50 Best Bakeries near Rutherford

“Working with Carrie was such a piece of cake. We discussed details of a birthday cake over email and she was very attentive and responsive. Finally she made a cake that didn't just look pretty as per our asks but also tasted amazingly good!“

“Erie is amazing. Highly recommend - coffee is absolutely the best - lattes and all different flavors - hot and cold! The banana bread is my favorite but All of the different baked goods are to die for! Never had anything but excellent here. The owners and the baristas and ALL of the staff are friendly and truly provide the BEST service! If I lived in Rutherford I’d be here every day!“

“Amazing!!! Will be our go to bakery! Was looking for an eggless bakery for my daughter’s birthday cake due to her egg allergy when I found this place on google and gave them a shot and they did not disappoint. Everyone at the party asked about where i got the cake from. It was the most rich, moist and flavorful cake i’ve eaten. They were also able to match the picture I sent them. Thank you!!“

“Best bakery I’ve ever been in.“

“Great friendly coffee shop in Rutherford - variety of pastries and coffees - my go to place since moving here.“

“The best coffee and pastry in the world!“

“if you love SE Asian food lady Wong is the one to follow“

“My husband and I made the long drive yesterday (2 1/2 hrs each way) from upstate NY to visit our daughter in NYC just for the day. While strolling around her neighborhood we came upon your lovely bakery and cafe and after eyeing the beautiful carrot cake in the window, we had to go in. Carrot cake is my favorite sweet treat. There were so many beautiful choices, but we got 2 slices of carrot cake to take back home with us. After the long drive back home we were really looking forward to a piece of cake and a cup of coffee. I opened one of the beautifully packed boxes, which revealed an enormous slice of yumminess!! The slice was big enough for at least 3 people. I thought I had died and gone to heaven. Everything about this cake was phenomenal. The frosting was outstanding, the cake was so flavorful and moist. It was the best we’ve ever had. We have enough left for a few days. I’m so glad we stopped in. It was a great way to end our lovely day in the city and will most certainly go back on our next trek in . I will also have to get our daughter pick up some baked goods when she’s coming home for a visit. I highly recommend Crumbly Cafe & Bakery😊😊“

“The best strawberry cheesecake and chocolate covered cannolis I have ever had. 100/10, I’ll dream about these items forever lol.“

“As most places in NYC, we stumbled upon this bakery. Once your eyes see it, I challenge you to not go into it. It’s a very colorful place and the person who served us was incredibly patient and friendly (I kept coming back to add to my order). The coffee was very, very good, my cortado was perfect.
We got a couple of pastries for the following day and the croissant (I’m French) was very good even after a day. It was filled with pistachio cream and the size was just right, the cream very nutty and not overly sweet and sickly. Shame we live so far away because I’d make it a regular.“

“The wait isn’t bad, the food is banging and cheap, don’t stand around in the line unless you know what you’re waiting for is the one tip I’ll give, people just stand around without seeing which line they’re in. You can walk right up to the counter if you’ve got cash. Get a few buns to go for later. The shu mai was ok seemed like it had been sitting a while.“

“Great, Great everything delicious. Outdoor eating area only 4 tables.“

“The best macaroons. The crème brûlée and Ferrero rocher were my favs!“

“We absolutely love the Kurly Kurdish shop. I had a Kurly kone with cherry vanilla ice cream. This is the best sweet treat. I recommend everyone stop in and try one!“

“Adorable place for a tea, coffee and pastry! Delicious for eating in or takeaway to sit and enjoy the views of the city just down the block“

“👍the best, miss going there, eccellente“

“Looking forward to my orders getting shipped“

“Yessssss we live in Dallas Texas and we always come to have your cookies 🍪 ♥️ Great place awesome customer service“

“I work for a law firm in CA and we have an employee who works remotely in NY.. For our employee's birthday I wanted to choose a bakery close to her home and who was local. Stumbled upon Buttercup Bake Shop and they were so awesome! Totally worked with me and delivered the cupcakes with NO hassle. Needless to say our NY employee was super happy and LOVED the flavors and decorations of the cupcakes. ❤️“

“incredible vegan options. amazing cakes 😍 definitely visiting again“

“Outstanding pastries! My favs are their black and white cookies, (best ever!), brownies and chocolate chip cookies. I find their blueberry muffins and cupcakes to be too small - very tiny.“

“amazing hot chocolate and cakes. i am not sure the wait to sit in is worth it though as i felt a little rushed. but to take away you wont be dissapointed.“

“OMG...this IS the best sponge cake you'll have in NYC. I've had my fair share looking for one that compares to the original Kam Hing. The owner apprenticed with the original Kam Hing owner and finally opened his own cafe! Can't go wrong with the original flavor but the pandan coconut is sooooo goood! it's my new fav! This is my new go to place for sponge cakes!“

“One of the best hidden gems for Chinese-style desserts in Chinatown! Kam Hing Coffee Shop is simple, affordable, and full of flavor. The sponge cakes are incredibly soft, fluffy, and freshly made with many interesting flavors to choose from. Perfect for a quick snack or takeaway.

The prices are very reasonable, and the service is fast and friendly. I also enjoyed the coffee – simple but satisfying. Great spot if you want something tasty without the fancy setup. Highly recommended, and I will definitely be back!“

“We were in NYC for the weekend and I was told to check this place out. They definitely did not disappoint! Everything was delicious but now I need this in Buffalo….will always be on my list when we visit NYC!“

“Delicious empanadas, and desserts! More than just cakes, stop in for a delicious treat like I did!!“

“Best pancakes on the eastern seaboard! Absolutely delicious maple butter! It’s the best breakfast anywhere in the world!!! 🥞🧇🥓🍁🧈🦋👐“

“Yummy, delicious, flavorful cookies, and friendly staff. We stood in line outside as they were super busy, but so worth it!“

“definitely recommend it.“

“UPDATE: So I went ahead and ordered from Fabrique on Fat Tuesday/Mardi Gras even though I was disappointed with the one I had initially, and as you can see on the second image on this review it's a lot better! Bun is fluffy, cream is great, color is spot on. It could have a bit more almond creme, but it's still enough to be nice. Thanks for the delivery to the Instagram office!

