50 Best Sandwich Shops near Bellmore

“Great food and very sweet people greeted us!“

“They make a really good sandwich here. Delicious traditional (and several imaginative) sandwiches round out a nice menu of choices that also includes salads. The Country Fried Chicken sandwich and the Cuban sandwich are excellent and portions seemed generous. My other half and I split a Country Fried Chicken sandwich on one visit and it was the perfect lunch.

Though there is limited seating, this is a take-out place, albeit mid- to high-end take-out (think Diner Boys). It is not inexpensive, but then you're not eating Jersey Mike's or Subway sandwiches here; while the dining area here is similar to those type of places, the quality, taste and style of these sandwiches are well above them. We felt the pricing was a bit high for what is a primarily take-out place, but we plan to go back to see about the raves on the Philly Cheese Steak and the Crispy Chicken alla Vodka, which we didn't try on our initial visit.

One thing to note if you don't order ahead: you'll wait longer than you might expect, especially for sandwiches like the fried chicken, which is obviously prepared fresh when ordered. We came at a completely quiet time (7:20p), and were just about to the point of asking when we'd get our order when it came out.

While the service was fine for counter service, we didn't experience the same level of service some reviews here have mentioned; it was simply a counter transaction.

Parking is street parking only, and is limited; we got there just in time to get one last available space on Merrick Rd directly in front of the business (there is a fire hydrant there, which limits the storefront to about 3 spaces). While there were a couple of spaces available on the side street, that was about all there was. I don't think I'd want to have to try parking there or crossing against traffic during rush hour, when this section of Merrick Road is jammed.“

“Came In Today To Pickup Lunch For The Family, As We Walked In The Entire Restaurant Was Newly Renovated, Everyone Was Very Nice & Attentive Met With John The New Owner, Super Nice 😊 A Definite Recommend In My Book ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Absolutely the best, most unique sandwich restaurant EVER. Passionate and dedicated team, serving healthy, innovative and just out of this world sandwiches and rich, freshly made coffees and espresso. Desserts available at on site (Francesco’s) bakery. Highest recommendation. A must try.“

“I made a 3:50 appt and was taken on time . The dermatologist took care of what I needed . I was very happy with the service I received. The office staff was great . I arrived early and said I didn’t want to just sit and wait . She told me to go out and just be back by this time .“

“Without a doubt the closest cooking to remind me of home. Catfish and Shrimp pivots was amazing. Crawfish Etoufee, chicken and sausage gumbo and chicken sausage and shrimp jambalaya was spot on. I will be back to shoot a video of the location and food for my Vlog without a doubt. Was a good feeling to here the chef ask if “The Boot was in the house” being from LA it made me feel like it was home.“

“Very pleasant staff. Great service“

“used them for catering and delivery. incredible! will be using again“

“Come here for the best most fresh tasting sandwich on long island. Definitely satisfies hunger when in Westbury/carle place area. It's so good worth driving any distance to get there. original Blimpie taste. fresh,clean,friendly service,fast and delicious. 5 stars“

“Best Pastrami on Long Island“

“I had the most delicious made to order omelet today- eggs, American cheese, with grilled tomatoes and onions. They always make it the way I like it- I highly recommend their omelets!! Other food is good too!“

“I'm definitely not a sandwich person. But this place hits the mark every time. Its my 1st time ordering from Syosset location have always ordered from Hicksville but the seem to stop delivering to my area. Back to the sandwich. I always try something different, this time I tried the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich and it did not disappoint. A sandwich is always last or mostly not even an option for me but this place makes me think about having a sandwich more often than I ever have. So good and consistent I had to leave a review even though I order from the Hicksville on the times before“

“I mean it’s still good, it’s not MY HERO without the old bread. That was the absolute best thing. I’d still recommend it but it’s not what it once was“

“I don’t usually leave reviews but I just had to in this case. Pantano’s of Plainview catered my baby shower this past weekend. The food was amazing!! Three days later and I'm still getting texts complimenting the food. Gian Luca and his staff made everything so so easy, from the amount of food I would need to what to actually order to the sides and extra sauces; everything was perfect. With such a busy day, that was one thing I didn't have to worry and stress about. I highly recommend!“

“Alberson location is a joke, literally half the meat on the sandwich as the other locations! Not a one time thing, third time, I'm done!“

“My buddy Noah requested this place to me. Me him and my buddy Thomas just got it for an early lunch, first day back from college. We were in need of a good food place, and Pantano’s did not disappoint. The Birria be kidding me was amazing, will be back.“

