50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Tenafly

“The attention was wonderful. The white sangria was very good. The food was absolutely delicious. Paella marinara, Chilean sea bass and the mariscada were all yummy. Best part. … the flamenco show.“

“Grab a bite and a glass of wine - relaxed atmosphere - great food - service is spot on. @lindaslist“

“We had a wonderful birthday dinner. They had some cute birthday confetti on the table and a birthday card which was a nice touch. The dumplings, beet salad, scallops, brussel sprouts,and stuffed shrimp were all delicious! The drinks were great. Dessert selection was nice - the lemon tart was fantastic. Loved listening to the live jazz band which raised the bar for the atmosphere. Will definitely return. High class restaurant with high class service!“

“Highly recommended. Very good food.“

“I went with a group of friends for my birthday last night. It was AMAZING. The service was great, everyone was so friendly. The place itself was so clean and cute, really cool vibe. The Apps were great, Hush Puppies and Fried Calamari, yum. I did a make-your-own Seafood Boil. OH MY GOD. The New Zealand Mussels, King Crab and Dungeness Crab was out of this world in the Cajun Butter Sauce. I HIGHLY recommend this spot and will be going back.“

“THE BEST“

“Made a reservation for Christmas eve, and despite the restaurant being full it did not feel overcrowded. Food was absolutely delicious. We had forgotten it was BYOB and the liquor store down the street was closed, bit overall great meal. They also have a kids menu.“

“Food is very fresh and excellent. Our server, Sandy was very friendly and attentive to our needs“

“It was my mom’s birthday and Briana was our server. She was so sweet and kind to us. She took her time to explain her favorites off the menu and helped us order as it was our first time there. When you go please ask for Briana!! We are definitely coming back, especially for her.“

“This is such an amazing place with the freshest seafood and very lg. Servings sizes on all their dishes. The staff is friendly and very helpful ! So glad we have such a fantastic place in our area!!!!“

“Great food & awesome service !!!“

“The trout is the best in the area. The servers can be unprofessional and rude. When asked to tie back their hair, the request was refused. A nonsense response of not required was insulting. As an experienced service trainer, the hair in question should have been restraining. Health department requirements override a servers vain attitude.“

“Oxtails, j*** wings, Rasta pasta es muy bueno. Cabbage, collards, rice and peas are great compliments to the mains..Prices are extremely reasonable and staff makes everyone feel welcome“

“I recently visited Donghae. and it was an amazing experience. The seafood is incredibly fresh and flavorful, and the dishes are beautifully presented. The staff are very friendly and attentive, making the whole meal enjoyable. The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming, perfect for a casual dinner or a special occasion. I’ll definitely be coming back. highly recommend Donghae Susan if you love fresh seafood!“

“I was there for Mother’s Day (had a reservation). The staff is friendly and very attentive. And the food was delicious. Will definitely try it again.“

“Luke's Lobster on the Upper West Side is a fantastic spot for fresh, quality seafood in a casual and enjoyable setting. The lobster rolls are the real deal — generous, flavorful, and worth every penny. The atmosphere has that relaxed New England seafood shack charm that works perfectly for the concept. Service was a bit inconsistent and could be more attentive, but it didn't take away too much from an otherwise great experience. A go-to for lobster rolls in the neighborhood.“

“Excelente atención y muy buen sazón“

“My brothers and I hosted our dad’s 60th birthday in one of the private rooms upstairs. Maria took care of us and service was incredible all night! We chose the 3 course sit down menu and family style appetizers which were all incredible. I highly recommend coming here for a private event and will be back soon to try the rest of the menu!“

