50 Best American Restaurants near Rochelle Park

“Truly nice place to take family or friends. Food is good and affordable. I remember when this place was a junkyard many many years ago but they really did nice things with it. It's clean even the bathroom.Parking: Tough to get into parking lot but it's hugeKid-friendliness: VeryWheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“A restaurant that I visit every two weeks is generally the same standard, but on my last visit, although I wanted the steak medium, it was undercooked and although the waiter sent the order medium well, the kitchen was wrong, the mushroom I ordered next to the steak was tasteless, the asparagus was very large and not cooked well, I hope you will reach your old standard on my next visit.“

“One word, phenomenal! My best friend and I had dinner here during our weekend trip and Daniel exceeded every expectation we could’ve had. We chose the Five Course Prix Fixe menu with caviar service and both the food and staff were excellent. We had such a great experience that we’ve decided to visit a new Michelin Star restaurant every year as a girls trip. Thank you all for making our experience exceptional.“

“Fun food joint with awesome portion sizes - which I feel are fair for the price. We got the poutine, sausage egg biscuit, and the honey chicken biscuit sandwich. They were all good. If I come again I’d like to come with more friends because this is definitely the kind of place with lots of options to choose from and the portions are so big it’s hard to try much among two people. Service could have even a little better - between 10 & 15 minutes before we ordered but they were nice and helpful when we asked for things. I can see why this place is popular. It’s a fun environment and they were able to get us in fast (party of 2 around 2:30pm).“

“A lovely dine-in bar-restaurant in UWS. I have been there during the happy hours (3:30 to 6 PM) and I would recommend the same. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, best for a group or an intimate date. I would highly recommend the Consulate's Old Fashioned which has Mescal. The French 85 is also good.“

“Nice Matin is a bright and lively restaurant. The servers are friendly, helpful, and often check in with your table. Their food is very good and has some unique brunch options (grapefruit with granola topping, scrambled eggs with Marquez sausage, etc.) Yet they have the beloved choices of egg benedicts, sandwiches, and entrees such as salmon and steak even at brunch time. The prices are very good for Manhattan and every seat was filled during our Saturday brunch.“

“AMAZING EXPERIENCEThe hostess and manager were kind enough to seat us despite a late arrival a few minutes after the kitchen was scheduled to close. This superior hospitality was our theme throughout the evening. The server ANFERNEE was prompt, professional, and polite while attending all of our needs. TEXAS-sized portions reminded us back home. Delicious food, tasty cocktails, and wonderful music made this a night to remember.Vegetarian options: The jerk cauliflower was spicy and delicious. The asparagus was roasted to perfection. The mashed potatoes were buttery, creamy goodness.“

“I cannot state enough just how delicious the food is here !!! Soooooooooo good !! Everything was full of soo much flavor and the steak had to have been one of the best cooked steaks I’ve ever had perfect temp and seasoning.It’s pretty inside and perfect to go for a date night the ambiance is nice. Definitely recommend this place“

“We visited on a Wednesday afternoon and it was bustling. I imagine weekend brunch is a whole vibe. The ambiance inside is inviting, warm and cozy (see photos). I appreciate the artwork, photographs and decor. It speaks to the rich heritage of Harlem and specifically to the area where the restaurant is located. There’s a decent amount of seating, some tables are closer to others than I prefer. However our table was perfect for me. You can make reservations which might be a good idea. There is also a good amount of outdoor seating. Visit their website for the policy regarding time allowed at table (to be able to accommodate more customers)… seems reasonable to me.Maia took good care of us. She was friendly, attentive without being intrusive and on point. She came back and checked on us although the restaurant was bustling as mentioned previously.There is a list of specials beautifully written on their board. With so many dishes I wanted to try… I must return (maybe for one of the live music events). I was intrigued by the fusion of food from different cuisines. I ended up ordering curry chicken sandwich with salad and plantain on the side. It was a good portion. I was full without feeling overstuffed. Definitely worth a trip to Harlem to check them out.“

“It was a day from hell and I took my daughter with me to happy hour for dinner. Everyone was so nice and accommodating. Our waiter was one of the kindest people I've met and the whole staff was amazing. The food was delicious and the drink specials were more than fair!! Everything was top notch and the vibe was fun and relaxing. I recommend this place 100%!! I can't wait to go back and try brunch there. We checked out the menu and it looks amazing!!“