“I previously gave a 1 star review due to the app Brendo’s used to order online but since I could not remove the review, I am giving it another review with the corrected 5 stars rating. The app used for online order charged some hidden fees that were not made transparent. When I confronted them about this during pickup, they immediately gave me cash back for the hidden fees that even they were not made aware of. I appreciate the honesty and the food was very good. I especially like the steak quesadillas, the Beast and the Buffalo chicken cheesesteak hero. Super tasty! The wings were a little overdone with some burnt sides but overall still tasty. I will order from here again but will call directly to place the order instead of placing the order via the online app.“

“I’ve coming here 12/13 yrs and the owner has nothing but nice and courteous. Always accommodating with our order. This is the best Blimpie restaurant. They have the best sandwich and smoothies. The smoothies are so freaking good. You should definitely order with co workers and enjoy. Thanks Blimpie for making my girls a great lunch and dinner.“

“Kitchen Kabaret was such a great find, and I’m so glad we stopped in. We went on a friend’s recommendation while heading to a Cowboys–Giants game, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. The place has a really cool vibe and an impressive variety of food options—especially for breakfast—so there’s truly something for everyone.
I ordered a pastrami sandwich with eggs and Swiss, and it was delicious. The pastrami was flavorful, the eggs were perfectly cooked, and the bread was soft, fresh, and held everything together beautifully. It was one of those meals that hits the spot and sticks with you (in the best way).
The cappuccino was decent—not the star of the show—but totally fine alongside the meal. What really stood out was the service: fast, friendly, and efficient, even though the place was packed. That says a lot. You can tell this is a popular spot for a reason.
Overall, Kitchen Kabaret is a fun, bustling place with great food, a wide selection, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast before a big game or just looking for a solid morning spot, this place is definitely worth the stop.“

“The best deli !!! & the people who work there are the best!!❤️ highly recommend 😊😊“

“I love Sandwich Express! The reuben panini is my go-to, but everything I’ve eaten from there has been delicious. I’ve also done catering a few times through Sandwich Express, and not only is the food great, but the prices are unbeatable. Plus, the owner is so kind and so helpful. The best place in Plainview!!“

“Thank you so much for donating lunch and dinner to the nurses and staff at Glen Cove Nursing and Rehab. Your support was GREATLY appreciated!“

“If you're in the area definitely check out this place the food is all fresh they have a great Smoothie Bar also everybody working the counter was friendly and helpful I got a grilled chicken panini it was amazing anytime I'm working in Mineola I will be here for breakfast or lunch for sure“

“I've had half way decent experiences at a couple Jersey Mike's in the past. I was visiting a friend and we decided to get some, I tried the buffalo chicken cheesteak for the first time and it was easily one of the best sandwiches I've ever had, so good! A couple weeks later I went to a different jersey Mike's local to me, craving the buffalo chicken and it was not great maybe a 3/5. It had none of the flavor I remember enjoying so much and overall it just missed the mark of what the East Meadow chain delivered. My friend who frequents the East Meadow one says they're always consistent and tasty, so I have to imagine my amazing sandwich there wasn't a fluke. If you're deciding which location to visit, this is the one.“

“Roast is by far one of Long Islands best sandwich shops. Food is unbelievably great!! Staff is always friendly & happy!!“

“ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL 10 STARS VERY GOOD DEFINITELY TRY THE CUBANO & THE ITALIAN SUB ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Pretty good service and clean place !! The boneless wings with barbecue sauce is the best !! Fries are okay but the mozzarella sticks are yummy, I love how perfectly crunchy they are !! Their Lemonades are also very refreshing so definitely come here for a lemonade during the summer !! (Or on hot days) also quick warning, the lemonades have fruit chunks, but they actually make the drink even better, kinda reminds me of boba tea with the tapioca pearls in it.“

“This is definitely the best subway I've been to in a very long time. The store itself is immaculately clean, the ingredients taste extremely fresh and the staff is very friendly. I haven't had good Subway in what feels like decades and this place really hit the spot“

“very clean, always fresh, I've been a customer for40 years!“

“I refuse to go to any other Jersey Mike’s!
I always get exactly what I came for. My only complaint is that the female employees don’t put enough meat on the sandwich even when you ask for extra and pay for it but they rarely ever make the sandwiches to begin with so all is good“

“Best Philly Cheesesteaks Heroes 🥖🥖🥖 Delicious 😋 😋😋 Shawn B Singh, Financial Professional at Guardian #supersinghs🙏🏽🕉💙“

“Love the sandwiches! I enjoy the turkey with provolone or the Italian sandwich’s Mikes way on the whole wheat bread it’s more flavorful. I also get the tuna and chicken salad in a bowl or again on the wheat bread. Much better than Subway!“

