40 Best Italian Restaurants in Salt Lake City

“Matteo Ristorante Italiano is a restaurant known for its unique Italian cuisine and generously sized portions. The service is exceptional, with well-trained and attentive staff. Reviews highlight the restaurant's amazing service, friendly hosts, and knowledgeable waiters. The food is described as inventive, delicious, and complex, with each dish being a work of art. The white chocolate cheesecake dessert is particularly praised. The restaurant is suitable for special occasions and celebrations. The team, including Harley, Seth, and Mateo, are commended for their exceptional service. Repeat visits are recommended to sample the extensive menu.“

“Caffé Molise offers a great location and ambiance in a historic building. While some dishes may lack flavor, the Italian-based menu has its excellent choices, such as the Spinach salad, Gnocchi with meatballs, Scallops, and Bruschetta. The staff provides excellent customer service, with polite and respectful servers. Prices may be a bit high, but the overall dining experience is wonderful.“

“Osteria Amore is a delightful restaurant that offers a delectable dining experience. The attentive service, delicious food, and beautiful presentation consistently impress guests. The menu features a variety of tempting options, from the shareable caprese salad to the in-house made pasta dishes, such as the lasagne with spinach and bolognese, and the pear gorgonzola ravioli with truffle and sage. Highly recommended for a memorable meal.“

“VENETO Ristorante Italiano offers an authentic Italian experience with lovingly prepared food served in courses. The trainwreck of flavors in each dish is truly a gem in SLC. Guests highly recommend the tasting menu with wine pairings for a divine experience. Marco's presence adds to the fun, making it a one-of-a-kind dining experience in the area.“

“Zaffo's Artisan Pasta is a restaurant that serves delicious food with amazing service. The menu features a variety of pasta dishes, including bolognese and pesto, as well as fresh pasta with sauces like San Marzano and San Marzano with veggies. The panna cottas, in chocolate and mixed berry flavors, are a highlight. The portions are generous, and the presentation is appealing. The restaurant has a communal seating area, but the food can also be ordered for delivery. The owners care about customer feedback and respond to reviews. Overall, Zaffo's offers excellent value, with fresh and flavorful pasta, generous portions, and a great selection of desserts.“

“Roux Restaurant serves great food, including the recommended trout and lamb shank, in a welcoming atmosphere. The staff is pleasant, and the service is excellent. The brunch and dinner options are delicious, with standout desserts like the perfect basque cheesecake. While entrees may vary, the chefs' top-notch execution makes it worth a visit.“

“Per Noi Trattoria is a wonderful spot for a night out with friends or a date. The restaurant offers delicious Italian food, including made-in-house pasta dishes that are highly recommended. The staff is friendly and attentive, with a hostess who can quickly resolve any issues with reservations. While parking can be a bit tricky, it's worth the effort. With a great atmosphere and excellent service, Per Noi Trattoria is a must-visit for Italian food lovers.“

“Stoneground Italian Kitchen offers an amazing dining experience with delicious food and a lovely atmosphere. Guests highly recommend dishes like oxtail ravioli, black and blue pizza, and lobster tagliatelle. The dipping sauces, marinara, and Gorgonzola cheese are particularly outstanding. The attentive servers, especially V, provide excellent recommendations and service. The restaurant is perfect for both casual and special occasions, with fresh, hot bread and flavorful dishes like gnocchi and coconut rice scallops. Despite some menu changes, Stoneground Italian Kitchen remains a favorite spot in Salt Lake City, offering a delightful culinary experience worth every penny.“

“Stanza Italian Bistro & Wine Bar offers top-tier food in an incredible environment, perfect for a first date or a date night. Guests recommend the Veal piccata, Yukon Gnocchi, arancini, and linguine dishes. The atmosphere is cool and the staff is friendly. The restaurant has gluten-free options, including pasta, and a nice wine selection. Parking is available behind the building. Overall, the experience was great with amazing food, excellent service, and a clean interior. Highly recommended for a quiet, enjoyable dining experience.“

“Salt & Olive is a restaurant that offers unique and tasty dishes for various meals, including brunch, lunch, and charcuterie. The Churro French toast and the wood-fired pizza are notable menu items. The staff is attentive, and they provide great recommendations. However, they can be a bit absent at times. The ordering system is cafeteria-style, and parking is limited on the street. The restaurant is suitable for a light lunch or a meal with a companion.“

“Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers a pleasant dining experience with professional and friendly service. The manager checks in regularly to ensure a great meal. The atmosphere is kid-friendly and accessible for wheelchairs. The food is delicious and prepared quickly, with options to customize orders. The staff is patient and attentive, making it a great spot for a lunch or dinner.“

“Valter's Osteria offers a magnificent dining experience with a super ingratiating atmosphere, reminiscent of an Italian experience. The service is a pleasure, with superbly crafted cocktails and generous meals served in a timely manner. The menu can be daunting, but the staff are always on hand to help. Each dish is exceptional, with exceptional flavors and presentation. The restaurant has a magnificent wine list covering the globe and offers extra samples of food to the table. While some may find the atmosphere stiff and touristy, the food and service are consistently great.“

“Bartolo's Sugar House is a restaurant that offers a pleasant atmosphere and friendly service. The menu features a variety of dishes, including a recommended steak and eggs for brunch and a savory gluten-free waffle smothered in hollandaise sauce. Customers have enjoyed the large portions, particularly the potatoes, and the gluten-free hunter's board. While the service may have been a bit slow at times, the overall experience is described as good.“

“Carlucci's Bakery is a warm and welcoming spot that serves excellent coffee, complete with unique coffee ice cubes. Their croissants and breakfast sandwich, featuring cheddar cheese, are also popular items. While some may find the Italian-inspired offerings lacking, the pastries are delicious and homemade-tasting, like the sugar cookie. With outstanding treats like the cannoli and carrot cake, Carlucci's is a highly recommended destination for a sweet treat.“

“Cucina Toscana is a wonderful Italian restaurant that serves exceptional food and provides outstanding service. The restaurant fills up quickly, making it a popular spot. The menu offers a range of delicious dishes, including short ribs, chicken, beet salad, and Cesar salad. The chef's attention to detail is evident in the perfectly cooked artichokes, capers, and potatoes. The desserts, such as the Moulton cake and sea salt lemon gelato, are a highlight. With its upscale atmosphere, Cucina Toscana is perfect for a special occasion or a nice evening out.“

“The Old Spaghetti Factory offers a nostalgic dining experience with delicious food. The "managers favorite" meal with mizithra cheese and rich meat sauce is a standout, along with the ranch pesto dressing on the salads. The bread loaf served is crusty outside and soft inside. Despite some issues with extra charges and missing condiments, the fresh pasta and homemade marinara sauce are highlights. The restaurant's fun and friendly atmosphere make it a great spot for families.“

“Piastra on Gallivan Plaza, located in the Marriott City Center, offers a standout dining experience with its Italian-inspired dishes. Notable menu items include a delicious hamburger with fries and a refreshing arugula beet salad. The hospitality, led by manager Berkay, enhances the memorable experience through warm welcomes and expert recommendations. Even the bar provides a pleasant atmosphere, thanks to the friendly and attentive bartenders like Alec. Piastra continues to be a top choice for excellent food and service, consistently surpassing other restaurants in Salt Lake City.“

“Tuscan Bistro by Soni's is a cozy spot with exceptional service and inviting atmosphere. The Caesar Salad is a must-try, with generous portions and freshness that will blow your mind. The pricing is very reasonable, with the house burger being a huge hit. While the drinks are a bit pricey, the staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is quiet. The chicken pot pie and lasagna are highly recommended for their generous servings and delicious taste. Located in Radisson, it's a great place to relax and enjoy exceptional food.“

“Tucci's Cucina Italiana offers tasty food with good presentation and portions. The appetizer bread is warm and soft, and the interior is nicely decorated. Some reviewers mentioned that the bathrooms could use some cleaning and updating. The staff is friendly and professional, with attentive service once initial confusion was cleared up. The complimentary bread appetizer was delicious, and the Cesare Della Casa salads were enjoyable. The Ravioli Gamberetti was tasty but slightly salty due to bacon and pine nuts, while the Due Pesto Gamberetti had a wonderful sauce and flavorful shrimp. The atmosphere is comfortable with a mix of vocal jazz and 50s rock music playing at a pleasant volume. Overall, a great restaurant for a nice and delicious dinner experience.“

