lobster tails! We drive 90min each way every time we have a Rispoli craving and bring their cookies and pastries to our friends in central jersey. Next week we're shipping cookies to Oregon! I have a feeling it will become a regular occurrence. Thanks for never disappointing us!“

“My son was recently diagnosed with EOE and is dairy, nut and egg free. Someone recommended AltEats so I contacted Laurie and she worked her magic! My son was able to enjoy an amazingly delicious birthday cake for the first time! She also created the most delicious cannoli filled cake for my guests! I can’t say enough about how easy Laurie was to work with and how lucky I feel blessed I feel to have found this establishment!“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“Everything is delicious and the place is so welcoming.“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“I highly recommend Sanders bakery. The food is always on point and I am consistently served cordially and with a smile. I do not dress or look like the typical customer one would expect at Sanders yet I am always treated with respect and grace, which is the reason I keep coming back.“

“Seems to be a newer business in downtown Ridgewood right on the corner across from the post office. Probably the best orange scone and oatmeal raisin cookie I have ever had. Everything is fresh and homemade. Nothing imported or stale. The setup is a little weird with how they have some of the baked goods because it's hard to see them all. I wish it was a little easier to see the selection. Maybe it's a good thing you can't really see everything because I would buy it all and be 900 pounds. Great addition to the area!“

“I am NYC born & raised but moved out of state. Happened to find this amazing bakery on a visit to NYC. I am beyond pleased with ALL the treats I purchased.“

“Wow this place is awesome!!! I bought the magic bar and a donut and both were amazing. I can't believe they were sugar free. I am often disappointed by gluten free dessert bakeries, but this place is the real deal. I will definitely be back.“

“Fantastic, good quality gf options! Lovely store front with both amazing gluten free options (scones, cookies, bread, sandwich’s, and other goodies!) and a cafe with coffees, teas, matcha). I always look forward to visiting.“

“Excellent service, taste and decorations. LOVE LOVE-LOVE THEM Thank you“

“Exceptional from start to finish!
The cake was absolutely divine, but what truly stood out was the impeccable service. I had to move my event date up unexpectedly, and Kimmy and her team handled everything with grace, speed, and outstanding professionalism.

Everything was ready right on time—the cake, the treats, the pickup—flawless. Their warmth, kindness, and attention to detail genuinely moved me.

This wasn’t just good service… it was above and beyond. I’m deeply grateful and will be a loyal customer for life.“

“Randy did an amazing job with our son's custom camper-themed cake. Our kid was beyond thrilled. Thank you for being so accommodating and wonderful! You really made his birthday special.“

“Excellent quiche and delicious cappuccino“

“Highly recommend anything from Despina's! Everything my family and I have tried has been out of this world. My most recent purchase was a beautiful cake designed perfectly for my MIL-one of the best cakes anyone in my family has ever eaten. Despina is so helpful and a pleasure to work with when ordering your special cake. You will not be disappointed!“

“first time visiting. Ashley M. was friendly and knowledgeable. cakes are delicious. I will be back!“

“Best baklava we ever had!“

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“Best cake ever ! Angela Logan you are an inspiration and bake the yummiest cakes ! Treat yourself to the best cake experience 🍰, you will be glad you did. 🤩“

“Truly unforgettable!! Sweet temptations made the individual desserts (making sure to have something for every dietary restrictions) for my baby sprinkle! The chocolate mousse cakes are literally heaven on a plate. Definitely consider working with this amazing bakery for any upcoming event!“

“This is my second time here and it’s just as good as the first time. We got the chocolate hazelnut filled donut, Red velvet sourdough cinnie, Raseberry jam toast cookie, pesto ricotta focaccia (not pictured) and 2 cappuccinos. All of their bakery goods are super fresh along with their coffee. super super yummy!“

“Wow this lady can bake! I have know her for a few years now but didn't really know about her baking till recently. I thought I would be nice and supportive and buy a cake. BAM! Best cake I ever eat! Now I am trying to think up excuses to buy another.“

“If you're looking for a delightful culinary experience, look no further than Taam Eden Bakery in New Square! This hidden gem has quickly become my go-to spot for fresh baked goods and mouthwatering treats.

From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked bread and pastries envelops you, setting the stage for an incredible experience. The selection is impressive, featuring everything from traditional challah and bagels to an array of delicious pastries that are hard to resist.

The quality of the ingredients is evident in every bite. I particularly recommend their signature babka—it's perfectly rich, moist, and beautifully braided. Each slice is a heavenly combination of chocolate and cinnamon, making it an absolute must-try. Their rugelach is also exceptional, with just the right amount of sweetness and a flaky texture that melts in your mouth.

The staff at Taam Eden Bakery are friendly and welcoming, always ready to help you choose the perfect treat or answer any questions you may have. Their passion for baking shines through in their customer service, making each visit feel special.

Whether you're stopping by for breakfast, a midday snack, or to pick up treats for a gathering, Taam Eden Bakery is the place to be. It's a fantastic spot to indulge your sweet tooth or enjoy a savory bite. I can't recommend it enough—definitely a five-star experience! 🍞🥐✨“

“Athens Bakery has the BEST spanakopita I've had in the U.S. or Greece!!! Amazing food and very kind staff. You will never be disappointed :)“

“excellent gluten free items!“

“I would like to recommend Amato bread, I ordered the Eggplant, Mozzarella and Prosciutto on a fresh roll with Balsamic glaze. It was delicious and Joe the owner was very friendly and accommodating.“

“I’ve been going to this bakery since 2016 when I was 14-15 years old, I unfortunately can’t go as much anymore, but I will alwaysss love this place. I love the owners and ofc the delicious baked goods. The sizing and affordability is just so unbelievable considering how expensive everything is this day….this spot is the definition of a hidden gem. Praying for more longevity and success for the owners 💜“

“Growing up, jelly donuts were at the bottom of my list in terms of flavors. I would eventually eat one, but it would be my last choice. A Polish coworker told me about how beloved jelly donuts are in Poland and I was skeptical of how good a jelly donut could be.

Then I found myself at Kohout Bakery and I've completely changed my tune, because damn, the raspberry jelly donuts are ridiculously good. It's the jelly. It's a very good jelly. It's not gummy or thick. It's full of raspberry flavor and there is plenty of the jelly in each donut. Even a couple of days after purchase, when the donut is a little stale, the donut is still so good because that jelly keeps the interior moist.

Other items in the store are also delicious, including the cream cheese cookies. They are not too sweet and have a great balance of flavors.

The service is very friendly and helpful, always patient with me and my indecisions.

Be prepared to bring cash, but the prices are also very affordable, so you can still get plenty of treats for under $10.

Make the trip out to Kohout Bakery!“

“The food at Oceanos is amazing, dishes are cooked to perfection and service is quick but not rushed. Prices are a little high but the quality is worth it. We have been to Oceanos several times for dinner and have never been dissappiointed and will for sure return again. We highly recommend this fabulous restaurant if you looking for a great restaurant to celebrate a special occasion or just in the mood for a great dinner out. We love this place and think you will as well.“

“I highly recommend people try out their cupcakes, shortbread cookies, strawberry shortcake, and their cakes. Delicious and Satisfying💯😋😋You will get you moneys worth.“