“Jersey mikes may technically be a fast food sandwich chain along with subway, blimpie, Quiznos and all that. But they are far cleaner and they slice their meat to order. Besides all that, they make a fantastic Italian. This jersey mikes is particularly well kept and the people I’ve interacted with so far have been very nice. As far as Italians go, theirs is delicious, even compared with local delis and other restaurants. It’s just really surprisingly good.“

“We enjoy dropping by Mikes for a quick dinner. We like tbe option of the.no bread bowls and also the gluten free roll choice. Everything is cut fresh and the veggies are crispy. I just wish they had more of a variety. Cucumbers would be nice.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free rolls.“

“Very good staff , friendly. Specially woman there I called her didi very pure heart. Thank you for complimentary cookies . My kid love it. Feel like always welcome. Good communication. Understanding need of customer . I appreciate their efforts and care.“

“Great staff! Very friendly and efficient. Establishment is very clean and well kept. Very good with allergies, When I told them what I was allergic to they told me what to look out for, and made sure to wipe everything down as to avoid cross contamination.“

“I’ve had Subway from many many different location, but this one is my most favorite. The sandwiches have the perfect amount of sauce and ingredients. It just makes my day! Thanks to the staff :) (who I haven’t even met) <3

Vegetarian options: I think most locations discontinued the veggie patties. Not sure what happen.“

“ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL 10 STARS VERY GOOD DEFINITELY TRY THE CUBANO & THE ITALIAN SUB ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I had an amazing experience here. The staff was friendly, professional, and very welcoming from start to finish. Everything was clean, well-organized, and handled quickly without any issues. The service exceeded my expectations, and the quality was top-notch. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great service and a smooth experience!“

“Maple Ave Deli is the best local deli in RVC. I come here almost daily! They know I’m a regular and treat me as such - love u guys! Egg sandwiches always hit and today I tried a panini which was absolutely fire. They never miss a step. Thankful to have this deli close by to work :)“

“Lovely lunch today. Ordered the chicken bacon ranch sandwich and was pleased by the quality of the sandwich , as well as nicely toasted and crisp hot bacon which accompanied it. A very good experience! Excellent location to crave your hunger?“

“I went there April 27th with my BF. He ordered the sandwich and I wasn't paying attention, we left and in the car he said he had issue with how it was made and wanted to throw it away. I said no, that sandwich was expensive, just bring me back and I will explain the issue and hopefully they will remake it for free. I talked to the manager Tanya, and explained and she remade it and remembered my order. I think I came back 15 minutes later, the manager seemed tired but was nice, quick and efficient. She deserves a raise.“

“Amazing food, the workers are so friendly. Personal experience I wanted my cookies to be warmed up because I love the nice warm feeling in my mouth and the worker got up with a smile on his face cracking jokes and did it just for me. They give amazing recommendations on vegetables to be put on the sandwich and helped me find a new favorite sandwich. Overall a very nice experience I found in a while.“

“(Translated by Google) Excellent service, good attention and very tasty and delicious food, I recommend this restaurant in Miami Florida(Original)Servicio exelente buena atencion y la comida muy sabrosa y deliciosa se los recomiendo ese restaurnte dede miami florida“

“I think they should continue to cookies the big one for cookies for cookies foot cookies because the they Oh so good so good so good and delicious too in the soft soft

Parking: Great and sometimes difficult to park in Walmart“

“Recently came back to this amazing establishment and once again Eddy knocked my socks off, he is truly one of the best sandwich artisans I have ever met in my life, the kindness he has shown me and the Sandwich he put his blood, sweat and gets into definitely made my month, I will be coming back for years to come as Long as is working at this restaurant. This world is truly better off with this man in it, I love him and the Jersey Mike's corporation. Thank you and good day!“

“I came here for a late night sandwich and the place looked clean, the ingredients looked fresh and also Judith (I think that’s her name on her necklace) helped us she was very quick but also nice :) all the other locations look like they’re going down so it was nice seeing a good clean location ??“

“This is the best place. They got the sandwich goods and this place is named after Mike Oberlender 😂.They got that double combo which is double the fun and almost too good to be true. Therefore I will continue support a place that loves Mike Oberlender and that loves to make amazing sandwiches“

“I have always liked coming into Subway. The staff is always awesome, until today. My husband and son went down to fetch us dinner. The lady was training someone and was very rude! To the point, she made them feel bad for ordering. Not ok! You work with the public, you be nice no matter what. This makes us want to stay away“

“I tried Subway for the very first time and absolutely loved it! Janvi, who prepared my order, was incredibly kind and patient. She took the time to suggest options I might enjoy and really knew her way around the menu. I appreciated how professional, friendly, and sweet she was throughout the process. Such a wonderful experience, I’ll definitely be coming back!“