“My daughter and son took me to Sylvia's on 4/27/24 for my birthday. We drove up from Philly, my sister and son-in-law was there as well. Food/service was excellent. Atmosphere was good. Our waitress Ms. Olga was a true blessing, her attitude and her politeness, matter of fact it was Ms. Olga birthday as well. They sang to me, I really enjoyed myself. Today is Monday, I'm eating my leftover ? for lunch. I had seafood combination, yams, mac&cheese. I pray one day I can visit again. The weather was cold so we ate and drove back to Philly. Normally I don't eat at restaurants, this was an excellent day for my 67th birthday ???God bless you all????????“

“Loving preservation of the French Dip!! Picture says it all. Bun was light, fresh and totally up to the task of embracing the perfectly roasted beef. Special shout out to Meg at the bar who shows as much respect for their fantastic whiskey collection as the kitchen does for the beef!“

“The place is very good, in a fairly normal neighborhood. The food is delicious and they were quick to serve us. Anthony was very kind to us and treated us great. The portions are very good, they give you tap water as soon as you sit down and the beer is cheap.Vegetarian options: They have vegan and vegetarian food and you can ask without problems and they will recommend you.Kid-friendliness: They let us enter with the children without problems and they have a children's menu“

“We live about an hour away and travel to Harlem every month or so just to eat at dino bbq! The food is always exceptional and the service is great, Maria is our favorite waitress but everyone is very nice. We always go for lunch because it's less busy, otherwise there's always a crowd, especially at night, you could be waiting well over an hour so be sure to make a reservation.“

“I pass the Penrose frequently, a block from the 2nd Ave Q entrance on 83rd. It is a perfect spot to meet up after work for drinks and snacks. Good music, friendly atmosphere. I tell everyone, my husband and I had brunch with our wedding party there. Great place. Recently my dad passed, and when trying to decide where to celebrate his life with extended family and friends my sister and I decided on The Penrose and emailed the events manager Chaya. She helped with everything, never got tired or short with her answers. We would think of all our questions after we signed off. Chaya made recommendations, helped our ideas come to life, and made a difficult moment easy. Day of memorial: Chaya and her team created the perfect atmosphere. Our server Emma and bartender Audrey were exceptional. The guests kept telling us what great service, atmosphere and food, but repeated to us how great the servers were. We had 30 people, in the back area with tables and bar seating. Chaya helped us choose the right amount of food, and beverages. Emma kept the area clean with out being intrussive, Audrey kept us “hydrated”. We had a buffet food area - food was great!They put to go boxes out for guest to take treats home. Thanks to Chaya we were able to truly celebrate dad, she had his play list, which we provided pumped in and a slide show with his great life moments on the screen over the bar. He served in WWII, a decorated war hero, with great taste in music. They also insured the Honor Guard ceremony, presenting flag and playing of taps went off seamlessly. As I said in my first paragraph The Penrose is a great place, but on this day it was exceptional. Chaya, Emma, and Audrey turned my dads celebration of life into a warm family moment that we will remember fondly and proudly. Thank you Chaya, Emma, and Audrey! If missed names for behind the scenes peeps sorry.“

“It was my first time at Prohibition... I live on the east side and cannot believe we have never been there! The atmosphere is casual with adult audience and amazing music (last night's opening act was a solo artist playing bluesy jazz and he had a great voice!). The food was good and the service was amazing! Dave the manager was especially helpful as I accidentally deleted my Resy invite and he reinstated us minutes later. I will definitely be back with friends. I wish there was something like this on the east side!“

“Let me just say wow! My wife and were in NY for her bday and decided to stop in on a Friday night. Instantly greeted by the maitre d, Cameron, who had the most positive energy and great food suggestions. The fillet mignon meatballs are a must! 10/10 would recommend.“

“This is a great spot for a date or special occasion. Dinner is Pre-Fix and the menu changes seasonally. The dining areas are very inviting. The staff was very detail oriented and just enough but not on top of you. Basically the service is impeccable. As for the food everything is timed great and everything we ate was awesome. I thought I might leave hungry initially but that was not the case. Must go to spot for a romantic dinner“