“Very delicious food .. seafood is on point“

“Delicious food and amazing service. Can’t beat the lunch special. Excellent!“

“I stopped by for a late lunch take out and I was pleasantly surprised.
First, the interior while not large is cozy and very inviting, complete with nice Japanese wall art, and even a stove heater in one section with many Japanese ceramics like tea pots on display.
I ordered a Chicken teriyaki lunch box (bento) - (Entree, $14.50, 4/5) - I was happy with the heft of the bag and upon opening it, food was hot and fresh. California rolls were good and 2 pieces of shumai were crispy and nicely seasoned. Rice was the right portion and chicken was fresh-tasting with good quantity of teriyaki veggies. Some pieces were a bit tough and the seasoning overall did not really permeate, but I didn't mind. I mean, it's lunch special so you can't really expect too much. I was nicely satisfied with this bento - not too much, not too little, and at a great price.

I used to do yoga right next door for years and had never gone in, but now I would like to dine in because they had that nice, cozy and authentic Japanese sushi house vibe that was so inviting + of course, good tasting food at reasonable price. I'll be back!“

“Excelente atención y muy buen sazón“

“Everything is good“

“Calamares y cóctel delicioso“

“The best lobster roll around!!! Delicious shrimp cocktail!! Can’t go wrong….Super easy curbside pick up“

“First time entering this location actually, the waitress Lakaiya I believe that was her name was very nice and helpful, food and service was great, and of course, my favorite appetizers are the "Cheddar Bay Biscuits" now, as for the ambience and overall environment of the restaurant, it has a low key vibe and very inviting, has a warm feel to it, the waiters and waitresses try their best to provide their services for their customers, as well as the chefs that cook and prepare their food, I do recommend this location though, I also like the music selection on the radio's overhead, nicely done...“

“Top burger spot in NYC

Fast delivery and fresh taste

Must-try signature burgers

Loaded fries with flavor

Value for money

Satisfying burger experience

Consistently great food

Crowd favorite smash burgers“

“We had a wonderful experience at Musette celebrating my husband’s birthday! They were very accommodating for our group of six, but I strongly recommend making a reservation!The evening felt easy and enjoyable from start to finish. The wine flights were excellent and a fun way to try a variety of options. Both the Musette flatbread and the salmon flatbread were absolutely amazing—fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. On top of that, the service was fast, friendly, and attentive, which really made the night special. We’ll definitely be back! Thank you Musette Team!“

“The staff was friendly and attentive to the wedding participants that I played for. The wedding started on time and everything went smoothly.“

“Great and affordable food. They did my wedding and all events for my family’s gathering. The owner and staff are very personable. Highly recommend it.“

“so fresh. highly recommend everything on the menu is so good“

“Wait times are usually long but that’s because they have a lot of people coming in I’ve had this place twice and the fish and chips always come out Devine. Seasonings on the fish itself are perfect and I love the amount of condiments they give you. The hot sauce is great I can’t tell if they use Texas Pete but it’s my fav with the tartar sauce“

“I always come to this restaurant and they always have a variety of food the service is always immaculate Robert serves me during the night and he gives great vibration to your food Christine is the loveliest she always over extends and does her very best to please she has always served me depending her shift and I recently have gotten to know a new waitress Maria who is always lovely and kind when serving me she is very attentive and servicing a place to enjoy at all hours“

“Drove 4 hours from Syracuse NY just for the stew chicken! Only to eat it in the car before I drove off 🤣 Safe to say, I went back inside for another dish 🤣🤣 5 ⭐️’s #ThaAuthor“

“The food and service was amazing!“

“This place is a hidden gem. We were looking for place to make our go to spot. Once my foodie fiance tasted the catfish it was goto spot approved. The service is outstanding as they took very good care of us. The food is very tasty and nicely seasoned. We will be back.“

“Es un lindo lugar para compartir con la familia, los empleados son muy atentos y amable, la comida muy buena y llega a la mesa aún caliente 🔥, lo recomiendo 💯.“