“Moochie's Meatballs and More is a top-rated sandwich place with a "fire" sauce. They offer a variety of options, including the Italian Deli, meatball sandwich, Mediterranean salad, and spaghetti and meatballs (now replaced with penne). The restaurant has a rustic ambiance, amazing service, and is kid-friendly with easy parking and wheelchair accessibility.“

“Mediterranean Market & Deli is a highly recommended spot, praised for its exquisitely delicious flavors and welcoming customer service. The menu offers a range of tasty options, including paninis, cannolis, and Greek Pasta Salad, which is a standout dish with fresh, perfectly cooked pasta and bright flavors. The staff provides top-notch service, and the open and window-friendly seating area adds to the pleasant dining experience. With endless fresh options and friendly staff, this deli has become a favorite among visitors.“

“Italian Graffiti offers exceptional food that is worth the price, even though it may be a bit expensive. The house-made bread, especially the focaccia with feta/honey, is a great way to start the meal. The ambiance is perfect for a relaxing evening with family or friends. The menu boasts delicious pasta dishes like Meatballs over Bucatini and Bucatini alla Carbonara. The service is top-notch, with passionate servers who are knowledgeable about the food. While the music may be a bit loud, the overall experience at Italian Graffiti is highly recommended, despite the higher prices.“

“Carmine's Italian Restaurant offers amazing Italian dishes like Casarecce 4 Formaggi and formaggi Gnocchi. The location is great for resort visitors. The carbonara, tiramisu, and pizzas are highly recommended. While some find the food average, dishes like chicken cacciatore stand out. Whether for a weekday takeout or a weekend night out, Carmine's is a gem worth visiting for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine.“

“Romano's Macaroni Grill provides an exceptional dining experience with accommodating staff and attentive service. They cater to dietary restrictions, including gluten-free options. Enjoy a warm and inviting atmosphere, with delicious food served promptly. Finish your meal with a sweet treat, like conoli's, and consider sharing the Trio for $22.95.“

“Tuscany Restaurant in Salt Lake City is a highly acclaimed establishment, known for its exceptional ambiance and delectable Italian cuisine. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience, catering to customers' needs with exceptional service. The outdoor patio, with its romantic vibe, transports guests to the heart of Tuscany, Italy. The menu offers a diverse range of tempting options, from the flavorful chicken pesto pizza to the succulent lemon chicken and the meticulously crafted lasagna special. The beet salad and the desserts, such as the cheesecake and the chocolate melting cake, are also praised for their freshness and deliciousness. While some dishes, like the lamb chops and the spicy seafood puttanesca, may not have lived up to the high expectations, the overall consensus is that Tuscany Restaurant is a must-try destination for those seeking an authentic Italian dining experience in a refined and elegant setting.“

“Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana is a restaurant that serves authentic Italian pizza, known for its delicious taste and true-to-style cooking. The smell of the pizza dough baking is a delightful experience for customers. The kitchen, including the big pizza oven, is in full view of diners, where the magic of creating the pizzas takes place. The menu offers a variety of dishes, all of which have been praised by customers. One popular pizza is the Settebello pizza, noted for its unique flavor from the roasted pine nuts. The restaurant is also known for its friendly staff and excellent service. In addition, there is a gelato shop next door, providing a perfect way to end the meal. For parking, customers can park in the lot behind the restaurant and get free parking by informing the host of their spot number. Other menu recommendations include the appetizers, particularly the bacon-wrapped stuffed dates. The restaurant has consistently received positive reviews, with customers expressing their intent to return on future visits to the area.“

“Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant offers a lively dining experience, though the quality of the food may have declined recently. The staff, including a server named Annalise, provide excellent customer service and recommendations. The restaurant's atmosphere is praised, and it is easily accessible for wheelchair users. Overall, the establishment is well-regarded and recommended by satisfied customers.“

“Big Apple Pizzeria is a welcoming restaurant that accommodates dietary requests with ease. They offer a variety of options, including New York-style pizza by the pie or slice, calzones, and garlic knots. The staff is friendly and understanding, even during busy times. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with a small concrete ramp. Their homemade blue cheese salad dressing is a highlight, and they are happy to make modifications to suit individual tastes.“

“Café Trio is appreciated for its accommodating owner and manager, and enjoyed for its tasty food. It's a great spot for business lunches with reasonable prices, free parking, and a convenient location away from downtown. Dinner is also delightful, offering a variety of options for a splendid meal with loved ones. The brunch menu could feature more lunch-type items.“