“Very unique and interesting experience for families and anyone who enjoys medieval period. There are a lot of add-ons you have include with extra cost. I can't say that it's worth it. Tomato soup with garlic bread tasted just like can soup and frozen garlic bread. So didn't enjoy that much. But main course chicken, potatoes and corn was pretty decent. And yes, don't expect utensils here. It is truly medieval period experience so you'll need to eat with your hands. Soft drinks are included so you don't need to order extra for kids. They'll have an option to get lemonade, coke or water. Dessert was eclaire and coffee. It was decent tasting. Don't over dress for this venue. Definitely dress down and get into the spirit of jousting and sword fighting between knights. Acting from staff was fantastic and overall, great experience.“

“Another brilliant meal! I never miss the opportunity to eat here when I’m in NYC and I Love sharing this place with people I know. An exceptional menu, great cocktails, amazing and attentive service and always a delightful culinary experience. Bravo!“

“Always lovely service and excellent food, but we were seated in a busy corner with a lot of small tables crammed together, and with the staff coming by and people squeezing in and out, my chair gets hit repeatedly, and I'm a very small person with my seat scooted in!“

“A great variety of well seasoned food. The portions were pretty large. The atmosphere is nice for a date or just to hang out with friends. I think they have two levels. Our large group ate downstairs. I would recommend the chicken enchiladas and the shrimp Po’ Boy.“

“We went for an engagement party and were blown away. Food was delicious. Every bite.Service went above and beyond. I mentioned once I was gluten free and the waiter brought me a special gluten free side and my own dessert. I couldn’t believe it!Probably the best meal I’ve had in a long long time. If they can pull off a large event so well I can only imagine how fab their regular dinner service is!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pros!“

“We only discovered St. Eves a couple weeks ago - great neighborhood spot! Food was very good, service on point, nice atmosphere. Seating a little tight though. Big plus for us - byob! On the pricier side but well worth it. Will definitely included St. Eves in our regular restaurant rotation.“

“Been going to Shannon Rose for years...dinner with friends, teacher appreciation etc. I love their food especially their nachos and burgers and I loooove the sangria. We love Ashley she's a great worker, pleasant and always willing to accommodate us. Def a 5 start visit when Ashley's working!!“

“Update***I had the drip coffee today and they refilled my coffee frequently. And it tasted great!!! Thanks for the great food and service!!!*******I really like the food and the ambience here - 5 stars. Why did I give it 3 stars overall then?It over charges for SMALL cups of americanos without refills. 1 small cup (1 shot expresso and 1 shot water) is $6. I’m talking about a small tea cup here.You end up paying $24 for 4 small tea cups of americanos for 2 people which is equivalent to 2 grande americanos at Starbucks for 3 TIMES the price. Sadly the drip coffees don’t taste as good and aren’t refilled either.Will I still eat here? Every so often because I like the food, but I won’t come as often as I would because of how much they over charge for coffee. I feel like I’m letting someone rob me…“

“Very classy interior, old fashioned atmosphere. A bit more expensive than I would be comfortable with. Appetizers and main course were amazing. I had tuna tartare and Jumbo Shrimp Scampi, my husband had New York Strip Steak. It was so good, so delicious!And we decided to order some deserts. It was a mistake though! My Apple Strudel was absolutely different from what I had expected. My husband had a Lemon Sorbet, which had not any test at all and was too icy, it had not a smoothie texture at all. So we had been really disappointed with desert.“

“This place is such a great addition to the neighborhood. Great music with tons of music memorabilia to look at. Excellent food and drink but the real draw is the atmosphere. The owners are awesome too - they just want everyone to have a good time.“

“Fantastic American lunch spot! I had the chicken sandwich and the sriracha mayo was just immaculate. The atmosphere of the restaurant was great and we were seated right away without any reservation. The staff and servers were also very kind and helpful throughout our meal! Would recommend to anyone wanting a good lunch in Manhattan!“

“I’m hesitant to even write a review because I consider this place a true hidden gem! With so many options in the area I find myself forgetting about Turtle & Wolf until after my recent visit it sprang to the top of my list!I went for a birthday celebration and my friends and I shared a bunch of dishes. Everything was so well executed, the portions were generous and we just had such a lovely evening. Cannot pass on this adorable BYOB.“

