20 Best American Restaurants in New Paltz

“Bryce was personable and energetic from the very beginning! My husband and I felt like we made a new friend from the first time we walked through the door for our first tour, all throughout the process. Our wedding day was absolute perfection! We would HIGHLY recommend Novellas to anyone looking for a beautiful and affordable Hudson valley wedding. Thank you so very much for making our day so completely special and beautiful, and making the entire planning process a million times easier!!“

“The Main Course provided 3 dinners and2 lunches for our group of artists and everything was amazing. They really listened, understood who we were and what we wanted and delivered above and beyond at a good price. We will happily use them again if wet are in the neighborhood.“

“Absolutely lovely local place to eat! This is a great stop if you like soups, sandwiches, salads, etc. Fun baked good to take home as well. A great place for lunch or dinner if you're checking out the Hudson Valley.“

“We were a group of 6 hungry hikers when we arrived to Maggie Mae's yesterday, July 27th. We certainly received 5 star service. The food & hospitality is top notch with so many great menu options. Thank you Garvan McCloskey from all of us at Team Aisling. If anyone is in the New Paltz area & you're wondering where to go, check out Maggie Mae's or Garvan's. You will not be disappointed.“

“We had an amazing lunch today! Great food and service . My daughter left her brand new homemade bracelet from Cancun there and they were so helpful when I called, they are mailing me it ! We will make the trip back ASAP!!“

“We visit this restaurant often, it is the absolute best vegan restaurant ever.?Every soup I’ve tried was delicious. The sweet potato biscuits are amazing. The desserts are fabulous. If 10 is the highest rating I can give, I give them an 11. I wish we had this gem in NEPA. We will always be back for more of this place. Thank you for having such a wonderful, variety filled menu always. I❤️ Karma Road“

“This place is awesome! We weren't planning on coming here originally but glad we did. Staff is outgoing and friendly. We were recommended some of the popular sandwiches and got the Italian combo and the APD which was prepared with quality ingredients. Delicious.
I'll be thinking about those sandwiches until I find myself in the area again.“

“Just great, tasty food. Any seafood spot that makes good tartar sauce gets my business and vote. In my top three for sure.“

“We came for our anniversary dinner after a recommendation from the Airbnb owners of the TreeCastle and we were not disappointed. Hands down one of the top three restaurants we have ever been to. Garvan himself was amazingly friendly and accommodating and so were all of his staff. 100 would recommend. We will be back soon (even though it is a 3 hour drive) and hope to enjoy dinners for years to come! Thank you so much for an unforgettable night!“

“The stuffed French toast and bacon are so delicious!“

“Great wine bar with great Sangria! Perfect place to relax after a morning of hiking or running!!!!“

“The owners, James and Michelle, and staff are always welcoming. Great selection of coffee and tea. They'll grind your selection of beans or take em home whole. James' paninis just great. Starbucks has nothing on Mudd except hype. You want good ☕️ and reasonably priced selection of quality products when you need a break Mudd Puddle is worth a drop in.“

“The choices are unique compared to other restaurants. The food was very tasty. I had the black bean burger which was excellent. It had a little too much sauce but the sauce was so good. My wife had the jambalaya which was tasty but the chicken was a little tough. Overall we had a great experience and this was our second time here. The service was very friendly. They lowered the air conditioning when we requested and were very polite and helpful.“

“Went to Buffalo area last week, ate great wings at bar where wings were first served. Plus ate wings at other bars in that area, very good wings. Stopped in New Paltz on way back to Ct. Cuddys wings were the best! Had three different sauces all were fantastic! Highly recommend eating Cuddys wings!!“

“R to spy Eric cordon go do if woo had so in cool ISP Choi C dry ow G go p“

“first time there food was great nice place second time last night not so much pork chops was so tuff the knife wood not cut I has the colliflour stake first time great this time like new cook cooked it no good“

“Have made stopping here for breakfast a tradition during our annual trips to upstate NY and Vermont. Awesome menu, not your usual repetitive selections, always primo quality every time. Your only concern will be trying to choose what to order, you might just want to get one of each. Can't wait to get there again!“

“Delicious food and drinks; great music and fun, welcome atmosphere; dog friendly. Definitely going back!“

“Best restaurant and coolest Owner Wayne and bartender dave“

“Stopped by with a few of my girls today. What a great atmosphere! Our server (Grace) was lovely. She was so understanding for certain needs at the table and she was very personable. The food and drinks were just as good! Def coming back with the girls!“