“We were in Salt Lake City for a conference and staying in a nearby hotel. My friend requires gluten-free options, so we headed here because they offered zucchini noodles. The food was so good we returned a few nights later for more of their tasty offerings! Nice atmosphere. Friendly staff.“

“Amelia's Grill & Bar, located in a hotel near the airport, offers a welcoming atmosphere and delightful dining experience. The food is praised for its quality, with the fried green beans and burgers being particularly noteworthy. Customers can also order from the adjacent Indian restaurant, as the kitchens are shared. The service is consistently excellent, with friendly and attentive staff who create a positive vibe. Whether you're a traveling adult or a local, Amelia's Grill & Bar is a recommended destination for a satisfying meal and a pleasant dining experience.“

“Maxwell's Little Bar is a downtown gem featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious food, including gluten-free options, make it a must-visit. While parking can be tricky, the experience is worth it. Their NY style pizza is a local favorite, with impeccable service. Despite a salad mishap, the staff handled it well. For authentic, top-notch pizza, Maxwell's is the place to go.“

“Sicilia Pizza & Kitchen in Salt Lake City is a gem with delicious food and impeccable service. Customers highly recommend the beef pepperoni pizza, which is a must-try. The friendly staff ensures a pleasant dining experience, even for large groups. Fast service and mouthwatering pizzas make it a perfect spot for a quick, satisfying meal.“

“Robert's Restaurant in Salt Lake City is known for its homemade food, with popular dishes including ravioli, Reuben sandwiches, cheeseburgers, and chicken noodle soup. Located near the airport and hotels, it is a convenient option for travelers. The breakfast menu features a variety of coffee options, though some guests have reported issues with the coffee machine. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere and offers excellent service, with staff going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. However, it is recommended to check the functioning of certain appliances before ordering.“

“Este Pizza SugarHouse is a great spot for a meal, whether you're with a group or on your own. The prices are reasonable and the service is quick and friendly. Vegetarians will be pleased with the plentiful options. The wood-fired pizza has a light and crispy crust with a slightly salty and slightly sweet flavor. The sauce is well-seasoned with balanced flavors and fresh tomato chunks. The toppings are generous and include fresh Italian sausage. The atmosphere is unique with cool decals, graffiti walls, and open ceilings. There's a fun selection of stickers on the booths. Don't forget to try the garlic knots, they're a favorite among regulars. Overall, Este Pizza SugarHouse is a real and unpretentious place that is worth a visit.“

“Este Pizzeria - Downtown is a top pizza spot in Salt Lake City, known for its NY style pies like the Bee Sting. The atmosphere is laid back, the staff is friendly, and they offer great gluten-free options. While some find the pizza so-so, others enjoy the filling slices, like the vegetarian and pepperoni options. Quick service makes it a popular choice for groups.“

“Little Caesars Pizza is located in a somewhat unusual spot, but it is easily accessible. The staff are young yet skilled and friendly. The food is affordably priced, with the quality reflecting the cost. As a take-out spot, it doesn't offer seating or nutritious meal options, so it's important to be mindful of health risks when frequently consuming their offerings. Despite this, customers have reported positive experiences, even on difficult days, attributing improved moods to the kind staff and satisfying food. There was an instance where an order was incorrect, but the staff promptly remedied the situation, making a fresh pizza with no fuss. Overall, Little Caesars Pizza offers great customer service and fresh pizza, making it a recommended choice for fast food.“

“Brio Italian Grille is a consistent and wonderful dining experience, with exceptional service and a wide variety of menu options, including gluten-free choices. The pasta alla vodka, featuring cheese-filled handmade ravioli in a savory vodka sauce, is a standout dish that keeps customers coming back. While parking can be a challenge in the downtown area, the restaurant offers a convenient valet service.“

“Pier 49 Pizza is a favorite spot for many pizza lovers, offering delicious options for both meat and vegetable enthusiasts. With a welcoming environment for all dietary restrictions, this pizza place is known for its friendly service and affordable prices. The availability of free parking anytime and wheelchair accessibility makes it convenient for all customers. The pizza by the slice option offers a variety of choices, with quick service and ample seating, including booths and tables. Despite some worn-out booths, the restaurant maintains a clean and tidy atmosphere. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch special or enjoying a full pizza, Pier 49 Pizza is a great choice for a satisfying meal.“