“Great food, great service, really nice atmosphere. We met dear friends for dinner and had an awesome evening! Every course was excellent, Stephanie our server was terrific, and as we waited for our ride home, Salih said I am going through Ridgewood I will give you a ride. Wow! Talk about full service.“

“This place and employees are the best in the business! Chrystal and Rafael handled my sister bday party perfectly! Their service and dedication are beyond appreciated and outstanding! Thank you again for providing us with PERFECT service! Oh and the food was excellent too ?“

“The BEST guacamole!Vegetarian options: I am vegan and can always find something delicious to eat at Sonoma Grill.My partner thoroughly enjoyed his short ribs.The table side guacamole is phenomenal!The cocktails are always amazing and the staff is always so friendly and accommodating. This is one of our favorite places to eat in Nutley.“

“I ordered catering for my birthday event last weekend and the food was amazing! I’ve been a true fan of this restaurant ever since I’ve moved up to Bloomfield a few years ago and I always bring my friends and family to this restaurant. Whether it’s Brunch or dinner, the food never disappoints! Hence why I thought it was a good idea to ask for them to cater for my bday! Anthony and his team were very accommodating and brought out the rest of trays as the previous ones started emptying out which I greatly appreciated due to the lack of space we were given at the venue. We ordered the chicken empanadas, beef empanadas, broccoli rabe, mixed greens salad, Mac and cheese, chicken parm, eggplant parm, pasta vodka, meatballs and potato croquettes. All dishes were excellent and everyone was excited to pack the leftovers home as well! I also ordered catering from here back in February for my galentines party and the food was also a success during that time. I know I can count on them for providing exemplary food as well as service. Thank you, Anthony and his team for making my birthday memorable!“

“Very lively friendly restaurant run by American African. Love the ambience the friendly crowd! Love the southern fried chicken eggnog waffle, The beef rib was super tender , it is a must try. They have unique cocktails too, the Strawberry Hennessy was very special!Gender-neutral restrooms, Good For Kids, Good for Brunch, Dinner, Private Dining, Compostable containers available, Covered Outdoor Seating.“

“I love this place. The chipotle chicken sandwich is amazing. The service is excellent. Humble interior, delicious food (try the wake and bake burger that has an egg and a hash brown) and reasonably priced. The servers have a great energy and are quick. As a local, I’d recommend this place to anyone around the area.“

“Third time I've been there and I must say that the steaks are still the best I've had and not close in my mind. Cooked to perfection. And what many steakhouse lack is the proper amount of seasoning. Too often steaks are under seasoned which, even if cooked perfectlyrics, the blandness of the steak is what one recalls. I've never had this issue here and thus I've never been disappointed. I will be back again!“

“Had Easter brunch with daughter and family last Sunday. A group of 6 including 2 grand kids (3 & 2) who enjoyed their pancakes. We had tuna tartar, octopus and thai salad for appetizers and they were all all excellent. For main, had the salmon, crab cake benedict and more. Overall food was great especially the octopus. No complaints on service and atmosphere. Definitely would come back.“

“Such a great experience doing intermission dining during the Opera! Even with the tight timeframe, the service and food were outstanding. Special shout-out to Jerry who was the MVP of the evening.I’m already looking to book another Opera just to re-do this experience, and that’s saying something ?“

“Wish I had found this place sooner. Saturday night dinner. Walk in the door to be greeted by the most friendly and happy manager who made us feel very welcome. Started with a drink at the bar where Malik made us feel like family! Amazing martini to kick things off. Restaurant is packed yet somehow not super loud. Got a great corner table where we had the Edamame hummus to start which is very good, wait staff is split and they are all super attentive and friendly. Entree was a nice pork chop on the bone for me and salmon for my wife. Both were very good. Decided to go back and sit at bar for a night cap with Malik and Benito who took great care of us. Can't wait to go back.“

“Overall a good spot for a brunch. The ambiance is lovely as there was a piano player and the shades were up. We requested a seat by the window but they weren't able to accommodate which is no big deal, they were able to seat us one row away from the window and that was even better for me. I ordered the burrata and the cheeseburger. The yucca fries are unique in texture and satisfyingly crunchy. The bun on the cheeseburger was a lot so I opted to only eat half of it. The burrata was creamy and went well with the balsamic caviar. We ordered the mango coconut panna cotta as well which was divine, would go back there just for that. It was also beautiful to look at! One star off because the service was not great -- it took a very long time to place our order for our entrees and our dessert, which kept us there for 2 hours. Servers themselves were great.“