Cosy cafe, but as a Swede with high standards, their Semla does not cut it.

At an initial look, the size is great. Not too much, but still substantial, and the whipped cream looks smooth. However, it's.. grey?! Not sure if they just forgot to add egg when baking the buns, but looks a bit sad.

When starting to eat, there are three things to observe: 1) the whipped cream is smooth, well done on that part. 2) the bun is not fluffy, actually closer to dry, making the whole Semla quite boring. 3) waaaay to little almond creme. A boring bun can be saved by a lot of almond creme, however there is a minimal amount in this one. Even if the bun was perfect I'd be disappointed.

Overall this is a 2 or 3 on a scale of 5. The only reason it could be a 3 is because there are very few places that offer Semla in NYC. That said, if you're one of the few Swedish bakeries in town, you have a responsibility to represent the country in a better way than this. Especially when you charge an outrageous $9.5 for it.

Back to the drawing board Fabrique, this is not good.

Otherwise the cafe is cosy and the people working there seem friendly.“

“Just had a delicious meal here and highly recommend it to everyone! our server, Maria was amazing and guided us in our menu choices.“

“OH MY GOSH i wish we had this where I live. Less than $3 for a HUGE 大包 (the “Big Bun”) in NYC?? Sooo good! Pork bun is also yummy <33 I’m gonna bring some home in my luggage LOL.
The place is cash or venmo only I believe. They also had mooncakes (unsure if it’s seasonal for October) and packaged Asian bread/pastries.“

“Yummy, delicious, flavorful cookies, and friendly staff. We stood in line outside as they were super busy, but so worth it!“

“Went bakery hopping that day. by far it has the best croissant. Even saved one for the next day, toasted it and tasted just as good. Staff was friendly too.“

“Sehr köstlich und empfehlenswert 😋“

“Amazing baked goods that are not the same played out options you find at most bakeries.“

“Unbelievably good individual cheesecakes. Always fresh and really tasty. I definitely recommend this store.“

“YUMMY, YUMMY AND DELICIOUS. Bring plenty of water and money. Don't go on an empty stomach.“

“best macarons in NYC! ❤️❤️❤️“

“Such an amazing Turkish breakfast experience. The spread was fresh and delicious, but the kuymak was the real highlight — rich, perfectly stretchy, and tasted just like my grandma made it. The staff were so kind and welcoming, truly peak Turkish hospitality. Definitely recommend!“

“Sullivan Street Bakery has serious the best sliced pizza in New York City. Was absolutely delicious. The coffee is amazing too. A cappuccino is a proper cappuccino (less milk and more foam to make the coffee taster stronger). This is now my regular after discovering it a few weeks back. You must go.“

“The kunafe is so good with the ice cream on top of the kunafe you should try it especially with Zubeyir 5 star service“

“Las galletas están súper frescas y siempre tienen sabores diferentes cada semana. • Repostería deliciosa, suave por dentro y con toppings increíbles. • Siempre tienen sabores nuevos y el chocolate chip es mi favorito. • El menú cambia cada semana y todo sabe recién horneado. • Perfecto para un antojo dulce, las galletas son enormes y riquísimas.“

“Looking forward to my orders getting shipped“

“Cloudy Donut never disappoints! Their donuts are not only beautiful to look at but absolutely delicious. Every bite tastes fresh, fluffy, and perfectly balanced. The team there clearly puts so much care into their craft, and it shows.

This season, I was thrilled to try their tiramisu donut—and wow! It’s rich, creamy, and melts in your mouth, with just the right touch of espresso and cocoa. Honestly, it tastes like heaven in donut form.

On top of that, their prices are very reasonable for the quality and taste you get. These donuts feel gourmet without breaking the bank, which makes indulging in them even sweeter.

I love them so much that I find myself buying donuts here every weekend—it has become a little tradition with my kids

If you’re looking for donuts that go above and beyond the ordinary, Cloudy Donut is the place. Highly recommend to anyone who loves a sweet treat done right!“

“The pastries and cakes at Petit Chou are absolutely divine. They not only look beautiful but taste beautiful.
I think a lot of the bakeries that have gone viral are severely overhyped. Petit Chou stands out because everything I have had from this bakery has been good.
Their chocolate chip cookie is also among the best in NYC.
The bakery doesn't have much seating. There is one counter with 4 chairs. And a second standing only counter. It can feel a bit cramped if you are enjoying your treats inside the bakery on a busy day.“

“Thank you for your generous donation to Glen Rock High School! The desserts were delicious! Can’t wait to go back and pick up some more desserts for my family!“

“The egg tart is the real deal, easily outshining the local dim sum spots and bakeries. The crust is incredibly flaky and shatters perfectly with every bite, while the custard is silky smooth and hits that “just right” level of sweetness. A must-try!“

“Amazingly delicious treats! We loved the cloud cake and earl grey puff! It’s to die for! The teas we bought were amazing too! I only have one request, please open up a store in Chicago so I can enjoy your amazing treats more regularly!“

“Ordered yellow duck cookies for my daughter's baby shower. They are adorable! They're large, wrapped individually, and the packing was fabulous. There is no way any could have broken. They came quick, and smell great. Can't wait to taste. If another occasion arrives, I will definitely order again.“