“I tried to give this place the benefit of the doubt. The food is awful. Mozzarella sticks were frozen, Cajun fries, a handful of paprika drowned over the top Today beer that's normally $6 was $8 plus a $4 tip, tax and looking for another tip. Bill should have been $20 it's $30. Live with your wn failure. Don't put it on the customers. Pretty bartenders won't cover incompetence.“

“My fiance and I came here the other day. The food was incredible, it was our first time trying KBBQ and we had such a great experience! The service was great all the staff was super nice (our waiter Joseph was super kind!) the power went out due to a snow storm mid meal & we still felt well taken care of (plenty of candles and servers around). I would recommend trying this place!!:) The hanger steak & marinated short rib were out favorites !“

“Best fried or steamed fish you will ever have from a store front. And seriously maybe the cheapest. My go to is the fried flounder sandwich, $5 today, sometimes $6 cash for two huge pieces depending upon market price. They give you the tarter and lemon and tons of other condiments and spices to put on yourself, just how you like it, before they neatly wrap it up and bag it for you. I always tip them two bucks. Been coming and thankful for them for the last 25 years when they used to be a block south. There are similar looking joints but none nearly as consistently good as Dyre Fish is. I have tried so many, hoping. It is the oil they dont allow to be used too long and the fresh fish picked up daily at Hunts Point Fish Market. And the prices have barely gone up in all that time.“

“The food was amazing , prices are outrageous affordable i recommend this restaurant ! Michael Ligon was the employee who was making sure that all time we would of get everything we ordered in a timely manner he made all of us table of 7 feel extremely welcome ! I will continue visiting this business ! Thank you“

“The food is super fresh here! Got the geoduck, lobster, spotted snails, and oysters. They clean and cook the food to whatever method you want. The waiters and waitresses are also super caring and makes me feel seen as a customer as they swap out plates, add tea, and portion soups for everyone at the table. Good value, great taste, and solid service. Would come here again.“

“The Henny colada was a 10/10. Went on a Saturday live Dj although kind of loud was an added vibe to this place. The service was amazing. I got the Deep ocean for 1 58$ definitely NOT worth the price could have been a 25/30$ price. The food portions do not add up. It’s a cute place for a simple outing.“

“Had a great dinner here recently. The service was good, they were also very child-friendly which is so nice to see.

Calamari was incredible, some of the best I’ve had. Scallops were good, truffle fries delicious. The mains were nice but I personally preferred the appetizers.

Highly recommend this restaurant!“

“The food was excellent. Thank you Earl. I will be back.“

“Everything that you expected about a seafood place except this is way better, they don't have a big menu but they offer fresh food and cooked at the moment everything is fresh and delicious, we had a great dinner and we definitely will be back“

“Poke is VERY good! Yummy to my tummy :-)“

“We tried the shrimp chowder and camaron saltado! Mommy and I would have licked the bowl and plate, if we weren't in public! Then he brought out the passion fruit creme brulee...Heaven!!!!“

“I rarely write a review but I have been obsessed with Crab Du Jour since they opened in Harlem. My experience here has been delightful from the food to the friendly and attentive staff members who make customers feel right at home. If you are a seafood lover who’s in the mood for mouth-watering authentic Cajun dishes that won't break the bank, look no further than Crab Du Jour in Harlem; just steps away from the hustle and bustle of 125th Street. Their signature boils are an absolute must-try! They offer a variety of options like Crawfish, Shrimp, Snow Crab legs, Dungeness Crabs and Lobster Tail – all cooked to perfection! Each boil comes with potatoes and corn on the cob and your choice of classic garlic butter, lemon pepper, and the original Cajun or Crab du jour special, sauce. I usually add sausage to my boil; Yummy! Looking for something other than boils, there are plenty of choices! They offer dishes like po’ boys sandwiches which come with fried oysters or fried fish filets. My friend really likes the crispy chicken po’boy. They also offer fried shrimp baskets, or crab cake baskets, just to name a few. Regardless of what you choose off the menu here, you can be sure that it will be delicious and flavorful every single time!“