“This is a very unassuming restaurant serves really good food. The chips and guacamole were made with freshly fried (and still warm) tortilla chips and the serving of guacamole generous. Had the duck and beef bourguignon and both were surprisingly delicious. Ambience may not be as welcoming as other restaurants in the hood but food is so good and worth returning.“

“Izzy was my waiter and host- very welcoming, helpful, and professional. As great and fresh as the food was, Izzy definitely went above and beyond to make a great experience even better.The food was authentic, freshly prepared but came out in a timely fashion. Baklava was light and flaky- the vanilla ice cream accompanying it had crushed pistachios on top- really went above and beyond for the little touches that might get overlooked by some clients. Shows a real pride in their food and service.Decor was of a bistro and had ample space. I did not feel crowded by other tables or patrons.Glad I happened on this restaurant. I will definitely be back again soon.Parking: 100+Wheelchair accessibility: 1st floor access directl from parking lot which had well over 100 spaces shared between the strip mall.“

“The best spot to hang out at in the UWS!! I have had the best martinis here, some of my fav fried chicken sliders and the tastiest shishito peppers ever. You can’t go wrong with any drink and whether it’s the weekend or a nice weekday celebration this is the most fun spot to chill at.We just celebrated our law school first semester here and it was awesome!!Vegetarian options: Great eggplant appetizer that’s fully vegan!! So creamy and great sides for it!!!Dietary restrictions: Some of my besties are vegan/vegetarian and they love this spot!!“

“My friends and I decided to indulge in the appetizers, raw bar, and sushi menu as the main entrees didn't quite catch our attention. They ordered the lychee martinis, while I savored the delightful Melon Spritz, which was absolutely delicious. Every dish we sampled was exquisite. We capped off the evening with martini espressos, enjoying the music and ambiance. The only downside was the prolonged wait for our drinks after ordering. Despite that, the bathroom's view of the kitchen, though unusual, was beautifully designed. We're definitely considering a return visit!“

“Have you ever found a gem and never wanted to share it? Lol, that's how I feel about Clay. Talk about perfect setting, food, and service. Absolutely stunning place in the heart of Harlem. Cool neighborhood, too. Highly recommend. Plan ahead because there could be a wait to get a reservation. Love this place.“

“YOU MUST VISIT THIS RESTAURANT IF YOU ARE IN NEW YORK. This is the definition of fine dining that you see on tv. I'm only able to post some of the many plates we had but the menu is seasonal and constantly changing but not to worry because everything is always good. Service is PHENOMENAL. You and your family will feel like kings and queens with the service they provide you. And your dinner comes with amuse bouche, bread service, madeleines, petit fours, chocolate sticks and a canele at the end of your meal. It just kept on coming and we were full till the next day! And the decor is fancy but also not too uptight where you feel too uncomfortable and stuffy! 100/10 for this restaurant. Must must visit.“

“Stumbled upon this place while doing some shopping , we were starving and Tanner got the job done . Staff was welcoming and polite , service was just a little too slow tho. For food we ordered shrimp toast sliders which were very good. The bread was so soft. Vietnamese crab chips were very good too , love the touch of jalapeño on it . Last be bbq brisket nachos. So very good. Everything was fresh and we were def full. The menu changes, not sure how often but it does. Always some cool items on the menu.“

“I chose a simple breakfast today! Cyndia's knocked it out of the park with their Over Easy Eggs, Home Fries and Whole Wheat toast! Everything was cooked to perfection. It was awesome! The Great Friendly Service and Atmosphere made my breakfast experience even better. Highly recommend stopping in you will be glad you did! To Cyndia's staff keep up the Great Work, Quality and Service you provide to your customers!!!“

“OMG! I think I just found my favorite restaurant in NYC! Massive shout out to TOMAS! Who made tonight's dinner so special. The lamb, brussel sprouts, and the corn soup were phenomenal! Archer and Goat is the restaurant we've been looking for a long time - great food, great vibe, all at a reasonable price point. We can't wait to come back!!“